Starlight Glimmer's Real Mother

by Mockingbirb

Starlight Glimmer's Real Family Tree

Princesses Celestia and Luna stood on either side of a philodendron with a broken pot, its soil spilled out onto the ground. Each alicorn gritted her teeth as they channeled beams of healing magic at the injured plant.

Twilight Sparkle put down her wastebasket and watched. "Girls," Twilight said, "if I'd known you wanted a houseplant, I could have just gotten you one."

Celestia and Luna grimaced as they stuggled to control the wildly gyrating vortex of glowing magical force. "Can't...talk right now," Luna said, "must...save it!"

A moment later, the philodendron's soil had been gathered back into the pot, and the broken pot's pieces melded together. "Phew!" Celestia said. "I was afraid we couldn't do it. After being dropped and broken twice in one day, that plant was in very bad shape."

Twilight picked up her wastebasket. "Is it safe now?" she asked. "For me to take out my trash, I mean?"

Luna nodded. "The danger is over. You may now use the trash can."

Twilight emptied her wastebasket into the can.

"So," she asked, "what was that all about?"

Celestia gave the purple pony a serious look. "Twilight," she said, "do you remember your entrance exam to my School for Gifted Unicorns?"

"How could I forget?" Twilight exclaimed. "That was the biggest day of my life!"

Celestia nodded. "Now that you're older...and probably wiser...and certainly more experienced in running a school...is there anything about that entrance exam that doesn't quite make sense to you?"

Twilight thought. "I guess expecting a five-year-old filly to hatch a dragon's egg is kind of ridiculous."

"Yes?" Celestia said.

"And...does a stressful exam like that OFTEN cause an uncontrolled magic surge? Those wacky side effects...a dragon baby instantly aged into an adult bigger than a house...my parents turned into potted ferns...NOOOOO!"

Twilight stared at the philodendron. "Is that plant SOMEPONY?"

"When your magic surge went out of control, and your parents were turned into plants," Luna said, "Celestia was able to reverse the spell and make them ponies again. But sometimes we are not so lucky. A few ponies are stuck as plants for good."

"So," Twilight said, "every time I was outside Starlight Glimmer's office and I thought I heard her having a conversation with nopony...every time she doted over her plant like it was her own child..."

"Or her own mother," Luna said.

Twilight stared at the plant. "That plant Trixie keeps trying to throw out is Starlight's MOTHER?"

"Yes," Celestia said. "I witnessed the transformation. Try as I might, I was unable to reverse the effects."

"So," Twilight asked, "I really wonder..."

"Oh?" Celestia said.

"When Starlight talks to her mother...can Starlight hear her mother talking back?"

"I don't know how to prove it," Celestia said, "but I think she can."

"Wow," Twilight said. "Just...wow."

"There's something about the architecture of that exam hall," Celestia said, "that seems to resonate in a funny way with the magic of a highly stressed five-year-old filly or colt, and amplify it. It brings out innate talent in a way that few other circumstances can."

Twilight glared at Celestia. "Wait a minute!" she shouted. "You're pranking me! Starlight Glimmer went to visit her parents just last year. She sent me a letter and a photo!"

Celestia explained sadly, "Her father divorced her original mother and remarried. So the ponies she visited were her father and her stepmother."

Twilight was struck speechless.

Celestia said, "Starlight doesn't like to explain her family history. She finds it very awkward."

"So..." Twilight said, "My parents were turned into ferns, until you turned them back. Starlight Glimmer's mother is a philodendron. Does this kind of thing happen to everypony who takes the exam?"

Celestia and Luna laughed. "Oh, heavens no!" Celestia said. "The exam isn't nearly that predictable."

"Is that...good?"

Celestia elaborated, "There was one other filly...Moondancer, I think. She accidentally invented a tragically flawed version of Haycarte's Method, sending her parents into a book. But nopony knows which book. So nopony's seen them since."

"That explains why she seems even more determined than me to read every book in Equestria. She's looking for her long-lost parents!"

"Yes. I'm afraid the whole thing left her with some...abandonment issues."

"At first she did a pretty good job of hiding how upset she was that I hadn't gone to her birthday party," Twilight said. "But it really bothered her, even years later. I guess that pony really does have some issues. I only hope I can be as good a friend to her as she deserves."

Celestia said, "Lemonhearts gave herself the ability to change into other states of matter."

"What?"

"She can become extremely rubbery and stretchy, or even turn herself into a liquid. Did she ever show you her famous party trick, where she pours herself into a beaker?"

"Uh...kind of? I never thought to wonder HOW she got her head stuck in a beaker in chemistry class."

Twilight said, "Don't you feel terrible about putting fillies and colts through that kind of stress? Telling us to do something totally weird and impossible like hatching a dragon's egg?"

"Oh, Twilight," Luna said, "You should be glad you didn't get an even harder question. Maybe something more cross-species."

"MORE cross-species than a pony hatching a dragon's egg?"

"How about hatching a foal out of a chicken egg?"

Twilight goggled. "Are you...is that..."

"Speaking of which, doesn't Scootaloo live in Ponyville now? How is she these days?"

"I know one of her friends was teasing her about being a chicken..." Twilight facehoofed. "I don't think I can deal with this."

"But Twilight," Celestia said, "these entrance exams are one of the most important magical resources Equestria has."

"What."

Luna said, "I know a five year old filly, not matter how precocious, doesn't have the magical experience of an older pony. But sometimes not knowing what's impossible is very powerful. Sometimes, when you carefully place a little filly right in the focal point of an insanely dangerous magical resonance, and challenge her to do the impossible...even if she might not succeed in the way you expect, you can still learn something useful."

Celestia said, "Flawed as Moondancer's spontaneously self-invented version of Haycarte's Method was, it was different from anything anypony had ever done before. I was able to learn a key technique from it. That's how I locked several dangerous ponies into my Book of Villainous Jerks. Now THAT'S a book we keep in the Restricted Section for a reason."

"Ah, yes," Luna said. "That book has given me many late evenings of entertainment." She grinned wickedly.

Celestia snorted. "Have I ever mentioned, Luna seems to have a thing for 'bad boys?'"

Twilight said, "Is this true? Celestia, you imprisoned ponies inside a book? Forever? Books should be our friends! Not our prisons!"

Luna said, "That book has certainly been MY friend." She slowly licked her lips.

"Oh, cut it out, Luna," Celestia scolded. "Twilight, I saved thousands of innocent ponies by imprisoning those villains. And it's not like you've never sent somepony to Tartarus. At least inside a book they have something to read."

"True," Twilight admitted. "But your entrance exam system still seems hard on the little fillies and colts who have to deal with the aftermath of a resonance-amplified uncontrolled magic surge. Do you know what that's like?"

Celestia said, "You seemed to take it well enough. I remember you jumping up and down cheering about your new cutie mark."

Twilight said, "Well, yes...I guess for me, it was worth it. Even though it was a bit rough being an unwed dragon-mother at the age of five."

"But Twilight, I'm so glad your mother Velvet adopted Spike and raised him as your little brother. That's another system that works well, for a lot of unwed mothers. You see? It's not all bad."

"It is hard to imagine my life without Spike. But I feel sorry for Starlight, and Phyllis--"

"Phyllis is an alias, to hide the plant's true identity as Starlight Glimmer's mother. Her real name is Ethel."

"I don't know if that makes it any better," Twilight said.

"And what about the Elements of Harmony?" Celestia asked.

"Okay," Twilight said, "what about them?"

"That was back when about half our entrance exam questions were based on poorly translated Chineighese fortune cookies," Luna said.

"Oh, really?" Twilight said sarcastically.

"It's the truth," Luna insisted. "I believe that exam question was something like, if you retranslate it into modern language:

A tree that is not but a tree,
but can protect all Equestri'.

That exam took the filly a rather long time to complete. But when she and the rest of the joint expedition returned several months later, with a map to the Tree of Harmony, and carrying the Elements, we were able to give her full passing marks."

"Did you turn her family into trees?" Twilight asked with some bitterness.

"Of course not!" Celestia said. "Although I believe the Tree of Harmony did adopt the filly as a sort of niece. But everypony got to stay in their own preferred species form, so it worked out fine!"

Twilight said, "You can't persuade me that asking five year old fillies to do the impossible is what keeps Equestria safe! That's crazy talk!"

Celestia chuckled. "Of course I don't ask you to believe that. Mares in their teens, twenties and thirties do their parts too. How many times have I asked you and the other Bearers of the Elements to defend Equestria from some terrible danger? And how often does it work out?"

Twilight mumbled, "A lot, I guess. But it's still crazy. Are we all crazy? Am I crazy?"

Celestia gently wrapped her wing around Twilight in a soft, feathery hug. "I know it's a lot to take in," the majestic alicorn said. "But if you're to be involved in running Equestria, you have to learn these things."

"It makes no sense! I don't understand how it can make sense!"

"My dear, you don't have to understand it. It's how things work. You just have to roll with it."

"Ha ha. It's like Pinkie Pie and her Pinkie Sense. Makes no logical sense. It can't possibly work. But somehow it works."

"Yes," Celestia said, "years ago, I had more than one reason for sending you to Ponyville, which just happens to be where Pinkie Pie lives."

"Now I know what I have to do," Twilight said. "This should just take a few minutes. Is it okay if I go do that?"

Celestia said, "You can catch up with us at Sugarcube Corner. I'm sure there's a cake with my name on it there."

"I'll do that," Twilight said. "See you soon."

Twilight picked up the potted philodendron and carried it back into the school. After a few minutes of puttering in a supply closet, she went to find Trixie.

"Trixie!" Twilight said. "Do you see what I painted on this plant's pot?"

"You're holding it the wrong way round," Trixie said.

Twilight put the plant on a table, and rotated it. "Read that to me," the purple princess demanded.

Trixie said, "Do NOT damage nor throw away this plant. It must be cared for and kept safe, by Princess Twilight Sparkle's royal decree."

Trixie laughed. "I don't think I've ever seen you issue a royal decree before."

"I'm not kidding. And one more thing! If you don't fear my royal wrath, or the wrath of Celestia or Luna, there's one more reason to treat this plant with respect and love."

"Oh? What?"

Twilight said, "If you don't want to get on Starlight Glimmer's bad side for the rest of your life...if you EVER want to be able to share a travel trailer with your little Glimglam again...DO NOT CROSS ME ON THIS! And if you ever decide you don't care how Starlight feels about you, or if you get angry at her or even decide that you hate her, the royal wrath part still counts."

Trixie sighed. "You are serious about this, aren't you?"

"Deadly serious. It's a matter of life and death."

Trixie said, "The Great and Powerful Trixie promises not to harm this plant. For as long as Starlight lets me, I'll make sure it gets enough water and sunlight."

"You'd better," Twilight said. "You don't know how much is riding on it. Do you know how much work Celestia and Luna put into mending this plant? Into healing it after you hurt it and broke it?"

"Did they really?"

"With my own eyes just now I watched them. I've never seen them combine magical forces quite like that before.

"And now," Twilight proclaimed, "I have an appointment to meet with the princesses and tell them, mission accomplished!"

Trixie gave Twilight a salute that was only half ironic, as the alicorn princess marched out of the room.

Author's Note:

This is my answer to a question posed by one of Pineta's stories.

The story image is part of a single frame from the show.

Comments

[Sunlight Rays]

I'm often surprised how authors seemingly pull out silly yet excellent ideas from their heads and then pull off writing a well-organized story with it. Good job!

[Xanderfox]

Would explain Tourchlight's obsession with his Pumky-Wumpky kind hard to have proper relationship with your wife when she's a potted plant.
Twilight's next projects are clear. A spell to detect books with somepony in them and co-project with Changelings on a universal transformation reversal spell

[Mica]

Intriguing idea, makes a lot of sense. But way too much dialog. It feels like a script rather than a story.

[VampDash]

This is amazing

[Mystic Sunrise]

Funny? Yes. Utterly stupid and not at all what's going on in the show? Very much so. Have a like anyway.

[Thought Prism]

This is a glorious string of hilarious headcanons in the guise of a narrative.

[TheHardie-Boy]

Well okay then...

[Wild Stallion]

Twilight glared at Celestia. "Wait a minute!" she shouted. "You're pranking me! Starlight Glimmer went to visit her parents just last year. She sent me a letter and a photo!"

Celestia explained sadly, "Her father divorced her original mother and remarried. So the ponies she visited were her father and her stepmother."

You do realize in the show that Starlight's Farther appears to be single with no sign of a step mother?

Twilight mumbled, "A lot, I guess. But it's still crazy. Are we all crazy? Am I crazy?"

In a word? Yes.

Great little head-canon you've got going here. Good Work.

[Mockingbirb]

Warning: the following is very silly.

10307396
I could guess, if Starlight sent Twilight a photo from her hometown visit, it probably had Starlight's father and Sunburst's mother in it. Twilight might have assumed that Sunburst's mother was Starlight's mother. Starlight really doesn't like explaining her family situation, so she'd just let Twilight keep thinking that. (Starlight also wouldn't have wanted to explain the pumpkin vine in the background was her father's mistress or common-law wife, as Xanderfox seems to have figured out.)

Either that, or I have a few too many levels of coverup here. Looks like you are able to handle the truth.

[Mockingbirb]

I'd like to thank you all for commenting. Reading different people's reactions to a story can be a big help to me when I think about how to write next time!

[Mystic Sunrise]

10307534
This is also called: the author didn't even think about this, or refused to, and was hoping nopony called them out on it.

Far more likely.

[Mockingbirb]

10308010

Realistically, in this case I was connecting my story to a lot of different in-show events and characters. When reviewing some in-show events and facts, I didn't properly review some of the evidences of Starlight's documented parent situation.

My previous comment about the discrepancy was intended to be, as labeled, very silly.

[Wild Stallion]

10307534

Either that, or I have a few too many levels of coverup here.

Layers upon Layers... And you know what that means!

We need to go deeper.

[PresentPerfect]

I rather wish you'd stayed more focused on the principle idea here, instead of going off on so many tangents. I mean, this could have stopped about halfway through.

That said, just reading the description made me laugh. I want to know what specifically in that other story inspired this. :)

[Sledge115]

I wish there was more to it, because this caught my eye by its very concept. Still, I liked it

[Mockingbirb]

10312033
What's the point about halfway through where you thought this story could have stopped?

[Mockingbirb]

10306403
"I'm sorry there was too much dialog," Mockingbirb intoned sorrowfully. "Maybe I can write a different story without any dialog at all, and then on average I can be a better writer, even if each individual story is still bad."
EDIT: Fixed my typo.

[Mockingbirb]

10306323
I expect this story responds to one of your points. (link).

[Mockingbirb]

10312033

I want to know what specifically in that other story inspired this. :)

From my perspective, Pineta's entire story implies the existence of the question that it seems to me to be answering. "Isn't hatching a dragon's egg a rather ridiculous entrance exam exercise for a litle filly, and what state of affairs could possibly explain it?" I simply posited a rather different answer to the question.

[PresentPerfect]

10313061
Ah, well that makes sense.

And it wasn't a particular event, just that there are so many tangents, the joke felt stretched thin. This might have had a stronger impact at a thousand words instead.

[FIM Fiction]

.... *smacks lips loudly.*
well then.

[FridayPie]

10308010
Question is why Starlight didn't asked Discord for help. Or why our Royal Purple Bookiness didn't try to research the problem :P

[Zubric]

Vscootalpo chicken joke made me facepalm. Well in the casual eye roll way

[Bicyclette]

well now you can switch out 'Other' for the 'Phyllis' tag if you want! otherwise, a fun exploration of the concept, using fillies not understanding the limits of magic to expand magical technology while also using this to explain as many weird canon bits as possible. you are good at coming up with ideas like this

[Tom Brahms]

Where's chapter 2?

[Mockingbirb]

10312033

I rather wish you'd stayed more focused on the principle idea here, instead of going off on so many tangents. I mean, this could have stopped about halfway through.

That said, just reading the description made me laugh. I want to know what specifically in that other story inspired this. :)

11165893

Where's chapter 2?

One of you thinks the story could have ended halfway through, and the other wants another chapter.
(shrugs)

[PresentPerfect]

11166159
there's just no pleasing people :B