• Published 16th Jan 2014
  • 2,184 Views, 56 Comments

The Carrot Dog Fight - xjuggernaughtx



Spike just wants to eat his delicious carrot dog, but Manehattan's birds have other ideas.

  • ...
2
 56
 2,184

The Carrot Dog Fight

Carl fanned his scrawny grey wings as his friend struggled back to their tree, a carrot dog firmly clamped in his beak. “Hey, hey! Maury comes through!” The pigeon took several steps to his left, giving his friend ample room to land with his heavy load.

“You shoulda seen the look on that mook’s face!” the red jay replied, sniggering. “Musta been a tourist or somethin’. He was just standin’ there with this dog, not even lookin’ at it. Like he ain’t got a care in the whole, wide world!”

Carl pulled a small bib from the nearby nest, tying it around his throat. “You’d think these ponies would be more on the ball, eh?” Pulling out another bib, he passed it over to his friend. “Seems like they get dumber every year!”

“This one wasn’t even a pony.” Maury took a deep whiff of the carrot dog. “Ho, buddy! You smell that? I’m so hungry I could eat a bus! We won’t havta eat for a week!”

“Good, ’cause I’m wasting away over here!” Carl drooled slightly as he rubbed his wings together. “I can’t even remember the last time we got this much grub! Wait...” He stared at Maury, tilting his head to the side. “Whattaya mean it wasn’t a pony?”

Maury shrugged. “I dunno. He was some sorta lizard-thing. They got all kinds of weirdos walkin’ around Manehattan now.”

Carl pointed a wing to the base of the tree. “Well, did he look anything like that guy?”

Maury yanked off his bib and threw it onto the branch. “Ah, nuts!”

“Hey, cool it.” Carl placed a wing on his friend’s shoulder. “That little butterball ain’t getting up here. I mean, look at him! He ain’t missing any meals, eh?" The pigeon tipped his head toward the carrot dog. “Well, besides this one.”

Carl and Maury stared at each other for a moment before bursting out laughing.

~~~

“Think you’re pretty slick, huh?” Spike said quietly while quickening his pace. “We’ll see who’s laughing when I take my lunch back!”

After the red jay had stolen his carrot dog, Spike silently fumed. Rarity had given it to him as a special thank-you present for all of his hard work, and he’d been ready to savor it. With his stomach growling, he’d gone to take his first bite when a small bird snatched it out of his claws. He’d scowled as the bird flew around a corner, nearly running into a wall as it labored to carry the heavy load in its beak.

He’d wanted to complain, but his friends were in the middle of another song; Twilight always hated it when he interrupted their performances. Spike was of the opinion that maybe the girls sang a few too many songs, but they just shrugged whenever he brought it up. Frowning deeply, he’d kicked at a loose stone, trailing along behind the mares as they belted out yet another heartwarming number about the power of something-or-other. After a while, all the singing started to blend together, and he never seemed to get a verse.

However, something interesting had caught his eye after a particularly vigorous kick. Squatting down, he’d noticed that his rock had landed in blob of mustard. And a bit further along the sidewalk, he noticed a dash of relish, followed by a little speck of ketchup. “Ketchup?” Spike steepled his claws. “Yeah, catching up’s exactly what I’m going to do! No bird steals my meal!”

The trail of spilled condiments led Spike to a small park. “Aha!” he cried, spying his thief in a nearby tree. “You’ve got to the count of three to hand that carrot dog over!” Crossing his arms, he scowled up at the pair of birds.

~~~

“Or what, bozo?” Carl’s eyes bulged as his feathers ruffled. “Oh, you wanna piece of the pigeon? Whattaya gonna do, fly on up here and take it? Unless you’re hiding feathers in all that fat somewhere, you’re outta luck with us, buddy!”

Maury shook his head. “It ain’t no use, Carl. You know those walkin’ types never speak Bird.”

“Well, whatever.” Carl strutted back and forth on the branch. “That yahoo got what was coming to him, even if he don’t know it." The pigeon stopped, staring incredulously at his friend. “The nerve of these creeps nowadays! You go through all the trouble of hunting down some food and they just come around looking for handouts! Like times ain’t tough enough for us already!”

Maury shrugged, spreading his wings. “I know. Don’t nobody wanna do an honest day’s work anymore.” He stretched his neck out, leaning over to squint at the angry… whatever it was. “Looks soft, anyway. This’ll be a good lesson for him.”

“One!” Spike drummed his claws against his arm as the birds squawked and strutted across the branch above him. “They’re probably getting feathers all over my dog,” he growled under his breath.

He waited a few moments. “Two!”

Maury scowled, retying his bib. “Sheesh, give it up! Can’t a bird eat around here without all this noise?” He leaned to the side, eyeballing Spike as he said the last word.

“Three!” Spike held up three claws for them to see. “Okay, you asked for it!”

“Yeah, good for you!” Carl yelled to Spike as the dragon stomped toward the tree. “I know a hippo at the zoo that can count all the way to five, but you just keep trying, buddy!”

“Whoa, hey!” Maury began backing away. Below them, the dragon sank his claws deep into the tree’s bark, hoisting himself up the trunk rapidly. “That little guy can really climb!” He turned to stare at his friend, wide-eyed. “You think maybe…”

“Yeah, I think you got the right idea.” Carl cocked his head toward the carrot dog, his eyes never leaving the dragon. “Grab that thing. Let’s get outta here!”

Spike was halfway up the tree when the birds took off with his carrot dog. Growling, he pounded his fist into the tree’s trunk. “Now what?” he said, watching them fly away.

“Maybe lay off the snacks next time, tubby!” Passing overhead, Carl stuck his tongue out at the fuming dragon. “Heh, look at the shmuck!” he said to Maury, sniggering. “Like he lost his best—holy crow!”

Both birds banked sharply as a huge seagull plummeted toward them. Twisting in midair, the gull angled in toward Maury.

GIMME DAT!” the gull screamed, snapping at the carrot dog. “You two take a blow to da head lately? You forget how it works around here?”

Carl adjusted his wings to catch a thermal, rising sharply away from the snarling sea bird. “Blow it out your tail feathers, Cecil! We ain’t no gulls and we don’t answer to none of you! You clowns think everything’s yours! We gotta eat too, ya know!”

“Be dealin’ with you in a minute, bub!” Cecil replied. “But for now…” He banked, bearing down on the overburdened red jay. The smaller bird flapped for all he was worth, but made little headway against the powerful gull. “…I got me a meal to catch!”

Pumping his giant wings, the gull soared upward. Directly overhead, Cecil’s shadow engulfed the panicked jay, and he grinned savagely. Taking aim, the gull folded his wings against his body and fell.

Maury gasped, losing his grip on the carrot dog as Cecil slammed into him. He snapped at it, but was too late: the massive gull snatched the carrot dog from the air.

“’Ater, ’umps!” Cecil grinned at Maury from around the buttery bun. “’Aybe ’ext—”

Cecil careened wildly in the air as a layer after layer of white, steaming liquid fell onto his face.

“And that’s why they call me a stool pigeon!” Carl yelled, diving after the carrot dog.

Below, Spike ran for the falling dog, his claws outstretched, but he pulled up short when the pigeon swooped down and grabbed it in midair. “Come on! Really?!” Spike threw his arms up, watching helplessly as the bird fly away with his meal. His stomach gave a long, rumbling growl. “For Pete’s sake, I just want to eat my lunch!”

Carl dove for the relative safety of the nearest tree but spread his wings wide, attempting to backpedal at the last second as the seagull cut him off. Flapping desperately, the pigeon searched for some way around, but Cecil's titanic wings seemed to be everywhere at once. He’s like a friggin’ wall of feathers or something! Carl thought, sweating a little, he searched for some way out. I gotta get away from him or—

“Wiseguy, huh?” Cecil shook his head, snarling. “Seems like we got two birds dat don’t remember howta act when they come to da waterfront! How many times we gotta tell you clowns?! We control da food on this side of the city!” The seagull pounced, locking his beak around the nape of Carl’s neck. Still beating his powerful wings, the seagull began tossing his head from side to side, shaking the pigeon.

“Hey—oof—ow!” Carl kicked and flapped, Cecil’s sharp beak tearing feathers from his neck. “Lemme go, you nutcase! I ain’t even got the dog no more!” Both birds looked down, groaning as the carrot dog landed neatly in the lizard-thing’s outstretched claws.

“Finally!” Spike’s claws closed around the delicious dog. “Nice try, birdbrains! Better luck next time.”

Inspecting the dog, he grimaced. It was a little worse for wear. Several beak marks scored the once-pristine surface of the bun, and the condiments were getting a little light. Shrugging, the dragon raised the dog to his open mouth.

“Oh, no you don’t!” Maury pulled out of a desperate power dive. Just as he reached the dragon, he unleashed several ferocious jabs with his beak to the top of Spike’s skull. The jay gasped, his head ringing like a bell. It was like pecking solid steel. Spike lowered the carrot dog and glowered up at him.

“Oh, criminy! My achin’ beak!” His vision doubling, Maury fought to stay airborne. “That thing’s skin is hard!” Distracted, he barely managed to dodge the clawed hand that swatted at him.

“Get out of here! Leave me alone!” Spike ducked as the jay careened through the air, nearly tumbling into the dragon’s face. “Somepony special gave me this carrot dog, and it’s—argh! Are you kidding me?!”

The momentary distraction had provided the gull with the perfect opportunity. Pouring on the speed, he’d snatched the carrot dog from the dragon’s claws. Laughing, Cecil flew away, clutching the carrot dog in his beak.

Maury took off after the gull. “Uh uh! No way, no how are you gettin’ that dog! We’re done lettin’ you guys eat everythin’! It stops today!” With his smaller wings, he knew he couldn’t match Cecil’s power, but he could use his superior agility to fly circles around the gull. “Carl, we gotta work together! Cut this joker off!”

“You got it!” Carl banked sharply toward the gull, growling. “It’s payback time!”

Cecil snarled something unintelligible from around the bun, staring at the pigeon balefully and angling away from a mid-air impact. Flapping and twisting, he barely got his head around in time to keep the red jay from snatching the dog. His smile lasted less than a second before Carl flew out of his blind spot and wrenched the meal from his mouth.

Cecil blinked in disbelief for a moment, staring after the fleeing pigeon. “Dat’s it! I’m done playin’ with you two!” His muscles standing out in cords, the gull growled, pumping his enormous wings. In a flash, he was on the pigeon, snatching a grey wing in his powerful jaws. Carl screamed as the gull began grinding the pigeon’s delicate bones between his beak.

Pouring on as much speed as he could muster, the red jay caught up to the burdened seagull. Spitting out obscenities, Maury yanked out two tail feathers from the gull’s rump. “Oh, didn’t like that, huh?” he yelled as Cecil turned to stare at him with a single, incredulous eye. “You think you’re so tough ’cause you’re big? Well, you ain’t got nothin’!” Maury viciously tore out another feather. “Nothin’!

“Oh, you’re askin’ for it, chump,” Cecil said quietly, spitting out the wounded pigeon. “You crossed da line!” Wheeling more adroitly than Maury had expected, Cecil grabbed the jay by the throat and tossed him into the trunk of a nearby tree. As the dazed jay fell fluttering to the ground, the gull swooped, catching Maury again in his webbed feet. Tucking his wings, Cecil dropped like a stone. "You're hungry, huh? Then eat dirt, wimp!” With a roar, Cecil launched the red jay at a large rock as he pulled out of his dive.

A few yards away, Spike stood, blinking. “Wh-what’s going on here?” His gaze travelled back and forth between the three birds. “I thought they just wanted my lunch...” Frowning deeply, the dragon ran toward the massive gull. “Hey! You leave that bird alone!”

Maury felt several feathers snap when he slammed into the stone. Gasping and coughing, he cracked one eye open to see Carl wheeling around, trying to get back to him. “No!” he croaked, attempting to wave the pigeon away. “Get outta here!”

“Good advice.” Zigzagging in for a haphazard landing, Cecil glared at the jay. He flexed his ragged tail frantically, attempting to keep from crashing into the ground. “Think you’re pretty cute, pullin’ out tail feathers, huh?”

Landing in a heap, Cecil quickly rose, dusting himself off as he walked to where Maury lay. Somewhere behind him, the lizard-thing was yelling, but Cecil didn’t pay it any mind. If it needed a reminder of who was on top in this town, he’d be happy to oblige. He just needed to deal with these two misfits first.

“Too bad you were too dumb to take your own advice when you had da chance.” Looming over Maury, the gull allowed a menacing smile to slowly stretch across his face. As the jay tried to scramble away, Cecil stepped on Maury’s tail feathers, pinning him in place. “Nobody comes to da docks and treats gulls like chumps.” The gull leaned down, his face nearly touching the bleeding jay's. “Nobody. Now I gotta teach you a hard lesson. Hope you weren’t too attached to flyin’, ’cause after today, you’ll be walkin’ everywhere.”

“Not gonna happen!” Carl swooped in and stabbed at the gull with his needle-sharp beak. Crying out, the gull threw his wings over his head.

“What are you? A total friggin’ moron?” Cecil yelled. “Here I was, out of da goodness of my heart, tryin’ to cut you a friggin’ break, and you come back for more?” The gull snapped at the pigeon, lightning fast, plucking him from the air, and slamming him down next to the dazed jay. “Have it your way, pal! Ain’t no feathers off my back if you need a little reminder, too. I can readjust two attitudes as quick as one!”

Carl and Maury waited, hiding behind their wings. Above them, Cecil reared back for what was sure to be a crippling blow.

“Sorry,” Carl whispered. “I tried.”

Maury swallowed hard. “I know you did. You’ve been a real pal over the years. At least we went down swingin’, huh?”

The gull rolled his eyes, grinning ferociously as his beak stabbed down at them. “Dat ain’t gonna be too big a comfort when—”

Cecil leapt into the air, his tail feathers ablaze. Squawking and beating his tail with his wings, he landed heavily several yards away. The two friends’ mouths fell open as they watched the gull disappear into the brush, managing to ignite a few dead branches along the way. Slowly, they both swiveled their heads to where Spike stood, breathing heavily. Thick smoke was still pouring out from between the dragon’s lips. Both birds turned to look at each other, swallowing hard.

Maury’s eyes widened. “Holy crow! That guy can breathe fire!

“He… he coulda fried us whenever he wanted to,” the pigeon replied in a faraway voice. As the dragon walked over and retrieved the carrot dog from where Carl had dropped it, both birds sagged, defeated.

“Ha! Finally!” Spike tipped his head back and opened his mouth wide. He was about to drop the entire carrot dog in when he spied the bedraggled, shivering birds, their wings still wrapped around each other. Spike sighed as they stared longingly at his meal. He lowered the carrot dog and squinted, scrutinizing the birds. They're… they're so thin. Scowling, he trudged toward them.

Maury chuckled weakly, his eyes frantically darting around. “Ah, heh-heh! Now, about takin’ that carrot dog…”

“Here,” Spike thrust his lunch toward the battered birds. He grimaced, his stomach growling in protest. “Take it!” Screwing his eyes shut, he still looked away, and the birds stared back up at him, their eyes wide and unblinking. “Look, I…” The dragon sighed, slumping as he looked down at his meal. “My friend gave this to me—a really special friend. That’s why I was so mad that you took it.”

Spike squatted down, his frown deepening as the birds flinched from him. “But you guys look like you don’t get enough to eat. I guess that seagull must be stealing your food, and, well… you guys stuck together, even though he was bigger than you. Where I come from, friendship like that says a lot.” Leaning toward them, Spike rested his elbows on his knees. “Look, if I don’t eat this, I’m going to be hungry until we finally go get some dinner, but if I do, I won’t be able to sleep tonight.” The dragon sighed, bringing the delicious treat to his nose and inhaling. His stomach growling in protest, he set the carrot dog down in front of the birds. “So here. I… You guys don’t know Rarity, but I don’t think I could look her in the eye if I didn’t give this to you.”

Maury and Carl waited a few seconds, making sure the creature wasn’t going to pounce, and then they climbed back to their feet. Amazed, the two birds stared at each other.

Carl rose slowly, dusting himself off. “Would you get a load of this guy? After all that, he’s just gonna give us the dog!”

Maury flexed his wings carefully, relieved that nothing seemed to be broken. “You know what? I-I just can’t do it. I swoop in and take his lunch, and what does he do? He friggin’ saves me! He saves both of us!” Maury dropped his gaze, wiping his eye with a wing. “Y’know, I don’t feel so hot about myself right now.”

“Yeah,” Carl said quietly. “Me neither.” He turned to Maury, pointing his wing at the carrot dog. “Not much we can do to repay this guy, but you know what? I don’t think I’m gonna be able to take that dog from him. It just ain’t right.”

“I’m with you on that,” Maury said. “C’mon. Let’s say thanks and beat it.”

Spike rocked back on his heels, blinking as the birds suddenly marched toward him and extended their wings formally. Unsure what to do, he gingerly took their wingtips and shook them. The two birds nodded solemnly, then pointed their wings at the carrot dog.

“Yeah, go ahead,” Spike said rather more sadly than he’d intended. “It’s yours.”

Both birds shook their heads, pointing their wings at him. Spike’s mouth dropped open as the red jay took to the air. Snatching up the carrot dog, he dropped it into Spike’s open claws.

“Wait…” Spike began, holding the dog out toward them, but it was too late. Both birds were disappearing into the trees.

~~~

“Jeez, whatta day!” Maury said as he alighted on a branch. “We better steer clear of the waterfront for a little while, huh?”

Carl landed nearby. Stretching, the pigeon rubbed his aching muscles. “You got that right! Oh, baby. I feel like I just went twelve rounds with a cat. Everything hurts!” He grinned at the red jay. “Still, at least we still got tail feathers, eh?”

Maury chuckled, wincing as the laughter rolled through him. “Cecil’s gonna be takin’ a lot of cabs until those feathers grow back!” His laughter tapering off, he turned back to his friend. “I still kinda can’t believe we gave that carrot dog up, though. We must be goin’ soft.”

Carl shook his head. “Nah, that guy deserved it. He was one stand-up lizard.” He leaned in conspiratorially, motioning for Maury to come closer. “Plus, I still pooped on his back when we flew off!” he said, grinning. “A bird’s gotta have some standards!”

Author's Note:

Special thanks to Dragonas77, InquisitorM, and Statoose for their help with this story.

Comments ( 56 )

I was smiling the whole way through.

Loved every minute of it.

~Skeeter The Lurker

Thanks! I'm pretty happy with how this turned out. :eeyup:

Beautiful. A very Goodfeathers feel to this. Two wings up. :moustache:

3794753 Thanks! You know, I should have thought about The Goodfeathers when I was writing this. I'd totally forgotten about them! Animaniacs used to be so damn funny!

I love this. I love this so much.

I'm with Skeeter on this one, I could NOT stop grinning the entire time I was reading this. :pinkiehappy:

Bravo, good sir. Brav-friggin'-o

3794974 Thanks so much! I really enjoyed writing this one. Those birds were awesome to characterize.

Fun story. Thanks

3795037 You bet! I love to entertain you guys! :pinkiehappy:

If only the birds in the real NYC were as courteous as Maury and Carl. I've been given me the poop treatment one time too many in my short life, even when I'm as nice as can be to them! Obviously, I agree with every danged person on this comment section. A++ all the way dude.

Ah, now this was both hilarious and heartwarming.

You sir are a genius for writing this!:rainbowlaugh:

Before reading: This aughta be good.

After reading: I was right. :rainbowlaugh:

“So here. I’m just going to give this to you. I… you guys don’t know Rarity, but I don’t think I could look her in the eye if I didn’t.”

He couldn't look in the eye if he didn't know her? Might wanna rearrange that there dialogue.

3796192 No, he couldn't look her in the eye is he didn't perform his act of generosity.

This is so awesome:moustache:

Is it wrong to say that I pictured the birds in this story with the voices of the Goodfeathers? Because I don't think it is. :ajsmug:

You have successfully taken a scene where Spike is given the Dangerfield treatment (no respect), and made it a study of how much his character has grown over the past few seasons. Take note, DHX. Spike can be a lot more than a simple butt monkey. Hats off. :moustache:

3795584 I'm happy you liked this, and I'm glad that, as a New Yorker, you didn't throw a brick at me for my portrayal of what I imagine a bird from Manehattan would sound like. I gave it my best guess.

3795688 Well, thank you! I worked really hard to try and make it entertaining.

3796475 You know, I watched so much Animaniacs that I think the Goodfeathers must have influenced this, but I'd actually totally forgotten about them until Georg mentioned them in the comment above.

It does not displease me in the least to be compared with those birds. They were friggin' hilarious!

3796192 I'm happy that it met your expectations.

I can see where that bit of dialogue is weird. I'll adjust it.

3796688 It's a bunch of stereotypes left over from older times, but I always preferred that version anyways :rainbowlaugh:

3796066 I'm thrilled you enjoyed it so much!

I wasn't kidding when I said the banter in this was fun to read. Seriously, I had a hard time not speaking all of Maury and Carl's lines out to myself as I read.

The changes in this draft definitely work; Cecil was still threatening, but it didn't feel as dark; And you handled the perspective switches nicely. I didn't think they were a big deal in the first draft, but this flows seamlessly.

Three small errors I spotted:

And a bit further along the sidewalk, he noticed dash of relish, followed by a little speck of ketchup.

Need an 'a' here.

Flapping desperately, the pigeon tried to find some way around, but Cecil titanic wings seemed to be everywhere at once.

Need possessive.

The momentary distraction has provided the gull with the perfect opportunity.

*Had.

3798060 Thanks for this. I swear, one day I'll find the secret to weeding all of these out.

I don't know what it is about tough city birds. Their dialogue practically writes itself! It's super fun to do! :pinkiehappy:

*Grins an applauds* Bravo! I loved the bird's characterization and it's always nice to see Spike getting some love (Of the non sticky kind:raritywink:)

Very solidly done. I love the ending line.:rainbowlaugh:

3833343 Thanks, man! I'm happy to hear that you liked it. This one hasn't been a big hit with readers, but it was among the most fun stories for me to actually write. I really liked writing the dialogue for those birds!

This was... surprisingly good! Truly, good on you!

I really liked how you used "angle of attack" in a way that would explain it to someone not in the know, and also, points for using seagulls' techniques for killing clams to great effect.

You get a surprised upvote and favourite!

3886585 Thanks! I looked up seagulls before I wrote this and tried to work in some actually mannerisms for the battle. I probably made Cecil too agile, but he needed to be a believable monster for it to work.

Glad you enjoyed this! :pinkiehappy:

A tiny typo. "Bothof" should be two words.

"...He saves bothof us!" Maury dropped his gaze, wiping his eye with a wing.

You really get a feel for the birds' personalities in a short time. A fun story with a sweet ending, but, hehe, that ending sentence just makes it all even better. :yay:

3934027 Thanks for pointing out that typo. I swear that I've read this story dozens of times, and still... typos. :ajsleepy:

I'm glad the birds worked for you. I was a little afraid people would be put off because their weren't enough ponies in these, but it seems like people like the birds. I'm pleased with that.

We'll see what EQD thinks whenever they finally get around to this story...

And I couldn't completely take the edge away from those birds! In the end, Spike still gets the business.

Up on EqD. Hurrah! About time, too.

4006242 Oh, wow! They didn't waste any time! I just got the email about fifteen minutes ago.

Thanks! I was just about to send you a PM on it.

I am so glad I took the chance on this one! The birds were just a bit extensive, but it worked well, and I was really enjoying the fact of their accents. Spike seemed to be in-character, and the secne where he decided to hand over the carrot dog was very well done. Anyone who's seen the show should be able to picture that perfectly; I could see the expressions on his face and hear the emotion in his voice so well... You've done a wonderful job on this; thank you for sharing it with us!

It's so great to finally see this up on EQD. They really put you through hell just sitting around waiting for so long.
Anyway, as you already know, great job!

4006314 Thank you very much for reading this. I spent a lot of time on this story, and it's nice to see people enjoying it after that! :pinkiehappy:

4006357 It was really the series of back and forth editing between EQD and The Royal Guard. For a story with 3,500 words, you would not believe how much editing I did. I guarantee Diary of a Pliant Tyrant, Taking a Job for Granite, and Checkmates combined didn't have the level of editing this story did. It seemed like it would never end.

However, I was kind of being a baby about it. While I did think they were super-nitpicky, it was helping to make a better overall product.

I've been waiting for this one. :yay:

P̩̀i̪̠̣̯͚g̟̣̱͙̳̤͍͝ḛ̠̹͙o҉̠̻n͚̣̤͔̼s̰̳͉̘͡... I hate pigeons! :twilightangry2:

Just wait until Carl soils Rarity's coiffure.
I see a new musical number in the very near future. :trixieshiftright:

4022062 One drop goes in Rarity's hair and it's all over for that bird. Not even Fluttershy could save him.

4010500 Well, I'm happy to provide! :pinkiehappy:

I'm reminded of Goodfeathers, and that's a very good thing. Magnificent work. Thank you for it.

4113548 No, thank you for reading it! I'm very appreciative that you took the time to read it and tell me that you enjoyed it. That means a lot to me. :twilightsmile:

This was quite awesome. I could just imagine Fluttershy trying to talk to these birds and end up buying the Brooklyn Bridge.

4114380 Ha! That's great! I could totally see that happening.

I was not expecting to enjoy a Spike story so much as I did with this one. Only thing I wonder is how did Spike not notice the bleeding on the bird? That sounded more severe than the rest of the story made it out to be. Yeesh.

But got to say this was wonderful little "Where was Spike?" side episode to Rarity taking Manehattan while Spike spent the majority of his time hunting for a carrot dog. xD

You really made him feel like Show Spike. I wish he could get episodes like this in canon. I doubt they'd make it look so violent though but still, it'd make a great episode nonetheless.

4116990 When it came to the injuries of the birds, I wanted to keep Spike's reactions to a minimum. That lets the reader know that the injuries aren't really that serious. If Spike had pointed them out, then it's an indication that he'd need to do something about it, and I didn't want to get caught up in that. He's noting that they are in a sorry state, and I felt that was probably enough.

And if this was an episode, you could get away with a lot less violence. Here, I had to make Cecil a threat with actions, and those actions care weight. However, in a cartoon, you can get away with softening the violence with silly faces with stars swirling around the head and such. Things like Rainbow slamming into windows at full speed and sliding off of them. It sounds a lot worse to write it than to see it in cartoon form. However, I did purposefully make this a little grittier than the typical level of violence because I wanted the story to be somewhat serious. Not totally, but I wanted it to have an edge to it.

I'm very pleased you liked the story overall, though! :pinkiehappy:

4118398 Oh, everything was fine. I was just pointing out that high speed slam into a ROCK the pidgeon got bashed into causing it to bleed, and the grinding hollow wing bones in a gull's beak, I meant that it just distracted and made Spike's reactions feel less impactful overall until a certain line was said(more on that later). I mean, did he really think a carrot would heal a couple bloodied up and limping pigeons?

I'm not saying they were limping, but it read like the previous descriptions of extra bits like blood feel unnecessary, that Gull was a serious threat from start to finish. Made me wanna quote a few of those moments and post a "Ain't Nature Beautiful?" Fluttershy reaction from the comics. xD

It's a fine story. Just, as a reader, it just served to distract from the scene later with Spike. It's like me walking up to you with blood rushing down the sides face from a gash on my head and choosing to take your offer of a hot dog over getting medical attention.

Cecil was awesome. I liked how brutal he was. He made a great antagonist. That whole mafia thug life thing was nice. I just personally couldn't connect with the ending with how stuff prior to an otherwise amazing ending.

I know you had Spike acknowledge they were a sorry mess and all that, basically. It's just, I don't see him ignoring "bloodied" up pigeons given how much he was willing to do just to protect an egg. Imagine his reaction to seeing bloodied up animals? He'd at least bandage them up at the least.

In short, when I read "bloodied" in the context of being slammed from on high at extreme velocity from such heights, well, following how the story has gone to be so raw with realism, and that constant sense of lives at genuine risk, it felt like it just ignored what it tried to be.

But! It did help show at least just how badly Spike cared for the gift. Not even a bunch of beaten bloodied pigeons can easily persuade Spike from giving up his lunch. Only, his love and respect for the pony who gave it to him really shone in that scene. Showing him once again defeat the greed, though more justified greed, beaten out by how much influence Rarity's generosity has on Spike. I wouldn't be able to show my face to her either if I had munched that carrot dog after seeing the state of those pigeons.

And that's why I basically told myself to ignore the flaws as they had a way of working themselves out at the end.

I'm not sure why I did spoilers on that. Maybe I should have thrown more in? Apologies to anyone who feels I somehow spoiled anything not marked spoiler.

Also, how did this get away with an Everyone tag? Teen is the only rating that allows blood and this level of violence. Pre-reader be slacking yo!

4119044 Well, when it comes to them being bloodied, there is "seriously injured" and there is "banged up but okay." This was the latter. I've been in plenty of situations where I, say, ran my head into something and cut it. I'm bleeding, and it hurts, but no one ran over to care for me. Everyone can see that it's not that big of a deal. It's the same for the birds. They aren't laying there wounded and suffering. They are actively pining over that dog. Their wounds aren't really on their minds.

But it's going to read differently to each reader. I've been in a lot of fights, so this stuff doesn't seem like that big of a deal to me. Maybe it does to other readers. It's something for me to think about in the future.

And as for the Teen rating, I dunno. I've never really looked at what defines the categories, since I think of myself as an Everyone writer. Though I've certainly pushed the boundaries in Cheerilee's Thousand a few times...

I really enjoyed reading this! You based a whole side-story and friendship lesson off of a minor detail (Spike losing the carrot dog), which is impressive.
The fight was exciting and the banter was fun to read. It had a good ending too. Though if I was Spike, I don't think I would have eaten that carrot dog after all it went through. :derpytongue2:

4546411 Thanks! It's nice to know you enjoyed it. :pinkiehappy:

I did think about Spike not eating the carrot dog, but he seems like a dragon that isn't too fussy about things like that. I mean, he fell asleep in a punch bowl, ate worm muffins, and licked himself clean when he was covered in icing. I figure he'd eat a beaten up carrot dog as long as it didn't cross the line into filthy.

Login or register to comment