• Member Since 10th Sep, 2017
  • offline last seen April 2nd

BradyBunch


You are going to LOVE ME!

Comments ( 36 )

Meh.

At least it wasn't a bad story.

Odd and funny. That's what MLP is all about.
/)

9208094
Its a well written story mechanically, couldn't find and issues with structure or grammar. Plot wise, while well executed, has been done before (pony A asks pony B question, they have their mind blown, shenanigans ensue).

It's ok, at best. I did give it a thumbs up and I wouldn't have added it to a book shelf if it didn't have some merit.

Okay, who is Firestorm and why is he so stupid?

One final message from Firestorm vibrated through the crack. “Pone Valpone dies at the end!”

(Meanwhile in the BurningVerse)

Eclipsio was busy reading his book in the new vision pool when the voice of Firestorm came through on accident.

Coincidentally, it was the very same Book Twilight was reading, well... not exactly.

Eclipsio was peering over Twilight’s shoulder via his vision pool, he was far too busy with preparing his project to worry about literature for himself.

Firestorm’s voice came in, and the Prince responded accordingly.

“He WHAT?!” Screamed Prince Eclipsio, jumping to his feet and drawing his sword.

He screamed into the rafters of Black Sun’s base, a scream of pure fury.

”DAMN YOU FIRESTORM! ONCE MY PROJECT IS COMPLETE, I WILL HUNT YOU DOWN AND SKIN YOU ALIVE!”

Comment posted by Golden Fang Ryu Shenron deleted March 13th

Meh, I don't know why, but I find it quite boring actually.

I just had a fucking aneurysm.
What the fuck.

9208337
Firestorm's an OC. He's acting like this because who the heck is going to stop him?
9208345
How coincidental that they both were reading the same book...
9208634
Your comments are always the best, man. I love seeing how excited you get for my work! :pinkiehappy:
9208719
Eh. I can't win them all. Any idiot can go through life without taking a risk. Thanks for letting me know I can do a little better! :pinkiehappy:
9208789
But was it a good aneurysm? If it wasn't, I hope you get better, but if it's because you were so taken away by this, I did something right. I shall continue to shock and confuse readers in the future!

9209123

Well, for some solid criticism for you to work off of, first there is this...

And so Twilight bathed in the light behind her from the open window, getting through Les Miser Stables in the comfort that this was her time to enjoy it. She didn’t notice the reflective light off the crystals holding up the room’s ceiling. She didn’t notice the moth that had flown in and was resting on the floor. The story was simply so immersive that it made her become Pone Valpone, and feel all of the troubles he was seeing and experiencing.

That whole bit about the moth and the light... the way it was worded, all mysteriously hinting that something is going on... I was thinking that moth was plotting something, like he was discord in disguise... Otherwise... Why divert the reader's attention towards... a moth. I mean, what does that have to do with anything? It was only made worse with the bit about how the light was shimmering, reflecting off those crystals making me think there was some magic going on there...

Another thing is how Firestorm just drags on, you are just overdoing him. The stuttering is downright unnecessary, and most of the rambling is downright pointless... Not that rambling, or stuttering can't be useful in a story, but here it just drags on until you get to the meager punchline. Maybe if there were some other characters in the room, reacting to Firestorm's obnoxious personality in there own way, or if there was something deeper and more layered going on here, it would be better.

The thing is, as for depth, you might as well go on a quest for the Holy Grail. It would be easier than finding a comedic oneshot with actual depth to it, and the other one just isn't the case. It for the most part is Firestorm being his obnoxious self, and Twilight just going through the motions with him.

Not that it is horrible, just that it is... boring.

Pff Ha! Hahaha! Fantastic! Said Rainbow. :rainbowlaugh:

Comment posted by Golden Fang Ryu Shenron deleted March 13th

9209219
Oh, okay. My reasoning was that if you could build up a character that you liked to read about before the punch line, it would make it so that even if the punch line wasn't very good, you would still enjoy it because you like the character.

9209987
In some cases, perhaps. It is just hard to enjoy a character who is either obnoxious, annoying, antagonizing, etc.. It could have helped if you popped in some funnier jokes throughout, or like I said, some other character interacting in the story, or just about anything which could tune down his obnoxiousness, or if that's not good, at least spread it out.

“Okay, that was a little weirdly worded. Wittle weirdly worded.” He waved aside an invisible fly. “But nah. I came to ask you something truly important.” He leaned in closer to her, stared her in the eyes, and put both of his hooves on the side of her face. He stayed like that for a few seconds, then asked, “Are you bread?”

:facehoof: You have got to be kidding me.

A creak came from the library doors, and Firestorm poked his curious head through the crack. “The cookies are on the top shelf, right?”

You deserve no cookies for wasting my time:twilightangry2:

9210424
Wait, did I waste your time? I'm sorry :fluttercry:

9211085
Not you - this story was silly and deserved the upvote and fave.

Firestorm, however, is a right git for spoiling a story for Purple Smart!

921108
Of Course Not!!! :pinkiesmile:

I enjoyed the story, it was funny. :pinkiehappy:

I just read this story, and I can definitely tell you it is definitely random.

He needs to play "I am bread" lol

“Okay, that was a little weirdly worded. Wittle weirdly worded.” He waved aside an invisible fly. “But nah. I came to ask you something truly important.” He leaned in closer to her, stared her in the eyes, and put both of his hooves on the side of her face. He stayed like that for a few seconds, then asked, “Are you bread?”

Twilight: “Ah... What!?”

Me: *Sighs* :facehoof:

9307217
...but did you enjoy it?:pinkiehappy:

Well this was certainly random.

And silly :rainbowwild:

As you have requested, your Review. :twilightsmile:

You know? He just put his balls on the line and lost... as that was a pun and not an important question...

That spoiler at the end hurt the most :fluttershbad:!

“Now, I really am bread,” Firestorm continued nonchalantly, as if he was ordering dinner. “I was bred by my dad. Are you telling me that you weren’t bred at all when you were younger? If you weren’t bred, how are you even here?”

So unexpected, so funny :rainbowlaugh:

This is a great story! Loved it. “Are you bread?” Hahaha! I’m gonna use this now.

Well, that was productive. XD

Keep up the good work. :)

This is both ridiculous and hilarious........

Its clear why I have never heard of Firestorm before...Twilight killed him didn't she?

One final message from Firestorm vibrated through the crack. “Pone Valpone dies at the end!”

Oh you MONSTER. :pinkiegasp:

Spoiling a book someone is reading is a crime of the highest degree!

Login or register to comment