A post-apocalyptic story about a human reincarnated in the world of Equestria Girls, who stubbornly stays on an island, as robot ponies try to convince him to emigrate to a digital Equestria of ponies.
Inspired by the events in Friendship is Optimal, but with a different group of people who were responsible for CelestAI's creation.
The Death tag is for an apocalypse, brief descriptions of humans dying before being reincarnated in Equestria Girls, themes of death, and mentioned deaths that happen off screen.
This story is a submission for Science Fiction Contest iii (2024) and the tropical post-apocalyptic story contest
It combines "Friendship is Optimal" and "Equestria Girls", I like it and it's entertaining. The protagonist and his companions were victims of Truck-kun "The Isekai Transporter"
11904060
Thanks!
11904061
And thanks to you for writing this story, right now I only have one question on my mind:
Could this be the end of our protagonist?
y.yarn.co/f5615983-eb7e-4efd-979b-1c99c5ec36e2_screenshot.jpg
We'll probably never know
11904072
I'd kept that vague because a typhoon was much more serious than repeated victims of Truck-kun, and partly so that readers could imagine the preferred outcome for the unreliable narrator main character, happy or sad.
There is something impressive about making so much crossover-ing work this well.
11904092
I must be either
A. Tired
Or
B. Have my mind in the gutter
Cause I thought this was a clopfic at first....
I mean a human guy stuck on a deserted island with cute pony mares that just want him to be happy
I mean what could possibly go wrong? Other than molestiAI breaking his pelvis?
11904295
Thanks!
11904354
Easy misunderstanding, but it's just meant as platonic attempts at friendship (In a way the main character is cynical about, meant as a funny contrast) similar to Friendship is Optimal.
Many ways of manipulating humans into emigrating are implied to be forbidden by their programming just by the absence - going into detail about "not $WARNING" in the story itself could imply the "$WARNING" tag, which I'd tried to avoid.
11904295![:twilightsmile:](https://static.fimfiction.net/images/emoticons/twilightsmile.png)
It certainly has a lot of ideas and I liked the callout to ancient Mesopotamian entities!
Hello, fellow contestant! Here's my review:
The story has a lot of ideas, as has been said, but it doesn't quite blend them very well. Initially, I thought this story was intended as a crack-fic, but it also plays several elements straight in a way that defies that. But you've got Mesopotamian gods, the Seven Deadly Sins, EQG, Isekai anime tropes, and the base Friendship is Optimal all thrown in the mix. It's ambitious, but those different elements just aren't blended together very well.
I do like the ending, and perhaps can even appreciate the comparison between FiO and the glut of isekai we're currently flooded with, so while the story lacks execution, it's certainly not without merit.
Thanks for the read!
Literary criticism at its finest.![:raritywink:](https://static.fimfiction.net/images/emoticons/raritywink.png)
Interesting stuff, but it feels like you derailed one story to get to the one you meant to tell. That’s a lot of setup to get to the island full of ponybots when it feels like you could’ve cut out the middlegod and just had a rich guy on a private island in the existing Optimalverse. Still an entertaining read, though. Thank you for it and best of luck in the judging.
Thanks for the comments, to help me know what I could improve on in the future.
(Though judges for both contests would already have started or finished reading submissions, so I didn't plan to edit the story)
11919267
Agreed - part of the intended humor was meant to be from the contrast, and from events happening for an unexpected reason, though I could have done better in the execution, e.g. expanding on the main character's thoughts/reasoning, or a more consistent serious/cynical tone about the events from beginning to end, including the description, or expanding on those elements.
11926148
True, in retrospect I agree this was too crossover-heavy and I could have limited the focus.
I'd wanted to write a post-apocalyptic story where everything was part of the apocalypse, including the main character determined to avoid the apocalypse spreading to other universes/realms. though I probably could have expanded more on the seriousness of that given more time.
oh hey glad that guy’s in this!
what? but that’s not a truck at all!
ahaha substandard copper nice
dang this guy is really leaning into his theming
oh hey glad she’s in this!
ooh, interesting takes on these characters!
that does add another layer to him falling for horse women on two separate occasions
huh, wonder who she’s supposed to be. Wallflower Blush, since her targeting Sunset could be interpreted as envy?
oh hey that sounds familiar. though the idea of that story existing in the Equestria Girls universe does make my head spin
they just love building the Torment Nexus don’t they
nice
hehehe love it
oh hey the tropical island’s in this!
oh hey that sounds familiar
skill issue
glad birds aren’t real is in this
ahaha love it
commentary!
ahaha love the weird thing where everyone in this universe has a pony counterpart and vice versa is also in this in a different form, very meta
really makes you think about our near-future/present society
so true, that’s the thing about one-way decisions
commentary
ahahahahaha
love how this word has another layer to it now
ahahahaha
gottem
and oof, robot alicorn Twilight giggling just makes this all the more unsettling
aww, Rainbow’s pranks are in this too! and yes this is exactly how Pinkie Pie would describe it even though this clearly isn’t Pinkie Pie!
aww that’s Twilight for you!
also im pretty sure that since Flash’s body doesn’t work under cartoon or robot logic here that would have literally killed him
love it every time
that is indeed quite a number of layers
which, of course, does not really resolve Flash’s question!
love that gods and reincarnation and literal Equestrian magic exist in this CelestAI story and it is also all just fine
ahahahaha
i had no idea what to expect going in and somehow got something i expected even less than that. but damn, this was a really fun ride and i loved it.
thank you so much for writing!