April, YOH 1505: Twilight Sparkle and her Companions have returned to Ponyville from Our Town. Now they must deal with the emotional price of their incomplete victory.
What if Starlight had rejected Twilight's friendship offer? What if she refused to change her ways and vowed to continue with her revenge on Twilight and her friends?
Starlight Glimmer is victorious in stealing everypony's cutie marks. But a mysterious and creepy filly is immune to her magic. While Starlight searches for a way to beat the filly, one thing is clear...there's something wrong with that girl.
For as long as she can remember Twilight Sparkle has enjoyed The Hunt. Her mother taught her that, even if they feed on the lifeblood of ponies, the hunt is always the best part. Now, Twilight is on the hunt for somepony, and that pony is Starlight.
Nothing to lose, and everything to gain. After weeks of starvation, thirst, and solitude, Starlight Glimmer thought she finally understood that phrase. She was wrong. So very, very wrong.