It all started with a car battery, a taco, and dreams of home.

Then Sonata Dusk's plans to return to Equestria literally blew up in her face...and left three strangers from an even stranger land relying on her to help get them home.

Can a former evil Siren, two teenage freelance heroes, and a naked mole rat somehow find a way to send everybody back where they belong?

Sonata the drama!

Pinkie Pie challenges her friends to play a game in which they take turns being evil, with the rest of the players tasked to thwart the evil schemes. The stakes are high, and all of Ponyville is caught in the middle...

Several weeks after recovering her crown from Sunset Shimmer, Twilight Sparkle discovers she can communicate with her counterpart from the other world, who has finally arrived at Canterlot High. When Celestia theorizes that the portal can be re-opened, Twilight and her friends--as well as the OTHER Twilight and HER friends--decide to trade places, so they can learn more about each others' worlds. The only catch: neither party can return to their own world for a full thirty moons...

This story is now cancelled. Its concepts will (eventually) be retooled into (Mis)taken Identity.

So what happened at the Spring Fling, and why did Sunset Shimmer go to all the trouble of destroying the friendships of five girls who were no threat to her?

The Ponyville Business District, home of Rarity's boutique and the Cakes' coffee shop, is threatened by a greedy land developer's plans to build a new mall. Rarity decides to use the Spring Fling to promote her business by running against Sunset Shimmer. She couldn't have anticipated the horrible things that would follow...

This story contains adult situations, but nothing explicit enough to require the Mature tag.

This is the tale of the early life of Silver Spoon: her birth, her struggles with her identity, her discovery of her special talent...and her friendship with Diamond Tiara, whose influence changes her in ways she doesn't even realize.

Mysterious deaths and unexplained incidents plague Pony City.

A standoffish transfer student has a secret: she is a magical girl sent to fight evil.

She intends to complete her mission alone, but five others share her destiny...

Welcome to Pony City, where friendship is magical girls.

This story is on hiatus until after the completion of Persona EG. Sorry.

Now with its own TV Tropes page!

It is strongly recommended that you set your chapter formatting to Dark or Ultra Dark when reading this story.

A guide to the chapter titles can be found here.

(This story may contain some vocabulary unfamiliar to many readers. It is strongly recommended you open this document in another tab for reference.)

This story is a sequel to Let's Be Evil!

Pinkie Pie's at it again! This time, she comes up with a game for her and her friends to play wherein they randomly choose eligible stallions out of a bag, and have a month to make a love connection with the stallion they choose.

Seems simple enough, right?

...yeah, right.

COMMENT-DRIVEN STORY
Please remember to vote!

VOTING IS NOW CLOSED.

Now that Discord's reformed and friends with a princess and her entourage, he's decided it's time to assimilate himself into pony culture. With Nightmare Night coming up, Discord decides to get into the spirit of things by opening a costume shop in Ponyville. His amazing costumes soon become the talk of the town, and Nightmare Night fever is stronger than ever...

...but is Discord about to play the ultimate Nightmare Night prank on an unsuspecting Ponyville?