• Member Since 20th Aug, 2021
  • offline last seen 4 hours ago

False Door


If you like feeling awful, you've come to the right place.

Comments ( 38 )

I popped in to say that's some rather good cover art.

Fantastic story. I loved every single thing about this.

I love the... subtle implication of the art

11770760
My other passion. Thank you.

11770777
Thank you! Great to hear.

11770786
Yeah, I figured if I was going to be kind of vague in the description, I should put as many clues in as I can.

I'm not normally a fan of gender swap stories but this one was good

11770867
My first story even approaching something like this. Guess I'm pushing the envelope.

That ending killed me.

May I make some fanart of their kiddos?

11771148
I'd love to see that! In my mind their names are Dusk and Dawn.

The commissioner requests they be identical but one a colt and one a filly.

An interesting premise. Overall, I liked it. The implications with Twilight was a good setup for the tone. The Wishing Star was a new angle for this, though the informal way the star behaved was a little jarring for me, personally, but I get that this is meant to be a comedy.
Celestia having to get drunk put me off a little, though. And the degree to which she drunk-speaks was noticeably inconsistent.

“I thing thiz’ll werk,” she slurred. “Lez make sum folz.”
“Shuddup an’ get on the bed,”
“Oh, that felt good but it also aches.”
“Thiz feels incredible,”
“I- I think I'm almost there,”
“The funnel comment wuz jus a joke; you don't hafta be zo cridigal all the time,”
“I'm exagly as drunk az I need ta be ta fuck my annoying moon zister,”
“We should just settle down and meditate on the beauty of creation and new life.”

But I'm not trying to prod your ass too hard over it. I'd just recommend going through and making sure that her level of drunk speak is consistent, or at least on a trend of getting steadily worse or better, depending on what you need her to say. Just not have it go up and down like a rollercoaster. That's really my only objective criticism.

As I said, I really enjoyed it overall.

Classic wish-granter, going the path of least effort that tramples the spirit of the wish.

I would like a second chapter, if not a follow up story, with Celestia and Luna realizing that kids are a struggle but also coming to grips with the fact that they both asked for this and they have to live with the decision.

11771672
Well that's an easy fix anyway.

11771187
Absolutely! I'll be sure to let you know when they're done.

Nice story! And they get to have kids? Cool.
One a colt and one a filly...why do I get the feeling that the incest stuff will carry on...

And now I will bore you with a little genetic stuff, even though Celestia became a stallion and temporarily changing appearances is easy, it's hard to imagine how she got a Y chromosome, as the DNA contained in it is drastically different from those from X chromosomes. In other words, she has to get the extra genes from somepony else who is a stallion to get an extra Y. Mares are XX and stallions are XY. Only when one of the partners have a Y will an offspring be a male.

You're doing great, keep on writing!

11786487
Also the twins are identical so I don't know how that works with a colt and a filly but why not? We're already in the neighborhood...

11787012
That's possible, most of the chromosomes are still the same and Celestia is very likely to be a thoroughbred horse so different sperms shouldn't be that different even if they have different sex chromosomes.

And on a side note, all sexual reproduction processes so far require an egg cell but they don't necessarily need a sperm cell. It's just more natural that way, and it doesn't need too much science involved. Cloning and artificial cell fusion already exist...

And happy new year, have a good one!

Very nice. At first, I thought the whole ‘have to get them drunk first’ thing was going to be a terrible cliche to hand-wave away reluctance. But your commitment to the bit — all the way to the hangover — redeemed it and made it good again.

Love the bickering dynamic between the two of them, too!

Just one question remains: who is the father of Twilight’s foal? I demand the answer in the form of a 7000 word clopfic.

11851167
I'd never waste a drunk character!

As for the father. In the original outline it's Shining Armor and if want THAT story it's in The New Normal... Mostly.

11851669
Well, that's a little too obvious, isn't it? We can do better!
(I vote for some futa or R63 self-cest, with Twi getting impregnated by a copy of herself.)

11852521
Asexual reproduction... Or is it?

11771187
I finally finished the art! Apologies for taking so long. I would like to know how you'd like to see it. Email, link to DA/Insta?

11860875
Ooo! Instagram works.

11860890
Awesome! I'll link it here once I get it posted.

11860927
That's so cool! I love the luna moth cutie marks. No one's ever made art based off my stuff before so this is a real treat. I'll make sure to pass this along to the commissioner too.

11860927
Commissioner wants to know if you'll be submitting it to Derpibooru.

11861070
If they'd prefer that, I'm more than happy to put it on there.

11861431
3330668t. I dunno if that's how that works. I've never used this site before.

11861543
Nevermind. It's cool. They're on DA.

11861897
Want me to put it there, then?

11861929
Yeah, that works great!

11861939
Awesome! Just gimme a sec. It's been a good year or so since I used the site.

11861944
Thanks so much!

11861962
Of course! I'd also like to say that, if you want art of your stories, I'm always happy to provide. Your stories are amazing.

Login or register to comment