at this point gerry deserves a win and celetia needs to be kept an eye on so she doent mess with any more future humans but the question is would gerry be willing to fill that role for the rest of time as celetia heraself has shown she is less then moral in her dealings.

I do hope Garry finds happiness

Yeah, that's basically the only thing she could have said and not looked like a monster. I mean it doesn't make anything better, but her admitting fault at least puts her on the first step to redemption.

Although the rest of it sounds like complete garbage, all it says it she deliberately hurt someone with Dark Magic and claimed it was a good thing. She really can't be trusted in anything related to humans at this point.

Well... gee, Celestia, I guess when you put it that way...

Eat shit and die.

Awesome chapter, truly. I'm pulling for ya, Gerry. You'll make it out of this, I hope.

If you live as long as Celestia, one would be afraid of losing many things... I can understand her, though that doesn't necessarily mean I agree with her.

It's a hard call to make and from I gather, Celestia's tried the 'let them be' method only for the human in question to... be overcome?

So she tries the 'make them a pony' and it has a few issues, but the end result ensures that Gerry won't be 'forever different'.

I understand why, and agree that she should have asked, but I don't know if Twilight and Gerry really thought through the ramifications of Gerry remaining human.

I like this story, but I think Gerry's gearing up learn what he's gained as a pony and lost as a human.

10316169
Its more than a few issues, it is psychological damaging to Gerry and was done without his permission by Celestia who during it was acting in a manner that says she is uncaring or hostile. Plus the fact that Gerry as a pony does not have a Cutie Mark of his own is frankly an abominable act for Celestia to commit. Consider what happens when a pony cannot live up to their Cutie Mark, has it switched for someone else's, or they lose it. That is what Celestia is subjecting him to, perhaps permanently.

At this point we only have the word of the one who deliberately hurt Gerry to go on, and they have been little help in fixing him so unless Celestia herself fixes what she has done without caveats she has no credibility.

10316169
The issue she didn't give Twilight a chance to send him home and making him aware. Yeah she hasn't earned forgiveness

Great introspection in the last bit of this chapter. Gerry never forgave Celestia but he didn't lose it with her either. He knew she was sorry and wants to help fix the problem she created as she genuinely thought what she was doing him a favor to better fit in, in her land. Yes Gerry is mad and rightly so but he IS willing to let her help him regain some normalcy in his life. Though i hope when they try and fix him they do but then Gerry suddenly feels wrong even if he is in the right body and gender, but keeps it to himself. But over time he starts feeling helpless because he can't help the Apples like he used to, he realises even in when in his correct body and gender he is still developing feelings for Big Mac, and having horrible dreams about him fighting his female self "Toffee" for control of his body and gender. Then eventually wanting to be Toffee in mind and body thus redoing the spell to make him a her and finally pursuing the happiness Celestia tried to give him and he gets his happy ending with a foal and a great stallion like Big Mac. Also Celestia should be forced to be a male for a few monthes to learn what it actually means to develop gender dysphoria and have to live with it for a month after to hammer into her mind not to pull the same stunt again unless expressly asked for. I look forward to your next chapter

10316169
Most in his situation would take their own life within a year. Besides I'd rather be different from everyone else than different from what I perceive as myself. Most importantly though is the fact that it was not Celestia's choice to make, not that that's ever stopped her from manipulating everyone around her.

10316818
Is this a spoiler? Cause I can't tell if this is a spoiler or a theory.