Comment/Review Trade 111 members · 689 stories

A group for writers who want to know what others think of their work, and are tired of simply getting likes or tracks with no input. Post a story here, then read another user's story and comment on it. If you get a comment from someone in the group, comment on one of their stories.
Submit stories you want detailed reviews on to the "For Review" folder.
This'll only work if people are willing to make reviews as well as request them, so check out the folders and read some stories.
Review Request form!

Comments ( 16 )
  • Viewing 1 - 16 of 16
Comment posted by Silver Inkwell deleted Jan 26th, 2017

New to this group.

Can you post incomplete/ non submitted stories for reviews?

Comment posted by Trainman2000 deleted Jul 23rd, 2013

So, I put mine on the Doc and returned the favor, but I have no idea how to put the story in the folder?
Maybe you can help?

Hey there,

I just tried to submit a fic to EqD and was essentially told that it was so bad that it's not even worth sending to the prereaders.

If anyone could take a look and tell me why, exactly, it's so shit, I'd really appreciate it.

Thanks a lot!

La Barata

Oh, this looks like a great place for me :pinkiegasp:
Bring it on world!

You are quite welcome!

As a leader of my own group, I can tell you that you don't get alerted for every comment made in your group. Only the ones that respond to comments you yourself have already made. I do wish it alerted us, though.

I added mine as well.

Ha! I added mine. Now I'm going to read. Mwahahahaha!

This is brilliant! :pinkiecrazy: This must be promoted ASAP, stat!

Edit; No one has submitted... Well then. I guess I'll just have to be selfish and take the initiative.

That's odd, I didn't get any alerts about these comments.

I'll gladly comply with this :moustache:

This is brilliant! :twilightsmile: Do hope dark fics will at least be allowed later on. If not, meh.:derpytongue2:

  • Viewing 1 - 16 of 16
Join our Patreon to remove these adverts!