Rainbow Dash wants to take her marefriend Fluttershy out to a nice meal on Hearths Warming Eve, she'd got something important she wants to tell her. If only she can get up the nerve to get the words out.
(Sequel to Birthday Built For Two.) Pinkie Pie decides the time has come to introduce her special somepony, Cheese Sandwich, to her big sister Maud. But Cheese worries about whether Maud will approve of him and Pinkie being together.
Cheese Sandwich returns to Ponyville to plan a party for Pinkie Pie's birthday. But Pinkie suspects Cheese has another reason for coming back on short notice, and why does he seem to be acting so weird around her?