My Little Killer: Creepypasta Is Magic
Founded by TwilieTheFoal · Report

Creepypasta and Death!

Absolutely any Mlp creepypasta that is, Scary, and very Dark. PONIES NEED TO DIE!!!!

Order: Date Added

TBirthday Pony
MLP: FiM
Dark
Horror
Thriller
The Mane 6 summon the Birthday pony, an old Ponyville urban legend.
Violence
Gore
Death
Main 6
Serenity Darkmoon Raven · 2k words · 309 views
TSilent Ponyville Side Stories
MLP: FiM
Romance
Dark
Sad
Slice of Life
Tragedy
Several stories that tie into Silent Ponyville
Crossover
Fluttershy
Rainbow Dash
Pinkie
OC
Octavia
Other
SamRose · 23k words · 296 6 · 5.8k views
TPegasus Device
MLP: FiM
Dark
In the sequel to Rainbow Factory, can two foals survive the secrets of the Corporation?
Gore
Alt. Universe
Rainbow Dash
OC
AuroraDawn · 51k words · 1,521 88 · 70k views
TSarcastic Applejack
MLP: FiM
Dark
Tragedy
Applejack has always believed in honesty, but when tragedy and loss has struck her family, how will she cope? The darkness and lies are consuming her as she unravels the truth and is betrayed by someone she loves most.
Gore
Alt. Universe
Applejack
Big Mac
Granny Smith
UglyPug · 5.8k words · 27 8 · 1.4k views
ESlender
MLP: FiM
Horror
Something evil has found Ponyville.
Applejack
Granny Smith
Jade Ring · 2.1k words · 219 5 · 6.1k views
EIt Moves Below
MLP: FiM
Horror
The Rock Farm is isolated from everyone. Marble Pie knows that. That's why no one else has seen the mouth in the snow, following her wherever she goes. Every day it's closer, and today she's alone. And the snowfall has become very deep...
Pie Sisters
boardgamebrony · 2.4k words · 225 4 · 5.6k views
TCarousel
MLP: FiM
Dark
Drama
Horror
There is a part of Ponyville’s past its citizens forgot, a part that was left to rot... until Rarity encounters a dark power in Old Town Hall.
Rarity
Thornquill · 69k words · 289 5 · 5.4k views
THaunting Nightmare
MLP: FiM
Dark
What lingers amongst the shelves? What watches from the corners? What is in the library?
Twilight
Rainbow Dash
Spike
Pen Stroke · 30k words · 572 16 · 15k views
TShattered Prism
MLP: FiM
Dark
Sad
Each night I’m trapped in the dark, immobilized. I hear whispers as they operate on me: they say I shouldn’t be alive. Twilight refuses to tell me about the operation. Sometimes she can’t look me in the eye. What did they do to me?
Twilight
Rainbow Dash
Tank
Main 6
Kaidan · 34k words · 1,083 48 · 13k views
TA Puppet To Her Fame
MLP: FiM
Romance
Dark
Tragedy
My unicorn parents called me a worthless mud pony. They pushed me every day to overcome my lowly status. When I woke up one morning with my cutie mark, I thought they would love me. I couldn't have been farther from the truth.
Gore
Sex
Lyra
Bon-Bon
DJ P0N-3
Octavia
Other
Kaidan · 30k words · 1,697 72 · 30k views
TSilent Ponyville 4
MLP: FiM
Dark
Horror
Sad
Octavia travels to Ponyville, seeking out her sister in the hopes of putting an end to her nightmares.
Sex
Gore
Crossover
Alt. Universe
Pinkie
Octavia
SamRose · 56k words · 134 5 · 3.8k views
TLet Her In
MLP: FiM
Dark
Horror
It's cold outside and all Fluttershy wants is for Apple Bloom to let her in.
Apple Bloom
TooShyShy · 2.7k words · 1,248 24 · 29k views
TTwilight's Dollhouse
MLP: FiM
Dark
Tragedy
This funeral was just Twilight’s first. She realizes every pony she loves will die. Now that she is an Alicorn, she will have to relive this crippling heartache hundreds of times. . . Unless she can find a way to keep her best friends forever.
Twilight
Scootaloo
Big Mac
Lyra
DJ P0N-3
Kaidan · 93k words · 1,016 59 · 30k views
TFlutterschmooze
MLP: FiM
Dark
Horror
Thriller
Lets all take off our masks
Gore
Human
Fluttershy
Other
Opium4TmassS · 1.6k words · 148 12 · 13k views
TWhy I stopped watching My Little Pony
MLP: FiM
Dark
Drama
Horror
Tragedy
“The meaning of life is that it stops.”
Gore
Human
OC
Other
Main 6
Opium4TmassS · 1.6k words · 246 34 · 21k views
TFluttershy's Darkest Secret
MLP: FiM
Dark
Thriller
Tragedy
Fluttershy wants to be malicious to her friends for some reason, is it because she's evil?
Gore
Fluttershy
Celestia
Luna
Main 6
Cutest Boxer Puppy Ever · 1k words · 17 16 · 1.1k views
TThey're Gone
MLP: FiM
Dark
Sad
Tragedy
Tirek and I did not negotiate; my friends are gone, and he is dead. The worst part? I won.
Alt. Universe
Twilight
Main 6
JackRipper · 1.4k words · 409 26 · 7.9k views
THolder's Boulder
MLP: FiM
Drama
Horror
Mystery
"Mind thy work. Honor thy kin. Stay away from Holder's Boulder." Marble disobeyed the warnings.
Other
Maud Pie
Limestone Pie
Marble Pie
Horse Voice · 5.1k words · 509 12 · 11k views
TWanna Play?
MLP: FiM
Dark
Horror
Thriller
We are all mad here
Gore
Human
Pinkie
Other
Opium4TmassS · 3.5k words · 125 12 · 7.9k views
TSilent Ponyville 3
MLP: FiM
Dark
Horror
Sad
Twilight must confront a town overcome by a demonic fog.
Gore
Crossover
Twilight
Celestia
SamRose · 153k words · 947 39 · 16k views
TSilent Ponyville 2
MLP: FiM
Romance
Dark
Horror
Sad
Fluttershy has been having horrible nightmares and goes to see Twilight for help.
Gore
Crossover
Fluttershy
Rainbow Dash
Pinkie
SamRose · 53k words · 997 24 · 19k views
TSilent Ponyville
MLP: FiM
Dark
Horror
Sad
Pinkie Pie goes to Twilight to end her horrible nightmares.
Gore
Crossover
Pinkie
SamRose · 30k words · 1,809 39 · 45k views
TSilent Ponyville: Reunion
MLP: FiM
Silent Hill
Dark
Lance Strongshy subjects himself to a mind delve to try and salvage the wreckage of his medical career
Gore
Sex
Crossover
OC
Chapter 17 · 259k words · 340 15 · 17k views
TPinkamena's Awakening: A Promise Unforgotten
MLP: FiM
Dark
Adventure
Tragedy
Pinkamena returns to reality with the help of Pinkie Pie and her friends, but everything is not as it seems when events start to take a turn for the worse.
Gore
Pinkie
OC
Other
Main 6
Kingsley · 19k words · 68 6 · 2.7k views

Creepypasta and Death!

Stats

FIMFiction

Follow & Support Us