Being a Villain Sucks
Actions have Consequences
Admiral Biscuit
Being a villain sucked.
Oh sure, there were lots of perks, lots of reasons a pony might want to be a villain. Having ponies tremble under her hooves, for example, was a great perk, especially since Cozy Glow was so small. There was also the appeal of vast magical powers, the opportunity to work alongside other villains, and the potential of nearly limitless power.
In her brief stint at villainy, she’d gotten a tantalizing taste of power, gotten caught, and gotten imprisoned in Tartarus. Tartarus sucked.
Had she been anything other than a villain, she might have seen the error of her ways and vowed to go straight once she got out of Tartarus, but of course she didn’t; she teamed up with two other villains.
Her last thought before being stoned was that she was never going to make that mistake again.
•••
Time passed.
At first, passing ponies spit on her or made rude gestures at her—not that she could see them, being petrified as she was. And then more time passed and fewer and fewer ponies could be bothered to do that. And then more time passed, and even fewer ponies really remembered who she was.
News reports became stories which became legends which would eventually become myth. In the winter, she was covered with snow and in the summer baked in the heat.
She didn’t know that sometimes Princess Twilight sat on the grass in front of her, nor did she know that in time, other statues were placed around her.
She couldn’t know that Princess Twilight thought of herself as a failure each time an intractable friendship problem became a new statue.
Years passed, and even the magical nature of her imprisonment was not complete proof against weathering. The sharp edges of her petrified form wore ever so slightly, softening her expression of horror.
Cozy Glow was unaware of the workponies who erected a scaffold around the statue, who very carefully chipped the stone away which joined her and Tirek and then carried her into the palace.
Ponies didn’t come to see the statues any more, so nopony noticed that Cozy Glow was missing. That was just as well; some of them might have panicked if they’d known.
•••
She had not known anything since being petrified other than a few moments of terror as her body stiffened, her futile attempts to escape and her resolution to never team up with other villains. Just as her brain tried to catch up with where she was now, her wings broke free and carried her on a brief flight, ending on the rug as her hind legs hadn’t quite unpetrified yet.
Cozy struggled to her hooves and looked around frantically. Last she could remember, she’d been outside and now she clearly wasn’t. Her two co-conspirators were nowhere to be found.
Am I back in Tartarus? That was unlikely; the room was too well-appointed.
Hoofsteps echoed across the room, and she turned her head to look.
An alicorn, one she didn’t know, approached. Her first instinct was to fight, and her second was to flee. Neither was likely to be a successful outcome, which left her to resort to her third option—act contrite, small, and helpless, and escape later.
“Cozy Glow.” The alicorn’s voice dripped with contempt. “You’re coming with me.”
“Do I have a choice in the matter?”
The alicorn’s ears flattened. “Neither of us does, I’m afraid.”
“I’m not coming.”
“Yes, you are. I’ve been appointed your guardian until you reach adulthood or until it becomes apparent that you’re beyond redemption.”
Cozy rolled her eyes. “And then what? I’ll go to Tartarus again and you’ll lose your throne?”
“My mother and Princess Twilight will both be disappointed, and I’ll see if I have better luck with Lily Longsocks. Oh, and I’ll probably turn you into stone again and keep you as a hat rack in my bedroom. I’ve been bugging the palace carvers for one, but they’re always so busy.”
“You wouldn’t dare.”
“Try me and find out. Now hurry up, we’re flying north.”
Cozy stomped a hoof on the ground. “I’m not going.”
“Fine.” The alicorn folded her legs under her and sat easily on the rug. “Hat rack it is. Could you do me a favor and keep your forelegs apart? Just in case I also need someplace to hang a dress?”
“You’re bluffing.”
•••
Flurry Heart wasn’t bluffing.
When Cozy Glow’s awareness next returned, she was inside a net bag, being carried under the belly of an alicorn. She had just enough time to look around before the bag flashed away under a burst of magic, and then she was falling.
She popped her wings out and hovered, one eye on the tail of the retreating alicorn, the other at the ground.
More properly, the lack of ground. It took her a minute to orient herself, to understand what she was seeing below. As far as she could see, there were no clouds, and there was no ground below, only open ocean.
She could barely make out Flurry Heart, who was still flying along as if she hadn’t noticed that she’d dropped her passenger. With no other option open to her, Cozy chased after her.
“That was mean.”
“Actions have consequences,” Flurry reminded her.
“What if I’d flown off in the wrong direction and then gotten tired and drown?”
Flurry shrugged. “Actions have consequences.”
“Where are we going?”
“North.”
“To the Crystal Empire?”
“Exactly.”
“Why didn’t we take the train?”
“It’s harder to drown you on a train and make it look like an accident. Now shut your mouth; we’ve got lots of flying still to do, and you don’t want to tire yourself out before we reach land.”
“You’ll—” Cozy began, and then bit her tongue. Would Flurry carry her? She actually wasn’t sure any more.
“What?”
“Nothing.”
•••
Being good sucked at first. She spent the first few weeks locked up in the tower, with only visits from Flurry Heart to break the monotony. Two guards stayed with her at all times, even stationing themselves outside the bathroom to make sure she wouldn’t escape.
Punishments were harsh and immediate. She refused to submit to the doctor and as a result, lost her blankets for a week.
She also kicked Flurry Heart and spent an afternoon as a hat rack. Cozy didn’t remember that afternoon, but Flurry took plenty of pictures.
Come the fall, she got enrolled in school, and promptly got picked on as one of the only non-crystal ponies attending. Without any magical artifacts, she didn’t really have much going for her, and while she could win a fight against one or two ponies, she didn’t stand a chance against a group of them.
It wasn’t too long before she was actually looking forward to returning home. At least Flurry Heart was fair—as long as she followed the rules, she didn’t get punished.
She learned to herd up with some of the other students, those who also got bullied, and the fights eventually stopped.
Her first Hearth’s Warming, she actually got gifts. All the Princesses had bought her something.
By spring, the guards were gone. She was trusted in her room again, and she didn’t have to be as careful about hiding the scissors she’d stolen from the school. There were still occasional room checks, but they weren’t as thorough as they’d been.
•••
Cozy couldn’t say when she’d reformed, when she’d decided that being the villain just wasn't worth it. One day, she’d been doing her homework and had been looking in the back of her desk for a fresh inkpot and she’d discovered the scissors she’d stolen from the school. She tried to remember what she’d meant to do with them, and couldn’t. Stab Flurry, maybe, but it was hard to imagine what the old Cozy Glow thought she could have accomplished with that.
“I might have been the only statue holding scissors,” she muttered, and set them on her desk to sneak back into the school.
•••
Her senior year, the entire class took a week-long trip to Canterlot. She’d been before, of course, but that was in the past. Bullies had used it against her, and potential friends had thought her bragging, so she rarely mentioned it.
They toured museums and the palace and got to meet Princess Twilight in the throne room. Cozy stayed towards the back and hoped she wouldn’t be noticed but of course after giving a speech about the value of friendship, Princess Twilight felt like she had to greet each one of them individually.
“Cozy . . . I’m glad you could make it back,” she’d whispered, and that was all she’d said.
•••
Cozy mostly didn’t break rules any more, and she certainly wasn't trying to overthrow Equestria as she sneaked out of her hotel room.
From above, even in darkness, it didn’t take her too long to find what she was looking for, and she circled around the statue, studying the two figures still trapped in stone. Flying closer, she could see the rough chisel marks where she’d been chipped free, and if she’d wanted to, she was sure she could have matched up the scars in her hind legs with the chips.
Would they ever be given another chance? Or had they already used all their chances?
Her mind flashed back to being all alone over the ocean, an image she could never quite get out of her mind. She’d always suspected that Flurry would have turned back and rescued her if she’d made the wrong choice, but what if she wouldn't? What if her last moments had been struggling to keep her head above the waves?
Being a villain had its perks. Ponies had cowered in fear of her, but she now knew that when she needed help, and when her only friends were those who she’d terrorized into loyalty—well, they weren’t likely to come rushing to her aid, were they?
Cozy took one last look at the statue and then flew off towards the hotel. Actions had consequences, and she’d be in trouble if anypony found out she’d left her room after curfew.
Also LikedSimilarAuthor
- semillon · 14k words · 278 41 · 5.3k views
- TrackdNTraild · 1.7k words · 96 3 · 2.2k views
- Shrinky Frod · 3.3k words · 11 4 · 679 views
- RomanSoldier · 2.1k words · 129 9 · 4.5k views
- Silvermyr · 82k words · 174 4 · 3.7k views
- PingZing · 3.8k words · 530 6 · 7.1k views
- bookhorse125 · 4.7k words · 14 1 · 1.1k views
Stats
Page generated in 0.312 seconds
Total duration
1,044 users online
2,242,943 hits today, 2,921,617 yesterday
FIMFiction
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Fanfiction
Designed and coded by knighty & Xaquseg - © 2011-2024
Follow & Support Us
Support us
SubStar
Chat!
Discord
Follow us
Twitter
MLP: Friendship is Magic® - © 2024 Hasbro Inc.®
Fimfiction is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Hasbro Inc.®
Also in the process of writing, I found this:
derpicdn.net/img/view/2019/9/2/2134492.png
Source
Interestingly, in the edited version (posted above; link goes to the original), the description said ‘In 100 years, Princess Twilight sends Flurry Heart to reform Cozy Glow.’
So I take it Flurry is so bitter in this story because she just found out where she got her name? Also, why was she sneaking out after curfew?
9996112
Heh, no, I was thinking just ‘cause she’s a teenage alicorn who’s been told to do something she doesn’t really want to do.
To get a look at the statue.
Wait, what did she do?
The tough love approach definitely seems promising with Cozy, along with socially isolating her at first so she can't just charm her way into a position of power. It's cruel, but sometimes that sort of cruelty is necessary in the early stages. A fine job with a difficult prompt. Thank you for it.
Not bad, but a bit abrupt in a number of places. Cozy doesn’t really get a chance to feel like Cozy or do much Cozy stuff, and the reformation feels...unearned, I guess? But that’s just the nature of a speed-write. I think this could actually serve as a great template for a longer story.
9996116
I fail to see any reason Cozy should have reformed. Flurry´s teaching was limited to "follow my rules or get punished" like any other prison warden. Nobody else made her undestand friendship or why her behaviour was wrong. At best Cozy´s spirit should have been broken and became apathetic, unwilling to either try to become a villain again or accomplish anything else.
Nicely done ! You really captured how to teach two timeless lessons:
You can't bully or buy loyalty.
Actions have consequences, good and bad.
I'm glad you put Flurry Heart as her teacher.
not a fan
Flurry Heart doesn't mess around which Cozy Glow nearly found out the hard way. I must say that I enjoyed reading this though I feel as though it could've gone on further. What you wrote is still plenty but it made me think of what could be next.
9996125
derpicdn.net/img/view/2015/11/9/1019443.png
YEET
In some ways, it’s not dissimilar to what we sometimes do with developmentally disabled adults. Elements were certainly inspired by treatment regimens (obviously, not dangerous stuff, but things like room searches and one-on-one supervision).
9996139
I can’t disagree . . . that is the difficulty of getting a prompt, coming up with an idea and making it into at least a workable story in a couple of hours. I suppose I could have expanded it before publishing, but I find it feels more authentic to publish as written, y’know?
Yes, it absolutely could. If I didn’t have a zillion other projects I’m working on . . .
9996140
Well, that’s often a good start. That’s something that is easily understood, and not only does it work on prisoners, it also works (to an extent) on children and equines. It’s not the whole treatment, of course, and I can tell you from working with developmentally disabled adults, progress can be quite slow, and there are setbacks, but if the goal is reformation, it can work.
If that was all Flurry did, it wouldn’t reform her. What’s key is once boundaries are set, give freedoms. Follow the rules, and the guards won’t be watching you all the time. Keep following the rules, and they’ll leave. Be a good filly and you’ll get Hearth’s Warming presents. You’ll be allowed to go to school with other ponies. You’ll be allowed to go on a field trip to Canterlot with only the usual chaperones.
I won’t disagree that there could have been a lot more detail in the story, and it could have filled in on a lot more details of freedoms given. I was inspired, in part, by one of the developmentally disabled adults I used to work with who originally had one-on-one supervision (i.e., somebody had to have eyes on him unless he was in the bathroom alone, or in his bedroom alone with the door closed), then, by following the rules, was allowed to remain at home by himself for a few hours, then could go out in town by himself alone for two hours, then four, and then he was allowed to get his own apartment with staff occasionally stopping by to help him out with shopping, bills, etc. In his case, it took years--as it normally does. Given the length of time I had to write the story, I had to gloss over a lot of that process. As 9996139 said, it could serve as a good template for a longer story, and perhaps one day I’ll revisit it and cover all that stuff I simply couldn’t because of time constraints.
9996152
Thank you!
Those are both valuable lessons, and some people have trouble learning them.
It was kind of surprising to me when I thought of it, but it seems like a natural choice.
9996170
That’s fair. Any particular reason?
9996194
Yes, which is why I think she’d be a good pony to be in charge of Cozy’s reformation.
Thank you!
It certainly could have gone on further, and perhaps should. In some ways, I condensed down about a decade’s worth of work down into under 2k words . . . but there was a two hour limit for writing the story from receiving the prompt, so there was only so much I could do.
Who knows, in the future I might decide to expand it out.
9996198
God in Heaven do I know that feel.
my god! they need a death penalty rather than this torture.
I’ve never seen the Cozy Glow episode, but I’ve read a couple of good and some brutal fanfics takes on it. I like reformation stories, especially at this time of year. I think you handled it well. Tough love. She’s young enough that it should be easier than for the older villains. I’d like to see how you’d handle Chrysalis’s, as a companion piece to this one, perhaps. I know lots on your plate and I haven’t commented on your scratched cart yet either. I will though.
9996210
i feel like from what we've seen of cozy glow, doing things like punishing her for what she did wouldnt make her see the error of her ways like a regular pony, it would probably just send her in the opposite direction, mental problems dont just dissapear
I liked seeing Flurry's effectiveness in using a different approach than a 'friendship lesson' or more simply, friendship by example. I don't think the Twilight we know at this moment could have done it using that method, without changing herself in the process.
I also know that my opinion isn't exactly popular, but I feel pretty strongly that the writers did the wrong thing in making a child an unredeemed (or unredeemable) villain in a show directed towards children. But I won't beat a dead... Ur, never mind. Said enough.
9996210 Drive-by horseapple flinging doesn't quite fit the definition of fair. You're just nice.
I get that there was a time limit on writing on this story but man I felt that Flurry Heart was stone cold here. I would love to see you on one day expanded this idea.
Hey there got to read your story. I found it very interesting amazing.
9996225
Hard to redeem somepony after administering the death penalty. Well, maybe not in Equestria, but still. . . .
9996233
I haven’t, either (in fact, it took a while of seeing Cozy art to figure out that she was a villain). Although I did see the final episodes, and she was in ‘em. Got stoned, in fact. And there was this scene, too:
derpicdn.net/img/view/2019/10/16/2170259.png
Thanks! Tough love is what you gotta do sometimes. And you’re right, this is a good time of year to think about rebirth.
Ooh, I don’t know about that one. Honestly, the best thing the ponies could do with her is kill her . . . not a popular opinion, I know, but now that they’ve at least made friends with some of the changelings, she’s more of a liability than anything else.
Or you can wait until I post a picture of my cart with the sticker, that’s okay too.
9996240
Can confirm; I work part-time with developmentally disabled adults. As you can imagine, even more so than some other mental disorders, you can’t simply cure a developmental disability.
Having said that, there is a bit of her treatment which is loosely based on one of the gentlemen I worked with who had a quite successful outcome. Obviously, we didn’t actually threaten to kill him or turn him to stone, but we did provide a tough but fair environment he was capable of thriving in, and over the years he’s gone from a person who required 24/7 one-on-one supervision to a person who lives in his own apartment with staff only occasionally stopping by to help with bills, shopping, etc. He earned that by following the rules and his treatment plan.
It’s been my experience that there is no one size fits all approach to developmental disabilities, and I would imagine the same holds true for mental illness (which I think it would be fair to class Cozy’s megalomania as). Some respond well to tough love, while others do far better with gentle teaching. I think that Cozy is more of a tough love pony, which is why I think that Twilight wouldn’t be the best teacher for her.
9996277
I don’t think Twilight could, either.
We of course don’t know what they’ve got planned for Gen 5, but I do agree that in Cozy’s case, it’s a bit of a downer to end things on. Of course we both know that some villains are unredeemable, but we’d like to think that children are always the exception to that. Just the same, there’s enough evidence in the show that they sometimes thaw their prior stoned failures, so maybe Cozy does have another shot at redemption.
images-wixmp-ed30a86b8c4ca887773594c2.wixmp.com/f/740e745b-9a46-45e6-b5c6-603a24a22287/d5w4v58-e465fa2d-b13e-42d4-9c0d-a603e6aef42e.jpg?token=eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJzdWIiOiJ1cm46YXBwOjdlMGQxODg5ODIyNjQzNzNhNWYwZDQxNWVhMGQyNmUwIiwiaXNzIjoidXJuOmFwcDo3ZTBkMTg4OTgyMjY0MzczYTVmMGQ0MTVlYTBkMjZlMCIsIm9iaiI6W1t7InBhdGgiOiJcL2ZcLzc0MGU3NDViLTlhNDYtNDVlNi1iNWM2LTYwM2EyNGEyMjI4N1wvZDV3NHY1OC1lNDY1ZmEyZC1iMTNlLTQyZDQtOWMwZC1hNjAzZTZhZWY0MmUuanBnIn1dXSwiYXVkIjpbInVybjpzZXJ2aWNlOmZpbGUuZG93bmxvYWQiXX0.9QYR7Su9NF-A38HjM3oUVb4QO8_UtnI5uM-v9LtxH7A
9996283
From what I know of her character, she could be.
Heh, you’re not the only one. I’m not opposed, but heaven knows I haven’t got the time right meow. . . .
9996288
To quote one of my favorite equine psychologists, “Make the right answer easy and the wrong answer hard.” If you keep putting a lot of effort into doing things the hard way, sooner or later you’re gonna wonder if there might be an easier way.
9996296
Thank you!
9996346
I know you meant now, but I am busting my gut out laughing because it reminds me of one of joke from Whose Line Is It Anyway? Where that was a gag during one show and one of the performers brought the house down when they said it.
9996328
Well I'm definitely going to have to disagree with that. Chrysalis, moreso than Tirek or Cozy Glow, has actual ties to the "real" world and reasons for acting the way she does, or at least more ties and reasons that we're aware of, including a valid reason (from her perspective) for seeing friendship as a disease to be opposed. It's just that she has a massive ego, and that the only pony to ever put in even a modicum of effort into reaching out to her, Starlight, did so at absolutely the worst possible time (a moment of extreme weakness when Chrysalis is a creature that can't stand being seen as weak) and in the worst possible way (by offering to give back everything that she had just stolen from Chrysalis if only Chrysalis would acquiesce to Starlight's demands).
Reaching Chrysalis has to begin with acknowledging that she has lost things, things that were important to her, and not brushing aside her feelings on that matter as being invalid or wrong.
Maybe I'm beeing naive here, but at least for cozy glow this seems more like a origin story than a redeem fic. In the show she allready was obsessed with the 'aestethics' of beeing a good person, without actually having internalized what this means - you know, like someone that had been forced into that role out of fear of punishment.
But then again that might just be my personal bias, as someone who never really was fazed by any punishment, when it wasn't a emotional one (e.g. the famous 'I'm not mad just disapointed speech').
Fun story! When I was young, verra young, like two or three, I was a massive pain in the arse. As all small children are. The kind of little brat that you'd dearly wish to drop off of a bridge. Trust me on this, no misunderstanding here, no deprivation or any kind of psychological whatsit, I was just being a little %$@#@.
Anyway, one time I decided to haul off and kick my mom in the shin just as hard as my three year old self could. Which honestly wasn't all that hard, but the intent was definitely there. So, my mom kicked me back, just as hard. Or just as softly as the case may be, more of an enthusiastic nudge really.
So I stared up at her with all of the confused heartbreak a small child is capable of, because I was supposed to get my way without consequences, right? And me mum says "well you kicked me, so I get to kick you back, that's fair right?" And from that day forward I realized, "Oh, it's like that thing with the stove, stupid games win stupid prizes."
Actions have consequences, yes? The earlier you learn the better your life will be.
I love this ruthless but fair Flurry Heart.
Somehow, I stop feeling that Cozy is depressed. From what I saw, Flurry basically used the water spray technique to 'train' Cozy.
Good story, though.
I adore this fic
If that’s true, then where’s the consequences of Harmony and Friendship? And I don’t believe that anything good has no consequences.
The consequences are maximum.
I respect your writing ability, and I'm a sucker for #RedeemCozyGlow stories, but this story feels rushed.
9996598
That is a very interesting question.
9996646
Well, considering it was the result of a random prompt in a speed writing challenge then that would be correct.
9996598
We often think of consequences as being a predominantly negative concept but that is not always so.
Positive actions will tend to have positive consequences. Friendship, support, companionship, compassion, community, help, kindness, inclusiveness, respect... these are just some of the consequences.
9996678
I don’t believe it. Nothing is forever good, it must have bad or living life itself is meaningless if it’s endless happiness. I mean if you lived in a forever peace and nothing changes and everything is always ends the same, wouldn’t you realized everything you learn is worthless?
9996195
Yeeting a boulder into the royal showers definitely seems unacceptable.
Yea, I've been there
Snuck. "Sneaked" is not a word and anyone who says it is is a fool. Including Firefox spellcheck.
9996877
Actually, fun fact, “sneaked” is the original correct past tense of “sneak”. “Snuck” is a relatively modern word that began to crop up in the late 1800s. So “sneaked” is archaic (although it’s also preferred by a lot of British grammarians), but that’s not quite the same thing as incorrect. And it most definitely is a word, much as “wherefore” is a word even if you’ll be hard-pressed to find someone who uses it instead of “why”.
Source
/pedant
9996682
I believe what your referring to is an existential crisis. And damn that's a negative view point, not all consequences are observable, arguably Nightmare Moon is exactly what your looking for, or the changeling invasion and Ignorance would also fit the bill.
Sometimes you and those around you can't see and never will see the negative consequence of our own actions, Equestria likely wont see the bad caused by their harmony as the bad is farther away and not directly impacting them.
kinda feel a reformed cozy would be determined to free and redeem tirek ann chrysalis instead of leaving them as statues but other than that great story