• Member Since 1st Mar, 2016
  • offline last seen Yesterday

Dreadnought


There is nothing as liberating, or terrifying, as a blank page.

E
Source

Applejack and Maud may be like oil and water. But they'll have to work together to solve this friendship problem.

Originally written for Everfree Northwest's Iron Author competition.

Chapters (1)
Comments ( 4 )

great story mate keep it up cant wait for the next story:pinkiehappy::twilightsmile:

11770469
Thanks for the feedback. I plan on publishing an EQG story next week. Check back soon!

Dreadnought

Well, you had a nice premise, if nothing else. Applejack and Maud solving a friendship problem is a good comedic setup, although I felt the execution was a bit poor. Firstly, the whole thing was much too fast-paced, with little time for character interactions or comedy. I understand that you had a time limit while writing this, but this story might have been too big to do justice in such a short time. I also think that the plot point about the islanders' ancestry was very odd, going against what we know about ponies, which made the conflict feel a bit contrived. All in all, I think this story really needed some more time and attention to make it solid.

11773797
Thank you for the feedback. I completely agree that more development was warranted. I really wanted to flesh this story out. However, two hours can be very short, especially under pressure. I've been known to spend an hour writing and re-writing half a page. I did realize when writing it that it was a bit ambitious for the allotted time, but it was the only premise that I could come up with.
Please check back next year for some stories that did not lack for time and editing.

In regards to the ancestry, I thought that was quite an interesting idea, as did the judging panel. I would like to explore the concept in a future story if inspiration strikes.

Login or register to comment