The fifth installment of a What If series, that involves the rewriting of episodes. But this collection contains only ten episodes from Seasons 1, and 4-6 (Warning!: Episodes rewritten based on personal opinion, please respect it. Thank you.).
(Sequel to Birthday Built For Two.) Pinkie Pie decides the time has come to introduce her special somepony, Cheese Sandwich, to her big sister Maud. But Cheese worries about whether Maud will approve of him and Pinkie being together.
A new PInball Machine has arrived at Sugarcube Corner and Pinkie being her hyperactive self just had to have a go at it. What madness will ensue? What treasure will be found? More importantly, can Pinkie beat Sweetie Belle’s high score?
Cheese Sandwich returns to Ponyville to plan a party for Pinkie Pie's birthday. But Pinkie suspects Cheese has another reason for coming back on short notice, and why does he seem to be acting so weird around her?
Rainbow Dash loses her temper and yells at Pinkie Pie, driving the talkative party pony to make a drastic promise. Now, it falls to Rainbow Dash to fix the mess she's made, lest Pinkie lose a vital part of herself forever...
Sweetie Belle is a normal filly, at least she thinks so. But even among her fellow Cutie Mark Crusaders, she had always been different. Maybe it was some slight bouts of immature behavior or taking after her older sister.
After their argument with Fluttershy, Rarity and Pinkie return to Sugarcube Corner in tears. Are they really following pointless pursuits? Rarity decides to stay the night. If they are to be frivolous ponies, can they be frivolous together?
Pinkie has a secret. So far, she's kept it from everyone, but Twilight can tell that something's wrong with her. So she offers what vague support she can… until Pinkie takes her into the basement to show her.
Like, at all. Unfortunately, she has to get her immunizations to continue working at Sugarcube Corner. With the help of a friend, she might just make it through.
When the fair comes to Ponyville, Twilight agrees to go with Pinkie Pie. She sees it as the perfect opportunity to express her feelings for the pink mare… but how will Pinkie respond?
When Pinkie falls ill, Rarity takes her place as a foalsitter for The Cake Twins, and they take a real shine her to. This makes Pinkie feel like she's been replaced, and it's up Mr. and Mrs. Cake to show her that's not true.