Well, the Nightmare Forces kidnapped Rarity, they broke her, and then were going to possess her right? What if Rarity absorbed them instead? She's still a powerful Nightmare, she looks even more beautiful than she did as a flesh and blood pony, and she just wants to give gifts, spread generosity, and help Equestria's ponies. But first she needs to convince everypony she's not just pretending to be Rarity and isn't evil incarnate. She's convinced Spike . . . now how does she convince the rest of the world?

The Benevolent Reign Of Queen Nightmare Rarity
STORY BY Alex Warlorn and trooper924
Inspired by and SUBVERSION of the Nightmare Arc of the My Little Pony comics.
And fanart by Hellbeholder, used with permission. http://hellbeholder.deviantart.com/art/Nightmare-Rarity-and-her-Spike-404955331

This started out as a simple RP in the comments section inspired by the art seen here.

This story has ZILCH to do with the Pony POV Series universe.

MLP FiM Copyright Hasbro

Nightmare Rarity lives on the moon. Until she learns how to behave, she will remain there, as ordained by her closest friends. Thankfully, she wasn't left alone, as they assigned Anon to watch over her progress and report back when she starts showing signs of improvement.

Rarity took this as his way of expressing his undying love and affection, something the lonely villainess is happy to return in kind.

He doesn't dislike it.

Rating for particularly passionate kissing/suggestive themes/innuendo.

Day #3 of Hearts and Hands Week.

It has been three years since the nightmare forces unleashed their second attack upon Equestria and, as a result of a truce made between them and the princesses, they now have their own country ruled by Nightmarity, their queen. One day, Coco Pommel comes across Nightmarity in Manehattan. Expecting to be attacked, Nightmarity ends up--protecting her?

Cover art by Fluttershy750

This story is a sequel to My Little Mages: The Grand Gala

It is the day after the Grand Gala and while everything seems normal a foe that was once bested is ready to make her move.

Nightmare Moon, with the aid of Nightshade, now possesses Rarity has taken a new name, Nightmare Rarity and with the Tantabus torn between his loyalties, Luna must reach out to the rest of the Elements of Harmony bearers to stop Nightmare Rarity. However, the Princesse of the Moon has more secrets which might undermine her only hope.

Can Twilight and friends save Rarity? Can they unravel the truth? Or will Nightmare Rarity accomplish her goals and plunge the world into an everlasting night?

Cover art by ZantyARZ and used with permission.

This story is a sequel to My Nightmarish Heroine

After years of being under the Nightmare Forces' control, Rarity is just now struggling to pick up the pieces and to figure out just how much she has really done. With only shreds of her memories of Nightmarity remaining, coming to terms with her darkest self will be hard enough. But when somepony from her time under the nightmare returns, Rarity must decide for herself whether this past is one that deserves to be completely buried.

Image from IDW Comics.

The Nightmare Rarity debacle has left the Elements of Harmony defeated and only Spike remains.

Nightmare Rarity tries to convince Spike to Join her, only for the dragon to put up on offer of his own, all to save what is his.

This story has been edited by fellow FIMfiction.net author: Bico.

Midnight Sparkle and Nightmare Rarity face off in a battle of wills to decide the fate of two worlds.

When Nightmare Moon was trapped on the moon, she was feeling alone and had time to think about her actions that resulted in her being where she is now. She just didn't expect to find a mate, who, coincidentally, was also on the moon. And over time, Nightmare Rarity begins to develop feelings for Nightmare Moon.

Rarity has fused with the Nightmare force, and their bond cannot be broken. But to what lengths would Fluttershy go to reach the pony she loves? Sometimes it takes a monster to tame a monster...

Each chapter will be a different take on how Nightmare Rarity and Flutterbat first met.

Contains: implication of lesbian sex, corruption, mention of blood.

All characters are 18+

Special thanks to Rioku for the cover image! <3

This story is a sequel to Sunny at Midnight

Dating hasn't been particularly easy for the likes of Midnight Sparkle and Sunny Flare.

One was an almighty entity of magic created by Twilight after being overcharged by magic, who could easily destroy the fabric of reality.

The other was a Crystal Prep student with an attitude.

If that wasn't bad enough, they could only date during The Witching Hour, between 12 at midnight and 1 AM.

During one of these nights, Midnight realizes she can't keep doing this forever, so to try and fix this, she asks for help from the most unexpected sources: Carousel Boutique.

More specifically, her old bully, Nightmare Rarity.

Collab work with this wonderful guy: leeroy_glBZ