Starlight Glimmer had all she could want. She was in charge of a village of ponies, and she had convinced them all to give up their cutie marks in pursuit of what she believed was true and irrefutable friendship.
Now though, the house of cards has come crashing down. Starlight is revealed as a fraud and captured by the element bearers. Her villagers reclaim their cutie marks and renounce her beliefs. However, one of the ponies formerly living under her rules decides she needs a punishment most befitting of her crime.
This story is part of a group of stories I'm calling the Taste of Their Own Medicine series. In all of these stories, the message is clear: It ain't so great to have a taste of your own medicine.
Chapters (12)
Interesting! Can't wait to see the next chapter!
To be honest I did like Starlight as a villain better and I did think she got off way too easily anyways
Happy Christmas! 🎄⛄
This is actually a very interesting concept. I always did think some of the villains in mlp got off too easily. Merry Christmas🎄
That's ok, can't wait for the next chapter
But she can fly. She just choose not to.
If I can remember correctly she can track gems. Also, I find it ironic she says that because she can’t do ANYTHING anymore.
11496544
She's being spiteful because that's all she can really do at the moment
11496590
Makes sense
Oh reading this has made my day.
Bout time she learned the hard way
So when's the next chapter?
11502042
I can't say exactly. I have some other stories I'm working on, plus I started doing artwork to go with stories, which takes time to get done. The best I can do with a time frame is probably sometime before summer. Can't be any more specific than that.
11502059
Okay
Nice for a second I thought Rainbow Das was Pinkie Pie , But let's see how she does with Starlight
not cool starlight
How about karma for starlight when she gets her backstory revealed and told off for how pathetic it is that she overrreacted and went full blown dictator just because a friend moved away
It kind of is.
Just punch her one time.
That would be me.
I’m gonna be honest I thought it just meant she was good with animals.
Hey pot, kettle called and he says your black.
Punch her one time, applejack. I promise you you’ll feel better.
I hope when she tells them about sunburst applejack says the same thing as revenge.
One, so far so good. Especially the first chapter when Twilight acts like a responsible adult and future ruler instead of naive emo brat.
And my hope is when its Rarity's turn she goes for the jugular.
Just point out to Starlight that, as the owner of a business, she had to learn a fair bit about Equastrian law. And that one of the oldest laws on the books just happens to be one that states "removing a ponies cutie mark by any means including force or guile, save by a licensed physician with informed consent duly witnessed by an agent of the crown, shall be punished by beheading to be carried out not less than the next sunrise."
Then just happen to mention that since that time no pony had been dumb enough to actually try removing a mark. Bet that would give her real nightmares.
At least losing her parents is way more deeper and tragic than one lousy friend moving away for magic school all because of a stupid cutie mark! Or some village full of ponies you've spent years forcing your twisted beliefs on by brainwashing if they didn't see or do things your way!😠
11529887
Goes without saying that Starlight is rather self centered
11529960
She is coming off as a petty brat here, I know it's sad losing a friend but that doesn't mean she can take it out on others, even if they take away her village she brought it on herself
11529995
The story is titled what it is for a reason. Soon enough she'll learn her lesson.
11530005
Is this gonna be a series? Because I got some recommended villains.
11533099
It is. The original story was titled A Taste of Their Own Medicine. I did it a while back, but I'm going to rewrite that story at some point in the future. There is another story I have planned as well, but I haven't done any serious work on it yet.
11533101
Another story? What’s it about?
11533153
Rough summary - A changeling fails a mission and Chrysalis drains his love. He's locked up and reflects on what happened.
11533160
Oh cool
Um...
Rarity? Is there something you want to tell your friends? Maybe corroborate an alibi in case some ponies come looking for their loved ones who were last seen headed to your shop?
Oooh Dang! Pinkie did NOT hold back!
Also I knew Starlight wouldn't have let the ponies leave even if they voiced their unhappiness and wanted their cutie marks back
Can't wait for the next chapter
.... yep. Thats the Rarity that became my favorite.
A definite drama queen, averse to dirt, and a few other flaws. But willing to do whatever is required to right a wrong. And she has a dangerous combination of cunning, esoteric knowledge, and talent that means she will find the flaws on your plan and drive the mother of all seam rippers through them.
Starlight, I highly suggest you shut your mouth and do exactly as the white unicorn says. She isn't bluffing.
I loved pinkie pie in this. She may be bubbly, naive, and sometimes a airhead, but she’s not stupid. Everything she spat was facts. I also loved rarity, sometimes villains need threats to be put in their place and starlight is one of those villains.
I wouldn’t mind that idea.
To be fair she forgave luna, discord, and sunset so I doubt she’s gonna do anything too bad.
NO!
That she deserves.
Is there a difference?
YES!
Finally!!!
If your hoof is hurting after punching then you need practice.
She has a good plan. She doesn’t even need to separate from the group. Fly up and call out the directions.
Fluttershy doesn't normally punch things, so I doubt she has much knowledge about things such as proper form.
Oh finally! I've been hoping for another chapter!
11586992
Good point. Also, you forgot to hit the reply button.
I am SO HOOKED on this!!!
Well Glimmer, congratulations.
You just made sure that the rest of your trip to prison is going to a literal hell of thirst, starvation, sleep deprivation, exposure, and being dragged across every patch of rough ground and patch of cacti they encounter. There is a reason smart career crooks don't fight when they're arrested.
Hope you look good in bandages and chains....
Fluttershy, I understand you’re the element of kindness, but sometimes you’re too nice.
Hope they throw her into prison and if she does try to fight again, I kind of hope it shows that was only successful in fighting before when she caught them unaware and they’re re holding back because I hated how much starlight matched twilight in that season finale
11630788
Honestly, I never understood it either.
11630756
Yeah. That is the big reason I dislike her in cannon. She's not kind. She's bloody naive. The sort of person who keeps forgiving, and demanding others forgive, no matter how monstrous the perpetrators actions or how often they relapse. Too many really good people get killed or worse because others don't want to accept the ugly side of reality. Seeing it waved about as some kind of virtue just ticked me off even more.
And nicely done. Show might have held my interest past the first season if Twilight had been a bit more like this and not some Pollyanna-ish Mary Sue.
Though maybe next time break her horn. Sun butt will probably reverse her mark being removed given said failures idiotic tendency to forgive ponies for the stupidest reasons. Busted horn however seemed to be beyond her given Tempests case.
11631169
Although I haven’t seen her force forgiveness on someone else I have seen it in other stories. And you’re right. I’m a huge fan of equestria girls and a pattern I’ve seen is no matter how bad sunset is she still gets forgiven. There have even been time where the others would even try and force forgiveness. So I 100% agree with some of the things you’re saying.
Bravo. I don't think it's a stretch to suggest that this is perhaps the only proper way to reform Starlight. It always felt cheap to me that she never had to experience what she did to the inhabitants of 'Our Town'. Also, not to say I necessarily have anything against canon!reformed Starlight, but I think this could believably lead to a version of her who's more considerate about how she uses her magic.
Yes, it’s back.
11722587
I’ve felt that way about her and a lot of villains.
I think this warrants a "Teen" rating since it's a bit violent for an E rating, including the swearing. Maybe also an "Alternate Universe" tag since the Mane 6 are more aggressive than they are in canon, plus I can't exactly see Starlight becoming good friends with them after this.
11739922
I hope not.
Interesting twist...
Is this Luna's doing? This feels like an orchestrated dream, considering what's already happened. Now sure how she knows about the connection between Sunburst and Starlight, though. It's either that or timey-wimey, like a time loop a la Groundhog Day, which might have been plausible up until Sunburst showed up. That's too big a difference. Unless the Mane Six are there to, and they just brought Sunburst with them and he went in first. Though I think Double Diamond would have mentioned there being multiple visitors, having been Starlight's enforcer during her rule of Our Town.
I’m a little upset that it was just a dream, but I’m curious on where this goes.
Nope. Just nope.
I really REALLY dislike (to put things mildly) this whole "it was all a dream" bit you have going on. Even if the first part did in fact happen and this is really Luna tearing through Starlight's mind. Aside from being a cliche, it does nothing for the overall story but distract and drag matters out. Neither does anything for a story but cause readers to get bored and leave.
I would suggest either A) breaking the first set out into their own story with this "it was all a dream" section as a sequel/ alternate or B) cut the dream section to one chapter maximum.
Just because an idea seems cool does not make it a good idea.