The Writers' Group 9,352 members · 57,096 stories

A general lounge group for all writers for discussion of writing and ponies. Write, Read, Comment.
-The Writers Group


Announcements:

Where to go next:

Groups we recommend:

Fading:(Feel free to suggest more active places or drum up activity!)

People who run this group:

Comments ( 1341 )
  • Viewing 1,322 - 1,341 of 1,341

So I’m currently watching the anime “Heidi girl of the alps” and “Katri girl of the meadows” and I had this thought for a story challenge if anyone is willing to take up the task: Diamond tiara/silver spoon/babs seed has to live in the countryside ( think like close to Canterlot/away from ponyville in remote countryside like in Finland or Switzerland) to live with an elderly relative and learn to improve their attitude (in the case of diamond or silver) bc her parents have to work to regain their wealth/her parents can’t afford to raise her so they must take work outside manehattan. Along the time they spend there they learn that country life isn’t so bad and that it’s bc of them that ponies like her can eat and live how they do and comes to appreciate their way of life. If anyone is willing to take up this idea plz credit me in the description of said story for the idea. I’d do this task myself but I don’t feel confident enough in my own writing to take up such a task. Hope you all have a wonderful day/evening/night and God bless.

ATTENTION!

Is adding like mp3 embed links available? I wanna add a soundeffect in my story. How do I add soundeffects?

448886
Thanks for the recommendation!

448823
This is a Group for fleshing out writing ideas and techniques, not for reading and commenting on individual stories. For that, you want Groups such as: No Author Left Unnoticed! or I Just Want a Comment.

Anyone want to collaborate on writing fanfic?

I've already written 6 chapters, and I'm stuck on chapter 7 because I'm not good at writing sex-and intimate scenes. I have ideas but I don't know how to express them. I want someone to collaborate with me to write these scenes, and I will give you credit for your account for your collaboration with me.

Comment posted by phil jones deleted June 12th

Hey! I would appreciate it if I could get some professional feedback on my masterpiece!

TAll Day, Everyday.
Follow the journey of a little girl who takes her football to the next level!
Penanka72 · 143k words  ·  121  19 · 1.1k views

Thank you for reading friends!

OP

448797
No problem!

448795
Thanks for responding to my post, thanks for the advice, although I have already changed many elements of the story. I have even changed the name of the protagonist, now it is a completely different story

OP
OP #1,331 · May 25th · · ·

448660
You may get more engagement by posting on the forum, but allow me to provide my opinion.

1: power can be defined as many things, but I’m assuming you mean the ability for one to assert themselves over the world around them. Powerful characters are not bad, you just need to make it believable in the setting. For instance, a physically weak character may domineer over others through wit. On the other hand, a near unstoppable fighter may be easily flattered and finds themselves being manipulated by a false friend. There are many ways to balance a character and some options don’t even require taking away any of the raw strengths. It all depends on how clever you can be.

2: I’m of the opinion that fan fiction is fiction written by a fan, therefore you can do whatever you want, no matter how far it deviates from the source material so long as you have the AU tag. Many do not share my opinion so take this with a grain of salt.

3: I would suggest you rework the OC. No offense, but he seems a bit generic and juvenile in design. His sword as a cutie mark might work narratively if you can justify it. Maybe he’s from a family of blacksmiths and he had a talent making and honing blades. Keep in mind that it’s agreed upon that cutie marks are achieved in childhood, so you’d have some explaining to do if you want to justify a foal being good with a sword. It can be done, just difficult.

Also, the red iris thing should be tossed. If you can justify it in the story then I suppose you can keep it, but, again no offense, it’s kind of basic. Like “evil robot has its eyes turn red,” trope. First, how do his eyes turn red? Is it a biochemical reaction (can of worms that you don’t want me going into) or is it magical? What are the consequences of this ability (if it’s just for show then it might not be worth including)? And can you explain the ability in a concise way? It seems like a lot of work for something most readers will see as a trope.

4: All personalities are generic and unique at the same time. People will do their best to be original while falling into groupthink and at the same time they will have ridiculous quirks that let them stand out and define who they truly are. Don’t get hung up on if the personality is too generic. The important thing is that the character has consistent traits that act and react to the events of the story. Keep a note pad to list out starting traits and it will give you ideas on what kind of conflicts the character may encounter.

Good luck writing, it’s a lot of fun!

Comment posted by SpiralKingdom deleted May 3rd

Hello, I am a new writer who is writing his first story in fimfiction, I need some advice to be able to write a good story as possible, so I have some questions so you can help me:
1.How can I make the protagonist of my story not so powerful but at the same time not be useless?
2.Should there be seven elements of harmony instead of six?? (my story is set in an alternate dimension of Equestria)

3. What name should I give to my protagonist?? (He is a black male unicorn who has a white sword as a cutie mark, but he has one unique thing: his eyes can show his emotions, for example when he is angry, his irises turn red)


4.How can I make the protagonist have a good personality that is not generic?

That would be all my doubts that I have so that you can help me, I hope you have a good day or night, it depends on what time you are reading this publication, bye

448546
Don't know if I'm too late but here goes: (I'm no expert, this is just on the top of my head)
First, chose a type of comedy. Is it pun-based, absurd, situation-based, character driven, etc?
Pun-based rely on puns. (duh) It can be from the narration or the characters.
Absurd and situation-based can be very similar, but in one, almost everyone is fine with the world not making sense, while in the other, only a few characters or things aren't making sense. (ASDFMovie is a good example of the first one, the second one would be your typical Pinkie comedy)
Situation-based can also occure if everything is perfectly rational but the way it plays out seems unlikely. (FiM does that)
Characted driven is were the characters are overeacting. Your typical slice of life comedy anime.

Of course, you can mix. Either way, now you gotta write. Have an outline, but try to make unexpected funny turns while you progress. Something that doesn't make you go too far from the intended outline, but something that isn't spotted that easily. Comedy often works best when you know it's coming, but you can't see it. (Although there is fun in just knowing it'll happen and just wonder how it will play out)
I could go all day, but it really depends on what you do/want to do. Just, write it. If it makes you smile or giggle, that's a good comedy.

How do I write comedy? Cause I am trying to make a retelling scene of flash and Twilight's first meeting, with flash being awkward and trying to be funny.

448122
I'd advise getting Grammarly and looking up editors.

Also you can look up assistance groups to give you aid.

448120
Like I said, do you have Grammarly? It's helped me a lot with spelling mistakes and punctuation even sentence restructuring.

448119
I wanna know how to not get grammar issues.

  • Viewing 1,322 - 1,341 of 1,341