As the Diamond City of Canterlot celebrates the onset of winter and the defeat of the shadowkin, Astra Princess Twilight Sparkle must find a way to define her relationship with Lady Rarity. Assuming Rarity can stop flirting with her for five seconds.
Twilight Sparkle and Pinkie Pie are going out. On a Trip to Canterlot high Twilight realizes that having two Pinkies is a lot weirder when you're dating one of them. But what is the reason she is dating one but not the other? what separates them?
Upon the defeat of Tirek, Pinkie Pie comes into terms rather quickly towards her feelings for Twilight Sparkle, but does Twilight feel the same way towards Pinkie?
This story takes place in Ponyville, with Twilight and Pinkie. They both have trouble with their feelings for each other so they go to their friends Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy for help. They also bake cupcakes while Pinkie tries to impress Twilight.
When Pinkie Pie is done making everypony smile for the day, what does she go back to? A lonely room full of overly bright party decorations to keep her smiling. But what happens when the brightness can't cheer her up anymore? Who will make her smile?