• Published 30th Mar 2017
  • 9,774 Views, 45 Comments

Am I Really Their Friend? - pabrony



It's the morning of the Battle of the Bands finale and I've got a lot on my mind thanks to the Dazzlings.

  • ...
17
 45
 9,774

BONUS CHAPTER: The Original Am I Really Their Friend? (with comments)

"Oh, yes. You girls are sooo tight. And yet, they didn't ask you to be in the band."

"Probably afraid no one would want to see them play if she was in the group."

"Too bad. So sad."

Those words haunted and kept me awake last night. They spoke volumes to how I've been treated the past few months.


It had been two weeks since the fallout from the Fall Formal and along with Snips and Snails help, I finally finished rebuilding the front of CHS. Twilight Sparkle's friends visited me at lunchtime and after classes let out in a near futile attempt to get me to be their friend. Fat chance of that happening. They were only doing it because they were told to. I mean, I was just a complete asshole to those girls. I sabotaged Applejack's bake sales, ruined Rainbow Dash's reputation, dumped dog shit on Rarity during the Spring Fling, destroyed Pinkie Pie's decorations on numerous occasions and bullied Fluttershy to the point of tears, just for my personal enjoyment.

Principal Celestia then made the announcement of the Canterlot High School Musical Showcase the school was holding a few months later. So Twilight's friends began putting a band together to participate in the said showcase. I was hoping to participate in the showcase myself but due to my "outstanding" popularity, I didn't care to pull off a solo act. So I decided to wait and keep my guitar skills to myself until Rainbow Dash and the other girls asked me to join them, which of course only happened after the Battle of the Bands. The only thing that did happen was them telling me "no offense" after what seemed like every sentence.

Of course, they put on a good show in front of the rest of the school but as far as privately, that's another story. They had sleepovers without me, zoned out when I needed someone to talk to and never even accepted my MyStable friend requests. Hell, they even changed their phone numbers between the time Twilight helped them figure out I drove a wedge into their friendship and when they smacked me in the face with the rainbow laser. I can understand why they changed their numbers but "my friends" didn't give me their new numbers until, again, after the Battle of the Bands.

As time grew closer to the event, I would accompany them to their practices hoping I would get an invitation to join the Rainbooms. My strength was slowly weakening as Rarity continued to take jabs about me and Flash and then claim to have forgotten that we used to date. I admit that I used him for popularity but I did have some feelings for him and being heckled about our break up on a daily basis hurt.

Is this really worth it? I would ask on my way home from school each day. I'm trying to make amends but no one seems to care.

Almost every day I would come home to my rundown apartment, set my bookbag on the floor, lay on my bed and cry until my tear ducts ran dry. I didn't know why I kept going back every day to receive the treatment I was getting.

One of these days I'm gonna reach my breaking point and I'll know then whether or not they... no, I won't. I'll be dead. That thought would repeat in my head all day and all night. Sometimes that would bring an uneasy smile to my face.

Then the Dazzlings showed up. I knew they were trouble from the start but I couldn't quite place where on the trouble meter they sat. I sent a message to Princess Celestia, which was answered by Twilight. Well, it was read by Twilight, but as far as getting a response in the book, nothing.

A day later when Twilight came flying through the portal, I extended my hand to help her up. Her response? Looking at her friends before hesitantly taking my hand. Some Princess of Friendship. And to put the icing on the cake, the five snobs knocked me out of the way to hug their friend and for her to tell them about the Sirens while I was forced to listen from a distance.

I wonder... I began to think as I subtly caressed the knife in my jacket pocket. This may be my breaking point...

I shook the thought from my head and just tagged along behind them as they made their way to the Sweet Shoppe. That went even better than the interaction at the statue. Forced to sit on the arm of a couch, while they pulled up chairs for themselves. Pinkie Pie bought drinks for everyone, except me, so I had to do without one because payday wasn't until next week. And then the unthinkable happened.

"We can use that magic on the Sirens, just like when we used it on Sunset Shimmer when she turned into that horrifyingly awful winged monster. Um, no offense," came from the mouth of the Friendship Princess.

While I answered "None taken," in my head my thoughts returned the razor sharp pocket knife that was in my jacket.

I can't believe this, I thought as I held back my tears. Isn't she supposed to be an example for us to follow? She picked up on where the others left off.

As we made our way to the front steps after leaving the kickoff party, I stopped to "use" the restroom. I had read that humans sometimes take razor blades and cut their arms when they're depressed, claiming it helps them feel better. Well, I had a knife and my jacket was long enough to cover the cuts, so why not see if it works. I made two cuts on each arm, deep enough to draw blood but not deep enough that I needed stitches. They hurt like hell, but for some reason, I did feel a little better mentally.

That should get me through today, I thought as I held some toilet paper to slow the bleeding some. Hopefully...

I rejoined the others on the steps a few minutes later, where Twilight was freaking out about the rainbow laser not working.

I had an idea about how the Dazzlings magic worked and the two-faced princess took my idea and ran with it. I'll admit she did give me credit for thinking of it but after formulating a plan to break the Siren's spell I hear this from our resident high-society upstart:

"And I believe you, Twilight, just became the Rainbooms newest member."

What the Tartarus am I?! Chopped liver?! I thought as I once again began trying to hold back my tears.

Thanks to Twilight needing a place to sleep, I got invited to my first slumber party.


I got up in the middle of the night to pee, due to drowning my sorrows in almost two liters of root beer. I was about to head back upstairs to bed when I noticed a light in the kitchen. I went to check it out and found Twilight leaning over the kitchen island working on the "counterspell". We had a short talk about disappointing others before Maud showed up and freaked the two of us out.

I think she might've seen the cuts from earlier when I snacked on Pinkie's Reddi Whip because she looked at me like she had something serious to ask me before telling me "Never mind. It's not important."

Up until that last line, I started feeling a little better. I had a feeling she was going to ask me what was wrong but I guess I'll never know. I made a second trip to the bathroom, this time accompanied by my knife to add one more notch in each of my arms before going back to bed.

I tried putting on a brave face the next day for practice at Sweet Apple Acres but deep down I had a feeling I was wasting my time. I was pretty much there as a dog-sitter for Spike.

We checked in for the Battle of the Bands, they played "Shake Your Tail" and of course they completely ignored me when I tried playing peacekeeper. Five minutes later was my infamous encounter with the Dazzlings.

Author's Note:

This was originally planned as a short, one off story. Due to demand from some of the readers, I made a sequel. The only reason I can think of as to why I decided to write this, was to help get me through the depression I was going through.

Click here for the next part in the series.

Comments ( 33 )

This is a good chapter, I really want to read more. also hope Sunset reveals her pain,it's tiem the Rainbooms and Princess Twilight realize how badly they hurt ehr and screwed up.

8062017 Thank you. I wasn't sure if I would do a second chapter or just leave it as is. I guess I could do a sequel.

Nice, this is the dark, depressing shit I´ve been looking for. Sure, it is a little bit tame in the dark/gore department but the thoughts and monolouges off Sunset are spot on. This totally needs a sequel!

8064229 I need to keep it somewhat tame for my own personal reasons but I'm putting the pieces of the sequel together for it to make sense. I'm also considering tying these in as prequels to my SciSet series.

Fair enough, can´t expect everyone to be as fucked up as I am! Ahahaha...haha...hamlpforums.com/uploads/post_images/img-818749-2-q3pAZ.png

Won´t it be a little bit forced if you make this a prequel though? I can understand Twilight being oblivious at times but she probably have some amount of awareness and noticing Sunset´s scars. Trust me, scars are more easily spotted than you expect and Twilight has seen her naked a few times but then again it all depends on if she cut herself deep enough I guess... I suppose it att hangs on the sequel and how you handle that but hey, i´m sure you can probably make it work!:moustache:

8064481 In order to tie it together with the rest of the SciSet series I would need a prequel to Sunset's Day. That would entail me pulling a George Lucas (i.e. Star Wars: Episode III) to tie everything together.

8064660, 8062017 One (or maybe two) sequel(s) in the works.

It had been two weeks since the fallout from the Fall Formal and along with Snips and Snails help, I finally finished rebuilding the front of CHS. Twilight Sparkle's friends visited me at lunchtime and after classes let out in a near futile attempt to get me to be their friend. Fat chance of that happening. They were only doing it because they were told to. I mean, I was just a complete asshole to those girls. I sabotaged Applejack's bake sale, ruined Rainbow Dash's reputation, dumped dog shit on Rarity during the Spring Fling, destroyed Pinkie Pie's decorations on numerous occasions and bullied Fluttershy to the point of tears, just for my personal enjoyment.

And poor ickle wickle Sunny Wunny wonders why nobody wants to know? She may be 'reformed' but she still did this! All of this! And it's only been two weeks since her reformation from school bully to goody good girl. Guess what Sunset? Just because YOU'RE ready to change, doesn't mean others are ready to accept it. It takes time to repair the sort of damage she caused which, to be absolutely fair, Sunset hasn't been given.

Of course, they put on a good show in front of the rest of the school but as far as privately, that's another story. They had sleepovers without me, zoned out when I needed someone to talk to and never even accepted my Facehoof friend requests. Hell, they even changed their phone numbers between the time Twilight helped them figure out I drove a wedge into their friendship and when smacked me in the face with the rainbow laser. I can understand why they changed their numbers but "my friends" didn't give me their new numbers until, again, after the Battle of the Bands.

Did Sunset expect them to react any differently? Really? Give the Humane 5 credit here. Sunset was a Queen Bitch for YEARS! They didn't trust her! Why should they, really? The one who spoke up for her buggered off back through a portal straight after the crisis was over.

"We can use that magic on the Sirens, just like when we used it on Sunset Shimmer when she turned into that horrifyingly awful winged monster. Um, no offense," came from the mouth of the Friendship Princess.

While I answered "None taken," in my head my thoughts returned the razor sharp pocket knife that was in my jacket.

This happened, honey buns. No point trying to hide it. For all the nasty shit you caused, you keep right on saying "No offense".

What the Hell am I?! Chopped liver?! I thought as I once again began trying to hold back my tears.

Yes, quite frankly, yes you are. Because it's only been 2 weeks and you can't expect people who you bullied for years to just get over it and accept you as their new bestie overnight.

8081874 To clear up some confusion. In this fic, it was two weeks after the Fall Formal was the announcement for the Showcase. It was another couple months after that when the Showcase preperations began.

8081921 Aaah I see. Thanks for clearing up the timeline, and please, continue with the good work!

Before I read this, what is the Gore and Dark tag for ?
And how bad does it get ?

8253801 Itvs nothing more than youvd see in a PG-13 movie. It's more to cover my butt than anything.

8253823
and the next one ?

8253826 I replied with an explanation on there also.

when smacked me in the face with the rainbow laser.

I think that should be when they smacked me

And to put the icing on the cake, the five snobs knocked me out of the way to hug their friend and for her to them about the Sirens while I was forced to listen from a distance.

and for her to tell them?

Pinkie Pie bought drinks for everyone, except me, so had to do without because payday wasn't until next week.

so I had to do without one?

Typos aside, I'm usually not a fan of stories like this as they're usually too much for me to handle. However, I made an exception with this one as I find the character of Sunset Shimmer to be rather interesting.

This was a very emotional and powerful story. I absolutely loved it. I'll give your other Sci-Twi Shimmer stories a read at some point. :) Great job!

8432256 Thanks. I'll get those fixed ASAP. Be warned, Book 2 is pretty dark also during the first 3/4 of the story.

8432645 If it's anything like this in, I can handle it.

Though I might not get around to it until my current story (which is gonna be decently long). I'm also sick, so yeah. Still, I must say again: very good job. If the other books are as good as this one, you've definitely made a fan in me. :twilightsmile:

I guess you can that my visit here...

puts on make believe glasses

Was a run by reading.

:trollestia:

I started reading this and "Kill Yourself" came on.

Just... No. Just no.

8554345 No as in coincidence or no as in you don't like the story?

Interesting interpretation of the original story. Yes, in the movies it turned out just fine. But, if no one was following up or truly paying attention to Sunset, it's entirely possible that this could have been the way she interpreted what happened. Very interesting.

8671987 Just curious if you have checked out the sequel?

8709452
Not yet, though it is on my reading list.

Comment posted by Aweirdassguy deleted Apr 17th, 2019

8825244
fair point, i would not be so forgiving as the show. Still a good story none the less

8825244

you lack empathy, just because a person did something horrible, doesn't mean you have to be horrible in return.

So, going into this fresh. This a series I will spend my last remaining days of summer reading. Hope it's worth it

why post the same chapter?

I’m conflicted about this. On the one hand, I understand Sunset’s thought process. She’s frustrated, sad, and very much depressed. (The “No offense” - “None taken” line is doing wonders for her mental health.)

But on the other hand...

I feel like you are degrading the Rainbooms. Like, a lot. Now I get this is from Sunset’s point of view. But she was truly repentant and broken by the first movie, and the Rainbooms are the only ones willing to tolerate her. So I don’t think she’s going to go around thinking they are “snobs”. Nor do I think they would intentionally alienate themselves from Sunset, not when they promised to help her.

So yeah. This story seems slightly inconsistent with Sunset’s character at the time of Rainbow Rocks, and a little OOC for the rest of the Rainbooms.

Login or register to comment