• Member Since 23rd Apr, 2020
  • offline last seen 18 minutes ago

Mockingbirb


A pony of mystery in the darkness. Or I forgot to take the lens cap off. (They/them is fine.)

T
Source

When your name is Midnight Sparkle, love means never having to admit your girlfriend is dead.


Contest Information:
An entry in the Sunset Shimmer x Midnight Sparkle Competition AND in Bicyclette's & EileenSaysHi's SciSet Contest!
:twilightsmile: :trollestia:


Art Credits: I edited an image by RileyAV (whose original version is larger, better, and unfortunately NSFW so I can't link directly to it from this T-rated fimfiction.net story description.)
https://derpibooru.org/tags/artist-colon-rileyav
http://RileyAV.tumblr.com/
http://RileyAV.deviantart.com/

Chapters (2)
Comments ( 10 )

Ah. Midnight's greatest evil isn't the callous disregard for collateral damage as she indulges her insatiable curiosity. It's shipping. Cadence would be proud.

Fascinating tale of the many uses of an active dark side. Thank you for it.

Quoting one of the contest runners I see... ...:derpyderp1:

So firearms are allowed!...

I don’t want to be harsh, but as a contest judge I do need to be frank. I didn’t like this story very much. It feels like a lot of wasted potential, in that you have an intriguing setup — Midnight Sparkle’s talents including the power of resurrection — that is entirely neglected by the narrative as soon as it fulfills its immediate function. The overall plot feels like a bunch of characters shrugging their shoulders and saying “well, this happened,” and I honestly forgot about Midnight entirely for a good chunk of the storyline. Overall, it reads like a mishmash of odd ideas that just never gel.

11717873

I don’t want to be harsh, but as a contest judge I do need to be frank. I didn’t like this story very much. It feels like a lot of wasted potential, in that you have an intriguing setup — Midnight Sparkle’s talents including the power of resurrection — that is entirely neglected by the narrative as soon as it fulfills its immediate function. The overall plot feels like a bunch of characters shrugging their shoulders and saying “well, this happened,” and I honestly forgot about Midnight entirely for a good chunk of the storyline. Overall, it reads like a mishmash of odd ideas that just never gel.

I suppose one take is:
'Midnight Sparkle only uses her powers to make her favorite ship's ponies kiss.'
:trollestia:

"And you know what else?" the monster said. "After you killed your best chance of ever finding a girlfriend...you'll be alone forever. Even CATS won't love you."

"Noooo!" Twilight moaned. "Not even cats? Wait, what about Spike?"

establishing the crackfic personalities early

"Just use Hoofle Maps, and search for 'morgue.'"

terrible pun, so probably what it actually is in the EqG world inexplicably

"I'm ALWAYS right. Now let's go inside."

oh hey that’s what the voice in my head always says to me too!

"Don't give up yet!" the voice whispered. "Remember that story from when you were a child. When Snow White lay in a glass coffin, and nopon--I mean, NO ONE could rouse her. Or so it SEEMED."

Twilight narrowed her eyes at the dead body, puckered her lips, and leaned forward.

very cool and normal

"So we're free?" Twilight's eyes brightened with hope. "We aren't grave robbers because it turns out there wasn't any grave to rob! Yay!" She waved one arm in the air. "I'm so glad we aren't criminals!"

well that resolved easily!

- Firearms over .50 caliber. I wanted to ban ALL firearms, but when I had an emergency meeting with the school board yesterday evening, this was the best compromise I could get."

commentary

"You're...creepy. Lust isn't love."

having the character in the story point out that it’s going in an unsavory direction but then doing it anyway is certainly a choice

Twilight added, "To quote Ox Gusty of Hippo: 'O Harmony...please help me to control my own body, to be seemly and proper...but not yet. PLEASE not yet!'"

it does work a bit too well for the ponification that Augustine was from Hippo

"You are the MOST sexy pony. Just looking at your pony form drives me wild."

you see, this is normally something i would love to read in a story but it’s like a weird twisted version of it that vacates it of the good things i like


birb i don’t want to discourage you from doing the thing where you take contest theme and fulfill them to letter but not the spirit in a way that makes a mockery of the theme itself, because weird birb ideas are fun and what writing is for. but i feel like the treatment of suicide here is in a weird spot where i assume it’s going for absurdist humor but it doesn't go absurdist enough so it just feels disrespectful. besides that, thanks for writing

Twilight took a deep breath. "Sunset, meet my brother Shining Armor. He's a Canter County sheriff's deputy. And Shining, this is my new girlfriend, Sunset Shimmer. She died yesterday afternoon...but just a few minutes ago she got better."

Oh dear, what did Shining even react?–

As students murmured and wondered, Princess Celestia walked out onto the stage. "Welcome, everyone!" She smiled and waved. "I have very good news. The rumors of a fellow CHS student's death have been greatly exaggerated."

WAIT- PRINCESS CELESTIA?

"I'm doing ok too," Twilight added. "Just in case anyone was wondering. Also, as you might already have heard yesterday, Sunset isn't really Anon-A-Miss after all! Anon-A-Miss was just a big hoax by people who were jealous of her. And I went on a date with Sunset last night, kind of, and I think now we're girlfriends!"

I NEVER EXPECTED THIS TO BE COMEDY OMG

"I'm just saying...this place has a real gift for insane crises followed by last minute happy endings."

He's.. he's not wrong..

11816551

As students murmured and wondered, Princess Celestia walked out onto the stage. "Welcome, everyone!" She smiled and waved. "I have very good news. The rumors of a fellow CHS student's death have been greatly exaggerated."

WAIT- PRINCESS CELESTIA?

I just want to say I think it's interesting that this story can go through not one but TWO contests, have hundreds of views on both chapters, receive several comments, some in considerable detail...
and somehow, YOU, MONTHS LATER, are the first person to catch this and point it out.

Anyway, thank you for this help improving my story! (I fixed it now.)
:twilightsmile:

Midnight lowered a claw-tipped hand, and she almost, but NOT quite, touched Sunset's fire colored hair. "How can you let this one girl, a girl who I KNOW you love, slip away from you? You SAW how she was looking at those pictures today. You know what she wants...and you are NOT it." The demonic looking form slowly licked her lips. "But we could give it to her. By letting her have what she wants...we could truly possess her. We could make her ours forever!"

I AGREE, MIDNIGHT. I, FRICKING, AGREE. 😭😭 (SUNSET SHIMMER, DON'T YOU CHEAT ON YOUR ADORKABLE GIRLFRIEND OR SO HELP ME–)

Somewhere, deep inside Twilight's inner essence, a shadowy form cackled with glee. "Yes! There's NOTHING better than making the horses kiss!"

OMG YES.


(This actually makes me feel kinda sad. Sunzet doesn't love Twilight for her, she just loves her as a pony :{)

Login or register to comment