• Member Since 3rd Oct, 2014
  • offline last seen Jul 6th, 2018

Hudibadudi


E
Source

Two years after Rarity and Twilight broke up, Twilight returns to Ponyville to make things right with her former marefriend. Rarity isn't going to make it easy for her.

Cover art by Volodragon on deviantart.

Chapters (1)
Comments ( 8 )

Those two are so sweet together. Thank you for writing this.

6297292 I'm glad you enjoyed it:pinkiehappy:

I cant help but think of the Three Days Grace song looking at the title.

Sorry, but the way Twilight left, and her argument when she was looking for Rarity just doesn't make me want to root for them to get back together. Maybe if Twilight took some time to sort out her priorities, maybe if there had been a more solid motive for the "PRINCESS OF FRIENDSHIP" to not even make contact with the mare after 2 years, I'd buy it. But as it stands, this Twilight doesn't even try to fit into her own character believably beyond a few token similarities.

That said the premise and writing are good, my primary issue is characterization and the plot's rushed conclusion leaving no chance for growth or at least some kind of progress to make Twilight's reunion with Rarity deserved.

6302232 I see what you mean. After reading your comment and thinking back on the story, I came to realize that this story wasn't as good as I thought it was (how can people like this?:trixieshiftright:). Thanks for pointing out the errors, I appreciate the criticism and hopefully I'll be able to avoid these mistakes in the future.

6302379

Your welcome, best wishes man, and remember, re-writes are a thing. Plus, I personally think taking a stroll through some other Twi/Rare fics might help you either with ideas or plot works. Just a suggestion, best of luck.

6302379 the only glaring issue really is the lack of motivation for Twilight to leave alone in the first place.

Was she leaving Rarity so Rarity wouldn't have to move? Was Celestia pressuring her to not date a mortal? Was Twilight worrying about, dating a mortal, Not being good enough for Rarity, Rarity only dating her because she is a princess?

Without a real reason for leaving her there's less of a reason to get back together.

I have to leave tomorrow, and I have to do this alone.

No offense to Twilight (this seems somewhat in character), but why the heck would she have to go to Canterlot alone. She never once had the idea of asking Rarity if she could come with her? Ugh, I swear Twilight's reasoning is harder to understand after season 3 canon.

Login or register to comment