On a dark night filled with even darker magics, an insane cult attempts to resurrect Nightmare Moon and blah blah blah, except omg it's really just a cute little filly, wowee what a twist.
Now, a little black alicorn with a cool racing stripe in her mane named Pyx (100% original character) finds herself living under the care of a perennially drunk librarian with OCD who really, really wants a foal. Is Pyx Nightmare Moon reborn, or is she simply a terrible OC? Will Twilight Sparkle eventually sober up and let her out of the basement, or is she stuck there forever? Will annoying cameos be given to a bunch of obscure background ponies from early seasons whose existences you've probably long-since forgotten? Or will these roles simply be filled by more terrible OCs?
Or, will Pyx suddenly turn into Nightmare Moon for some reason, and do a bunch of evil stuff for some other reason, and then maybe get redeemed for some third reason? All of these questions and more will be answered. Probably.
This gigantic shitpost exists because I needed something to do for NaNoWriMo 2022, but ran into immediate writer's block in the original project I had planned on doing. Instead of giving up, I decided to do something fun and silly.
This started out as a fairly straightforward satire of Past Sins, and then slowly morphed into kind of a weird dark comedy. The plot loosely follows that of the original story, but many creative liberties were taken, and it can probably be read as a more or less original work. None of Pen Stroke's OCs appear in this story.
Edit 3/30/2025:
I originally had this story rated Mature, but after coming back and rereading it I decided to downgrade it to Teen. There is a small amount of comically-exaggerated violence in here, but I don't think it's really enough to justify an M rating.
As much as it pains me to thank anyone on Reddit for anything, I'd like to thank Reddit user DropTheTubbs for the "Wimpy Kid" fonts used in the cover art. Also, thanks to DeviantArt user AibotNya for the original illustration of disguised Nyx, which I traced (badly). Also thanks to the following artists whose work I borrowed for the cover: Dipi11, xRainbowSugar, smlahyee, vapor-tea, linkitch, oelderoth, mariobros64.
I did not bother to obtain anyone's permission to use any of these things because that's just how I roll, but I thank their original creators nonetheless. If you see your work in here and you would prefer it not to be in here, let me know and I'll remove it.
Last but not least, thanks in advance to Pen Stroke, who I can only assume will have little choice but to be a good sport about all of this.