“All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain”
Page generated in 0.242 seconds
Total duration
853 users online
25,498 hits today, 1,685,165 yesterday
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Fanfiction
Designed and coded by knighty & Xaquseg - © 2011-2025
Support us
SubStar
Chat!
Discord
Follow us
Twitter
MLP: Friendship is Magic® - © 2025 Hasbro Inc.®
Fimfiction is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Hasbro Inc.®
you had me at that suicide/self-harm tag. not a lot of HIE fics with something like that and upon reading the chapter there are clearly signs that things are going to go wrong.
10584517
Yep! But we gotta build to that first. Things are gonna get heavy....
What’s the difference between the Introduction and Prologue?
I don’t think she’s the friendship connoisseur at this point in time.
That means they were wonderful, right?
Will that come up?
Not that well, but I’ll try.
I don’t think there was a mention of a dragon.
So, spike is the same height as the ponies?
Is that actually what it looks like?
Why is that bad?
How does she understand him the most?
Is this being written in a diary or something?
Is that foreshadowing?
You mean how he got there?
Does he know he’s in a tv show?
Are they saying “anyone” because they have a human living there, now?
To answer twilight’s question, maybe it’s because he’s not from equestria?
What is she’s touching him with?
He has aneurysms?
What was that?
Why didn’t she tell him?
Why not tell the others? they might help.
White smoke?
What does that mean?
What has he been through?
Is she dreaming?
We need a comedy tag after that.
Sorry about the long comment, this usually happens when I read a long chapters.
10585882
Alright this is a lot to unpack but, I really appreciate the comment, must have taken you a while so I’ll try my best to answer it! I’m going to label each questions you give numerically to make this easier to follow.
1. I didn’t do a good job really separating the intro from really being a prologue and that’s on me, what I visioned the prologue to be is his day of transition to Equestria from Earth. I still did end up explaining however the cast and my version of Equestria while giving the setting as well so it’s really not all that different. What I should have said was, “if anyone wants a chapter on his arrival, I’d be willing to do that”
2. Not exactly however this takes place somewhere around season 2 when I stopped watching. They’re going to be some things that don’t add up and that’s my memory failing me so if anything doesn’t add up to the actual show take it as this is a unique universe with a few changes. Twilight isn’t an alicorn however is likely well known in town as a figure to seek guidance from. It’s really just the main characters opinion in the long run based on what he already knows.
3. Yes, lol like I said I quickly run over these chapters on my phone in bed at roughly 1-4 am. There’s going to be some sentences I miss that sound weird. I’ll look into rewording that line.
4. Yes, it’ll mainly be the reason for the narcotics tag
5. You low key roasted me but, I deserve it :( hopefully as I write some more, I’ll get better with my descriptions
6. Very briefly, I mention him when speaking on the town being full of ponies besides one dragon.
7. No he’s slightly shorter, I described it has the ponies were at his lower chest while spike was around his waist, I feel like I should add a line around there to compare him to ponies.
8. In the show? Fuck if I know, that was like 9 years ago for me feels like. Also our main character leaves out a lot of details on the interior and that’s on me. Also I didn’t describe how the library’s living quarters is a dining room and kitchen all in one room, another set of stairs leads to the bedrooms. I will fix this as I really need this to be more accurate then what I wrote. Also, I’m making the interior completely up from scratch with a small relation to the show, as you read more you’ll realize I will be doing this for a lot of settings.
9. He’s being sarcastic
10. The main character doesn’t explain this as he doesn’t like getting all sappy. I’d rather it show through actions in the story on how she understands him the most just based on how well he gets along with everyone
11. Yea, scenes without our character will be written jumping from character to character however, only ones with close relationships to the MC will be sometimes in first person, we won’t know the thoughts of characters like Celestia.
12. Maybe? I’m coming up with this as I go. I have a few scenes in my head I want played out and a general plot oh what occurs but getting there is the challenge.
13. How he gets to the point where he’s at currently, writing in the journal
14. No he uses PG as a way to describe ponies as very innocent, they are not as strong minded or inappropriate as humans and you will see how in future chapters.
15. No missed that, thank you!
16. For real twilight what the fuck! Can u believe her? I wanted to show that Twilight is very curious when it comes to magic even to a point of checking things that seem like they already have an answer.
17. Her penis, nah magic, she confirms it with the next sentence, he can be touched by others magic without any complications
18. Worded weird, he telling twilight she’s more likely to pop a vessel trying to make something happen then something actually happening.
19. His magic consumes, it takes over others magic and sickens the one who is inflicted. If he were to let someone get attached to his magic, it would work like a virus and eventually do stuff that I can’t say without spoiling stuff. It’s pretty much a virus
20. Next chapter, lot more gets answered
21. I explain in next chapter a little, mainly to avoid unwanted ears from hearing about it’s contagious abilities. She wants to prevent panic and certain ponies can’t keep their mouths shut friend or no friend.
22. In this universe teleportation magic requires a reaction like Newton’s third law, something has to happen in order for her to arrive there and the smoke is a indicator that some sort of energy was spent to bring her there rather then just appearing suddenly.
23. Celestia originally thought his magic has been leaking out of him like radioactive waves, she doesn’t know at this point that Twilights actions are what causes his shit to start pouring out. Think of it like radiation, waves of dangerous magic
24. Well this takes place less than 2 weeks from his arrival! That’s a lot for someone to handle, being ripped away from your life and knowing you can’t go back? That’s a lot if you ask me.
25. Nah smoke teleportation shit like previous question, number 22
26. Yeaaa your right, that one good for ya? There’s definitely more coming
Alright, this cut into my writing time but, it was necessary, I hope I answered all your questions good enough and thank you for taking your time to read this, I’ll make some changes right after I post this reply. Expect the next chapter to be somewhere around 5-10 k, I’d like to be consistently above 5k at least per chapter
10586615
Wow, I need to watch how I comment. That was a lot, and I’m the one that commented it.
Did this happen when he was a sleep?
It’s because of the elements of harmony, isn’t it?
If she’s telling everyone, then she’s not a terrible gossiper. It means she’s too good at it.
What does he mean by that?
Was that a sex joke?
What happened the other day?
Yea, she’s technically a lesbian.
Ohh, I see what you did there.
Anything with cookie in it, I’m probably eating.
What misinterpreted actions can he make?
Still can’t imagine it, but I’ll try.
Oh, I thought it was a high five at first.
I didn’t know that was a troupe.
Heros?
Maybe his depression got transferred to someone.
Then why was he still depressed?
RD picked my favorite ice cream
10593355
Alright alright Let’s tackle this again the same way as before and thanks again for reading this.
1. No, same time as the incident just Twilights perspective a little
2. Yep
3. Fuck your right, will change
4. If spike sees him not wearing it and it’s for his safety, he likely will suspect something else is up or that it’s not actually for his safety
5. Perhaps
6. Not important but I can add something the next time our human meets rainbow to hint toward what he did just for you Pete
7. Is she really? Is that confirmed? I don’t know much about the show now
8. Terrible pun
9. Agreeable
10. Idk look scary? Think of people that have prejudice views and imagine he’s almost seen like a monster currently, so anything he might do could be taken in the worst way possible, like him approaching a filly to help tie her shoe might first come off like he’s gonna eat her or something stupid. Ponies are naturally herbivores so they are easily startled
11. I try, trust me I try
12. Never seen a racist hick in a movie?
13. Sarcasm
14. I can’t answer this question without spoiling
15. He’s grateful for their friendship however, there’s more he’s holding back. That was him revealing something about himself that he wouldn’t normally and maybe in the future we will discover the rest of his problems (wink)
I hate to fill the whole chat up with my response so sorry for that, hope I was able to answer your questions and thanks for pointing out that slip up.
10593744
2nd fav, can’t go wrong
10594388
Thanks for answering my questions. I can’t believe you responded to them.
10594402
Lol why wouldn’t I? You took the time to read and ask questions, I should take the time to answer them!
10595927
I do have one more question. That thing that she was drawing out of him. Was that his magic or what was it something blocking his magic?
10595957
Twilight wanted to draw out his magic assuming he had some however once she attempted to there was something unusual. That’s where the blocking part comes into play, although we don’t know what it is that blocks his magic from coming out, Twilight removes it to get to his magic and in doing so has removed the only thing keeping it back. It’s pouring out of him now
Also I’m calling it for tonight’s session, currently at 2,100 words and I feel like I just started the chapter lol
10596029
Oh ok
That’s literally what I had for breakfast this morning.
Is it that stuff in his body?
Interesting
Well, he does have more experience.
If he knows about lord of the right, then that would mean he’s from the same as us, right?
Just ignore it and go about your business.
Really?
Just act a little hostile.
It’s pinkie pie, just go with it.
Damnit
I like how she corrected him.
How does Joey rhyme with any of those?
He has to be from our world, right?
When he says the other day does he mean two days ago?
What does that mean?
Was they playing a game?
Really?
What does that look like?
Smart. Pinkie promises could come in handy.
Depends on who it is.
So, he’s wearing perfume.
I called it.
Isn’t she supposed to flap her hooves?
Maybe to fit in?
Wait, which one is his real name and which one is his nickname?
Can she hear his thoughts?
No, he proved the intelligence of himself.
Wow, she knows pinkie well.
10604316
Pete! Toooo much my friend, but I’ll try to comment on what ya gotta say
1. Yep I totally knew that
2. Yea it’s his magic, even though it comes out of him forcibly, it’s still within him just not as potent when it’s constantly released.
5. Yep! Same Earth
7. In this universe yes
8. Not his personality, very insecure
12. His names legally Joe, Joeys his nickname
15-16. Alliteration is the occurrence of the same letter or sound at the beginning of adjacent or closely connected words. It was a game
17. Yes, I myself actually struggle with public communication, while you wouldn’t be able to tell it’s rather exhausting for me to keep up with conversation. I don’t know why, maybe because I overthink? I don’t know but if I can avoid large groups or talking a lot I sure as fuck will.
18. https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0128/9515/8336/products/IMG-20191006-145437_1024x.jpg?v=1570398898
That face ^
21. I’m not going to lie, that just made me laugh out loud. No silly her shampoo and body soap is lavender lol
28. Yea, I don’t think it’s ridiculous for her to know about her close friends personal issues especially in this universe where ponies care for one another much more than humans, I know some of my close friends problems and they know mine, there’s certain things we keep to ourselves of course but things like what bothers us and makes us feel better are generally more acceptable to know about each other.
I enjoy the comments you did and for questions I didn’t know the answer or they didn’t really matter if you knew them or not I skipped. Thanks for the read as always!
10605332
So if he’s from the same earth as us, shouldn’t he know he’s in a cartoon?
10605337
My bad forgot to clarify, everything the same but My little Pony never existed. Think of it that way ;)
10605377
Ok, got it. I’ll be sure to try and make my comments shorter.
More. Maybe have a chapter with Joey at the worst?
10605445
At the worst? Well currently he’s just kinda going through the motions but I got something planned to happen and I don’t like making it occur so suddenly, I want to slowly build to it, maybe even rise things up to bring them down harder in the future. Trust me, we got some sad boy times ahead
I don’t remember betting, but if I did I would have bet twilight, too.
I’m so stupid to not have realized what that looked like until now.
Actually, it makes a lot of sense.
I may have figured out how his magic works.
I have a dirty mind.
There were others with the same magic?
If that’s how rarity thinks of herself as well, then she needs to get off her high HORSE. (I’m bad at jokes.)
What’s the worst spike can do?
Just punch him once, I promise he’ll leave you alone, or use spike as a flamethrower.
Ok, so twilight was right, if he doesn’t release his magic it builds up, and based on what I’m seeing leaks out of him.
Fluttershy is definitely that grandmother that would bake you some chocolate chip cookies.
Aw man, I wish he would have stayed to talk to fluttershy.
That’s messed up, but funny at the same time.
Third?
Something tells me he’s gonna break that promise.
What damages?
Also, the comment is a lot shorter believe it or not.
10616248
Lmao love your comment,
The magic load was meant to be dirty for you dirty boys and gals out there
Spike as a flamethrower is genius!
Fluttershy is that grandma, also I wanted the man to stay as well but he was cracking like an egg. That pony would have the tears flowing out of him if he didn’t bail, but we will get more shy later....
I don’t think it was actually the third time, our boy Joey was guessing
Damages were inflicted on him, he’s a leaky boy now cuz of Twi
It is shorter lol, thanks for reading Pete! Your this stories mvf, most valuable follower
Also I wanna add I’m really glad people seem to be enjoying this generally, I don’t know what the fuck I’m doing yet it’s apparently okay
So far I'm really digging this. Keep up the good work! Can't wait to see how this story evolves.
10616496

10616444
Thank you and so far you are doing good. Although, it would be a good idea to plan what you are doing.
Who used to live there? Because, I’ve seen too many horror movies.
Does that count as neighbors?
Throw a stick, see if she goes for it.
When your in a different world, you gotta be cautious.
Hasn’t he only encountered her twice?
Enjoy it while it last.
How do they not know what a tomb raider is?
I wish we had a chapter on that.
I don’t remember him saying that.
Aww, poor dashie.
Jesus Christ, just kiss already.
Burn that thing to the damn ground.
Yea, your gonna need help burning it.
This is one of the situations where you friends are tired of your bullsh*t.
I’m honestly surprised he didn’t tell her before.
Technically, it is, isn’t it?
So the color protects him, it’s just not it’s main function.
This seems interesting.
I remember you saying something about a prologue, is that still in the works or is there going to be a flashback or maybe a filler chapter?
So he was either in school, on his way to school, or leaving school when he came to equestria.
How does he know it’s a weekend?
They have bills?
I think I’m starting to understand his magic. Also, only 8 years? Celestia must not be doing her job or something.
10625971
This chapter felt sloppy, I didn’t really like it looking back. I’ll answer your questions in order like normal,
5. He has met her a handful of times, it’s a stupid question by Twilight
16. Yes it is, it just doesn’t worry about himself enough to mention that
19. I said I would if you wanted one, it seems like I should given how many questions are caused by lack of background
21. Spoke would be up early if the library was open, it seems stoopid but it’s closed during weekends
22. Yea, there’s still rent and shit even in Equestrian, that’s why Joey is compensated with 800 bits a month
I love your notes, always get a laugh out of me! Also Celestia needs to step her game up for real right? Best thing you said tho was them all being fed up with Fluttershy passing out all the damn time.
Thanks for reading Pete! I’ll make a prologue along with the next chapter so you don’t feel cheated, just might take longer than usual but, ya never know I keep breaking my own rules on when I’m supposed to take nights off
10626951
The funny thing is that the comments just come from the top of my head, glad you enjoy them.
Hope to see it.
Uh oh
10630189
Hey you did this! Nah I’m playing, also been super busy so only have like 75% of the prologue done. The new chapter with it as well is going to be a very important ass chapter so I’m taking my time with it once I get going.
10633089
I would never. Or would I?
Who is he talking about?
Welp, he’s in for a big surprise.
Where is he?
Who’s that?
Damn, my man was just tryna take a piss and got isekai’d.
Yup, definitely isekai’d.
Aw man, if he got isekai’d he must’ve died in the bathroom. Damn, one of the worst ways to go.
If you’re a different world it would make sense to ask as many questions as you can to get as much information as you can, even if it’s a name. I’m socially a coward too, but I’ll be damned if I’m not gonna get as much information as I can. And if it means being ‘rude’ and asking them to repeat themselves, then so be it.
A planet? I thought it was a country or continent.
Usually you say that AFTER you hear their name.
That’s good. When dealing with aliens keep the answers quick and short.
Don’t give her too much information, yet.
How does that work?
I think there are only three.
That explains why when twilight experimented on him he used his nickname.
Who knows? Celestia night have a bad side to her.
Ok, that’s doing too much. I’ll be damned if I’m about to do that.
Wait, I thought they could.
I wonder what the others reaction would have been?
There was a timeskip after this chapter, so is there going to be a filler chapter going over day two and all that?
For your censored question, they don’t know til the incident, I’m trying to keep my answer from spoiling lol
Also no to your last question, this story will have time skips occasionally
Also I forgot to to write about where he currently is in relation to the story but I think it could ruin what I have planned potentially so I’m keeping it from being added, like I said before though he is writing in a journal, each chapter he writes taking place in the present with the occasional narration which is him in the future.
Thanks for reading ;p
10650472
I don’t think you pushed the reply button so i didn’t see this until now. Also, what do you mean by that last part?
10652084
The main character isn’t currently where he is in the story, he’s in the future writing this story your reading now. I was stating that I forgot to mention this in the prologue but thinking about it more, I would prefer I didn’t as I could spoil how things turn out.
10653521
But, how will we be able to tell if he’s in the past, present, or future?
10653981
The story is mainly told in past and honestly might stay in the past the entire time. Also the story is like opening a book and being dragged into the chapter, experiencing it as if it was the present. If we have moments where things are described like me talking about the logistics of the world then we are hearing the voice of current Joey, narrating during the moment. If the story is taking place in the current time you’ll know because I’ll write saying so. To avoid confusion, just assume every chapter is the present.
10655257
So there’s going to be chapters of past, present, and future Joey?
10655623
No future, always present or past. I use the term future to explain where he currently is in relation to the chapters time line. Might catch up to him currently or might not depends on how I feel things should go
10656631
Ohh. So if/when we do catch up to him will you transition back and forth between past and current or on eve we catch up to current it’ll stay there?
not bad but I really wonder why this collar situation is as tough as it is. At this point I guess he refuses to remove the collar out of obligation, but seems everyone else has a point, just remove it when alone or with an element and put it back on later. It was easier about 3-4 chapters ago when he didnt NEED to feel so guilty. In fact Im surprised he didn't remove it just to have a single night of sleep.
10660857
Well our stupid pal Joey here has a terrible issue of hating himself to the point where he purposely seems to make things difficult. He feels like he deserves suffering, it’s the root to most of his problems
We don’t know that, yet.
Why can’t spike be there?
If it was supposed to be a surprise, then why tell him?
I need to see more evidence. Innocent until proven guilty.
When did he meet her in his dreams?
Ok, I don’t care if she’s a pony, human, or whatever, if I get the opportunity to do this with a girl, I’m taking it.
She’s not 100% wrong, but she’s also not 100% right.
Deal with it, purple.
You know, all of a sudden I wouldn’t mind being bullied.
This right here, shows that he’s supposed to be in equestria.
Me and twilight must have been thinking the same thing.
Will we get more info on that relationship?
Magic horses=Magic fur
GOD DAMNIT!!!
OMFG!!! Does he even live in ponyville?
WHAT!? He started it.
YOU WEREN’T EVEN THERE. WHAT THE F*CK ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT?
Ok, this may be useful.
I hope twilight has a spell for that.
Great, now his magic has a voice.
Wait, do the badlands not exist here?
Ok, he has one of the nicest neighbors in equestria telling him that he can come to her for help. If he doesn’t take advantage of that, and tell her everything that’s going on in that thick head of his, he just doesn’t want to be happy.
If she knows what that means, then he’s probably rubbed off them more than I thought.
Is he still scared of the bear?
It wasn’t even a fight. It was a flawless victory.
Yup, definitely rubbed off on them.
He didn’t know her name before? Didn’t she introduce herself when they first met?
If I have to die in order to get friends like this, tell them I’m on the way.
He thought he was safe. Nice try though.
No, sad and confused is YOUR situation. Hers was just anger and rage.
Equestria must be rubbing off on him, too.
What does that mean?
I wish my phone could charge that quick.
Yikes
10684346
Time to unpack!
6. Although wasn’t a question, I will tell you that it’s not all what it’s cracked up to be, cuddling under some covers is the real deal
21. I don’t know anything about badlands, remember I haven’t watched past season 2 and this was when the show first launched
32. I have no idea what the fuck I wrote there lmao, that’s going to be fixed pronto
I skipped a ton of questions that either have an answer in the previous chapters or is answered in the future, or isn’t important to know like Joey still being a baby about bears. Thanks for reading, I always enjoy your notes!
10684689
Laying your head on a girls lap counts as cuddling?
I may have forgot.
You’re welcome
No silly, I said laying on a girls lap isn’t what it’s cracked up to be. What people should desire for is some hugs and cuddles under blankets, that’s what’s up
10685998
Ohh. I may have misread it. Also you didn’t hit the reply button so I didn’t see this until now.
Hey I just binge read your story, and noticed that even if he's trying to say things like "everypony", he still wonders why they say that. Well, why don't you have him point that out? I'm tired of every HIE story having the human accept using that word like it's no big deal.
Is Joe a pony? NO! Is spike a pony? NO! Are all the other native races ponies? NO! For them to keep on saying "everypony" is very xenophobic!!!
Moving on, what is the first half of the word personality? Person!!! So are they saying that they don't have a personality? Now the plural word for person is people. Easy right?
Moving on, does twilight have a body? Does spike have a body? Does Joe have a body? Do all the other sapient races have bodies? If the answer is yes to all of those than I think you can use the term everyBODY!!! Also each of them is one person, so you can say everyONE!!!
Sorry for the long rant, but I'm so sick and tired of every human that comes to Equestria bend over backwards to us the stupid word that is everypony!!!
I just for once I want the human to point out how stupid and xenophobic that word is, especially for the other native races on that planet!!!
Now it would be nice if you had this human decide to explain this to them, but you don't have to. After all, it is your story. I just needed to get his off my chest after seeing something like this for the Billionth time!!!
So if you read this entire thing, thanks for taking the time to read it.
P.S.
I like your story so far. And if we do end up getting romance in this story my top three choices in order of most wanted to least are,
1. Twilight
2. Pinkie
3. Rainbow Dash
10693986
Lmao he does one time refer to the word as xenophobic but not even out loud. He’s sorta a pushover sadly and that’s just the character not because I missed that issue, it bothers him but he’s too much of a baby for conflict. As for the romance I’m gotta let ya know something....
I haven’t picked a gal yet, it’s completely up for grabs still based on how this story goes. I got some events I still want to happen and an ending but how we get there is very flexible so you never know... ya just might get your wish