I Just Want A Comment 3,022 members · 12,065 stories

This group is made for people who just want feedback on their work.

And not those silly likes or dislikes. I'm talking about solid comments with words in them that tell the author exactly how you felt about their story. Come on, now...

First, though, why don't you introduce yourself?

And as always, don't forget about the rules!

Join our Discord server! Click the image below for the link. :twilightsmile:

Wanna take a look at groups like this one?


If you'd like more visibility for your story, be sure to promote it in the main forum, rather than the group thread here. That way, you can be sure that many, many more people will see your promotion!

Comments ( 422 )
  • Viewing 403 - 422 of 422

432657
a 1000 thank you’s.

:pinkiesmile:

432553

Probably better if you post a full thread on that here, rather than down in the group comments where most people won't ever see it. :twilightsmile:

how do I draw more viewers to my story without advertising on other peoples stories?

Comment posted by Element of Malice deleted May 24th

432334
It's best if you promote your story in the forum, rather than here on the main page. That way, you are much more likely to be noticed.

Hello! I am a new writer that has been working on something for a very VERY long time but it basically turned into a 1.5k long story made from parts of 3 stories instead. I would absolutely love feedback so I can improve it!
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/394529/deep-thoughts

432192
Yeah, I know how that feels. But people are entitled to their own opinion, after all. If things don't seem to click with your target audience, go ahead and look around to see who it might appeal to.

432189
I know, write for myself and all, but it is very unmotivating to see someone doesn't like your story

432178
Hey, never hurts to try. Even if you do end up receiving negative comments, just pull yourself up and keep going! You are the one writing. It doesn't necessarily matter whether or not others may like it, so long as you enjoy what you do. :twilightsmile:

I feel like this was exactly the sorta group I need... But now I'm gonna upload a story to this group and have comments be... Negative...

432164

432165
Not necessarily down, but yeah, the group founder and old admin both haven't been on in years, and following the incident when Avengers: Endgame spoilers were spammed in the forums, I ended up getting promoted in the group by the sitemods.

Since SweetAI Belle has so much more experience in running large groups, I also pulled them in as Co-admin as well.

But yeah, we're trying to pull the group back into relevance, starting with the new icon and banner! :raritywink:

432164
I didn't know it was downed.

This group has been revived? :pinkiegasp:!

Note: If you'd like more visibility for your story, be sure to promote it in the main forum, rather than the group thread here. That way, you can be sure that many, many more people will see your promotion!

Just be sure to follow site and group rules! :raritywink:

Hello, my name is Animefan608.

I write crossover stories to express my imagination. Now my writing is not the best and I sometimes leave some spelling here and there (which I fix if I see it.) but at least it's readable and I'm always okay with anyone who wants to be my editor. I would like to know about other people's feedback. Mostly about the direction I'm taking the plot of the story or how I'm telling it.


My latest story is https://www.fimfiction.net/story/436125/equestria-girls-a-cruel-angels-thesis

Music for Ambiance

Greetings to you, Readers.

I am known as the Scribe of the Nightwings! A rather new addition to the site who hopes to share his story with others. The story I present to you is My Little Pony: The Pyres of Friendship, a crossover fiction between MLP and the videogame Pyre, by Supergiant Games.
After a spell goes wrong, Twilight finds herself in a whole new world, in a land known as the Downside. This land is reserved for exiles of a civilization known as the Commonwealth, where literacy and even books themselves are banned. Injured and stranded, it seemed like Twilight would never see Equestria again. But there is hope.
For there is an ancient tradition in the Downside that gives these exiles the opportunity to achieve freedom and leave their prison forever. Will this freedom get Twilight back to her home? Read as the alicorn joins with a group of sympathetic exiles as they make their way across this wasteland to finally gain their freedom.
Will Twilight be able to lead this band of exiles to victory? What will happen when Twilight finds out that all of her friends have been sent to this world as well? Only time will tell.
Let the Rites commence!

Updates will arrive for this story between one to two weeks. A comment would be very helpful for me to improve my writing and make this story better. Thank you for the consideration and may the Eight Scribes watch over you all.

LOXALAS!!!

  • Viewing 403 - 422 of 422
Join our Patreon to remove these adverts!