Page generated in 0.025 seconds
Total duration
1,013 users online
1,254,086 hits today, 1,960,719 yesterday
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Fanfiction
Designed and coded by knighty & Xaquseg - © 2011-2024
Support us
SubStar
Chat!
Discord
Follow us
Twitter
MLP: Friendship is Magic® - © 2024 Hasbro Inc.®
Fimfiction is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Hasbro Inc.®
10387917
Yeah, I realized about ten seconds after I posted that comment that you had in fact, already commented on Romancing the (Martial) Artist
Pinkie. She never left her family's farm.
Duskfall must free Celestia and bring Luna back to complete her mission
fluttershy died didnt she
10390885
If Fluttershy was the one who died, do you have a guess on how that might have effected things?
10390879
A very good guess. Although you only have 3 to guess from, it's also a very reasonable thing to think.
Unfortunately for Duskfall, the rabbit hole goes a little further than that...
10390889
i mean she was the only one that almost dies as a child by not opening her wings and it would explane rainbow in the guard as a frend dieing due to lack of safty could have sent her down the road of feeling she needs to be the protecter because she failed her frend
10390891
Four things.
1.) You're working off the assumption that Fluttershy is indeed dead. There might be other reasons why she might not have joined the others to find the Elements.
2.) You're working off the assumption that things were very close to the show up until very recently. Rainbow being a Thestral should be your first clue this isn't the case.
3.) Rainbow is a Thestral. What makes you think she even knew Fluttershy to begin with?
4.) Why would Rainbow join the Royal Guard under Celestia and then become a guard under Nightmare Moon?
10390891
IGIARI! To continue with Dimension's explanation. You have made a critical contradiction. -slams desk with palm- It wasn't the rainboom that made the butterflies appear to cushion her fall! The Rainboom scared the animals away when she's already on the ground! -dramatic pointy finger-
Sill waiting for a reply......
10390934
It was a mistake to reply the first time. I don't intend to repeat it. I may be dumb, but not quite that stupid.
10390936
So you choose to bury your head in the sand than confront your own attitudes? That is being stupid.
This is not a matter of "Us Vs them" I'm not part of the US and I'm not involved in your country's utterly nonsensical partisan issues/attitudes.
Hate groups are Hate groups, because they explicitly exist as a category of people who object to people simply for existing- many of which have no option of being that way yet are hated for it.
I think it's simple, while not very explored in many fics, just like too much darkness is bad, too much light may blind you, zealots are both from light and darkness, many bad things had been made in the name of the light
10390936
Also others are in agreement with me about what I have said and what you have said.
Maybe you choose not to reply because you simply have no come back nor retort to what has been stated bar your own personal feelings that no not match reality.
10390959
good lad. A light that is too bright blinds as surely as the deepest darkness.
10390960
I'm not responding because you are actively looking to pick a fight. I simply have better things to do with my time. Please, drop it.
10390979
I'm not intentionally trying to pick a fight, but you are digging your head in the sand and refusing to have your harmful views challenged in a constructive manner.
Running to Hate Groups for comfort is not the right repsonse either.
I do not live in the US, and I'm not part of your culture's BS partisan atttudes
.
edit: Apparently the Group he has started to hang out with are classed as MRAs which are Men Superiority group that are highly sexist towards women and expects then to stop working and just become servants to men.
When i tried to clarify if he meant actual MRAs or just standard men right groups, and repeated what is classed as Hate Group, he just blocked me without any reply or retort.
When I decided to see what this "The Red Pill" documentary is, turns out it's banned where i Live due to being highly misogynistic propaganda that claims are 100% truths.
While Christianity teaches hate the sin not the sinner, people forget that still does not mean you let people do hurtful or hateful things.
St Paul's letter to the Galatians 3:28
While I can’t say for sure. Applejack I bet is more then likely either in mainhaten or still working at her farm. I going with the idea there was no rainboom either starlight or rainbow being a thestral and could not ether join the flight school where it happened or preform it in general.
Just....be careful, okay?
10391013
Reasonable assumptions to make. Rainbow being a Thestral in this timeline certainly does raise the question of if she's even capable of the rainboom. Even if she is, what circumstances could have caused her to preform it as the others were getting their Cutie Marks? Was there perhaps a 3rd, unknown party who preformed the Rainboom? Did the Rainboom happen at all and the others acquired their Cutie Marks some other way?
If AJ is missing, then what might've played out differently?
10391327
As much as this guy bemoans repetitiveness, he's legitimately said the same thing I've heard 100 times over about conservatives. I've also heard the same arguments leveled against Leftists.
My candidate was Bernie Sanders, I'm proud of my Jewish heritage even if I hate my father, and I absolutely hate that this guy claims that "not choosing" is leaning right. That's bullshit.
Does that make you feel better?
Also claiming that trying to fix an """"Alt-Right"""" is dangerous to the 'general populous' is super toxic. Speaking like that makes it sound like 'gabe' is a lost cause.
Finally, the claim that the left has a monopoly on hope is so utterly morally bankrupt that it makes me want to instantly discredit the rest of the video as nonsense. I legitimately feel physically sick after hearing that man make that claim.
10391327
Also, I'm not a cis male. I'm a bi gender fluid. The real alt-right hates me by default. Almost as much as I hate myself.
10391327
I might also mention, for how much progessives and the left are supposed to bring "hope", the DNC has caused me more depression from the time I was 13 and especially this last election cycle to match the GOP at least 5 times over.
If I had gotten no hope from the right, then I wouldn't have lived to see my 14th birthday. I would have killed myself 4 months into my 13th year.
My guess on the missing Mane 6 will be Pinkie. Starlight's messing with time interrupted Rainbow's Sonic Rainboom, so Pinkie would never see such joy and wouldn't throw a party for her family. Her cutie mark would probably be rock-related and still be living on her parent's rock farm.
10390982
Considering feminism is a very popular hate group, promoting female interests regardless of the cost to males (and not the actual "gender equality" movement - that's egalitarianism), and has turned society into a male-hostile place, I'm not surprised that men who want their rights acknowledged would be classed as "male superiority", "highly sexist", or a "hate group".
Men face issues with many topics - child custody, adoption, genital mutilation ("circumcision"), education, criminal justice, suicide rates, domestic violence, divorce settlements, homelessness, conscription, health, reproductive rights, paternity fraud, rape, and more.
Yet when men want their plight known, for the fundamental issues made public so they can hopefully be changed, they're accused of "sexism" and "misogyny" for some inane reason. A lot of men just want actual egalitarianism, and boosting men's rights is currently the way to get there.
It's why men are starting to no longer date, or mentor younger women. It's why #MeToo is seen as a misandristic witch-hunt, since male lives are ruined without the chance to defend themselves, without actual proper evidence and legal procedures.
It's how men are automatically labelled as "pedophiles" when wanting to spend time with children, or are even sitting next to a child. It's how there's very few male domestic abuse shelters, and the minority that exist are not funded to the same level as female shelters. It's how five girls falsely accused a teenaged boy of rape, because they "just don't like him", and got away with it while his life was destroyed.
i.redd.it/3vvz6dsty8z11.jpg i.redd.it/o5oc59lcx8z11.png i.imgur.com/Fh0E1r9.jpg
It's possible that instead of AJ, it could have been Big Mac. Then there's Laughter. For all we know, it could be Lyra in this world.
With Nightmare Moon running things, who knows what she did to keep the others in line, give Rarity's reaction to Sweetie Bell.
Lastly, odds are that Luna had the Element of Honesty in this world, like she did in most others. Who's to say that NMM didn't pick up on the half truths that Dusk was giving out. Add to the fact that Luna/Nightmare Moon had a LOT of time to learn how to read people.
10391552
Good guess. Without knowing the Rainboom happened, anyone could be missing. However, Twilight did not go alone to face the Nightmare. There was only one star missing from her Cutie Mark. So, if the Rainboom did happen, who would be least likely to show up? If the Rainboom didn't happen, how did any of them shpw up?
10391555
I blocked him for something he said in DMs. I don't need that toxicity in my life. I have enough of that already.
Also thank you for being reasonable.
10391562
Very clever. NMM does indeed have a dark hold over Twilight, Rarity, and one other. Rainbow is actually loyal to the Nightmare, as we'll see why probably next chapter.
Either Fluttershy or Pinkie Pie.
Fluttershy was too soft to be a thestral and the thestrals killed her or simply removed her.
Pinkie Pie never became happy because I bet the rain-boom was different since Dash is a thestral.
Applejack I don’t see anything different other than maybe the everfree outgrowing since Dusk couldn’t sense the tree of harmony.
10391853
Bold of you to assume Fluttershy was a Thestral...
It's completely possible for Pinkie to have found a different kind of happiness and desire to leave the Rock Farm...
Applejack might have played a bigger role than you think...
not sure what the state of aj is but that last verse leaves the implication that honesty was a bit of a weak link in this timeline
edit: if this is loosely following the canon alterations then my bet is that she never went back home so theres a whole lot of lying to oneself going on here
Because cookies are in the line I'm guessing it's Pinkie. Something happened to her during the rainboom or, something happened during Nightmare Moons return and Pinkie is gone.
10392187
You are correct that Honesty is weakened, but maybe not for the reasons you think...
10392472
Now that I think about it, given the reward is internet cookies, I should've expected more Pinkie answers. I should've went with Power Pellets...but those start with P, also inviting Pinkie answers... CURSES!
Since I haven't looked past this chapter yet I'll make a guess the missing is not a character, but an unrealized friendship (thus 5 stars and the reason why they didn't beat the NM - Twi haven't got the crown). Now I'll go read the right answer.
Fluttershy. My bet is on Fluttershy.
10797867
to be fair, not many of the elements had a chance to be in danger before lun's return. rarity was dragged to a rock quarry, but we see her here. so fluttershy, pinkie or applejack.