While playing an innocent game of Power Ponies inside an enchanted comic book, Rarity, Applejack, and Rainbow Dash come upon an impasse. For the "adventure" to end, Mistress Marevelous and Zapp are required to kiss. *Passionately.*
Sent to a Ranch to improve her attitude and relations in her losing soccer team, Rainbow Dash realizes she is quickly falling for the female farm worker, Applejack.
Rarity discovers an old tradition involving the exchange of felt dolls as a sign of affection. This sparks a brilliant plan to play matchmaker with her friends, and between herself and Twilight. But brilliant plans never go as expected, do they?
Snippets of the lives of Rainbow Dash and Applejack. Time and again, they discover that this phrase accurately describes falling in love, being in love, and life in general.
Most ponies have relatively benign problems in their relationships. Small arguments, things like that. When the universe itself begins to meddle in Applejack's love life, both her and Rainbow realize it isn't going to be as easy as they thought.