Page generated in 0.066 seconds
Total duration
848 users online
709,165 hits today, 2,328,677 yesterday
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Fanfiction
Designed and coded by knighty & Xaquseg - © 2011-2024
Support us
SubStar
Chat!
Discord
Follow us
Twitter
MLP: Friendship is Magic® - © 2024 Hasbro Inc.®
Fimfiction is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Hasbro Inc.®
So to be clear, was the baby going to be stillborn?
11739033
Yes. And it does say in the chapter.
Mmm, so you're going with the Nightmare and Luna being two different beings then?
Honestly, this chapter made me felt less emphatic toward luna.
There's this anime called 'black butler' about a boy who sold his soul to a demon, who become his faithful butler. When the studio gave in to yaoi fanbase, They decided to turn the boy into a demon, so the butler got to stuck with him for eternity because of his contract.
And that whole event was potrayed as somewhat of an accident, I still hate it with passion.
If I guess correctly, then Nightmare is similiar to that demon butler. Deep down is straight forward and pure to the most primal desire.
This... Luna purposefully find a loop hole and cheat. What's different between her Celestia? They ain't much different, isn't it? Doing whatever they believed is for the best and blindsidely dragged everyone along with them.
I do hope you do something worthwhile with it. I'd hate to see this to turned into Nightmare-bashing like that another human-nightmare transformation fanfic.
The new Luna kind of smell a little bit like anon the green guy. That could either be good or bad. Anon could be absolutely cool dude or a piece of shit while still have the same personality.
Will the mixed being they become once they retrive all their memorys go to their mother to talk
11739076
My best guess is that nightmare moon is a nightmare that luna employed insted of vanquishing. I do hope that luna and the human mc do have some sort of meeting, if anything maby she left a recording along with the memorys to say her piece to the new her after they have her memorys for context.
11739292
From the narration so far there wasn't a "human mc" at all, as it's made clear the baby Luna "inhabited" was stillborn ie no soul inside. "Lucas" is just Luna as a blank slate without her previous memories, and now what's happening is she's recovering said memories.
11739401
im thinking of them as diffrent people atm. while they have the same base personality proberbly they have diffrent lives and stuff. while the memorys might be his as lucas was luna there is the argument that he is still lucus, he might have lunas memorys now but is still basicly lucus.
We likely wont ever have a real example of this but it is a quite interesting thing to think about with things like this. If you yourself were a reincarnation of someone would you be them? what if i told you that you were a mass murderer from ages past? you dont rememeber that but does that matter? what if you got your memorys back? are you now them? a better question is are you still you at that point?
What im saying is i hope lucus goes home and hugs his mother. maby he can once rememebring lunas life then let it go. Luna died and now he is there.
I wonder what is gonna happen with nightmare moon though
Well, that is quite dark. There was only Luna inside the whole time. Does the mother still remember that the moon is her son?
Ya know.... I just realized... in the original series, celestia new she banished her sister to the moon. But in this fic... it has to look like she just forced the elements to obliterate her sister. Not just kill... erase. I wonder how that will effect her?
11739292
That's the same conclusion as my own.
But a creature of purity. One who follows their beastial desires faithfully like a contract demon.
I like those guys...
11739719
i thought part of the early chapters said that luna relised she would hit the moon so used some power to steer herself
11739770
Yah. She changed her trajectory. Which means that no face appeared on the moon. So from celestia's perspective. Luna was just gone, Vanished, Thanos snapped out of existence.
11739801
for all we know the moon could have decided celestia does not deserve to know what happend so could refuse to tell her that luna missed on purpose and insted let her think she killed her sister
11739805
11739801
*sipping tea*
11739759
11739292
11739514
the background is not bad, the logic is there, Nightmare Moon is not very crazy.
It just hit me, 2 days after I read this chapter, that this song fits, kinda:
Honestly a Really good story so far. Plus no discontinuation or indefinite hiatus within the first 15 chapters so thats a plus. Hope to see it continue on for a long time.
Is that a terraria reference?
Bloodmoon? That sounds very... Unlike any Unicornia, Earthpony, or Pegasi city... Perhaps some ancient alicorn city? Discord himself kinda begs the question of where he came from, perhaps some kind of old alicorn prison? I'm throwing out random ideas at this point.
Did you cut the scene of Celestia using the elements against Luna? I remember there being one before this
11837244
You should know, it’s unnecessary because that was already counted