• Published 16th Aug 2016
  • 5,870 Views, 78 Comments

Dear Rarity - Alyssa Hartwick



Rarity is bored...she reads Sweetie belles diary. Its fine she isn't here anymore....

  • ...
6
 78
 5,870

The beginning

Rarity had just finished closing her boutique for the day.

“It had been quite a slow one though.” Rarity thought as she turned the “OPEN” Sign to “CLOSED”. She began walking through the main floor of the boutique, Luna’s pale moon shone brightly through the many windows as she had already turned out the lights. Rarity began humming a sweet tune to herself.

She was almost to the stair’s, “Finally I can take a- “

Rarity froze.

Her thoughts interrupted by an unsettling noise.

She heard a pitter-patter of hooves behind her.

She quickly spun around to confront the hooligan only to realize no pony was there. She sighed before turning around one more.

Out of the corner of her eye she saw a shadow scurry in the darkness. Her eyes pin pricks as she felt her chest tighten as she turned toward where the shadow had run. She felt as a chilling fear gripped her hear

The undressed mannequins stood only partially glowing in the moon’s light while the rest was engulfed within an inky black shadow. Rarity felt as she slowly walked toward the looming figures. She didn’t want to, their featureless faces almost taunting her, mocking her.

Rarity gulped.

Ignited her horn and its light only illuminated some of the darkness. As she weaved through the many unused mannequins a sense of dread started to tie a knot in her stomach.

As she felt herself nearing the back wall she felt as the hairs on the back of her neck began to prick up as she felt her skin tingle and heart quicken as her adrenaline started to build in her system.

As she moved ever closer to the wall a small amount of light from her horn illuminated part of the wall. But something quickly skittered out of her view.

It was white.

As she neared the back wall she saw something glint.

Eye’s.

She Starred into eyes that reflected a yellow glow within the darkness. With a shaky voice Rarity spoke out into the thick darkness.

“Hello? Is Someone there?”

Her words hung as the air began felt suddenly heavy.

Rarity screamed.

Opal darted out of the corner hissing at her owner. Rarity let out a relived sigh. She Turned back toward the stair way that lead up to her room.

She didn’t notice a black figure in the corner. She didn’t hear it giggle either.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________


Rarity walked down the hall into her living room. After entering She picked up a magazine in her magic whilst she sat down in one of her comfortably fashionable chairs. After scanning the pages for a half an hour she quickly grew board. She gently set the magazine on the table beside her.

She accidentally switched off the light.

In front of the door way where the light shone through the hall she saw an indistinguishable figure. She quickly switched the light back one only to realize there was no pony there.

Of course there wasn’t anypony there. Sweetie Belle was sleeping over at Apple Jacks with Scootalo and Apple bloom.

Rarity breathed. She hadn’t realized that she had been holding her breath for the past minute.

She stood up. She was bored and she wanted to read. She began walking into her room. As she trotted past sweeties room she saw something that caught her eye.

Her eyes widened.

Sweetie Bell’s Diary.

It had been what? A month since she gave it to her? Rarity looked at the book longingly. She looked left and right looking for anypony who would notice this act she was about to perform. Not that someone would. She gingerly walked in to the room.

Her aura surrounded the book as she lifted it off the night stand and into her waiting hooves. She starred at its pink cover. She bit her hoof in as she argued the morality of reading her little sisters diary. “What if she has a crush!” she asked herself. She opened up the book with no hesitation.

To say that the first two pages were boring would be an understatement. Until she read something about a filly named Angel feather.

She pondered a moment “Where have I heard that name?” She asked herself out load.

After skimming the next three pages her face drained of all its color.

Au/17/16
Dear Diary
Rarity said yes! I introduced Angel to rarity today, Rarity acted quite odd while meeting her. They didn’t even speak or even make eye contact! Angel didn’t say anything so I asked for her. Rarity said yes and that Angel Feather was welcome to stay as long as she’d like!
I have a pretty big closet and I never use it so I decided that Angel could live there! She looked at it and nodded in approval so I brought her some pillows and a blanket from one of the guest rooms. I also bought her a night light in case she got scarred. It was my old red one that when turned on shone a pretty red light. She thanked me before going to her new room and making it her own.
It’s Getting pretty late. Goodnight!

She remembered that.

Rarity was sitting in her favorite arm chair reading The Hoofington post browsing through the gossip section. “Rarity!” Rarity jumped at the sudden yell. Putting the article down she starred down at sweetie who had an exited look plastered on her face. “Yes Sweetie?” she asked slightly annoyed to be interrupted from her reading, and she was getting to a juicy part to.

“I Made a new friend!” sweetie shouted excitedly, “That’s wonderful sweetie!” she said genuinely excited for her. “So Meet Angel feather!” sweetie nearly yelled as she pointed… to nothing. Rarity’s eye twitched. “OH Great! Another imaginary friend!” Rarity thought bitterly.

“It’s a pleasure to meet you “Angel feather” Darling” Rarity spoke through Clenched teeth. “you see she’s homeless and she has nowhere to go…” Sweetie bell began. “So I was wondering…” Rarity bitterly thought” Here it comes!”. “Can she live with us?” Sweetie bell asked exited.

“Of course sweetie bell!” Rarity said in an overly sweet voice. She looked to where this “Angel feather” was standing. Rarity thought that Sweetie had finally got over this imaginary friend thing.

Rarity nodded idly as sweetie “Introduced” her “New friend” as she looked in “Her” general direction.

Rarity began scanning the pages faster as all the pieces fell into place in her mind. Her mind racking her brain for an explanation.

A Changeling? A Windigo? A Ghost?

What had Sweetie bell befriended?

A Question that burned through her mind.

She suddenly had a problem. The page was stuck. She used her magic to pry it open.

What she saw made her heart stop.


The page had splotches of dried blood. She read the still legible writing.

Her magic extinguished as her mind couldn't fathom what she was reading.
She turned the page once more to be met by more blood.

The word “Look” was written in fresh dried blood. The putrid smell stinging her nose.
She wanted to scream, cry, shout. She wanted this nightmare to end.

But she sat there turning the next page.

The word “behind” was written in crimson.

With a shaking hoof she turned the page one last time.

The word “YOU” was scrawled across the page.

Rarity slowly craned her neck.

There was a shadow in the doorway.

Author's Note:

And finished! :pinkiecrazy: Oh you want more?:derpytongue2: if this gets 25 likes then ill make this a trilogy :trollestia:

Comments ( 77 )

I don't know, for some reason I didn't enjoy this as much as the first part of this story.
The ending was, well, meh to me. It wasn't like the last part's ending, which I found to be better then this one.

7486805 ok I must say that I agree with you on that. more or less.

Why do I picture this creature - a nocnitsa, I figure - impersonating Pinkie Pie and doing Cupcakes?

Suitably terrifying, at any rate, and more than a match for the common unicorn...

(ObHeresy: it targets Flurry Heart. OTOH, maybe it doesn't wanna risk tangling with an alicorn princess in Mama Bear mode...)

7486805
7486888
I agree...
In all honesty i didn't want to make a sequal but every one asked so i tried...
I had never made a sequal so i didn't know where to begin
sorry to dissapoint:fluttercry::heart:

7486934 It's not bad, as such, just a little rushed. But it is fuel for many a crack theory of mine...

The ending was a little cliche to be honest, but was better with the 'horror.' Even if this doesn't get 25 likes you should make the next.

7486947
Thank you for the kind words :twilightsmile:

7486949
I know it was but i didn't know how to end it sorry:pinkiesad2:

7486950 It's totally fine!, you didn't disappoint me!

I do apologize though, seeing as I was one of the people who wanted a sequel. I apologize for forcing you to make it, even though you didn't want to.

7486952 No offense, it just seemed rushed. Even though it was a great sequel.

7486954
To be honest i wanted to leave it on a permanent cliff hanger so that it would always leave the reader wondering..."What happend":twilightsheepish:
but thank you for the kind words:twilightsmile:
and its not your fault i just wanted to please every one:pinkiesmile:

7486963
yea i know its rushed i just wanted to make the readers happy:pinkiesad2:

7486969 Well, I would have liked it if it was a cliffhanger, but at the same time I did want to learn more/see more.
And you're welcome, I don't know if you'll do another one to end the trilogy, but if you don't feel like doing it, then don't do it. We'll understand.

7486971 And the readers are happy from the looks of it. No dislikes means it was good, so keep up the good work!:pinkiehappy:

7486973
if you want to see more of my work i have about 2 other one shots that are dark:pinkiesmile:
check them out if youd like:rainbowkiss:

7486978
thanks :pinkiehappy:
I have some other oneshots that you can veiw if you'd like:rainbowkiss:

Why is there so much blank space in the synopsis?

7486979 I'll definitely make sure to!

Which one would you recommend?

7486998
Well i would recommend "The Tale of a mad mare" for those who love edger Allen poe:twilightsmile:
and "forever silent" for those who enjoy physiological horror:pinkiesmile:

7486992
It makes it..... DRAMATIC:pinkiecrazy::rainbowwild:

7487044 Cool, I'll definitely give Forever Silent a look then!

Thank you for recommending them to me. :twilightsmile:

The ending sold it to me.

So... It makes identical copies of ponies it killed?

7486934
ohhhhh don't feel bad, think of it as feed back on your first sequel...... for better or worst. but either way, it is still a good story.

7487269
Puny mortal the truth is always so much more gruesome than one may think:pinkiecrazy:

A good story, keeping up the vibe of horror established in the prequel to this. I will agree that the ending was a bit more cliché and duller in this story compared to its predecessor, but that's not entirely a fault of your own.

Making a story should be something you do to the point where you feel satisfied, so don't always feel as if you have to rush something out. We can understand that life may not always accommodate. There are plenty of kind people and various groups on this site dedicated to providing editing services and general advice/improvement for one's writing. Even just one pre-reader and some edits can make a great difference for a story, although the process is ultimately your choice.

If you do make a sequel, I look forward to seeing it when you feel it's ready. Keep up the good work.

7487438
Thank you for the advice and the kind words:pinkiesmile::heart::twilightsmile:

I saw a video on YouTube that had a creature similar to what you described in the first story and the pony it attacked was rarity. We're you inspired by it or a horror movie that had a similar monster?

Also great story. I should no have read this right now seeing it is about 12:00 though. I got chills from reading both stories back to back.

7487476
Your welcome:pinkiecrazy:

if you want more terror i have a few more dark oneshots that you can read:rainbowkiss:

If you dare

7487494 let me at em, I can take em!

7487499
the other two dark one shots i have is "Tale of a Madmare" and "Forever silent":pinkiecrazy: you can find them in the oneshots section on my user page:twilightsmile:






Sweet dreams

7487507 I will definitely check them out.

that was awesome I did not want to scroll down to keep reading.

7487926
Im glad you enjoyed:yay:

I have a few more horror themed oneshots that you can read:pinkiecrazy:

and more horror will be coming soon:rainbowkiss:

I like this story more than the "Dear Diary" story.It had more of an explanation and i think i have theories behind Angel.

Our previous protagonist, Sweetie bell from the previous story is possibly dead since her diary has blood and it would make a little sense if her diary had blood on it.It would also explain why it doesn't mention Sweetie bell anywhere in the story.

I can't tell Angel's reason for the attack but here's what i can only predict: Angel is after the members of the elements of harmony and if she could even at least kill 1 of them,the elements wont work properly and but her reason behind Sweetie bell im not so sure.Maybe Sweeite bell is always with Rarity meaning she's a witness and Angel has to eliminate her to prevent future consequences.

Another reason i come to think of is that Angel is preparing for a satanic ritual and needs dead bodies of Unicorns.This makes sense since both Sweeite bell and Rarity are Unicorns.

I really like this story though.It puts a lot of theories into the readers and i enjoy that.Same goes to Resident evil 7.I apologize if im over-thinking this but its just interesting to think about.

This has the same absurdity as all those 'found footage' movies.

Why the hell is Sweetie writing down what the monster is doing? Usually, when someone sees something like that, they tend to put down the pen/camera and GET THE HECK AWAY FROM IT!!

And the old 'look behind you' trope... *sighs*

This is like a first-year film student's attempt at a horror film script.

7488250
Im working on a third:pinkiecrazy:






IM going to be nice and going to give you a little spoiler. Its from the monsters point of veiw

7488483

I see where your coming :twistnerd:
and thank you for the criticism:pinkiesmile:

I. AM. DISTURBED. AND. CREEPED. OUT.

The writing was great! :)

I read this and the previous story. Which you should know since I added it in my "Stories Read" library. Anyway.
I never said I would give this a review and this isn't exactly a review but... some of my thoughts.
It's creepy, no doubt about that. As you said in a comment, you didn't want to really do a sequel. I honestly felt like the ending to the first story was better. It was just better thought out, and while I going to say it was obvious you had been planning and working on it, it's really just a guess.
I've just read so many stories of all kinds (and not just on this site) that I'm really not surprised by many things. The ending to this... I didn't know what was exactly going to happen, but I had a suspicion, and as soon as I saw the first bloody message that Rarity was reading, I knew exactly what was going to happen. I just shrugged, said, 'Meh' and continued reading.
It's not a bad story by any means. Though there are a few typos here and there. With a little more polish in terms of editing, it'd be even better. I'd be willing to help with editing, if you request it.
And I can definitely tell that you like dark and horror just as much as I do. Maybe more so, maybe not. Hell, I'm tempted to even let you know (if you ask) about a horror fic I'm planning in the far future, in some detail. Just PM me about it. Or not.

Edit: I did enjoy both stories, but the first one more so than the second.

Perfect for some night reading I love it!

7521079
I have more horror if you want:pinkiecrazy:

Login or register to comment