• Member Since 29th Sep, 2012
  • offline last seen Jan 2nd, 2022

Pony-Berserker


E

Fluttershy asks Twilight to check out a weird orange flower she saw. Unfortunately, the flower turns out to be dangerous and Twilight becomes paralyzed. What are her friends going to do? Will they be able to help her?

Chapters (1)
Comments ( 14 )

Feedback is appreciated.

why is twilight a bad librarian?

1392400 Because AJ couldn't find the book in the catalogues. :ajsmug:

AJ is actually right. The only pony that can ever find a book in Twilight's library is Pinkie. :pinkiehappy:
Admittedly .. sometimes they land on her face ... :heart:

“Whaaa.... – Twilight shouted when the flower puffed in her face.”

Should be "Whaaa..." Twilight shouted when the flower puffed in her face. Everything in the " marks is what the characters say.

“Twilight!? – Spike turned around terrified.”

Same problem as the above.

“Aa.a..aaaaa”

Firstly, it should have a full stop or something on the end. Secondly, three full stops in a row (...) means a trail off, one means the end of a sentence. There is no two (..).

Ponyville.Worried

Missing space.

“My dear. What has happened to her!?” Rarity shouted running out of her boutique.

This is an example of correct dialogue. However, I would change the end to Rarity shouted as she ran out of her boutique.

“Could..

Either use one full stop or three.

“Can I have a go after her??

Unneeded ?

Hihihi... You have a funny face Twilie. I also can do squint eyes . I train it every day. Look!” she said and started doing squinty eyes until she bumped into a wall.

1. I think you mean Hahaha. 2. I can also squint my eyes.

“Don’t feel guilty, sugarcube. Who could’ve known that dangerous flowers could grown so far away from Everfree Forest,” Applejack tried to comfort her.

You're looking for grow.

“I Personally believe that Zecora would do a better job here,” Rarity interjected without much hope that anyone would take her suggestion into consideration.

Personally shouldn't be capitalised.

“I wanted you to treat her... somehow
“Oh, certainly. But I can’t.”

1. Somehow should have a full stop after it. 2. The doctor says certainly, as in he will treat her, but then says he can't. This doesn't make sense. How about: "I'm sorry, but I can't."

“Well then, I can’t help here. I will send you a bill later

Needs a full stop.

“I will reply: But the doctor said that this involves MAGIC

Full stop.

Believe me, the newas about

Typo here. I think you meant news.

“Where’s Rarity.”

Should have a question mark.

“Ha, ha, ha.

The commas aren't needed. A comma represents a pause, or breaks up a sentence. What's happening there is Ha (pause) ha (pause) ha., when it should just be Ha ha ha.

“Uhm... Twilight isn’t doing a very good job as a librarian, is she? Pinkie was wondering.

Missing "

“So???

Only one question mark is needed.

“Phi!”

Not necesarily wrong, but I've never heard that before.

“No offense but you are a bad librarian.”

Should have a comma after offense.

1399675
You're very welcome.

Pacing was a bit fast at the beginning.

1500077

Looks like it's a common problem in my stories. :pinkiesad2:

Bad Celestia! I'm glad they didn't write you a letter. :ajbemused:
Letting her die like that, without even visiting, you deserve to think she's dead. :applecry:
Not as funny as your other work, but still a good read, hmmm, I'm not good at comments... :fluttercry:

1821746

Not as funny as your other work

It's my first fan-fic after all. No wonder it's not the best :twilightsheepish:

1824803
Don't get me wrong:fluttershysad:, it was still funny:pinkiesmile:, and being your first fan-fic it makes sense that you would get better, lol. :rainbowderp:
I'll probably be reading them in order from this point, so they'll only get better. :pinkiehappy:

The pacing is bit too fast. I notice that it's mostly rapid-fire dialogue. Not the worst thing, but it would help if you let some of the scenes breathe. Describe the place where Twilight finds the strange flower. Let some of the tension build instead of jumping from one moment to the next.

But other than that, the dialogue is pretty sharp and hilarious at times. Just needs more time. :raritywink:

Login or register to comment