This is a story about a sheep. A little sheep, locked deep in prison, put there by ponies. He doesn't want to be there, but then he's had to do a lot of things he doesn't want to. It's a shame he deserves to be in there.
Page generated in 0.027 seconds
Total duration
896 users online
1,323,381 hits today, 2,561,572 yesterday
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Fanfiction
Designed and coded by knighty & Xaquseg - © 2011-2024
Support us
SubStar
Chat!
Discord
Follow us
Twitter
MLP: Friendship is Magic® - © 2024 Hasbro Inc.®
Fimfiction is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Hasbro Inc.®
9045580
Wow.... I didn't think I had made that many mistakes..... (Yikes, gotta' re-read more carefully)
But thank you very much for your help and pointing them all out! It is a great help, since I'm still not too sure what I'm doing yet. (I'm blaming my English teacher. Yes. That's my excuse and I'm sticking with it)
Also thank you for telling me about those Proof Reader's (I will need to go and learn what the requirements are there)
The word you are looking for is dormant volcano.
9079700
Hello. Thank you for your help! Pointing out things that I did wrong is most appreciated.
Also, you're not supposed to like Valour 😄So I guess I'm doing him right.
Your pacing is nice. Plenty of description and yet you're not describing the same thing for four paragraphs. I don't usually like darker stories, but you have my interest.
9248913
Glad that you like it. As you said, they can sometimes go on and on... I usually have to go back and delete half of what I write because it turns out to be superfluous.
Very impressive for a first fic.
Only three points I'd change, and they are mainly just formatting.
First off, it looks much more professional if you use the word instead of the number. (One and 1, etc.)
Secondly, make sure to have it as a new paragraph when you switch who is talking.
(E.g:
)
And finally, make sure to only put speech at the end and start of a pragraph. It looks janky if you don't.
(E.g
)
Regardless, I like it.
Usually the first few chapters of fics are a bit average, but this is quite good.
My hopes are already being fufilled. :D
mediate->meditate
was in ->was I in
Hmm... interesting
Ah, at last, a story I can enjoy for a good long while. Very well done.
Well, I sometimes note every typo I come across in fanfiction, just to have at least something for a review. Other times, I just want to relax and enjoy a good story - not worry about reviews or repeatedly interrupting my reading to copy-paste sentences into a notepad - Which is what I did the first time I read through this story.
Well, here's a proper review for this chapter. I'll probably write some more, though I can't guarantee covering all the chapters. But I feel like it's the least I can do in return for all the story you're writing to my great entertainment.
Thoughts and stuff
So, considering how many Zebras and Griffins seem to make up the core of the rebellion, is the implication that this is a minor proxy war waged by, at least elements within, Zebrica and Griffonia? I hope to learn more about the war later on.
I think the griffin in this chapter turns out to be a named character later, but were one of the zebras Snake? Unsure if it's ever mentioned.
Boulder started this little pet-peeve?
yes, this does indeed seem correct to say when you are speaking of only ponies... I find his later aversion to this manner of speaking just a little too absolute in one or two places.
How? Maybe not important, but I just don't see how potential rebel recruits would get into contact with the "rebel recruiting station".
Is that his responsibility? Is that how this works? Or how it's perceived? I'm curious about the world-building, the society. I hope to find out more about this unequine inequity in Equestria.
More like, "who". Sure sounds funnier in hindsight...
Do I see what you did there, or am I just reading too much into it?
"He'd driven ponies mad with just a passing touch before". Maybe not his strongest point, but hardly a weak point, under the right circumstances.
but forgot it again not long after, to the detriment of his poor cheek. A bit uncharacteristic.
a mystery I really hope will one day be cleared up.
first time I read this, I thought maybe mind-leeching came with eternal youth, but now I guess it's just that Valor chooses not to regard mind leeches as children. Palpatine_Ironic.webm.
a bit ironic too, that Valor, of all people, gets him immediately.
where? It's a pretty small room, and the bed is in the middle of it. It just seems very close to the bed which triggers my OCD.
small number. Not exactly 24601. Really is quite exclusive membership with Dreverton.
usually, you mean, right? Or is he really that big?
Typos, grammar, etc
Now, I know this looks like a lot, but there is a lot of chapter to cover.
rocky what?
was
"crummy, rat infested", just to make clear the rats aren't crummy. At least, I asssume they're perfectly fine rats.
Whatever. In adjectival uses, only the one-word form is used. "What ever do you mean by that?"
prisoners'
whistful
meditate
Not a typo, the "because" just isn't necessary and just makes the sentence a bit colloquial for non-dialogue. It's a minor thing, I admit.
maybe replace that "he" with "Gossamer", for more clarity's sake.
Strange thing to say. Is it really Gossamer who needs to know he's not badly hurt?
Seems like omniscient POV, suddenly? Or is it the way our protagonist interprets his memories in hindsight? And on that note, if I may jump a bit: Also, uncertainly. Only caught that after re-reading my own comment for mistakes.
Speculation, informed guess in hindsight, or omniscient POV? His mother gulping, that Gossamer could possibly see from a range, I don't know enough about sheep physiology, but this goes a bit far. I suppose its a statistical certainty...
"around, sweetie"
"do, , sweetie"
Seperate paragraphs, but here there's no space between them for some reason.
"then, as one, tried to"
"halfway" is more common.
"the Resistance's question"
closest.
Boulder's still "talking"
Griffin's
brother's
we've done this row
brother's
"even with his" etc
This line just bothers me. The word "lifestyle" somehow doesn't seem in character for an enlightment-era peasant boy. And the words "poor lifestyle" in and off themselves just don't seem right together.
very minor, but I think you can remove the "Fleece told him" and "He said" from these sentences, unnecessary and superfluous.
colloqial, or "think about how"?
Possibly there're instead of there's. Depends on what's more natural for Fleece to pronounce in speech.
nothing's
Probably who're, but it depends on Fleece.
either period or lowercase b in "but". You usually use period.
"then, Fleece?"
are right now, didn't you
you mean you actually thought(?)
"preferable to the uncertainty"
"unlikely they would do little" means they would likely do a lot. It's either "unlikely they would do more than delay", or they simply "would do little more than delay".
on the cells
like 85% sure it really should be "were definitely more guards"
what is a "set of guards"? Unclear.
Something's
something's missing here.
don't see what the "through" is doing here. Also, "fourth time of re-living" probably.
villagers'
could be alright, or did you mean "the town's militia"?
Ram's
pretty sure you can take off this comma.
Guard's
ask
headway, defintely one word.
in putting down
On a little hunch, I made a search, and sure enough, you spell it "Firestrike" in chapter 52.
Whoa. I don't even know how to search for the rules to this possessive. Very cool. But it should at least be "cell's".
some do spell it in two words, yes, my only complaint is that it hurts my eyes. I leave this comment in here because this is in part a review. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
unicorns'
I'd go with "unseen"
- "door's threshold. He"
peak
Guards'
hereby
"to me, inmate 452"
snapped off
the captain's abrupt order spoke volumes of their respect
but they only stay for 2,5 years at most, right? I guess that's a plurality of years, technically, but...
Valor's
something's wrong or missing.
Pegasi
Pegasi
Also some inconsistent capitalization of "resistance". Would perhaps make sense for lower case R in Prey's narration, and upper case in rebel dialogue.
Same for the "guard" part of "Border Guard". Interestingly, the "Border" part is always spelled with a capital B.
And lastly the same goes for "unicorn", "earth pony" and "pegasus". I'd just Ctrl+F these through all chapters. griffin, zebra and whatever else, too. dragon?
Left out the most minor issues. Like
It's clearly colloqial dialogue and from rebel scum no less, so it could be intentional for all I know.
... this may be the most monstrous comment I've ever written.
10409405
Hello and thank you for pointing all those out. I blame this being my first chapter. I haven't edited them yet, but I will. (Currently away for a week and replying to this on my phone) is ridiculously hard to edit a chapter on a phone as opposed to my nice easy convenient computer. But seriously, thanks. 😄
10409405
Okay, phew, finally got back today and can correct all those little mistakes you've raised. Thanks for that.😄 I know it's a week late, but in answer to the questions you asked at the start of your post:
-Fixed the "rebel recruiting station", had Boulder say they'd be back to take on recruits.
-The "resistance" mention was a slight joke, yes. Well spotted.
-The mixed up dates... That's going to be a thing at a... later date. Ha! Ha. Ha. *Wheeze*
-Fixed the toilet placement and along with the size of Valor when compared to any random Earth pony.
-The number 452. Yeah, Equestria doesn't have much in the way of serious criminal elements. Also, Dreverton is fairly new. (Not that it matters storywise, but about 200 hundred years old. And Prey was in there for 57 of those.) Also, number relates to how far down the cell block you were. The closer you are to the bottom, the worse the criminal is. Roughly speaking.
Thanks again, and have a nice day 🍎
Well, it starts intresting. Will read further on.
I mean, hey, it beats getting executed.
Seriously though, never understood why in so many stories Equestria has the death penalty, pretty sure that goes against their morals.
ok is that a really big pony or a really small sheep? or a bit of both?
10916757
Yes, both. 🙃
(It's kinda' a really bad and dated drawing now.)
i love your ART, your style; you´re genius!!!!!!! <3
This looks like an interesting fic. And a long one too, that's always a bonus. Good fics always tend to end too soon.
11106993
Thanks and good luck! (I like to think that the writing got a bit better over the first few thousand words, but sorry if you end up cringing still. 😄)
I've got more edits because me and some friends are reading this out loud in a discord chat! Edits in bold!
Missing apostrophe and thus the plural on head.
In, not into.
Missing i.
The, not they.
Oh boy I feel sorry for the guy trying to do Prey's voice, nine-year-old is a tall order.
11171953
Save it. Make it a professional reading. Publish it for 5$ per chapter. You'll become a millionaire I guarantee. Once you reach the cliffhangers you'll have an audience for life.
Too bad, it would probably fall under copyright for making money of a universe based on Hasbro's intellectual property.
Going back to finally reread this, wow… How much has changed in almost 100 chapters
leave replace tray —> place the empty tray
Their village had been on the wrong side of the border —> Forest maybe? He was still in Equestria
two possible exit—> two possible exits
for the village—> to the village
Celestial personal elite guard—> Celestias’ personal elite guard?
11173815
Thank you for the edits. 😄
How I would love that Prey erased my memory (Prey And A Lamb) and be able to "read" this with the innocence of the child ; If so, I would be the happiest ignorant and envied by everyone.
Alright, there's chapter one recorded. Had some fun with my power supply dying and losing my audio. Unfortunately we never got Tara Strong to voice Prey, despite our most mediocre effort. Anyway, I've got two edits I remember from this, only one of them being because it induced a flub. Anyway, those two edits in bold.
Extra plural.
Missing an s on that there seven.
Man this is gonna be a lot of work.
11192575
Thank you for the edits, unfortunately, it seems those will always be needed. There is always "One more" mistake to correct it seems. But thank you and good luck.
I want a side story depicting how Prey got caught.
This is literally the only paragraph in the whole story (i think) that tells how he got caught.
What “Forbidden knowledge?”
What was the trap? Was it an ambush or something more complex?
I'm doing a re-read, so this question has spoilers in it for the end of the story:
I thought he was imprisoned by Celestia's decree? I don't recall that it's ever stated how he wound up in Dreverton, but Celestia saw straight through the glamour on him to his true form when she forced an audience with him; Luna was on the moon when it happened so she wouldn't know anything about his original imprisonment. And everyone within the prison knew of Prey's abilities. So who exactly put him here? Wouldn't Celestia be well aware of a mindleech being at Dreverton and wish to see him?
11601521
No, it wasn't Celestia directly. If you recall, Prey never actually went before Celestia to be sentenced. It was the Border Guard command who sent him to Dreverton directly. Hence, Celestia would've only received a report after the fact, and would not have seen Prey in person. Maybe a photo, but that wouldn't let her see through the 'glamor' second-hand.
now I can take Prey with me <3!
https://www.deviantart.com/ilubatar/art/Gossamer-Prey-Presa-y-un-cordero-camiseta-1019495831
11820385
Ha, would you look at that? 🙂 It'd be funny to hear if anyone recognizes the reference when you wear it.