• Published 5th Nov 2020
  • 2,343 Views, 38 Comments

The Eagle And The Squirrel - Estee



The world is not what we make of it. The world doesn't care.

  • ...
8
 38
 2,343

The rest is silence

It was that part of autumn where the heartbeat of the forest had accelerated into the frantic rhythm of desperation. The leaves which lay outside the lie of control which was offered by the Running had come down on their own, and what had once been a glorious color palette offered as a riotous wake for a season celebrating its own funeral... it was all on the ground now, dried out and producing skeletal crackling under her hooves. Other portions would be wet, with mud hidden under the coating of death: stepping into that was very much like pushing a leg against the resilience of dead flesh, and the forest bled brown into her fur.

So much was preparing for death, or the long sleep which too often passed for it. Just about nothing was growing any more, not when it came to the plants, and for what little remained... hardly any of it was edible. And so there was desperation, because there was so little food left. There were portions of the forest which existed as rushing bodies, and a wake phased into funeral simply created the question of what they would rush towards. Some amount of life had fled towards distant warmth, instinct vowing to return when the green did. Other living fragments of the whole were engaged in anguished final searches, for there had to be some food left, something which hadn't been reached first, which would keep and sustain through the cold. Under that leaf, or that one, or that one, and there were so many leaves...

That was one of the ways she sometimes chose to see it, because she was the part of the world which could make a choice. But she had learned many lessons during her long trots. Most of them had been on the subject of truth, and one of the first had taught her that thought could be a response to silence.

It was seldom truly quiet in the forest, not with death of all sorts breaking beneath her step. Branches swayed in the wind: a sound which felt oddly exposed without leaves left to rustle. The world around her creaked like old bone.

She could listen to deeper sounds, if she tried. It was often easy in the desperation of autumn, when so much birdsong had stopped or retreated, and those movements of paws and claws which hadn't been accelerated were stilled. So much of the forest's life was already gone. Fled, tucked into warrens and dens and whatever else might offer some degree of safety. There wasn't much left to hear, and her ears rotated as she steadily moved through the self-renewing graveyard. But for the most part, all she heard was silence.

And when a pony's mind was surrounded by silence, while knowing that to actively produce any more sound than that created by heartbeat and breath might destroy all efforts to maintain both... that mind would try to shatter the quiet from within. Thoughts would spin against the lathe of the aural void. There were times when that led to insight, because a pony who had to think about something might find their minds exploring unfamiliar paths. But so many others would have those thoughts endlessly repeating until all true meaning was worn away, until all they could truly hear was the panicked babble which arose from within. And in both cases, it was possible to have inner words block outer sounds, because a pony who was solely listening to themselves might never hear hunger approaching behind them.

She had learned to moderate her thoughts: to find a balance between a mobile meditation and the fear which could so easily take over, deep in the forest and alone. She was always alone during such trots. It was possible to bring company, and she could certainly ask protection to walk at her side and growl at anything which got too close -- but to do so was self-defeating. She needed to be alone, because to have any others with her stood the chance to sabotage the goal, the reason she went into the forest at all.

The mark told her to take such trots, and she followed the directives of that which was softer than a whisper because she understood the necessity. But during all of those journeys, her most constant companion would be fear, and she never would have survived without its company.

It was too cold in the mornings and she had chosen a particularly early hour, because she knew that some of that desperation began at dawnlight and she could choose. There would be frost on some of the fallen leaves: something else which broke in her presence. There were times when she could see her breath, and that was welcome because there was still something which could be seen at all.

Too cold in the morning, and it was something which offered an illusion: the suggestion that the warmth would never return, the graveyard was the world itself, and it would be so easy to just... stop. To settle her body into the crackle and chill, and simply remain until the forest claimed another source of sound.

That too was a thought, and the pressure of it kept her legs shifting at a steady beat.

She listened to the currents of the wind as she moved, tried to feel the course of it within her feathers and mostly failed. It was something she had learned to live with, and it led her to primarily track things through the shifting of the coating on the forest floor. Knowing the directions in which her own scent was being carried was crucial.

It told her which direction was downwind, which served as up, and so when she saw the eagle which had draped its wings as a cloak over death, she recognized that it could not scent her.

She seldom saw eagles, and most of what she did perceive came at a great distance. When she was in the air, there was a chance to feel the shadow drape across fur and skin, and it always came from above because no matter how high she went (and she tried to stay close to the ground so much of the time), they would shift so that they were forever soaring above her. And at the cottage... there were herbs sprinkled across grass and the sod of her roof, invisible trails of scent drifting up and powerful wings scattering those deterrents throughout the sky in the course of their patrols. Eagles didn't approach the cottage, and making sure they continued to avoid it required a near-constant effort.

To see one on the ground, at the very edge of a small clearing, with the treeline so close...

A cold Sun offered the gift of frozen light, and she looked.

The spread of the wings was... strange. She could see no injury in the flaring of those joints, but there was something unnatural about the curve. The eagle had flared its limbs in a way which allowed her to examine almost every feather, but for those along the bottom edges. The ones which were partially pushed into dead leaves and frost and mulch, allowing pinions to act as wicks drawing in cold.

Its head was down. She could just barely make out the curve of the crown: beak and eyes were hidden by the cloak. It made no sound, because it had no awareness of her presence. And yet it felt as if there was a sound there: something barely audible, fast and frantic. But that too could have been a thought, something created by imagination and the desire for the dying world to break the silence.

It could have been. But she wasn't sure.

She took a step forward and because she was upwind, made sure to bring her left forehoof down on a tree's severed wooden limb with just enough force to matter.

There was sound then, if only for an instant, and the eagle's head came up.

The stare of near-white eyes was not maniacal, because perception of that quality was something which she had chosen not to bring into the forest and she would not let it intrude now. But she recognized some ponies saw madness in the frozen regard of avians, and had even come to understand why they felt that way. It was the lack of muscles around the eyes. They could not widen or squint, crinkle somewhat at the edges or slowly close against the weight of emotions which could not truly be felt. The eagle's eyes were either open or shut. It did not exist in a world which allowed it the dubious benefits of intermediary states. If it was looking at her, it was doing nothing except looking, and for ponies, whose minds were forever spinning... that degree of focus was something which could only be born from madness.

It knew she was there now, because to approach it unsensed would have startled it. She had expected it to shift its wings. To hiss, or jab the sharp beak towards her, no more than a threat of future across that great distance. But it simply looked at her.

There was no anger in that gaze, nor was there confusion. Anger would have been easy to perceive, because that illusion was in the bone. Eagles had a small ridge projecting over the top of their eyes, something which made them appear forever fierce and on the verge of attack and once you took all of the actual emotions out of it, that description wasn't necessarily inaccurate. But to see anger...

Anger was, in many ways, an aspect of fear. The response which tried to push the source of terror away. The eagle did not comprehend complex emotions, and one of the oldest parts of her soul offered a moment of envy. But to live was to know fear, because fear was life's way of trying to maintain itself. Avoiding anything which could end that life while, for the eagle, never understanding that its own end would always come.

It was something else she could envy.

She had needed it to know she was there. But it wasn't responding with aggression, nor had it adjusted the cloak of wings into a configuration which offered the potential for takeoff. It simply stayed where it was, with joints flared and feathers spread as cold shifted up through grounded limbs. Looking at her now, and that was all.

A cloak of wings. Something which suggested an attempt to shelter, conceal...

...another thought, and she paused to consider what she had brought into the forest.

The next shift of hooves was a careful one. She was trying to edge sideways, and she had to do so in a way which brought her no closer to those focused eyes. And its head changed position in the way which only avians could manage: all at once, as if there had been a flickerless teleport to each new stage. It watched her -- but it did not try to adjust its wings, nor did talons twist against the cold. It stayed just where it was, as if stillness was the only option possible.

She moved, and when she saw the fur over the heaving rib cage, she stopped.

The squirrel's head was not visible. Her view stopped somewhat short of the neck, and most of what she truly observed was the motion of that rib cage. How very fast it was, sending breath out so soon after bringing it in, too quickly to do any good. It was not breathing to sustain life. It was breathing because that was something which the living did and on the verge of death, the squirrel breathed all the faster.

She could have told herself that it was trying to fit all the breaths of what would have been a normal life into a short span. There had been a time, shortly after she had come to her mark, when she would have brought that into the forest. But she had listened to silent lessons, and so she recognized the core of it. That to live was to know fear and in what it could not understand to be the last moments of its life, fear was all the squirrel had left.

It was on its back. The brush and bush of tail was pointing towards her. The hind legs made no attempt to move: not a single kick or twitch. It simply lay still in the graveyard, with the eagle's wings cloaking so much of its form, as if trying to conceal the squirrel from Sun's final regard.

She could see it that way, if she chose to. But instead, she measured the rate of breath, and moved a little more.

Fear: that was how life maintained. To be too bold was to believe you could take on whatever the world offered, and then you would never prepare. Fear was what had sent the squirrel out into the last days of the funeral, searching for whatever food might remain. And then terror would have swooped down from the sky...

But she was telling herself a story.

That was the truest sound which spun from a pony's mind. It wasn't something which was limited to the forest, although that was where the unspoken words became all the louder.

You came into the world and at some point after your arrival, when instinct began to recede and the cruelty of thought asserted itself, you realized that none of it made sense. And at the moment when that was fully recognized, a new kind of fear began. Something which only ended when the mind which lived through all of it went silent in the only way it truly could.

There was a response to that fear: an avoidant one. You didn't want to confront the fact that the world existed as something with no regard for those within it: an impossibly complex system of interacting aspects which didn't think about any part of the whole because thought would have made the whole thing impossible. Ponies brought thought to the process, and it was something which drove them towards control. If they could regulate the world around them, create any degree of mastery, then it would all have to make sense. They would be the ones to dictate the rhythms and when they did... there would be no more fear.

But control was limited. And so ponies huddled within the zones where control was possible, telling themselves that everything outside those little pockets of magic was unnatural. Huddled, afraid, while she went into the places where the world was still fully real.

There was a second, twinned response to that fear, and it was the one where you told yourself a story.

You were the lead character, of course. There were others around you, but the pony mind often convinced itself that the primary player was just a little more real. Events were about how they affected you. Anything which never directly reached you could offer the chance for empathy as you gazed at sorrow crystallized in a newspaper's ink, but others just saw the pointless offering of unnecessary background material.

You told yourself a story because by trying to enforce a story's structure on the events of your life, you could lie to yourself. You could believe it all made sense, and then you could reach the next lie. The one which said that part of the fear had gone away.

An eagle and a squirrel on the cold floor of a forest which was racing towards its eternally-cycling death. It would be so easy to tell herself a story about that. But it was more important to understand what was, and so she moved a little more. Doing so just as the wind shifted, and the scent of blood flowed towards her.

She didn't jump. Her wings failed to flare, for it was simply blood. She'd scented her own enough times: the drives of her mark led to multiple opportunities to feel it soaking into her fur. She could distinguish the scent of her own blood from that of other sources: that too had been an oft-repeated lesson. There had been an education in varieties of blood, and it might have been an aspect of her talent which allowed her to sort things down to a more refined level.

There was blood in the forest, fresh and flowing.

It was coming from the eagle.

The predator tried to shift its right wing then, instinct and fear driving it to conceal weakness. But it was too late. She'd seen the talons of the left foot. Two of the four were distorted in shape, the scaly skin broken by something darker than natural ridges. Scabs had recently split open along the bent hallux, asked to support too much weight.

For the squirrel...

She looked down at fur which had lost so much color around the muzzle and when she saw the portion of the broken branch under the head, she looked up until she found the other half of the fracture.

It was possible to tell herself another story now. Something where a squirrel approaching the very last winter hadn't been able to react quickly enough when support cracked under its weight. Aged reflexes failed to twist the plummeting body, and now legs didn't kick because a broken spine kept the visible expressions of fear within the portions which could still move.

The squirrel would die: there was no magic which could stop that, no medicine or surgery to allow so much as one more hour. And the eagle, talons injured by something else in the forest, had seen the potential for a single extra sunrise exposed within the graveyard.

But it could no longer swoop and carry. And unable to bring the squirrel to a roost, instincts offering no options for hastening death when the talons were so hurt, it... waited.

The squirrel would die. The eagle would feed. (It was possible to measure any perceived magnificence of an eagle's life in dead squirrels.) And then it would take off, but... nothing could stay in the air forever. And an open wound in a forest filled with decay would draw death in.

Anger was an aspect of fear. So was hatred. She could have hated the eagle, if that had been the story she was telling herself. Some ponies did, especially those with pets who were small and ventured outside on their own. For those, she could offer herbs.

Anger and hatred, directed at the relentless gaze of a predator. Something which took lives to sustain its own, and ponies shuddered at the thought of raw meat, avoided scents from the cooked stuff while retaining more than a touch of skittishness when among the sapient omnivores and carnivores. Ponies didn't kill, so why did anything else need to do so? Didn't they understand?

She understood.

She'd had a petal salad before setting out, and every splash of color had been a piece of decay.

Fruit was a rather tasty portion of the corpse.

Was oxygen alone enough to sustain you? If not, then if you lived, something else died. Some of the future cadavers simply possessed the capacity to flee from their potential fate, because the world had gifted them with fear. A plant which had no capacity for thought couldn't experience any of it. Trees stood unrelenting and unaware, and so they too had her envy.

Could you hate the eagle? Why not hate the squirrel? If you harvested nuts for a living, then squirrels were the subjects of curses and rants and hard-kicked objects which never came close to hitting the speeding form. A bushy tail went from something amusing and worthy of greeting as you moved through the park to that which was making a deliberate effort to ruin your life. (The effort had to be deliberate, because the story of a nut-harvester's life required an antagonist.) Multiple ponies had asked her to talk the scavengers away from their property: others had requested advice regarding solutions which would never truly be permanent, because life existed as a cycle and the gears of the great machine were forever replacing themselves. She had very few answers for those ponies. To communicate didn't mean that which she spoke to would remember for a lifetime after her departure. Live-capture traps always assumed nothing would find its way back. And she would not inflict what those ponies were unwilling to directly create.

The eagle existed to kill, and the squirrel existed to scavenge. She could describe herself as the part of the world which tried to understand itself and everything around it, even when the only way to do so was through the creation of lies. And after she had stripped away the lies over the course of her many trots through the forest, she had found the truth.

The world didn't recognize eagle or squirrel.
The world didn't know she existed.
The world wouldn't remember.
The world didn't care.

Caring was for ponies, and so that was something you could bring into the forest. Something you could project. The squirrel was cute and the eagle was vicious because that way, it made some kind of sense. The story was no longer about the absence of attention, living gears forever turning in a machine unaware of their existence. It was about the one who simply took what fell and the other who ended that innocent activity -- or rather, the activity which the observer had chosen to see as innocent. Choice was the product of thought, and so was the decision to lie.

Her mark brought her into the forest, the visible manifestation of endless duty. Thought wasn't a duty. Thought was the burden, and she could never choose not to think. She simply had to decide whether the truth was better than the lies. Or whether it was possible to live within a state where the only thing acknowledged was truth, when the baseline of the world's own honesty was so cold and cruel.

But of those two aspects, only the cold was real. Cruelty was the product of fear. Another gift of thought, for those who wished for an excuse to never truly think again.

The forest was about truth, and she had learned that truth alone wasn't enough to sustain herself. The warmth of a lie was needed to keep the cold away, and a lie which everypony told was something which could mask itself as a truth. There was a falsehood known as justice, another labeled itself as karma, and both served as a fire for the soul to bask in false warmth.

She knew about truth and lies. She went into the forest for duty and truth, and she came out because at some point, the story had to resume.

The world was cold on the edge of death, and the squirrel breathed faster and faster as fear pushed it towards something it was incapable of truly understanding. Truth was cold, and it was necessary to recognize that. It allowed her to comprehend the need for lies.

She was the part of the world which told itself a story, and so she watched the squirrel die.

There was a name given, just before the end. Gears were sometimes labeled, and somepony had to remember that the squirrel had existed, when the world would not.

She silently watched what happened next, because that was part of the cycle. And when the wet beak came up for the last time as the final drops of blood dripped away, she spread her wings.

It was hard, bringing the sweep of her feathers so low and forward. Painful to walk that way, with the majority of her bent forelegs hidden, while keeping her eyes wide and preventing all movement at the edges. But it was a state she could exist in for a time, and that was the way she approached the eagle.

There was some effort required to get it safely onto her back. The talons scratched wings and the flesh above her spine, but she was used to the scent of her own blood.

She began to trot out of the forest, towards the increasing warmth of the afternoon and, given enough time, cold and snow and then spring again because the cycle always turned. And as she caught first sight of the cottage, she thought about the need for isolation, to keep the eagle away from everything else while it healed. Or until, as she often suspected, her own magic had brought the avian the dark gift of a new lie. The falsehood of comprehension.

But before she returned to Sun and sod, she found bright colors in the form of a fresh corpse. She often did towards the end of autumn, when both world and stories grew cold. And Fluttershy brought the bluejay with her.

Her guest would need to eat.

Comments ( 38 )
Estee #1 · Nov 5th, 2020 · · ·

Author's Very Public Note: I went for a long walk yesterday.

I shouldn't have done that.

*sigh*

For those of my Patreon sponsors who happen to see the story in the New column before the site's email notification: at 4100 words, this mood (or in-a-mood) piece falls under the 5k line which I use to determine whether to check the Charge For This Post box. But I wasn't going to artificially pad it out in order to reach the minimum, and it was a story I wanted to tell. As such, there's no pledge charge attached to this posting. Anyone who feels it's worth their pledge amount anyway may use my Ko-Fi account at their own discretion: otherwise, it's a freebie.

And for those who read it, and wonder how much is real... there was an eagle, and there was a squirrel.

You can take over the story from there.

The world didn't recognize eagle or squirrel.
The world didn't know she existed.
The world wouldn't remember.
The world didn't care.

Caring was for ponies, and so that was something you could bring into the forest. Something you could project.

Well, well. What does that say about Earth Ponies??

But really, this story could work for basically any Fluttershy. It doesn't have to be Triptych...

...

Wow! The nature of the(ir) world, stories, truth, lies, etc.

A lot to unpack!

Gazer #3 · Nov 5th, 2020 · · ·

Familiar, this feels familiar. The cold is inside and every movement hurts. There is no joy in food, sleep only makes you more tired. Is there anyone you are close to? Anyone at all you trust? You need someone safe to let you break. To scream and cry and rage, bleed as much of the poison as you can bear. Please, reach out. No one can fix this, but you will be surprised at how many will sit with you and let you be.

With all my empathy,
Kelly

But she recognized some ponies saw madness in the frozen regard of avians, and had even come to understand why they felt that way. It was the lack of muscles around the eyes.

This raises some interesting questions about griffon anatomy. Of course, given that a feathered mammal's thinking this, some degree of bleedover is to be expected in the eagle-lions.

Trees stood unrelenting and unaware, and so they too had her envy.

This grim take on "I'd like to be a tree" is a perfect encapsulation of your style, and I mean that as a compliment.

I find myself at a crossroads. There are a number of other things I could say about the setting, Fluttershy's place in it, and so forth. But I don't know how much of this went through your own mind, and how much is me trying and failing to retell the story of making this story. I don't want to prod too deeply into the thoughts that led to this, because cruelty isn't just projected when it's coming from one who can choose. Even when they don't mean to cause it.

What I will say is that caring is indeed for those who think. The greater world doesn't because it can't, but we can and often should. This was an excellent melancholy piece. Thank you for it.

There's a slow beauty to this; fluttershys got a really healthy way of looking at our bleak mechanistic universe.

She could describe herself as the part of the world which tried to understand itself and everything around it. even when the only way to doing so was through the creation of lies.

Not sure if that 'even' should be capitalized or if the preceding period should be another punctuation mark.

This feels less "sad" and more like a melancholy existential meditation. The world at large is indeed uncaring, but I don't think caring is a lie. It's simply part of our nature, and a part that I'm glad we have, despite the pain it so often brings.

This was brutal. I loved it.

Seriously, I've been thinking about these topics and seeing the thoughts laid out in such a way here was so interesting and enjoyable. Thank you!!

Spotted a couple of small typos:
d the forest bleed brown into her fur.
Fear was what had send the squirrel

I know you're under a tremendous amount of stress, but damn... are you okay? This reads a lot like my thought process after I got back from Iraq. It was not a nice place to be.

You came into the world and at some point after your arrival, when instinct began to recede and the cruelty of thought asserted itself, you realized that none of it made sense. And at the moment when that was fully recognized, a new kind of fear began. Something which only ended when the mind which lived through all of it went silent in the only way it truly could.

Today's SMBC seems rather appropriate.

The Eagle
Tennyson

He clasps the crag with crooked hands;
Close to the sun in lonely lands,
Ring'd with the azure world, he stands.

The wrinkled sea beneath him crawls;
He watches from his mountain walls,
And like a thunderbolt he farts.

Poetry can be so inspirational. :pinkiehappy:

B_Munro #12 · Nov 5th, 2020 · · 1 ·

“All right," said Susan. "I'm not stupid. You're saying humans need... fantasies to make life bearable."

REALLY? AS IF IT WAS SOME KIND OF PINK PILL? NO. HUMANS NEED FANTASY TO BE HUMAN. TO BE THE PLACE WHERE THE FALLING ANGEL MEETS THE RISING APE.

"Tooth fairies? Hogfathers? Little—"

YES. AS PRACTICE. YOU HAVE TO START OUT LEARNING TO BELIEVE THE LITTLE LIES.

"So we can believe the big ones?"

YES. JUSTICE. MERCY. DUTY. THAT SORT OF THING.

"They're not the same at all!"

YOU THINK SO? THEN TAKE THE UNIVERSE AND GRIND IT DOWN TO THE FINEST POWDER AND SIEVE IT THROUGH THE FINEST SIEVE AND THEN SHOW ME ONE ATOM OF JUSTICE, ONE MOLECULE OF MERCY. AND YET—Death waved a hand. AND YET YOU ACT AS IF THERE IS SOME IDEAL ORDER IN THE WORLD, AS IF THERE IS SOME...SOME RIGHTNESS IN THE UNIVERSE BY WHICH IT MAY BE JUDGED.

"Yes, but people have got to believe that, or what's the point—"

MY POINT EXACTLY.”
Terry Pratchett, Hogfather

Is it wrong that after reading this story I have this song stuck in my head?

RDT

This is probably the most, hmm, directly existential story I've read from you.

Thank you for these stories.

This is a big part of what fascinates me about Fluttershy's character: out of the Mane Six, she is perhaps uniquely positioned to understand "harsh realities" like this. It seems almost at odds with her highly empathetic qualities, but a very valid read of her character might be that her empathy draws significantly from this very understanding.

Philosophical stories, especially fanfics, are hard to come by. This really drove home for me, as I understand the darkness of the world, and have seen things no man should ever hope to see, be it in a TV show, or my nightmares. Thank you for this.

A deep and thought inducing read, it brings forwards some thoughts that some people living in the cities are in desperate need of.

Truly a good read, thank you.

Thank you for writing, and good luck, Estee.

This is an awe-inspiring insight into Fluttershy’s character and defines true kindness in the starkest of terms: it isn’t an exchange or a reward, it is seeing value in that which is outside oneself, and choosing to include it in the circle of what matters to oneself. Kindness is a choice, something that requires a decision being made, and thus a mind to make that decision.
In your story, Fluttershy’s early experiences with cold harshness of life, combined with her hyper-developed empathic skill, have perfectly positioned her to have this insight: the world doesn’t care, so Fluttershy does. By making this choice, meek little Fluttershy takes on the world. And she wins. God, I love your Fluttershy! And thanks for this amazing peek into the nature of mind, and for showing us the beauty of Fluttershy’s.

Was pretty good introspection there. Although I would argue that justice isn't a lie; but it can't be applied to the vast majority of the natural world.

What you saw wasn't an unnatural way of holding itself, it's a thing known as "mantling" and most raptors will do it when on food on the ground to hide it from competitors.

I work with birds of prey (in fact I'm with them now) so I'm pretty used to the brutality that can exist in nature. Nothing like a bird catching something and waiting for you to arrive and do the dirty work for it.

Deepest Fluttershy is often best Fluttershy.

They say that still waters run deep. No one is stiller or deeper than Fluttershy 4.0. Fluttershy 4.5, otoh......

10518239
Possibly Fluttershy didn't recognise mantling due to being less familiar with raptor behaviour. (It mentions she keeps them away from the cottage with scents)

And Flutters is great here. Connects well with 500 Little Murders.

I think this shows why Discord chose Fluttershy to carry the "elimination sphere" in Triptych, because even being the manifestation of Chaos, he understood that Fluttershy would have the understanding of the situation to make the correct choice. By this, I mean he had a pretty good idea what happened at the (newly-formed) ravine near Trotter's Falls; he just wanted to make sure that it was handled properly, which he wouldn't have been able to do at that time

10519544
IMO, you're being too kind to Discord. As I see it
He knew damned good & well EXACTLY what the Mane 6 would find out about Dr. Gentle.
He did things the way he did because
1) He knew it would hurt Dr. Gentle more if his friends turned on him
1A) If they DIDN'T turn on him, it would hurt Celestia
2) If HE punished Dr. Gentle, he would run the risk of being punished himself.
By leaving it to others, he could punish the Dr. & avoid the risk of being punished

You posted this on Thursday, it's still Featured on Saturday.
"I still got it." Ralph Malph (Happy Days)
You too.

10518239
I'll say this, there are behaviors that certainly seem to suggest mental qualities — some critters simply ~like~ to bite for no other reason than they seem to enjoy it — but in the end, if the behavior serves a purpose, the purpose is the purpose.

But I think this relates well, to both your comment and the story as a whole. So, I'll let the master of clever introspection say it for me.

The world didn't recognize eagle or squirrel. The world didn't know she existed. The world wouldn't remember. The world didn't care.

It's quite nice seeing someone realize this. Often nature is characterized as motherly , which I don't exactly agree on.

So it is just me that is a terrible (approximation of a) person, or just inured to Nature by decades of watching/reading Sir David that it sort of just passes me on this one?

I mean, I can see how it's a big deal to ponies, but... I think I'm too much of an engineer and amateur zoologist for this one to strike quite as home for me personally on a resonance level.



Look, the only things I've watched on nature stuff I didn't take in stride was a) slug sex in Life in the Undergrowth (I just can't. I don't know why, it just makes me equesy, I have to look away on that bit on th DVD) and watching on one of the Planet Earths geese chicks deliberately chuck themselves down cliffs (because I'm not fond of falling myself and that just made me wince.) Chimps in eating monkeys? Killer Wahales batting seal-cubs around with their tails? That parasite infects snails and makes their eye-stalks pulse out? Did nowt, I'm afraid.

(Also, always been more on the predators side than the prey anyway...)

10517313
I thought of a different poem. In Memoriam A.H.H., cantos LIV-LVI:

LIV
Oh yet we trust that somehow good
Will be the final goal of ill,
To pangs of nature, sins of will,
Defects of doubt, and taints of blood;

That nothing walks with aimless feet;
That not one life shall be destroy'd,
Or cast as rubbish to the void,
When God hath made the pile complete;

That not a worm is cloven in vain;
That not a moth with vain desire
Is shrivell'd in a fruitless fire,
Or but subserves another's gain.

Behold, we know not anything;
I can but trust that good shall fall
At last—far off—at last, to all,
And every winter change to spring.

So runs my dream: but what am I?
An infant crying in the night:
An infant crying for the light:
And with no language but a cry.

LV
The wish, that of the living whole
No life may fail beyond the grave,
Derives it not from what we have
The likest God within the soul?

Are God and Nature then at strife,
That Nature lends such evil dreams?
So careful of the type she seems,
So careless of the single life;

That I, considering everywhere
Her secret meaning in her deeds,
And finding that of fifty seeds
She often brings but one to bear,

I falter where I firmly trod,
And falling with my weight of cares
Upon the great world's altar-stairs
That slope thro' darkness up to God,

I stretch lame hands of faith, and grope,
And gather dust and chaff, and call
To what I feel is Lord of all,
And faintly trust the larger hope.

LVI
'So careful of the type?' but no.
From scarped cliff and quarried stone
She cries, `A thousand types are gone:
I care for nothing, all shall go.

'Thou makest thine appeal to me:
I bring to life, I bring to death:
The spirit does but mean the breath:
I know no more.' And he, shall he,

Man, her last work, who seem'd so fair,
Such splendid purpose in his eyes,
Who roll'd the psalm to wintry skies,
Who built him fanes of fruitless prayer,

Who trusted God was love indeed
And love Creation's final law—
Tho' Nature, red in tooth and claw
With ravine, shriek'd against his creed—

Who loved, who suffer'd countless ills,
Who battled for the True, the Just,
Be blown about the desert dust,
Or seal'd within the iron hills?

No more? A monster then, a dream,
A discord. Dragons of the prime,
That tare each other in their slime,
Were mellow music match'd with him.

O life as futile, then, as frail!
O for thy voice to soothe and bless!
What hope of answer, or redress?
Behind the veil, behind the veil.

Life moves on. And death is a ever present companion. But for the young Death is a challenge, forever teasing him. For the old, Death is a old companion. Just one you are tired of meeting and want to put that final reunion off for one more day.

Death though has more patience than anyone else.

I feel like you probably wear a lot of black, mostly purchased at Hot Topic

10616990

The last thing I purchased at Hot Topic was a DVD set for Neurotically Yours.

...which kind of tells you how long it's been since I've purchased anything at Hot Topic.

10517498
Me, I'm more thinking of this one.

There is a regular blog called "Pitch Meeting" about TV & movies.

Their comment on The Lion King
"He tells him 'It's part of the Circle Of Life. Lions eat gazelles. Then, when we die our bodies grow grass for the gazelles to eat.' ."

"I think we know who got the better of that deal."

:rainbowlaugh:

10517405
I previously brought it up when some madman decided that Fluttershy would be the Vetinari analogue in their Discworld parody, but the latter's drunk monologue on the horrible things that happen in nature is just as relevant:

I was walking along the bank of a stream when I saw a mother otter with her cubs, a very endearing sight, I'm sure you'll agree. And even as I watched, the mother otter dived into the water and came up with a plump salmon, which she subdued and dragged onto a half submerged log. As she ate it, while of course it was still alive, the body split and I remember to this day the sweet pinkness of its roes as they spilled out, much to the delight of the baby otters, who scrambled over themselves to feed on the delicacy. One of nature's wonders, gentlemen. Mother and children dining upon mother and children. And that is when I first learned about evil. It is built into the very nature of the universe. Every world spins in pain. If there is any kind of supreme being, I told myself, it is up to all of us to become his moral superior.

10527156
reminds me of a scene in a Discworld novel, "Sourcery", where a wizard cheated death by putting his soul into a staff.
he boasted that he had beaten death, but Death said, "FROM MY POINT OF VIEW, THIS IS JUST A DELAY."

Login or register to comment