• Published 7th Oct 2014
  • 1,810 Views, 57 Comments

I'd Do Anything - 2006midnight



Spike writes a letter to Rarity confessing his love for her, and his regrets for waiting so long.

  • ...
1
 57
 1,810

Drowning in Seas of Hopelessness

To the most beautiful mare I’ve ever met,

Each and every morning I wake up and I’m miles away from home. No one here means much to me, not like you. Every single day is a struggle to make it till the end. To me, it seems like there’s no point in even continuing on living. When there’s nothing left to live for, why try? I’ll tell you why. The one and only thing that keeps me going now is you even though you don’t know it. And you are also the reason why I’m coming back home, why I’m abandoning this quest to find who I truly am.

You might not want me to give up for a second time, but really I don’t see it that way. In my mind, I have found who I truly am. Both times that I’ve gone on these quests to find out what it means to be a dragon and how that applies to me, it will seem like I’ve failed. The first time, when I was still a baby dragon, I won’t go so far as to say I failed, but I can’t say that I succeeded either. This time, I found answers. Not the ones I expected to find, don’t get me wrong, but I definitely found the answers to my existential quandaries. I’ve realized that anything and everything that makes me the dragon I am, lies close to my heart, back home in Ponyville. And most importantly, with you.

I don’t know what’s happened over the course of the few years that I’ve been gone, but I can only hope that you haven’t found that special stallion yet. I don’t mean to sound selfish, but all I want is just one chance. One chance to show you that I can become the lifelong partner you’ve always dreamed of having. You might think that I’m asking for you to commit to me, but I’m not. I don’t want you to give me all the love in your heart just yet. In fact, I beg you not to. I wouldn’t feel that I’ve earned it. You can’t just go away for years, come back one day, and expect those you left behind to sell their souls to you.

With all these miles separating us, all I can do is weep. Weep for the opportunity that I’ve almost certainly thrown away. Don’t feel bad if you don’t want to go out with me, I’ll understand. Times change, sometimes for the better, sometimes for the worse. If fortune chooses to smile upon me, then I can vow to you, here and now, that I will give you the best night of your life. I have no way to prove this to you, since all I have to offer at the moment are these few written words, so I’ll have to hope that you can trust me.

In our shared past, we’ve both had our ups and downs. I can’t speak in much more detail as to what your experiences were like, but I can shed some light on some of mine, at least, the ones that wrenched my heart the most. By now you already know that I’ve had a crush on you since the moment I first saw you all those years ago. Each and every time you missed the real, deeper meaning behind an act of kindness I directed towards you, left a deep gouge upon my heart. The one that hurt most of all was probably the time with the fire ruby. Don’t misunderstand what I’m trying to say, I’m very glad that I gave you a gift that could make you so ecstatic. The only thing that has continued to haunt me is how you didn’t realize that you were taking advantage of the crush I had on you even as you did so. In a way, I regret not telling you directly, right then and there, exactly how I felt. If I had then maybe I wouldn’t have had to suffer so many future blows upon my heart. I won’t continue to describe these times; I’m pretty sure you already knew what they are anyway. It will suffice to say that all the dark times I’ve been through with you are still far outnumbered by the good.

Now that I’ve been gone, I’m hoping we can both forgive and forget the bad times we had in the past and move on, if not into a relationship, then at least continue to be good friends. The last thing I would want is for this confession of mine to destroy our friendship. Even with the knowledge that it could never become anything more, our friendship would still mean the world to me.

My greatest sorrow amongst all of this is that I already know what your answer will be. I’m a dragon and you’re a pony, so how could this possibly work. It couldn’t. Society just isn’t made that way. If there was ever a chance for our relationship, then I’ve destroyed it by going away for so many years. If I hadn’t been so blind as to what was directly in front of me, then maybe we could’ve been the rebels of sorts. Maybe we could’ve been those who pushed forward and strove to make a change in the norms of society. But now, I’m sure that most of the ponies in Ponyville have forgotten about me entirely. I was never noticed by them that much aside from that one birthday anyway.

I know that I’ve rambled on for way too long in order to get across such a simple point, so I’ll do my best to wrap this up quickly. In short, I have no doubts that I could love you for the rest of eternity and beyond. The thing that worries me most, is whether or not I’m too late with this letter. No matter what your answer may be I promise I’ll see you again soon. I’m sorry for all the mistakes that I’ve made.

Here’s hoping you’ll pick up the pieces of my broken heart…

Comments ( 57 )

Not going to lie, there's a lot in this pretty close to my heart right now. Great job.

Nice story. Make a sequel. :pinkiehappy::pinkiehappy::pinkiehappy::pinkiehappy:

5112320 Thank you! :pinkiehappy:And you know, I'd have a really hard time picking out what those things are.:twilightsheepish:

5112398 Thanks! :twilightsmile:What would the sequel be about though?:rainbowhuh:

Pretty good. I would love to see a sequel to this :pinkiehappy:

5112435 Thank you! :pinkiehappy:What could I do for a sequel though?:rainbowderp:

There is quite a bit of potential here. There could be a sequel in the form of Rarity writing Spike back. You could tell the story of Spike's return to Ponyville and what he finds there, both good and bad. This is a wonderful opening that you should run with. Having read this, I have no doubt that you could make the follow up into something special.

5112444 Interesting. I might make a sequel once I finish One-shotober and NaPoWriMo.:twilightblush:

5112439 To piggy back on what Random said, you could do that and show the reactions of everyone else in Ponyville. Not to mention do some back story and explain what exactly triggered Spike's desire to go on another quest of self discovery in the first place. Like Random said... lots of potential

5112470 Interesting ideas. And as I said to Random, I will consider a sequel after finishing One-shotober and NaPoWriMo.

5112425
Well the sequel could be about Rarity getting the letter Spike had wrote to her. Spike already has returned home, and waits for a response. The ending is up to you. :rainbowwild::pinkiehappy::pinkiehappy::pinkiehappy::pinkiehappy::pinkiehappy:

5112707 As I've said below, I will consider doing a sequel after I finish One-shotober and NaPoWriMo.:twilightsheepish:

5112746
Ahh I see. Well good fortune to you. :pinkiehappy::pinkiehappy::pinkiehappy:

My mind often goes to the tragically comical in setups like this story has presented. Spike's not pulling any punches here - he's using guilt, sympathy, romance, charity, and anything else he can get his hands on to get that second chance. But in my mind, the thing I kept thinking was "I wonder how much time has actually passed. What if he took a dragon nap? What if Rarity is old and grey? What if he comes back to Ponyville and finds a blustering metropolis with technology well beyond the world he left behind and its Rarity's descendants he finds a la Bicentennial Man?"

Comically tragic.

5113524 :rainbowlaugh:He didn't take a dragon nap. He's only been gone for about 3 years.

The romantic in me wants a sequel where they get together.

The dramatist wants Rarity to have moved on and found somepony, and Spike's poor little heart fractures into a million pieces. :pinkiecrazy:

5113852 :rainbowlaugh: Wait for the sequel!

5115190 That's contradictory!:trixieshiftright:

5115194

I won't tell anyone. :rainbowwild:

5115199 I probably won't do both. Maybe I'll make a blog putting up a vote for how they want Rarity to react and choose that way.:twilightblush:

Wow, lot of feels from this one....

5115194
No, alternate endings, not contradictory, you can do it.....

5115203
Nah, do both... would satisfy both sides that way... Let them have both... to do with what they choose....

5115410 Is that a good thing?:trixieshiftright:

5115415
5115416 I've got plenty of time to figure it out. It won't be until December before I even think about a sequel.:twilightblush:

5115421
Yep, it's like flipping a coin and getting heads and tails at the same time, you get what you wanted, plus an extra...

5115428 Interesting analogy, but thank you!:pinkiehappy:

5115427
Take your time....

5115434 I actually would've had one finished by the weekend if I wasn't busy with One-shotober and during November I won't have time for anything else other than NaPoWriMo.:twilightblush:

5115439
It's alright, everyone has their own life to lead....

Oh, by the way, what's NaPoWriMo?

5115443 It's where you write 50,000 words of a novel only during November.

5115446
Ok, what's it mean?

5115493 The original term is NaNoWriMo which means National Novel Writing Month, so NaPoWriMo is National Pony Writing Month.

5115498 Wow, they actually have that? Well, best of luck to you midnight, maybe I might enter too, if I can think of anything to write, that is....

5115502 Yep, they do. Thanks, and same to you if you choose to enter.:twilightsmile:

5115511
Oh, thanks, by the way, do you know where the rules and stuff for this are listed?

5115617 Here's the group for it that I'm in.

great story! it really sad and sweet and it rocks!
my biggest complaint would be spike, but I don't think ill ever be able to like him.
also, it might be good to talk about how spike came to this conclusion, the things that happened that made him finally get the resolve to go back home. it would probably be to much to change right now, but maybe you could talk about it if you make a squeal.
overall, I think this is probably one of your better oneshotober fics

5141403 Yeah, I'm not a huge Spike fan either so this was kinda hard to do...

Thank you though.:twilightsmile:

5141414 Wow, that must have been really hard

5141422 Yeah, I just wanted to do a sad romance type story and Spike and Rarity fit the best.

That was awesome! Like the majority of the comments: We need a sequel! (I know, you're probably tired of hearing that.) But it's true! BTW, if you ever need an editor for small one chapter stories like this, just ask me! :twilightsmile:

5247532 I will probably eventually write a sequel, but right now is not a good time. And thank you for the offer, I've never actually had an editor.

This was so beautiful. It takes a little bit each from romance, heartache and hope, and blends it together so well, and so vividly. For a minute, I really thought this letter was what Spike was really thinking.

I'll read the sequel when I can. I'm sure it's just as amazing as this one. Liked and faved. :pinkiesmile:

Login or register to comment