"I'm not afraid of dying. I just don't want to be there when it happens." —Woody Allen
The Writers' Group56,454 stories ·9,300 members
One-Shots18,923 stories ·2,369 members
Alicorn Twilight2,144 stories ·2,853 members
Twilight is Best Pony6,382 stories ·3,070 members
Comedy4,739 stories ·1,292 members
Stories on Goodreads28,599 stories ·492 members
Despite Rarity having been the one to learn a proper lesson in the city of Manehatten, the others who went with her all had their own experiences in the big city. One in particular stands out in the mind of Twilight Sparkle, and she can't help but put it down in the journal she shares with her friends.
—————
Written for the "Rarity Takes Manehatten" Writer's Training Grounds on EQD.
MLP: FiM and Cover Art © Hasbro/Lauren Faust
Page generated in 0.346 seconds
Total duration
700 users online
973,046 hits today, 2,139,894 yesterday
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Fanfiction
Designed and coded by knighty & Xaquseg - © 2011-2024
Support us
SubStar
Chat!
Discord
Follow us
Twitter
MLP: Friendship is Magic® - © 2024 Hasbro Inc.®
Fimfiction is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Hasbro Inc.®
That last line.
Good job! You've earned an up vote and a favourite from me.
Yes, Spike, Luggage is heavy.
Seriously, the girls must have made the little dude carry at least five times his body weight. Little fella's got some power in those muscles.
3744001
He is a dragon after all. One could estimate his physical strength to be rather high even if his body is not much more than that of a toddler.
Wheels in Equestria are obviously magical. Even flying Pegasus wagons have them!
Trixie is right not to trust them...
You just summed up everything that was going through me head during that episode when Twilight was refused the cab.
Also that last line. Great job.
3744053
I kinda thought...If there's cabs, shouldn't a Princess have a personal carriage, anyway?
3744056 Also why don't they have a larger bedroom. Surely as a princess she has enough money to buy a penthouse even if no pony recognizes her ( which is just stupid anyway why does she even have a title if nobody cares)
Beautiful. I thought of a few of these as well (particularly the cabs, at least as far as speed went), but somehow I forgot about the weather being regulated! Maybe it was a few weather ponies in training that day, creating those mishaps?
You know, it didn't dawn on me at the time, but Fluttershy could've asked the bird to give back the carrot dog. Although, maybe they didn't think that was sanitary?
Princess Twilight Sparkle apparently needs a retinue and a magical hair-style to get noticed. Maybe she needs to invest in one of those Royal Guard driven sky-chariots? Shining could recommend some of the best for that job! And I imagine, despite being hard work, it could be something of an honor. (You're getting the royalty where they need to go and you're not in a battle. It's tiring, I'm sure, but less boring than standing around the castle the entire day. Hopefully you wouldn't get hurt. If I had the strength, I'd gladly do it!)
I think the episode captured the New York spirit quite well.
People don't care how important you think you are. This is New York.
The question of "how famous are the Mane Six" really is an inconsistency that's dogged the show for quite a while, even as far back as the season-1 finale. When you get right down to it, the Mane Six really should have far more social prestige and recognition than the show gives them, considering that they are (or were) the Bearers of the Elements of Harmony, which is only the most powerful magical force in all of Equestria, and that they've only saved the world from numerous world-ending disasters every time one of Celestia's old boyfriends breaks out of whatever can she sealed him into.
Not to mention that even before Twilight Sparkle ascended to alicorn status, she was still Celestia's personal student, and Celestia clearly considers her and her friends to be important ponies. You'd think everypony would want to be seen in their company and would be wary of offending them...
3744070
And guards. I can understand in Ponyville, where a new person would be noticed right away, Canterlot where there's a bunch of them anyway, and Everfree where nopony in their right minds would go alone anyway, but having the Princess who has been attacked by numerous super-powers, has an entire race of beings who may hold a grudge against her and are able to blend in anywhere, in a huge freakin' city, and Twilight doesn't even have a single guard?
Despite seeing the map of Equestria a few times you would think that the news of the mane six would travel through out the land. Then again, I'm guessing other areas just don't care and when it comes down to it the whole celebrations that have to do with Royalty anyway are probably just from Canterlot itself, Ponyville (obvious reasons), maybe Cloudsdale and the Crystal Empire. Every other place like Appleloosa and now Manehatten has pretty much has very little or non-existent reason to be associated with royalty.
Yes that was confusing I admit but as far as I'm guessing... The stories don't travel far or either no pony really cares. It's like when in your home country you hear about a tragedy that happened in another country and you really don't seem to bat much of an eye unless you're interested. But if said tragedy happened in your home country then yeah you're going to want to read about it if even once and your emotions and feelings tend to mix because it could have happened very close to you, 100 miles away, in another state. Maybe bad analogy but if you twist it, it can pertain to Twilight and her friends. No pony probably gives a crap about your accomplishments outside Ponyville, Crystal Empire, and Canterlot. Sure it might look bad for tourism but you got to remember that not everyone is going to be holding you up on a mantel while others are going to be saying that everyone has to roll out a red carpet just for you because you did blah blah blah.
I'm not defending what that pony did to Twilight, I was a bit surprised myself.
I joyed this a lot
I still wonder why the others didn't considered on having Rainbow Dash, the best flyer in all of Equestria, to either transport Rarity to the runway show and/or to transport the dresses for her? Rainbow is one of the fastest Pegasus in the known world, and she can maneuver easily in the air compared to the ground. Plus, she is quite strong since she has saved Rarity, Spitfire, and two other Wonderbolts while unleashing a Sonic Rainboom. Sure, she may not know where the runway show is, but Rarity could have pointed it out to Rainbow if she knows where it is.
I'm just saying.
Funnily enough, I was kvetching on my local pony thread about this very issue. At this point, the fact that nopony outside Ponyville in four seasons appears to recognise Twilight and co is becoming more and more disconcerting. (The fact that Daring Do is real and apparently no-one knew that either just makes it worse.)
Frankly, it's beginning to get to nightmare fuel territory, since I'm starting to ask WHY. Is there something wrong with the ponies? Are they THAT insular (which doesn't really match all that well with what we've seen.) Is this sort of thing being repressed, either for the sake of keeping the notoriously panic-prone citizens of Equestria calm or for the security of the Elements? If it's the former of that last pair, then it worryingly asks the question, what ELSE is being repressed?
Whatever it is, it's becoming clear there's definitely something wrong somewhere.
They do seem to do that to the little ones on occasion, don't they? (See also "Sleepless in Ponyville".)
I didn't even think to notice any of this when I was watching the episode, but now that I read this, my mental expression for the Manehattan ponies is simply this:
. Im sure that if Twilight really wanted to, she could get all of those ponies into some deep trouble.
Also, if it really is every pony for themselves, wouldn't you want to be nice to other people, in case they were someone big and important, thus maybe giving you a slight chance for an amazing opportunity? Didn't Coco kind of prove that?
You kinda just said what we were all thinking, just from Twilight's perspective. I like it.
I felt sorry for Spike during the whole episode.
3744172
Indeed, we can point, as a notable example, "Sweet and Elite" episode. At this point, the 6 Bearers have defeated Nightmare Moon and Discord, among other accomplishments, and even get commended by Celestia, and cheered in Canterlot's throne room, ater Discord is back to stone. Also counting Twilight as Celestia's personal student. And yet, the 6 of them are like perfectly unknown by Canterlot's nobility in "Sweet and Elite", and the five mares (except Rarity), including the princess' star pupil, are even called ruffians...
If she wants to be treated like a princess, she should fucking wear her crown
3748389
Generosity doesn´t apply to him, it seems. Not even Twilight complains about Rarity using her femenine charm to make him do what she wants (a kid, not less).
3746272
After the coronation, the brony fandom raged about how turning Twi into a princess ruined the character ( royal duties, being forced to live in Canterlot, immortality, etc..) so the writters went in the opposite direction. Maybe too much, after the first new episode .
Yeah, I agree is ridiculous.
3745981
That is exactly what I was thinking watching that episode.
3746272 To be a TV Trope stickler, it would be Fridge Horror and not Nightmare Fuel, but I'm with you 100% of the way there. It's getting creepy how little people actually recognize the mane six except at public ceremonies convenient to their importance, at which point they become super stars who would naturally get invited to do something important (Canterlot's Hearth's Warming play, Cadance's Wedding, Twilight's first Summer Sun Celebration). Maybe the Elements Of Harmony put some sort of blurring shimmer on them that makes it impossible for ponies to recognize them when they are doing disharmonious activities, or something. Or maybe the writers are just lazy about addressing the issue of fame.
Quite honestly, in my opinion, the entire letter/entry is nearly overshadowed by Spike's one line. Now I want a letter/entry that's just Spike ranting about how he's taken advantage of. Not taken for granted, or being useless, but being the pack mule butt-monkey.
3748389
They make him like Meg Griffin in Family Guy
3751484
3752814
Indeed. I should clarify I'm not saying that everypony should be mobbing them every time they go out, or at everypony should recognise them - but the fact absolutely no-one does, I find slightly disturbing. There ought to be the occasional nod to that here and there - not major plot points, but at least some acknowledgement.
Whichever way you slice it, as it stands though, it's not got good implications. The denizens of Equestria are either being influenced (probably magically, either by state or Elements) or astoundingly insular and self-obsessed and/or stupid beyond even humans levels. On my local ponythread someone dismissively suggested that, as evidenced by Daring Do, perhaps saving Equestria hijinks occur for many other ponies on a regular basis, rendering the mane six's efforts not especially remarkable; worthy of a few paragraphs in the local paper, but no more. I find that idea even more disturbing, frankly, since it not only undermines the elements, but suggests that Equestria is on a catastrophy curve to extinction and bad as, say the SCP Foundation (whom I heavily blame for making me see the Bad Things in this instance) is, only with public knowledge on top. (It would mean the various forces arrays against Equestria only need to be lucky once - Equestria needs to be lucky all the time.) Doesn't gel well with what we see of the show to me.
Note that the writer's intentions in not addressing it (presumably because they don't want to deal with it) are completely irrelevant - until they address it one way or another in the show, we are obliged to take what they show - and don't show - at face value and have to supply our own reasons why that is. And currently, I can see no scenario where this is a not a significant sign of a serious socital problem.
3753069
Spike is, sadly, a very downplayed character. Considering his usually down to earth perspective and sharp/sarcastic tongue, he could be the perfect counterbalance to the Mare Six´s antics, or even the Crusaders´
Even worse, in those few episodes about him, his I.Q suddenly drops into a single digit.
3744231
Considering its Twilight, giving her a guard would be the equilivant of saying president Captian America needs a secret service.
3744172
3754387
3752814
The way I see it, it works like this
Ponyville-Respects the privacy of the mane 6 and would rather not bring it up.
Canterlot- Sure you have saved the day, but what have you done for us 'lately'? As in, today. OR- Yeah, they saved the world...so what? They are still commoners *insert haughty lauigh here*
Manehatten- I DONT CARE IF YER CELESTIA HERSELF! YA AINT GETTIN NO CAB!
Basically, welcome to the Marvel universe way of thinking! Saved the world once or twice? Ok...but mess up once and we will turn on you. Villian caused the damage to the city? Blame it on the heroes! Sure, Spider-man has saved us about 345 time so far, but he is still a menance because of what that guy in the newspaper said!
Also, I wonder if the mane 6 want it this way?
3755052
For Canterlot, I kinda like the idea that they just aren't impressed, like every good Canterlot noble is some super-bad-ass hero (Makes things easier once you imagine Fancy Pants dressed as Solid Snake, which isn't too hard to do). This also leads to me thinking of Twilight as a Pony Tomb Raider, which is why she like Daring Do, because Lara croft, as hot and tough as she may be, will pretty much always be in Indiana Jone's shadow.
Twilight knows this and understands she still has a bit to go, Spike too, but they don't bring it up with the others because, to them, it's common knowledge...
I may have to write something for that...
3755073
Fancy Pants as solid snake
Lets see, Fancy as a badass high class assassin, and so much more.
But yeah, like you said, they just aren't impressed. This doesn't lower the accomplishments of the mane 6, oh heavens no, if we said that then we would lower the accomplishments of heroes like Spider-man or Nightwing who pale in comparison to the WORLD saving exploits of Captain America and Superman. This just shos that they are awesome in thier own way and their exploits are something that is just a little bigger than the high class badasses.
Wait, does this mean that Fluer is his Emma peel?
Ps. If you do write something about it, I will read it!
Lol
Basically all my complains about this episode in a nutshell. ( Do not get me wrong, I really liked the entire episode, but those stuff mentioned in the Dairy kind of annoyed me ).
On side note, Cadence and Shining Armor ( and Spike one time ) assisted mane 6 in fighting against Chrysalis and Sombra, so it was nice that mane 6 didn't had to do all dirty work alone again.
Also, Twilight could teleport Rarity around, even if not in a single jump, she could make short range teleports while Rarity point the way. Oh, and Dash being the fastest pony in Equestria, and also a strong athlete could fly Rarity to her destination in seconds. so yea. ( Pony pulling you in a cap help only if you are unicorn in very poor shape, if you are earth pony with not bad physical condition, unicorn with good physical condition or pegasus who can fly, you do not need earth pony to pull you ).
Also, Spike should write something like:
3755052
Let's be fair - some of my favourite characters ever are X-Men, but in NO WAY can you argue that the average citizens (and indeed, non-superhero politians, usually) of the Marvel (and to a microscopically lesser level, DC) universe are not cataclysmically idiotic, even more so than regular humans...
If it indeed is "everything is like a superhero universe" that ITSELF is clearly a rather large problem. (And if Equestria does indeed need saving that often, you'd expect there to be far more circumstantial evidence than we've seen. Whether or not you'd get it another matter...)
And ESPECIALLY in the current climate, aside from the animated side of things, I don't think anyone can accuse Marvel or DC's modal quality writing to be something that is at all desirable to emulate...
Lol Spike
We have two athletes, two unicorns, and a pinkie pie. Lets make the baby carry absolutely everything.
Sums it up just about right.
3755135
How about a little snippet? Here you go
3759821 one unicorn, one alicorn. :P
3750216 no.this is a bit out of Twilights character.Its just for humor.In the real show, she even states it in threes a crowd, she said-it twice actually- :Princess Twilight Sparkle part 2- Discord: "I didn't think you'll be the type of pony who would think she was better than everypony else..." I love Discord!! :P Twilight:"I don't think I'm better than anypony!" Discord:"Sure, you keep saying that."
Threes A Crowd:Discord:"So what if Twilight thinks that now that she's a 'princess' she's to good for me?" Twilight:"I have never con-"
Discord:"Shh!Im talking!"
Yeah, bottom line, no crown because Discord stole it and now owns it.
3984949 I was referring to the Twilight of this fic
3747245 that's true.about Twilight getting them into trouble if she ever felt like it.But that's WAY to OoC.Couldn she have gotten them in trouble before she was even a princess? :P
I think Sunset Shimmer would probably get them in trouble whenever the heck she felt like it.
Sunset:YOU!
Random Stallion:Me?
Sunset:Yeah you!Im going to report you to my teacher!
Random:What did I do?Whos your reacher anyway?
Sunset:Princess Celestia!
Random: umm..you.a little filly?Again, what did I do wrong?I have somewhere to be so...
Sunset: yes me!Ill have you now that I have awesome power!And your getting in trouble for wearing such an ugly scarf and trotting like that.
Random:If your so awesome, why is their a purple foal over there levitating a bear?
Sunset:WHAT?!
Random:*evil lagh*
Foal Twilight:Bear!Bear!
Bear:When I grow up, you'll be taking me on because a blue mare will show you off and you'll show her back!
Foal Twilight:YAY!
Sunset:there must be no witnesses...
3984954 I figured. :P Discord still owns her crown
3984977 Discord owns everything
3984980 he does look good in Twilights crown. T:
3984924 I sometimes forget that she has wings.
3988567 how dare you? :P
Did you watch Twilight Time?
3989416 Yes I watched it. I was so happy when they acknowledge her princessness.
3989462 I know right?!They finally realized there was an AWESOME pony princess living in their library!!!I love how that finally happened, yet Twi isn't a perfect little princess, like in the burger scene.Did you see how she ate those burgers?It was so adorable!In a Twilight-awkward-Princess sort of way. :P
3989574 I know. but then she had her serious moments like when she called all the childern out on not coming over to learn things. and then there was the sweetie belle who spent the whole episode scheming then in the end she learned a lesson on friendship and she did magic. best cmc can do magic now. I like this. This is a good thing.