Nightmare Rarity lives on the moon. Until she learns how to behave, she will remain there, as ordained by her closest friends. Thankfully, she wasn't left alone, as they assigned Anon to watch over her progress and report back when she starts showing signs of improvement.
Rarity took this as his way of expressing his undying love and affection, something the lonely villainess is happy to return in kind.
He doesn't dislike it.
Rating for particularly passionate kissing/suggestive themes/innuendo.
Day #3 of Hearts and Hands Week.
Well, this is just lovely.

This is the 1st MLP: Comic Story you made.
In short summarize, straight from the IDW Comic. 👍
Don't be, describing and narrating mature stories like the last one you made was 🔥. (plus a few more will do ok)
Very beautiful!
I like this! It really makes me want a full length story about it.
its villainess not villainous
Am I the only one that realizes that this is so insulting for Spike!?
An awesome oneshot. Though did anyone else expect this to be a sad one?
11819991
Fixed!
A shame we never got Nightmare Rarity in the show. It could have been a nice twist.
Proving that Runic just cannot stay out of the feature box, I've seen all three of the H&H Week stories there at one time, albeit only for about an hour. Even now, however, there's still two of them showing.
For shame, Runic, didn't you learn from the previous complaints about you hogging up the feature box with all of these quality horsewords
?!?
11820106
.
Rarity going all tall, dark, and glam-evil? Spike would have lost his mind
11820116
I'm just having a good time writing.
MORE OF HER PLEASE I NEED SEQUELS OF HER GETTING BETTER-
11820214
Maybe in the future
Nightmare rarity is interesting
11820116
Hey relax! Its us who puts him there
...unless Rob or Perph or some of the other site staff are putting him there
Very well characterized indeed. Bravo n_n
This was a lot more wholesome than I was expecting. Certainly a refreshing change of pace from the fics that I've been reading as of late. Great work as always, Runic.
I would love to see more nightmare rarity.
Yes Anon, follow your queen to glory!