The world is lost and listless, hope and magic gone in the world. King Lysso is the King after he defeated the six princesses. Not even the retired Celestia and Luna can stop him. The world's only hope is the Freedom Guard and their leader, Captain Lunis. But a dark secret is behind the mask of Lunis, a deep dark secret that could destroy the guard for good.
Page generated in 0.098 seconds
Total duration
669 users online
804,531 hits today, 1,872,792 yesterday
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Fanfiction
Designed and coded by knighty & Xaquseg - © 2011-2024
Support us
SubStar
Chat!
Discord
Follow us
Twitter
MLP: Friendship is Magic® - © 2024 Hasbro Inc.®
Fimfiction is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Hasbro Inc.®
You know that's a nice alicorn OC you got there.
Description... and I'm already lost! Reading it, I'm like... wtf am I reading??? Six princesses, Freedom Guard, OC's EVERYWHERE??? Whoa there buddy, slow down!
>in b4 TWE
Guys, calm the fuck down. Have a potato.
media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m7mfhyewrm1qh3jq7.gif
1630674
Um not a buddy and I am still working on the desc. It's not meant to have any of the canon character really. 6 princesses... Twilight Sparkle, Apple Jack, Rarity, Pinkie Pie, Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash.
Freedom Guard; the rebellion force...etc etc...
1630792 One sec...
(Scrambles to your user page)
She/he's only been here... for HOW LONG???
(Comes back...)
Lol, welcome to FIMFiction. Some words of advice, read more stories. After about 3-4 weeks, then try to make a story. Also, peruse the groups for author support and school for new writers. It will help... A LOT!
1630816
U-um...well...I'm popular on DA for it so I'm not going to change it...
1630823 Right, well this is FIMFiction. You can't just... go about spewing any idea out. You need to... ugh... get to know what people on this site like, and improve as you go along. DA is for pictures, not stories. FIMFiction... Let me be clear. If it's not an original story, it's not good. Things to avoid include OC alicorns. the worst kinds are red manned, black coated ones, and Mary Sues/Gary Stews. Those are flawless characters. They make no mistake. They, however, make horrible characters.
I understand you thought you'd come in here all alicorn OC gun hoe, but that's very rare to happen with ANY user.
1630853
........Yea. you are slightly getting rude.
It's not a mary sue story, and no I'm not going to change it because she's an alicorn. I like my oc and I'm not going to falter in my decision. You came here and commented; Okay cool. I'm not 'gun hoeing' and certainly just because you didn't enjoy it does not mean the whole world doesn't.
Oh boy. I'm going to cut you some slack because it's late and you literally just joined so maybe you're not sure how things work around here.
First I want to say that it takes guts to come up with a totally original story and not use any of the canon characters especially as your first story. Also, your grammar, spelling and structure seem to be top notch. I couldn't see any problems but then I really wasn't paying attention so maybe that's my fault. I just want to think that you did a good job on this.
As for the bad, you've got an alicorn OC. This does not bode well. Kudos for not making her red & black or giving her a ridiculous name like "Raven Dark'ness" or something like that. But there are only supposed to be 2 Alicorns in all of Equestria. That's it. No more. Cadance was originally supposed to be a unicorn but Hasbro decided to make her an Alicorn for whatever reason. This is canon although I don't know how King Sombra fits into all this now but that's for another time.
Secondly, this is written in first person. As such it's coming off as a self-insert. Writing in first person is too limiting and it takes a talented writer to pull it off correctly. You have promise, but you're not there yet.
Next is the purple prose. You really like describing things in the most detailed way using really nice words. Stop it. Seriously, stop it. Getting too flowery with your story will only serve to turn people off. There's no reason to go into too great detail if you can say the same thing in fewer words.
And finally, your OC is bordering on being a complete Mary Sue. Tone it down a bit. Reel in the terrific. Make her less perfect and more real. An Alicorn OC is bad enough. An Alicorn Mary Sue OC is a recipe for disaster.
1630872 Look, you've been here 3 hours, and you've already gotten a story out. That's... just not good.
I wasn't trying to be mean. If I sounded like that, I'm sorry. I've read it, and I can tell you, this needs work. If you think I'm mean... Lol, see these guys. They'll probably be here soon.
Edit: As I typed... There they are!
1630872
Judging my the dislike bar? The world doesn't like it.
Also, your badmouthing fething Art Inspired, one of the most successful authors on the site. He knows what he's talking about, and he's trying to help. People can be a lot more blunt with their advice; I know I am. So instead of sticking to your poorly executed idea, perhaps you should let the advice of those better than you sink in.
1630884
I do thank you for the compliment. She is by all means not a mary sue. Yes she's an alicorn, but if you read the story you would know why. Her father is the tyrant that rules the world. first person is my favorite style though I do understand it is quite limiting.
She is by all means perfect. She has a temper and is spunky. She does have to act proper because she is the princess and that is normal. She is the rebellion's leader, and is not even that powerful. She is not overpowered in any way. She shows one moment in which she power bursts from her but that's about it.
1630884
Isn't Sombra just a unicorn? Or am I missing the point of that comment?
Wow. That's a lot of downvotes, and the story really isn't that bad.
So, you have obviously put a lot of thought into your mythology and building a world with some new characters. I liked how you set it up that the Mane Six became princesses...then were defeated.
One thing that you can do that will immediately improve this is to change the format just a bit. Every time you have dialogue, it should be in a new paragraph. Also, large paragraphs scare readers away. You've got to feed your story to your readers in bite-sized bits. (Okay, that might be a terrible metaphor, but it's true. People have short attention spans and a story with shorter paragraphs just looks easier to digest at a glance.)
Your alicorn OC is not bad. I mean, she's not all-powerful, so there shouldn't be any complaint on that score. Really, she's just a cool princess character. The fact that she's a Secret Princess is going to grate on some readers who are familiar with fantasy storytelling tropes because it's a cliche. But the truth about cliches is that they are popular because some part of human beings want to be told those stories again and again. The important thing is to make sure your character has the kind of depth that will win your readers' hearts. Right now, she could use a few more layers to her character.
One of your greatest strengths, the story's mythology, can also trip you up. You throw a lot of information at the readers right at the beginning, before they even have the chance to become emotionally invested in the story. It might be a good idea to open with a scene showing how wicked Lysso is so that the readers want him defeated right off the bat, or do something to win their hearts right away for your princess heroine.
You have the odds stacked against you right from the beginning because you have an alicorn OC as the main character. You are going to get a bunch of tired downvotes just for that, from people who aren't even going to read your story and meet your characters. It's just something you are going to have to overcome by really, really good character building and writing.
Don't be discouraged. You have some good ideas here, and the potential for a neat fantasy adventure. As you are writing the following chapters in this story, I would recommend that you try your hand at a few one-shot short stories on the side as well. It will give you opportunity to play around with different characters and situations. (I have no idea what your writing experience is. You might already be doing this. But if not, then I recommend it.)
Keep writing, my friend.
1630908
Oh no, don't thank me because that wasn't a compliment. Your story sucks and I just don't have the time or the effort to put in a full review right now. That's why I didn't attach the seal or my title in the TWE. It's not an official review so don't get your hopes up.
You're missing the point. You've got an alicorn OC. She's a Mary Sue. The two pretty much go hand in hand when you consider that alicorns are like f*cking gods. They can literally do whatever they want. Celestia raises the sun. Luna raises the moon and arranges the stars. That takes power. They are game changers. They are the living definition of a Deus ex Machina. Want something impossible done? Get an alicorn, they can do it.
And giving her a little flaw like having a temper does not mean she's no longer a Sue. In fact, she's even more of one now because it's a minor little thing that shows you can't be bothered to give her a real disadvantage. And spunky? That's a classic Sue trait, in fact the original Mary Sue was as spunky as you can imagine. Gee Willikers she was spunky!
21 dislikes so far and this has barely been out for an hour. You're not doing well and in fact right now you're crashing and burning. Wait until the morning and the rest of the site gets a gander at this and you'll really see how alicorn OCs are hated on this site. Do yourself a favour, take this story down and rework it.
If you choose to stick to your guns, then you can't say I didn't try to warn you.
1630908
1. I'm just curious, are you biologically male or female at this time? Please refrain from answering with the sex you would prefer to be and check between your legs to avoid confusion. Because you write like a guy. Just sayin'.
2.
ohboyherewego.jpg
Since you're so adamant that what's-her-name isn't a Mary-Sue, I'm not going to put much effort into this. I'll let other people argue with you for comments and comments like it's srs bzns. All I'm going to say is, you just described the archetypal Mary Sue/Gary Stu.
1630928
Maybe he is, I don't know as I wasn't really paying attention when the show was on. I was pretty bored by the whole Crystal Empire thing as it's nothing more than a way for Hasbro to sell more toys.
So maybe he is just a unicorn if he is, then I retract that original statement.
1630928
Supposedly he *was* a unicorn, but is now shadow magic in its ironically "purest" form.
it's canon that he WAS one, but not that he IS.
1630964 Lol, dude, I literally hear Homer saying this as I read!
I think someone should write a story about an alicorn OC who thinks he/she is completely awesome by virtue of being an alicorn, but is actually completely useless and generally unlikable, although everyone pretends otherwise because they're too polite/have given up trying to get through his/her skull.
1630884
So they could sell the Pinklestias they made before they realized how silly it was to have her pink.
As for this story... Does the OC really NEED to be an Alicorn for the story to work?
Wow... okay.
I see a lot of potential in your writing, that's a good start.
Little known secret, I was guilty of writing Mary Sue's when I first started too.
I do love your OC's physical design though. It's not off putting at all, the colors are well matched and she's a rather pretty little thing. If you could write her as a deeper character that would be great. Alicorn OCs are often reviled, and for good reason, because most of them are utter piles of crap. You've got the first half of the battle (design) down though, why not the second(characterization and writing)?
As for the story, I would recommend just starting with one OC, if ANY, and practicing.
Also, we have no idea what's going on, who are these people? What are their motivations?
I didn't understand that the mane six were princesses until you mentioned it in the comments.
You could start with a story about the ponies in the show, practice with the characters already established before you try to create your own.
Welcome to FiMFiction.
Been here for less than a week, you already have a story out, you're ignoring critique from some very talented and popular people, and your character is an Alicorn?
Sit down, let's talk.
Alicorn OC's, they are hated on this site. Bar none, they are this sites definition of horrible. It takes a powerful author to get an alicorn out, AND have him/her be liked.
Secondly, don't argue with your critics. If they misunderstand something, explain the circumstances with it, and take whatever they have to offer. Arguing with your crits makes you look whiny, and lazy.
Thirdly, take some time to read fictions. You may be alright on deviant art, but this is Fimfiction, we hold pretty high standards on this site. And if you're trying to make it to our leagues, you're gonna have to step up your game. The review givers on this site don't hold back.
Fourthly, don't get frustrated. It takes time, study, and effort to write a good story. I just recently got featured for the first time on my newest fic. The chapter I wrote for it, it took over a month to write. So take your time, think concepts through, add, revise, delete, retry, think how your reader sees, think how your character sees. Now, I personally find it easier to write in first person than in third, but it's still a tightrope we walk.
Writing, It's not easy, but it is worth it.
Now, the readers have spoken, you have potential. That means a lot on this site, so use it! Read and learn, find your style, and POOF! You're knocking them out.
Hell, you've pissed me off. Let's give this a right proper review, eh? I'm going to ignore all the typos, redundancies, and minor grammar infringements because honestly, who likes hearing about those? Suffice to say that they are numerous.
First person. All right, you've already stated that you know the limitations of writing in the first person, so I'll leave you to your stylistic choices.
One of these two does not make sense. How does Orithyia communicate with 'the underground' if she's locked up? Who is 'the underground?' What's with the magical mirror that can teleport Orithyia in her prison? What's with the lax security Lysso has put on his daughter? A single guard isn't enough to protect the only other known alicorn in existence. Why the fuck does he even keep her around?
Remember how this alicorn totally destroyed eight princesses? What are a hundred starved peasants going to do that they couldn't?
They're going to... blow up some weapons? Remember the god who took over everything? How the fuck does taking out some weapons and coal equal toppling a tyrant? What's stopping Lysso from just getting more weapons? There's no way that 100% of all weapons exist in four locations. And why are they doing this during two different days? If Lysso looses half his stocked weapons one day, wouldn't he go to extra lengths to protect the other half? How poorly is the empire designed if two small raids can topple the whole fething thing?
Really, this lieutenant is an egotistical bitch. Orithyia has a legitimate point; Star Wing has to use a brace to keep one of her legs up, and dragging a wounded soldier around during a stealth-centered mission is a pretty big liability. And when she doesn't get her way, she just storms off like a whiny kid. If Orithyia is worried about Star Wing betraying her friends in a fit of rage, why the fuck is she even there, much less in a place of command?
For the love of god, a new paragraph for each new speaker. It's really, really hard to follow dialogue when it's in a brick of text like this. And "daddykins?" Really? Not to mention the fact that Orithyia is a fucking idiot for running headlong into dangerous territory alone.
Look, the bitch decided to come back. Also, turns out that Orithyia doesn't even recognize the voice of her own lieutenant.
Considering that his daughter just, you know, escaped her prison, Lysso seems pretty calm. After sending a pair of monsters to fuck her shit up, he shows up in his full battle regalia, skinned princess cloak and all, and... draws her a bubble bath? The fuck? At least tell me he has the sense to increase security after she easily slipped through the pathetic measures he has up right now. Hell, he doesn't even say a harsh word to her about going out into the deadly wilderness alone and against his wishes.
1630908
I couldn't help but see this story, and though I've only read the description, base on the fact you said she 'is perfect' automatically makes her a mary sue in my eyes. However, I'm not going to condemn. But, I am going to advise.
Go here. Read the OP, take the online test. It is EXTREMELY helpful and basic. It is easy to understand. Note, the OP is the only post I advise reading, and again. Take the test and use your OC. The information in the OP and the test itself are accurate, and reliable.
And one more thing, alicorn OCs tend to get hate right off the bat, especially here. You have to do it extremely well. The people who offer advice, do generally mean well and make some valid points. The thing is, picking out what is helpful fact and good advice, and what is biased opinion veiled behind fancy words and vague logic.
But, yea, I advise clicking the link and reading through the OP and taking the test.
And one last piece of advice. Just because people on deviantart like it, doesn't mean everyone will like it. Stories change between groups and communities from a reason, because each has its own likes and dislikes.
I'M HERE TO KICK ASS AND PUNCH FACE... AND I'M ALL OUTA FACE!
Here we go.
1631003 Oh my. You've never read Kingofsquirrles's fics, have you? Don't, because they suck. They had no business being featured.
1630891 Picking a fight with you? Oh, this poor bitch/son of a bitch.
1630884 Going easy? What is this, Canada?
1630908 Not that you'll note this, but... girl, you're in for a world of hurt. Picking a fight with Art Inspired AND Evil Homer? ALso, don't come in with that DA attitude. DA is full of fucktards and true bronyfags. I should know, I used to live on that site.
You've all been officially Regidar'd.
i2.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/newsfeed/000/343/616/a02.gif
1631112 Try and go easy on him/her. he/she is new. (Ah-ha, and I mean NEW!)
Just remember, this is FIMFiction, a writing site. DA is for drawers. if you think you can't play two different sports, don't try.
1631137
I'm sorry, but I must correct you. FimFiction is a writing site yes, but DA is for spoiled, self-entitled, think they're a gift to the world, newbie artists who don't know the meaning of the word critique.
1631159 True, and to the point... I'm just not that harsh. Never can be, as I get too many replies when I do.
1631137 Excuse me, there is plenty of writing there. I would know, as a writer on that site... but mostly it gets glossed over.
1631159 This. This so hard. You can occasionally find a few good artists in there... but mostly it's a bunch of re-coloring douchebags.
Grammar, capitalization/typos, and format all could use work.
Conversation grammar is off in a couple of ways. Poor comma use when addressing people, capitalizing tags improperly, that sort of thing. I'd suggest this guide for some excellent examples of how conversation should be formatted, including the one speaker per paragraph.
For capitalization, there's a few words that are capitalized but should not be. When talking about the castle walls, for example, the north, east, west, and south are capitalized. They should only be so when talking about geographic areas, not directions. The South will rise again, capitalized. We attack the south wall, not capitalized. "What Should I do.....What Would mom do?" => Neither should nor would ought to be capitalized. Fallen Ponies is capitalized in one sentence then shortly thereafter, it is lowercase. Whether you choose to capitalize it or not, pick one way and be consistent. There's a few typos as well. A hi that should be his. A choose that should be chose. A your that should be a you're. Flied should be flew. And an ellipsis has three periods, no more. Overall, not too bad in this regard, but could have benefited from an additional proofreading pass or two.
Format could use some help. Right now, there's many large paragraphs that don't go flow together well. For example, the paragraph where the protagonist decides to chase after Star Wing. It starts out about that chase, then takes a detour to talk about Fallen Ponies. When it makes that shift, boom, new paragraph should have started. Right now, most paragraphs are the paragraph equivalent of run on sentences.
The story could also flow better. It tries to explain too much that doesn't need to be explained right away, but could be developed later, over time, in the course of the story. An example would be Big Apple. There isn't any reason to go into detail about him at that moment and doing so hurts the pacing. You want to draw your audience in, get them to invest in the story. Don't sidetrack yourself. And keep in mind that even some things you might think you need to explain you might not have to. If the characters act like something is right and proper, the audience will usually go along (unless it conflicts with what they do know, of course). There's also a bad time jump. She goes from trying to decide what to do to suddenly having a military force and apparently winning the war.
As far as the Mary Sue factor, I'd say I'm getting a bit of that as well. Princess is locked in the castle. One day, she decides to start a revolution. So suddenly, she's not imprisoned anymore. And in this world that is so bad and terrible, she has a force of a paltry one hundred members, that easily gather, and are apparently on the verge of victory, striking at will. Then she happily carves up some bad guys, and returns home, no problems.
Short version, it needs work.
That's the bad.
The good? The writing isn't too bad. Once you learn how to format things a bit better, correct the relatively few grammatical errors, and so on, you'll be doing fine on that side. Which is far better than most people starting to write here. You need to work on pacing as well, but that should improve with experience.
I'd suggest going with a bit more audience friendly subject matter in the meantime. Hold off on the OC alicorn for a bit. The stories can work. One of the fandom's biggest stories is an OC alicorn one, after all. But it needs to be done well to get past the bias.
1631170
Essentially, the bad writers, and "artists" out number the good ones, eight to one. I've seen some good artist on there, some really amazing stuff. But the majority causes me to see the site as "Spoiled Brat Central"
1631159
Well, truth be told, we've got our fair share of writers here that suffer from the same issues. Like dArt, this site is very amateur friendly. And, unfortunately, a lot of the reader base is not very discerning when it comes to the quality of what they decide to praise/read. Lot of that has to do with the low mean age of FiM fans, of course. They like wish fulfillment crap, bad crossovers, and are apparently not doing well in their English classes, so poor grammar frequently doesn't bother them.
That said, some are willing to learn and improve, just need experience. There are some truly talented writers among us. And we all like ponies.
1631161
Indeed, didn't really see anything that hostile in what you said. It might be stated plainly, not sugar-coated, but it wasn't really hostile.
1631184 And the whole community takes this look on writers:
"Oh, you just write because you suck at drawing, fag." I look at their galleries and see a whole bunch of re-colored sonic/homestuck/MLP/Adventure Time/Regular Show characters.
But hey, I found out about this place through DA, and it offered me ponies before I knew sites like this were out there. It has a few redeeming qualities.
1631191
Don't forget kingdom heart and lion king.
1631228
Oh yes, how could I forget.
Most of the time, I can-
You know what, eff it. I'm not going to even try.
Okay, I'll give my honest opinion just like everyone else in here.
The thing I don't like most about a story is the wall of text. That alone put my mind off. I highly suggest breaking it up to at least five sentences a paragraph or starting a new paragraph after each dialogue. The second problem is that, like what most of the people here are saying, you made your OC a little too perfect. She's pretty much borderline Mary Sue. Try smoothing out the edges with this one, especially since its an alicorn OC. Put challenges in front of her. The road to a good character is full of flaws which you should pick from. And, as you can already guess from the others, there are lots of capitalization and grammar errors throughout the story that you need to look into. Try getting a pre-reader to help you before you post a new chapter.
Okay, now with that out of the way, the good thing I like about the story is the OC itself. I generally like alicorn OCs, and she's not like many of them which are made to be just as powerful as Celestia or Luna, or the typical Mary-Sue type character. The characterization, in my opinion, is medium at best and you did well to make your own universe with original characters -- good and evil.
So yeah, that's my take on it. And you really should listen to them, dA is extremely different than FimFiction. But, all in all, this story has the potential to be a well-liked fanfic on this site.
I absolutely ADORE Orithyia's picture! SO CUTE! Seriously, how can you not love that adorable filly!? I just want to give 'er a big ol' hug!
Mm, wish I was cute. I'm about as pretty as a rat with Shingles.
1631171
That's one of the best critiques I've read in ages - very good show.
Brilliant story. Amazing OC and well developed, fluid, storyline. everybody here be posting RePEWs, not reviews. Dem haters homegirl, stick wit what chu got.
1631360
...did you read the same thing I did?
1631360
RePEWs?
05.images.fireden.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/Diablo3.png
Hi buddy :
Pop start from here,Beautiful first choose ,ready to shopping ,Characteristics, novel, variety, low price and good quality, and the sales price is low , Move your mouse to work shopping! Hey hey
==== ( http://www.netetrader.com ) =====
==== ( http://www.netetrader.com ) =====
$33 True Religion jeans, Ed Hardy jeans,LV,Coogi jeans,Affliction jeans
$30 Air Jordan shoes,Shox shoes,Gucci,LV shoes
50%Discount winter fashion :Sandle,t-shirt,caps,jerseys,handbag and brand watches!!!
$15 Ed Hardy ,LV ,Gucci Bikini
$15 Polo, Ed Hardy, Gucci, LV, Lacoste T-shirts
$25 Coach,Gucci,LV,Prada,Juicy,Chanel handbag,
$10 Gucci,Ed Hardy sunglasses
$9 New Era caps.
give you the unexpected harvest
==== ( http://www.netetrader.com ) =====
==== ( http://www.netetrader.com ) =====
==== ( http://www.netetrader.com ) =====
==== ( http://www.netetrader.com ) =====
==== ( http://www.scnshop.com ) =====
1631112 Personally, I'm glad I stayed far away from this one
1630884
I just want to put this down here. A lot of things are supposed to be, in the end, they end up being something else. How many alicorns there were supposed to be is one of them. There's now four canon alicorns in the show, and there's nothing any of us can do about it. Most likely, we're going to see some more coming. It's time for you to get away from Faust's original intentions, she isn't on the show.
1631660 *Three. Gherkin was right, Sombra's a unicorn. So they added none after Cadance.
1630908 And you must realize that if you're trying to ARGUE those points, the phrase is "by NO means." When you say "by ALL means," you're admitting to every point of Homer's being correct. And to an extent, it is; this may be far from the worst thing I've seen on this site, but if you want a even a snowball's chance in hell of getting people to enjoy it, some revisions are in order. The nice people above me are trying to show you exactly what needs to be revised.
Full disclosure: I think you might actually be onto something here, but the fault lies in the execution. As a general rule of thumb, most of this should NEVER be done, but you're closer to breaking the mold than most I've seen.
In terms of grammar, you're LEAGUES ahead of the shit I sift through on a daily basis, but there's still work that needs to be done that a spell checker alone won't pick up.
Your main character... well, it does look like you're trying more to create a character than to insert a caricature of yourself into the story, so I guess I can lend you props for your attempt at that. She's definitely much more visually appealing than most OCs. But there's a SERIOUS aversion to alicorn OCs on the site because tragically few writers know how to handle properly writing characters with that much natural power. Even the ones that DO write them properly still get some shit for writing them at all. They're overpowered by design, and as biased as it may seem, you WILL get downvotes based on that alone. If you don't want her to be all-powerful, just make her be of another race. Family shouldn't be used as a defense; Celestia's nephew, Blueblood, is a unicorn, and two earth ponies birthed a pegasus and a unicorn, so you don't need to make her an alicorn because Daddy is (hell, I don't even think her father should really be one).
The plot of the story is somewhat interesting, but again, the fault is in the execution. The way you set the plot up, there are enough holes for it to not even be able to properly function as a story. It basically relies on hiccups in the narrative and stupidity on the characters' part to ever work. Most of the people above me explain where those plot holes are so you can patch them up and make the story more stable.
I don't want to come across as mean here. I know a lot of my coworkers at the TWE don't give much of a rat's ass and just unload on the story, but even EVIL MOTHERFUCKING HOMER, whose honesty is usually laced with vicious brutality, went easy on you. I'd actually like to see this story develop and improve, since the framework isn't actually that bad. What I'd recommend to you is:
- Possibly get an editor or proofreader to clean up what the spell check functions won't.
- Patch up the inconsistencies and loopholes that tear the narrative apart on a fundamental level.
- Reconsider the alicorn thing. Pick EITHER the earth ponies' strength, the pegasi's flight, or the unicorns' magic; determine which, in terms of necessity in the story, is best for Princess Ori-
...
Oh.
- Change either Orithyia's name or your username. If you don't want her to look like an author avatar, don't name her after your account name and/or don't name your account after her. I damn near revoked my statement about developing an actual original character when I saw that name, but I'm TRYING to stay positive.
You show more promise than most of the writers I see here, and most of your comments appear to made out of simple ignorance of the way things typically run on this site rather than actual malice towards the guys trying to give you a helping hand. Just to warn you, though, the viewership on FIMFiction usually has higher quality standards than that on deviantART. This site isn't as ball-busting as EqD about quality (and thank god for that, or my story may never have survived), but the readers still expect to see something decent when they come by. This, as the like/dislike ratio indicates, falls short of that standard. But for once, I don't think this needs to be scrapped completely. It does need a bit of a hard reset, but I think you can keep the rebellion-against-a-tyrant-overlord framework intact while you make the necessary tweaks to the details themselves. You don't need to touch it on dA, but if you want people here to like your story, you need to put in the effort to make it likable.
...wow, I didn't intend for that to be a full review (well, lengthy, not really FULL). I didn't even think that I'd make anything beyond that first paragraph. I got a bit carried away. You're... welcome?
>Fallen Prime, TWE Moderator and Resident Riffmaster
i.imgur.com/3lZia.png?1
1631720
Cadance is the fourth one. There's an Alicorn briefly shown in the Hearts and Hooves Day episode. While we don't anything about her other than that she drank the love potion, she's still canon.
1631887 Oh yeah, right. Wow, forgot about that one. She was an alicorn...? And I think her existence is up for debate; wasn't it a book of legends?