The Share Center
Founded by LyraAlluse · Report

Mystery

Put your mystery themed fan fictions here.

Order: Word Count

TPonyville Noire: Kriegspiel—Black, White, and Scarlet
MLP: FiM
Romance
Horror
Mystery
War has come to Ponyville. As a criminal mastermind, a cruel pirate, and a mare with mysterious motives fight for control, Daring Do and Phillip Finder are put to the test with new cases and new foes.
Gore
Sex
Narcotics
Violence
Death
Profanity
Alt. Universe
Twilight
OC
Other
Daring Do
Flash Sentry
PonyJosiah13 · 282k words · 120 8 · 2k views
TCMC Watch Bedtime Stories
MLP: FiM
Dark
Mystery
Slice of Life
The Cutie Mark Crusaders react to the Bedtime Stories YouTube channel.
Sex
Gore
Violence
Suicide / Self Harm
Death
Profanity
Crossover
Human
Rarity
Other
CMCs
Lord Blundergosh · 150k words · 126 9 · 3.9k views
TThe Pony Of Vengeance
MLP: FiM
Dark
Horror
Sad
A mysterious figure, living in shadows, is attacking seemingly random crime leaders and leaving little to no trace. The Mane Six investigate, but they find a secret more startling than what they had ever imagined.
Gore
Violence
Death
OC
Main 6
Griffons
BradyBunch · 130k words · 129 12 · 3.8k views
TWhere Only Silver Shines
MLP: FiM
Romance
Drama
Mystery
Two young ponies attempt to unveil the mysteries of The Tower, a strange and cruel place that seems to defy many laws of nature.
Violence
Death
Alt. Universe
Luna
OC
Bat Pony
Etyco Filly · 105k words · 26 3 · 429 views
TThere's a Monster Pony Outside My Window
MLP: FiM
Dark
Adventure
The Portsmith family is a regular American family living in Denver in 1986. Life is hard, but it is about to get harder when they find themselves hunted by something that is not of this Earth.
Narcotics
Violence
Profanity
Human
Alt. Universe
OC
Halira · 105k words · 55 6 · 829 views
TSpilled Ink
MLP: FiM
Mystery
Slice of Life
A stallion, dazed and confused, wakes up in the forest near Ponyville without his memory. Now he must make sense of what he can and make a new life for himself, in one way or another. (Post Season 9)
Death
Violence
Profanity
Human
Applejack
OC
Other
Starlight Glimmer
Fiddlove Enfemme · 93k words · 48 4 · 1.3k views
TRedeemed
MLP: FiM
MLP: Movie
MLP Gen 5
Dark
Adventure
Slice of Life
The long-anticipated clash has finally arrived. The world’s magic has been destroyed and all hope is gone. With the fate of Equestria hanging in delicate balance, Misty must lead her friends in their final confrontation against Opaline….
Gore
Violence
Suicide / Self Harm
Death
Profanity
Alt. Universe
Izzy Moonbow
Sunny Starscout
Mane 5
Opaline
Misty
Admiral Producer · 84k words · 26 5 · 1.7k views
TTeenage Equestria Ninja Girls
MLP: FiM
Ninja Turtles
Adventure
Comedy
Mystery
The ninja turtles had a lot of fighting, action and adventure in Equestria, now it's the girls' turn to have it in New York.
Violence
Crossover
Human
Other
Main 6
MlpTmntDisneyKauane · 58k words · 39 5 · 3.1k views
TForgotten Bygones
MLP: FiM
Adventure
Mystery
Thriller
Starlight, Trixie, and Discord are treated like enemies again, but how? And why?
Violence
Gore
Death
Alt. Universe
Twilight
Trixie
Discord
Starlight Glimmer
Catpaw616 · 57k words · 126 9 · 2.3k views
TYou Will Never Escape
Equestria Girls
Horror
Mystery
Sad
Shimmering Diamond Detective Agency receives another missing persons case. These rarely involves more than a few phone calls to find out the person just went no contact with the client, but this one's a bit different.
Profanity
Death
Sunset Shimmer
Autistic Witch · 49k words · 10 1 · 248 views
TSamneo: The Earth Pony
MLP: FiM
Romance
Mystery
It was a regular day, until a stallion named Sam, mysteriously showed up. He has no memory of where he was from, not even knowing what a Cutie Mark is! Soon Sam must discover who he is, and defeat the coming darkness that threatens Ponyville...
Sex
Twilight
Rainbow Dash
OC
Samuel-Neocros · 46k words · 9 4 · 2.1k views
TThe maned ape
MLP: FiM
Adventure
Mystery
A strange ape-like creature is found in a lab in Manehattan. Its injuries are clear that it was hunted for sport by poachers before being captured.
Violence
Gore
Profanity
Human
Alt. Universe
Fluttershy
Twilight
Rainbow Dash
Applejack
Main 6
sykko · 44k words · 376 26 · 5.9k views
E40 Years
MLP: FiM
MLP Gen 5
Adventure
Mystery
A community collaboration of a tale that spawns across all generations of My Little Pony.
Alt. Universe
Crossover
Main 6
Grogar
Mane 5
bookhorse125 · 41k words · 72 3 · 1.4k views
TSpectral Eclipse
MLP: FiM
Mystery
Dusk Shine, archmage of Her Majesty Nightmare Moon, is assigned to aid the Lunar Inquisition in finding a terrorist known as "Ghost" where they last struck: Ponyville.
Alt. Universe
Twilight
OC
Nightmare Moon
Other
Main 6
Relux_the_Relux · 36k words · 31 1 · 1.3k views
TMy Little Ninja Turtle (Part 2)
MLP: FiM
Ninja Turtles
Comedy
Drama
Thriller
Equestria is in danger, now Mane 6 and Turtles need to reconsider, leave differences behind and be friends again to save Equestria from these terrible villains.
Violence
Crossover
Other
Main 6
MlpTmntDisneyKauane · 35k words · 38 7 · 2.8k views
TMy Little Ninja Turtle (Part 1)
MLP: FiM
Ninja Turtles
Adventure
Comedy
Mystery
The turtles went on an adventure in another world called Equestria to saved it from the evil Kraangs, but for that, they needed to learn more about this new world, but luckily they meet the Mane 6.
Violence
Crossover
Other
Main 6
MlpTmntDisneyKauane · 33k words · 51 11 · 3.7k views
TSpringtrapped: An MLP/FNAF Crossover
MLP: FiM
FNAF
Dark
Sad
Thriller
An innocent person went to a convention dressed as Springtrap from FNAF, only to become the actual killer when transported to Equestria.
Gore
Violence
Death
Profanity
Crossover
Spike
Celestia
Luna
Other
Main 6
Lord Shadow Eclipse · 25k words · 37 6 · 760 views
TRecollections: A Sunflower Story
Equestria Girls
Romance
Mystery
Thriller
I didn't know what I was expecting when I rushed to help an unconscious girl I found laying on the school grounds, alone with no memories. I didn't expect a mystery. I didn't expect to dig so deep into a rabbit hole. I didn't expect to find love.
Sex
Violence
Suicide / Self Harm
Alt. Universe
Twilight
Sunset Shimmer
Main 7 (EqG)
Wallflower Blush
The Lone Doctor · 23k words · 33 5 · 874 views
TThe Golden Falcon
MLP: FiM
Romance
Mystery
Sad
A lost pegasus filly, raised by falcons.
Rainbow Dash
Spitfire
OC
Main 6
Wonderbolts
Blueelectric · 20k words · 22 2 · 845 views
TGhastly Mistakes = Ghostly Soulmates
MLP: FiM
Comedy
Drama
Mystery
You are an earth pony mare, who serves as a paranormal investigator... or so you claim. Despite what you tell others, the truth is that you are a con artist, but that's fine. Ghosts and specters, they aren't real... right?
Sex
Second Person
Alt. Universe
OC
Other
Mistmane
Kirins
Robipony · 19k words · 31 3 · 693 views
TSamneo: The Earth Pony DX
MLP: FiM
Romance
Mystery
Slice of Life
Starlight went to get some fresh air, when a comet suddenly crashes in the yard, leaving a mystery stallion in the impact. He's taken into the care of everypony, where he reveals a secret power.
Profanity
Human
Rainbow Dash
OC
Samuel-Neocros · 18k words · 222 views
EStarlight's Great Adventure
MLP: FiM
Adventure
Horror
Mystery
When a magic meteor strikes Equestria, Starlight will fight... against her friends...
Spike
Main 6
Starlight Glimmer
Discord The Narrator · 15k words · 20 6 · 963 views
TThe Murder at Mane Melody
MLP Gen 5
Mystery
Sad
Tragedy
A body was found in Pipp’s salon, Mane Melody. It’s time for Zipp to get on the case
Death
Violence
Other
Pipp
Zipp
Lulamoon-Crystal · 15k words · 37 2 · 1.2k views
TMLP Pulps
MLP: FiM
Dark
Adventure
Anthology
Stories of crime westerns sci-fi and horror.
Narcotics
Violence
Death
Profanity
Anthro
Alt. Universe
OC
Other
anarchywolf18 · 15k words · 17 2 · 399 views

Mystery

Stats

FIMFiction

Follow & Support Us