• Member Since 25th Mar, 2015
  • offline last seen 15 hours ago

The Hat Man


Specialties include comedy, robots, and precision strikes to your feelings. Hobbies include hat and watch collecting. May contain alcohol.

T
Source

Stories about monsters disguised as treasure chests were thought to be no more than legends.

But when Sunburst finds the last one in existence, the Changelings come to the Crystal Empire with a demand: kill it and send the species to extinction.

This story is based on a suggestion by LordMentat!

Chapters (5)
Comments ( 46 )

Never enough stories with mimics in them. So this is awesome before I even start reading :pinkiehappy:.

The shopkeep rolled his eyes. “Typical collector. You tell them you’re selling an item associated with the probable deaths of a previous owner - or several of them - and they think you’re just being a salespony.”

Well, in fairness, despite fully knowing that reputation and acknowledging the fact there may indeed be a potentially grave danger to anyone owning it...you're still selling it anyway. :trixieshiftright:

Shining Armor blinked. “Wait… you mean you have changeling spies in the Crystal Empire?!”

“Let’s just say that I like to keep an eye on our neighbors,” Pharynx replied with a smirk.

Yes, "neighbors." "Neighbors" that, according to official G4 maps of Equestria, should be pretty much located on the other side of the continent from the changeling hive.

Not exactly helping your case here, Pharynx. :trixieshiftleft:

But when Sunburst finds the last one in existence, the Changelings come to the Crystal Empire with a demand: kill it and send the species to extinction.

This part makes this story sound like it needs a dark tag. Why doesn’t it have one?

I like this a lot, very imaginative, but the greatest mimic to ever grace fiction would take issue with this.

i.redd.it/kohgp4rejbz11.png

“Oh,” Shining Armor said, nodding thoughtfully. “So you’re the Changeling formerly known as ‘Prince?’”

Now this is the kind of quality word play I show up for.

Well, definitely looking forward to where this story goes.
Any chance the mimic is named Boxxy T. Morningwood?

Well this can only go well :derpytongue2:

Nice story so far! Though I figured it’d make more sense the chest to rip Sunbursts cape than his tail

Sunburst chuckled. “Sure thing. I actually have a few more adult games we can try too!”
Starlight froze.
“I’m sure you’ll love them!” he continued, not noticing Starlight’s uneasy expression. “We could try ‘Settlers of Catrot’ or ‘Agricolta’ or ‘Terra Mysticanter.’ They’re really fun!”
“Ah, right,” Starlight said, heaving a sigh of relief.

Well, what did she expect?

“Hmm… this is a tricky one. Starlight, could you go down to the library and look up a spell of unlocking for me? It’ll be under ‘U.’”
“Why would it be under me?”
He gave her a withering look.
“Oh!” she exclaimed, blushing. “R-right, the letter U. For ‘Unlocking.’ Got it.”

That's a good one.

“Sunburst?!” she called again.
Then she noticed a slight, almost imperceptible rattling from the chest, and her expression darkened. A trap!

“What in Equestria is that thing?!” Starlight shouted as she tried to pry herself free of the floorboards. “That treasure chest almost ate you!”

Treasure chest: "That's our revenge for you looting us all the time!"


Good premise!
I look forwards to see where it goes.


When I first read the description of the story I had to think of this picture:
derpicdn.net/img/view/2021/1/26/2538017.png
Source.

“Well, I didn’t tell anyone but you, Princess Cadance,” Sunburst protested. “I mean… I suppose there were guards who heard me frantically yelling ‘Mimic, mimic!’ as I ran through the castle doors.”
“Yes, and then they all got confused, thought you were playing some sort of game where they were supposed to mimic you, and started running after you and yelling ‘Mimic, mimic!’ as well,” Starlight said.

Guess the Crystal Empire guards got trained by the same guy who trained the Canterlot Guards...
Edit: It seems that was exactly the joke you were aiming for...

Cadance nodded, smiling at him. “Very well, Pharynx,” she said. “After we recovered it, we placed it in a cell in the castle dungeon. It’s being closely guarded as we speak.”

I wonder how many guards the mimic had already eaten by now.
(Considering the standards of guard training we saw earlier that's a relevant question!)

“It's a mimic. They are vicious monsters that are a threat to every sapient creature around them. But more than that, they are the mortal enemies of the entire changeling race. The one you’ve found might be the very last one, and I will not be denied when I am so close to finishing the Hive’s great work!”

Is he secretly just afraid of competition?
And how can he consider destroying treasure chests their greatest work?


Good chapter!
I enjoyed reading it.


Have another picture of a mimic:
derpicdn.net/img/view/2018/9/1/1822241.png
Source.

11771887
Glad you're enjoying the story.

And that image was very nearly the cover image for this story! :twilightsheepish:

Shining Armor drew himself up. “Hey, I trained them exactly as well as I trained the Canterlot Royal Guard!”

Talk about low, slow, and over the plate...

“Oh,” Shining Armor said, nodding thoughtfully. “So you’re the Changeling formerly known as ‘Prince?’”

Get out.

“Once we eliminated them all - or almost all of them, it seems - we snuck certain operatives into Equestria’s ranks to convince them that the danger was over and the revealing magic fields could be taken down....

(raises hand slowly) I have a question. Um... No, never mind. Some minor plot points deserve to just be hand-waved so the major plot points don't get overwhelmed.

You know, the mimic seems to be doing fairly well after eating Starburst's tail and most of his mane. Maybe they can be sustained by the end products (sorry) of barber shops, and kept in captivity as historical examples. Since they apparently don't require a breeding pair, just the one for now (behind glass) should do.

11772236

“Oh,” Shining Armor said, nodding thoughtfully. “So you’re the Changeling formerly known as ‘Prince?’”

You know what they say... not everyone will get it. But the right people will. :raritywink:

11772241

(raises hand slowly) I have a question. Um... No, never mind. Some minor plot points deserve to just be hand-waved so the major plot points don't get overwhelmed.

Well, now I'm just curious to see if I have an adequate backstory for whatever plot points you mean or if I'll have to make one up on the spot. :trollestia:

You know, the mimic seems to be doing fairly well after eating Starburst's tail and most of his mane.

Ah, someone else mentioned this, so maybe this is on me, but the gag is that Sunburst and Starlight were covered with the mimic's glue-like slime in chapter 1. After the mimic was knocked out, Sunburst tried to pry himself free from the glue, giving himself the equivalent of, well...

...that.

So the mimic hasn't really been fed all that well... but Sunburst is probably going to need some professional floor cleaners to get his "leavings" scraped off the floor of his attic.

:rainbowlaugh::rainbowlaugh::rainbowlaugh: The window scene was the best part of this entire chapter. Damn bugs!!!!

i’m guessing the agents snuck in were enthralled ponies

Equestria is filled with critters straight out of the Monster Manual, so this is fitting. :twilightsmile:

Also, Sunburst geeking over the mimic that almost ate him fits him so well. Time for Starlight to be the long-suffering (girl)friend and the sound of reason (unusual!).

“Ooh, ooh, ooh!” Twilight exclaimed, raising her hoof and waving it wildly.
“Are… are you waiting for me to call on you like some school filly?!” Pharynx asked.

:twilightsheepish:: "Uhm... no?"

Twilight froze. “Nnnoooo?” She slowly lowered her hoof, grinning sheepishly. “Anyway, Starlight, it’s believed that mimics are ‘sapiovores.’ They only eat intelligent, thinking creatures.”

So that's why it didn't try to attack the guards.

Her horn lit up and a box suddenly appeared on the table, landing on it roughly as its contents rattled.

For a short moment I was afraid this box may try to eat someone.
...Well, maybe later.


Good chapter!
I enjoyed reading it.

By the stars, we used to be one of the most feared races in all the land…

"You were also killed on sight when discovered in Equestria," noted Shining.
"Please. The only thing you ponies can execute is choreography. You couldn't even kill Thorax."
(Note: Wrote this before I saw later developments contradict it.)

This is quite the fascinating dilemma. Life is precious, but how precious is the life of an artificially created predator who feeds only on sapient life and has no ecological role? I suppose the question is whether the mimic can be reformed... and that's making a lot of assumptions about its ability to make complex moral and ethical decisions. Looking forward to seeing where this goes.

Yep, that's very much Pharynx's thought process. Makes total sense for him, even the nonsense.

Gotta say, really love how this chapter played out. Pahrynx' motivations make sense, and love how Starlight's response to the situation basically boils down to "I think you're right but you're doing it wrong". Also loved that spell.

Why didn’t you reply to my comment?

"But give him some credit: he’s got guts. Out of all the changelings, he’s the only one I’ve ever heard of to defy Chrysalis.”

More than that, he's the only one who both dared to believe the changelings could be better but also the only one who actively sought to try and refusing to accept the alternative, even if it meant going, alone, out into enemy territory on what could've easily been a foolhardy and/or fatal attempt to make peace with those enemies. And he succeeded on all accounts, despite the extremely uphill battle to get there that, as Pharynx points out, others tougher than he couldn't also do.

The hive honestly owes quite a lot to Thorax's bravery. Because he is brave. He just doesn't put it out on display for all to see like one stereotypically expects of a "brave" person. Because, to Thorax, it was never about himself, it was about the others he could help. :twilightsmile:

That's actually what Pharynx is missing here. One doesn't have to be physically tough, strong, or show force to be a good leader, much less the best leader. It's Thorax's kindness and good heart that's precisely that makes him such a wonderful leader.

11772276
But no one is mentioning the follow-up reference.

“Oh, don’t be silly, Pharynx,” Starlight said, “nothing compares to you!”

11778455
I affectionately refer to that as "The Bonus Round." :raritywink:

Ah, Pharynx. Who else could be so concerned about the changelings’ appearance on the world stage that he very nearly ruined it? Truly Chrysalis’s heir in terms of his ambitions shooting his stated goals in the foot. At least he’s sincere in his concern for the hive.

Also, brilliant showing from Starlight. Having experience on both sides of the moral divide provides a lot of helpful perspective.

Also also, glad my cheeky asides were inspiring enough to include in the story proper. :twilightsmile:

Looking forward to the conclusion.

11777962
Okay, fine:
It's not tagged "Dark" because it's not "Dark."

Despite the subject matter, it's still a comedy with Prince references and a few gags about changelings basically being bug ponies. The tone itself doesn't warrant a "Dark" tag.

If I was Starlight, I couldn't have resisted using that spell, either.

A solitary guard strolled down the stairs and into the dungeon. “Your shift’s over,” he said.
“Finally!” the first guard exclaimed.
“Wait, where’s the other one?” the second guard asked.

*suspicion rises*

“Oh for the love of the Hive, why do you even care?!” he shouted. “It’s a monster! It would eat you and everyone you love without a second thought! It has no purpose other than being a monster!”

Sounds like a fitting way to describe a changeling...

Please. The only thing you ponies can execute is choreography.

To be fair, they are very good at this.

“By the Queen’s spinnerets, you’re insufferable!” he snapped.

If it makes you feel better, I'm sure Starlight thinks the same about you.


Good chapter!
I enjoyed reading it.

An entertaining story so far, though I worry a little because the discussion here clearly shows that the story's conflict could fizzle out, and nothing since chapter one has matched its intensity...lots of talk of it being a pony-eating monster since, but it's now getting rather hard to see this as an actual problem (no ponies are under threat of being eaten, and none that we know were, and there's seemingly no way for that to happen again) rather than an abstract analytical discussion.

Also, why rated Teen? Unless I missed something, everything so far is very E-rated, tamer even than many shows on Cartoon Network. Are things going to possibly ramp up a bit, or is it just out of caution of talk of genocide?

It turned out, the old mimic’s offspring grew rapidly and reproduced much faster with a steady supply of food, and most of them were glad to take up a role as a sort of live-in guardian.

That...does raise a potential concern about mimic overpopulation though, especially as there is now nothing that will naturally curtail the population from growing too big, what with no natural predators or known enemies seeking to kill them anymore. And as they clearly reproduce much faster than they die off from natural causes...you might end up in a tribble-esque situation and be unintentionally overrun by the things. And good luck finding enough of these biscuits to keep them all fed then.

Otherwise, good that everybody were able to work out a peaceful solution that left everybody happy. :twilightsmile:

11849684
Eh, thought about it, but figured I'd keep it around for a potential sequel if I ever felt like it... or just for any potential fridge horror like what I've apparently wrought here. :trollestia:

Thanks for reading!

“And how did he know what they tasted like?” Twilight asked.

Well there's at least sixteen fics on this site that could answer that.

11849744
I was going to have Fluttershy start to explain this as the start of another shaggy dog story until I realized it was just as funny to leave it totally unanswered. :twilightsheepish:

A very odd story, but in a very wholesome, earnest kind of way.
The right mix of silly and serious that, in my estimation, is not too far off from G4's own writing.
Nothing that truly wowed me but nothing that I truly disliked either.

All in all, 7/10 for me.

"Visual Pun Spell"

And if he keeps being a pain, she might give him the bum's rush. (That one materializes a mob of Pony hoboes, which grab you, race to the nearest exit, and then chuck you out.)

This was delightful! I really love the worldbuilding and the tentative friendship between Starlight and Pharynx was delightful. Starlight's obsession with Dragon Pit was a very silly throughline.

you really managed to capture the feeling of an episode of the show, and that's tricky to do, so bravo. n_n

11850028
Ha! I'ma have to write that one down. :pinkiesmile:

This feels like the sort of adventure that, had it been in the show, it would've been a map episode. It needed very specific characters, with Starlight to stop Pharynx and Fluttershy to talk to the mimic. I suppose the fact that everything worked out without its intervention is probably a good enough explanation for why the map didn't send them.

Lovely work. It’s always nice to see a solution that can make everyone happy, and Fluttershy excels at them, especially with a little help from Discord to bridge otherwise insurmountable gaps. Heck, he’s another example of an apparent monster finding a place in society.

Thank you for a great read. I especially appreciate Pharynx as a white-hat intiltrator and that Discworld reference.

11851118
Thanks! This was definitely an odd story for me, but I'm glad its struck a chord with folks, and I'm glad you enjoyed it. I enjoyed writing it as well! :twilightsmile:

And yeah, it being me, I had to sneak in a little Discworld reference for those in the know.

Cadance gasped. “What?! But when—”
“I switched places with him when he went to the bathroom a few minutes ago,” Pharynx said with a smirk. He trotted over to the real Shining Armor. “I’ve disguised myself as a dozen different ponies in the last hour to see if your guards would catch on. They didn’t. Starlight’s right: you really need to train your guards better.”

In other words: Nothing we didn't know before.

“If you are going to suggest that the mimic and I have some sort of playdate and bond over our mutual ability to transform, I will be forced to ask what sort of weird pony drugs you’ve been putting into your crumpets. And then ask for a few to go, because they sound fun.”

I love this response!

Pharynx looked down at her. “Before you go in there, I want you to know that I think you’re very brave.”
Fluttershy smiled. “Why, thank you, Pharynx!”
“You are welcome,” he said. “After it eats you, I will tell my people to build a memorial in your honor.”
“That’s… um, nice?”

Certainly!

At first, the mimic said nothing. But then, as its slatted wooden sides creaked, it began to speak in a strange, guttural language unlike anything they’d ever heard. (To say it sounded ancient and profound like the eldritch song of a bygone era would be accurate, though it also wouldn’t be wrong to compare it to the sound of someone repeatedly trying to shut a suitcase filled with tapioca pudding.)

Ah, that makes perfectly sense!

Starlight had even heard of one that had grown legs and was working as a piece of living mobile luggage (and occasional bodyguard) for somepony named Two Flowers on his travels.

Neat!
Maybe they will one day turn into another changeling-like form.
But say, is this a reference to something else? It sounds way too specific to just be a random stand-alone.


Good story!
I enjoyed reading it!

Login or register to comment