knighty 4,210 followers

knighty is the creator and lead developer of Fimfiction. It's probably best if most requests for help go to other staff members

News Archive

  • 4 weeks
    S7E24 - Uncommon Bond

    Synopsis

    When Starlight gets a visit from Sunburst, she discovers that he has tons in common with her friends and starts to wonder if he still has anything in common with her.

    Reminder: Links to download episodes are not allowed!

    178 comments · 8,277 views
  • 5 weeks
    S7E23 - Secrets and Pies

    Synopsis

    When Pinkie Pie thinks she sees Rainbow Dash throw away one of her pies, she suspects the worst. Pinkie Pie attempts to catch Rainbow Dash in her web of lies…using pies.

    Reminder: Links to download episodes are not allowed!

    97 comments · 9,458 views
  • 6 weeks
    S7E22 - Once Upon a Zeppelin

    Synopsis

    Twilight is torn when she discovers the cruise she and her family are on is actually a themed vacation experience in which ponies have paid for the privilege of spending time with her. Will she be able to please both her family and the cruise attendees?

    Reminder: Links to download episodes are not allowed!

    209 comments · 7,846 views
  • 7 weeks
    S7E21 - Marks and Recreation

    Synopsis

    The Cutie Mark Crusaders start a Cutie Mark Day Camp only to find out that one of their campers doesn't want a cutie mark.

    130 comments · 8,329 views
  • 8 weeks
    S7E20 - A Health of Information

    Synopsis

    While helping Fluttershy gather supplies in a swamp, Zecora contracts a rare and terrible disease called Swamp Fever that threatens to eventually turn her into a tree, for which no cure is known.

    100 comments · 9,883 views
  • 8 weeks
    S7E19 - It Isn't the Mane Thing About You

    Synopsis

    (Having a hard time finding one for this episode)

    Apologies for the mega late post, I've been in Spain the past week.

    73 comments · 7,749 views
  • 10 weeks
    S7E18 - Daring Done

    Synopsis

    Rainbow Dash is distressed when she and Pinkie Pie discover that A.K. Yearling has announced her retirement from writing the Daring Do book series, thus ending her adventures as the titular hero.

    100 comments · 10,038 views
  • 11 weeks
    S7E17 - To Change a Changeling

    Synopsis

    Starlight Glimmer and Trixie visit Thorax at the changeling hive and meet his brother, the only changeling still unwilling to share love and transform.

    mfw looking through the trixie and glim tags on DB ordered by score

    162 comments · 11,611 views
  • 12 weeks
    S7E16 - Campfire Tales

    Synopsis

    When their big sister/little sister camping trip is ruined by Fly-ders, Applejack, Rarity and Rainbow Dash tell Sweetie Belle, Apple Bloom, and Scootaloo the stories of their favorite legends. Inspired by the tales, the girls make the most out of their new situation.

    182 comments · 9,040 views
  • 13 weeks
    S7E15 - Triple Threat

    Synopsis

    Spike accidentally invites Ember and Thorax to Ponyville on the same day! Confident that the two new leaders will not get along, he does all he can to keep them apart and cover the fact that the other is there.

    284 comments · 10,206 views
Oct
28th
2017

Episode Discussion » S7E25-26 - Shadow Play · 3:03pm October 28th

Synopsis

When Sunburst discovers the lost journal of Starswirl the Bearded, Twilight becomes obsessed with saving her magical idol from a thousand year old prison.

Reminder: Links to download episodes are not allowed!

Report knighty · 7,210 views · #season 7 #s7e25 #s7e26 #shadow play
Comments ( 233 )
Nohate #1 · 3 weeks ago · · ·

Alright guys please don’t fight and let’s have a peaceful discussion.

Interesting how Stygian's story parallels Nightmare Moon's.

4710182 And ruin a brony tradition?

Hoops #4 · 3 weeks ago · · ·

I liked the episode. It was a cool adventure style ending, and it was built up well. I saw it when it was leaked, but I still watched it today. I give it a 9/10. I didn't love the soundtrack (or how weird some of the old ponies looked lol)

Maran #5 · 3 weeks ago · · ·

“It'd take a whole team of ponies to clear away all this brush.”

:looks ahead: Or one Rarity, apparently.

Me and a curator from the amino collaborated on an Analysis about a week ago on this

http://aminoapps.com/p/05mbhg

Maran #7 · 3 weeks ago · · ·

RIP Star Swirl headcanons.

Which characters did the writers assign the idiot ball to in this episode(s)?

Was there multiple idiot balls, or just one swapped around from character to character?

Bring on Season 8!

You know, so we can see if Flzzlepop Berrytwist makes an appearance.

So many potential fun spur-of-the-moment conversations and flame wars ruined by a leak.
Oh well. *shrug*

4710192
Now why in Equestria would we ruin it for you like that and not let you pick 'em out on your own? :trollestia:

SpitFlame #11 · 3 weeks ago · · 1 ·

This one comment from EqD sums up my thoughts on this two-parter perfectly:

FIM's canon is created and rounded on the fly, so it's a huge compliment when this episode is able to make it all look preplanned. This isn't a simple good-vs.-evil story at all. The entire conflict contains several side plots, but weaves them together so well that nothing falls out of place. Every line has spunk and purpose. Even though the stakes are high, the snappy dialogue and varied characterizations provide a boatload of well-done humour. To have the Elements of Harmony be the Pillars' heirs is a genius idea.

But what it does best is how it builds up the Pony of Shadows's backstory more and more, beginning with an excellent homage to the pilot's opening, treating Ponehenge as the Pillars' final resting place (a reference to the possible origins of Stonehenge), and not treating the PoS as some generic villain. Tying the whole plot into a friendship problem in Part 2 is the best plot twist of the series, because it brings Starlight into the conflict and humanizes the story even more.

Starlight has her best appearance to date: She shows off excellent detective skills, understands something was fishy with the entire conflict, and gets very emotional after Star Swirl casts Stygian off as irredeemable; it's my top moment of the second half. While other villain backstories are often isolated or rather short, SP doesn't leave theirs alone and expands it with each scene, deepening the conflict. When Stygian explains he felt like an outcast in the team for being so weak physically and magically, the story takes such a round turn, and goes back to Celestia's line from MMC: Star Swirl doesn't understand friendship. Starlight's whole arc (much higher quantitatively than S6 and better written by far than in S6) made it feel properly built up.

How Haber successfully balanced out fifteen characters (not including side ones and Stygian) in 44 minutes astounds me. SP gets better with every re-watch, and the conflict makes more sense each time you think about it. It's what To Where would be had it been written well. Best two-parter of the series.

Probably my second favorite finale, just behind Twilight's Kingdom.

This episode answered some questions I had with the show. That is awesome. What's not awesome is that it seemed for years that they never would answer them, and I had some stories planned that were going to answer them with my own headcanon. Those stories have now been comprehensively ripped to shreds. *sigh* It's still cool that they answered those questions, don't get me wrong. I guess I wish they'd answered them sooner, so I wouldn't have sunk so much planning into fics that will never see the light of day.

daniboyi #13 · 3 weeks ago · · 1 ·

4710192
I personally feel Twilight got the idiot ball the most.

But that is just personal opinion really.

The real moral of this finale is that if Starlight Glimmer, the Queen of Bad Ideas, tells you your idea isn't great, you should probably listen to her.

I've been having this conversation with a friend since the leak. This season has been the best by far in terms of lore, which built everything up properly over the course of the season, even if it was mainly over 4 episodes. It also tied in Castle Mane-ia's mention of the PoS (I don't really want to use that acronym, but eh) in season 4, which Josh Haber wrote. This either could have actually been pre-planned, but I'm pretty sure Haber just used it as an opportunity to tie up his plot line.

Overall, I loved this finale.

Nohate #16 · 3 weeks ago · · ·

So far it seems pretty peaceful good. Alright now back on topic. This was easily my favorite season and finale for MLP. Not only did they tie the side Legends together into the finale they even foreshadowed the fate of the Pillars of Equestria in MLP FIM #58 when they said Meadowbrook suddenly vanished. They also managed foreshadowed Starswirl’s book all the way from the end of MLP FIM #53 From the Shadows where we saw the Pony of Shadows for the first time. Not to mention now the reason Shadowlock was erasing the history books in that arc makes sense. He was trying to erase Starswirl’s book so somepony like Twilight won’t accidentally release the Pony of Shadows. Also a bonus that they incorporated the Sirens into both the comics and the show.

4710210
Starlight Glimmer, the Alicorn of ISLAGIATT :scootangel:

4710218

ISLAGIATT

...Please elaborate.

I liked this finale a lot, more than the season 5 finale, and more consistently than the season 6 finale. I love To Where and Back Again Part 1 more than either part of Shadow Play, but I dislike part 2.

Shadow Play got a lot done without feeling rushed. It set up elements of not only Princess Twilight Sparkle, but even the series premiere. I was bothered when Princess Twilight Sparkle, the only two parter I don't like, dropped the Tree of Harmony on us without much explanation, so having that now is satisfying. Plus, we got an explanation for the Elements of Harmony, and got to see Starswirl in pony, and they still made time for a good character story! Shadow Play is really good on its own, but also importantly for a finale, it benefits the series as a whole, providing some explanations while opening up new doors with Starswirl and the legendary crew.

Now for some nice nerdy numbers. I've got the season ranked from favorite to least favorite episode with a number score for each. If I give above a 5, I liked the episode and below a 5 is dislike. If these numbers look low to you, they're not. I loved this season, I just don't score as high as a lot of people.

1. Fluttershy Leans In - 9.5
2. Discordant Harmony - 9
3. Shadow Play Part 2 - 8.5
4. Fame and Misfortune - 8.5
5. A Royal Problem - 8.5
6. Campire Tales - 8
7. Marks and Recreation - 8
8. Shadow Play Part 1 - 7.5
9. Parental Glideance - 7.5
10. The Perfect Pair - 7.5
11. A Health of Information - 7.5
12. Rock Solid Friendship - 7
13. Honest Apple - 7
14. Uncommon Bond - 7
15. Celestial Advice - 7
16. It Isn't the Mane Thing About You - 6.5
17. Hard to Say Anything - 6.5
18. Forever Filly - 6
19. Daring Done - 6
20. Triple Threat - 6
21. Al Bottled Up - 5.5
22. To Change a Changeling - 5
23. Not Asking For Trouble - 4.5
24. Once Upon a Zeppelin - 4.5
25. Secrets and Pies - 3
26. A Flurry of Emotions - 1.5
Overall, I give this season a high 9, which could move up to a 9.5 with some rewatching. It's my favorite season since season one. Wonderful consistency, only disliked 4 episodes. Fluttershy Leans In is my favorite episode since Pinkie Pride.

One last note, this was the season where I decided FiM is my favorite show of all time, which is a bigger deal for me than it would be for some, as The Simspons and Digimon are also two of the best things that have ever happened to me.

Dun dun dunnnnnnnnn

As if nobody saw that coming.

4710222
Man, this is a weird ranking. Fluttershy Leans in 9.5?!

It's a good episode.

But what's really disappointing is that the show's main villains are mostly Unicorns. It would be really cool if there's an Earth Pony or a Pegasus villain with magical powers.

Oh yeah, and Equestria really needs to upgrade their military (or self defense force) and stop being a doormat.

4710226
I have weird taste most seasons, except maybe seasons 3 and 4.

I loved Fluttershy Leans In. I saw it as a perfect exclamation point at the end of her character arc, or what felt like the end at the time, considering A Health of Information impressively managed to find a new angle. She was the right balance of kind and assertive. I also like how little conflict there is. It's the closest the series has gotten to a no conflict episode, a concept I've been interested in for years. It such a serene, down to earth, gently paced, innocent quality, much like season one, only maybe more so. I cared about Fluttershy's vision, and I cared when she told her friends how much they helped her evolve, because it rung so true. I especially loved the little montage at the end. It reminded of the one at the end of Winter Wrap Up, which was one of my favorite moments of the series.

When I look at Fluttershy's problems with learning to be assertive as a multi season conflict, Fluttershy Leans In feels like the happy resolution. I know it's one of the least popular season 7 episodes, but I also loved Party Pooped and 28 Pranks Later, so I have a history of odd taste.

OH SHIT! MOVIE TIE-IN! :pinkiegasp:

"Seapony etiquette isn't going to help, Spike!"

Didn't notice that the first time! And it's been confirmed that the movie is supposed to take place between seasons 7 and 8, so I'm pretty sure that was intentional.

4710227
I know, right? The major unicorn villains are pretty much the only holdover that supports the faulty "unicorn supremacist" meme. The show does have a few minor earth pony and pegasus antagonists, but none with powerful magic. Maud Pie is powerful, however, and I think she has potential to be corrupted by the Alicorn Amulet or something similar, given her line in "Rock Solid Friendship." "With the right stone, you could rule all of Equestria if you wanted to." Why couldn't Maud rule all of Equestria instead? And imagine the drama if Pinkie is forced to fight her own sister!

As for a major pegasus villain, it would have to be an entirely new character, maybe somepony mucking with the weather, creating hurricanes and floods and other natural disasters.

I never imagined that Staswirl the Bearded would be a Knight Templar though considering the Sirens story from Fiendship is Magic, I should have seen it coming.

Raugos #27 · 3 weeks ago · · 1 ·

4710227 Horns are the number one causes and solutions of all problems in Equestria. :trollestia:

Something I noticed and thought was cool, although it might be a coincidence, is how Twilights actions when saving Stygian from the shadows coincide with her special her magical talent as stated in the show bible: "Casts light in the darkness, to illuminate, lights the way"

Well, I was surprised. Great tie in with previous episode. But Man!! Twilight was making some cute and hilarious facial expressions!! I did get upset that Starswirl was rude to Twilight though. I hope that Chrysalis gets reformed in season 8, and that there are a few more seasons to go.

Everyone’s still gushing over the episode that they’ve forgotten that Equestria Girls IS canon with FIM now...

4710244
Not just EQG but some of the comics and some of the chapter books as well. This is the ultimate tie in season.

4710247
I know.

Surely, this finale will have the biggest impact on the show since Twilight got her wings back in Season 3...

I know that everyone is truly showing that friendship is INDEED magic...but honestly when I saw this, I really see a lot of potential parallels between Syrigan and Spike.

Take a closer look at it, and think about it if you have time. I have to go to work, so for now that is all I really can say about it...:twilightsmile:

4710186
4710202
4710214
4710216

Yeah, I agree with this 100%. This finale is by far one of the more well-balenced ones in my opinion, all of the mane six got to play their part, the show expanded upon the lore of Equestria, Starlight got her own role that didn't feel forced or OOC, we got to see the Legends in the flesh, and we finally got an origin for the Elements of Harmony!

Now I know a few fans are going to state that this messes up the established timeline for what happened1000 years ago, but I think i have the perfect way to tie it all together.

4710222
Hmmm... nice list.

4710238
It makes sense, Celestia said he didn't quite understand friendship the way Twilight did. Plus there's the fact that he came from a much harsher time for Equestria as opposed to what it has developed into.

On another note Legends of magic Issue 6 has rendered that issue of Fiendship is Magic non-canon.

4710190
Meh, good 95.5% of them claimed that he was Discord the entire time.

4710192
None really. Everyone was in-character.

4710193
Considering there was that little nod towards the movie mentioning Seaponies, I hope so!

4710204
There are always ways to work around certain canonical factors in the show. Word of advice: the flexible your head-canons are, the more fun you can have adapting the canon material to them!

4710237

I think unicorns are used more because it's easier for them to go mad with power. I mean, have you ever tried going mad without power? It's boring, no-one listens to you.

4710244
Oh, no-one has forgotten. In fact, I've been holding on to this for a while:
derpicdn.net/img/view/2017/10/8/1555325__safe_artist-colon-jdmiles_screencap_adagio+dazzle_aria+blaze_somnambula_sonata+dusk_star+swirl+the+bearded_equestria+girls_rainbow+rocks_shado.png

Nohate #35 · 3 weeks ago · · 4 ·

4710250
Right now I hope they make some of FIENDship is Magic canon as well. I really want to see reformed King Sombra, Radiant Hope, and Shadowlock on the show. They also have perfect jobs for the new Friendship school in Season 8.

King Sombra can be the security guard for the school since he can nullify magic.
Radiant Hope can be the nurse or healer since her healing talent is so powerful she can literally recreate entire bodies for a Pony.
Shadowlock can be a history chaperone since he can literally send ponies into old hisotry where they can experience what happened in the past themselves.

Not to mention all the interaction they can have.

4710233
That line made me wonder if there are seaponies that aren't transformed hippogriffs.

4710262
Not a bad idea... but at the moment only the Legends of Magic comics are directly canon to the series. That's why they made them a separate comic series instead of just having it take place in the main comic lineup. As I see it: anything outside of the show is only "semi-canon" until the show fully acknowledges it.

4710267
They have made MLP FIM Issue #51 and on canon with all the foreshadowing so there is a possibility they can make some of the other comics canon as well. Although some people might not be happy if that happens.

Raugos #40 · 3 weeks ago · · ·

This one's a pretty tightly-knit story that hits all the right notes for me. Fun interactions between all of the characters, world-building, and the resolution of a thousand-year-old friendship problem, all with what feels like relatively minimal contrivance.

It's a little odd that they didn't enlist the help of the princesses before going after the Pony of Shadows, but, eh, I'll take that over them somehow getting captured or incapacitated.

All in all, a good way to end the season.

4710220
ISLAGIATT (aka ISLAGATT) =
It Seemed Like A Good Idea At The Time

4710273
THANK YOU.

That was one of the only things that bothered me about this finale. This was almost a complete parallel with Nightmare Moon, and they didn't think to call in Luna for help? She would have been the BEST one to consult.

I mean yes, save the world now, reunion later, but seriously. This would have covered both.

4710277
Ha! I like, I like.

4710266
It would not surprise me in the slightest if they were introduced in Season 8.

4710270
I'm not saying there isn't, after all they also had issue 59 tie in to "Secrets and Pies", I'm all for it. Like I said, I prefer to wait until the show directly acknowledges it as canon.

4710190 I like canon Starswirl, but it's another plotbuster having him loose in Equestria. Now everytime some crisis arises, the author has to answer, "Why doesn't Celestia handle it? Why doesn't Luna handle it? Why doesn't Discord handle it? Why doesn't Starswirl handle it?" We have too many super-powerful friendly non-protagonists on the loose for a show that routinely has the Mane 6 tackle existential threats to Equestria. All these episodes have to spend more and more time as the show progresses explaining why all the existing supers don't deal with the threat. Or else just pretend they don't exist, like this episode did.

4710273 4710278 Just another example of having too many supers. Obviously Twilight should have called in Celestia and Luna before putting the entire world at risk, but that would complicate the plot a lot, so the writers just gave her the idiot ball.

Some nice things about the episode, but MLP has yet to do a decent villain redemption, because they have trouble showing real villainy, or showing the kind of real-world ugliness that can make someone a villain, or doing a realistic psychological exploration of horrible things, or taking the time needed for that great amount of change in a pony. They should stop trying, and get back to friendship problems, which is what they're good at.

Genuinely the best season finale

I liked this finale a lot, I really did, but I feel these episodes more than any really highlight the show's need to adopt a serial format. Soooo much stuff was crammed into this finale that could've stood to be fleshed out more. More interactions between the Mane 6, their respective Pillars, Stygian, and the others would've gone a long way toward filling out the narrative and given the final confrontation with the PoS the weight it was trying to convey. Starlight rises up and becomes the voice of reason and understanding, ultimately using her past experience as a paradigm to show Starswirl that Stygian can be reasoned with. That's superb character development!

But everything rushed by so fast that I couldn't get absorbed into the story, as sound as it was. It's an issue that the show's had ever since MMC, but now it's come to a point where my interest is noticeably waning. I crave fleshed out narratives, is what I'm saying, and the show's denied it to me for longer than I think I can put up with. It's a subjective criticism, of course, but I don't feel like it's asking too much out of Hasbro to take the serial approach moving forward. Other children's shows have done it and been successful (Avatar, for example) as well as all the big, famous animes.

tl;dr The episode was good, but it should've been double or even triple the episode count.

4710288
Lol, when I was reading your post, I thought you were calling the Pony of Shadows something else!

Great analysis, by the way.

4710284 And it's only going to get more pronounced as the show goes on. At their rate of amassing new allies, they'll soon need a Thanos-level villain to pose a credible threat if everyone is available.

Or they could just worf everyone as usual. That takes far less effort. :unsuresweetie:

No Raisin #49 · 3 weeks ago · · 2 ·

The thing that bugs me here is that the entire conflict basically starts because Twilight has a death grip on the idiot ball. She spends days trying to find a way to set Starswirl and his friends free, and yet at no point does she even consider the possibility that doing so would also release the Pony of Shadows. It's like... the only reason why the PoS is imprisoned is Starswirl and his friends also being imprisoned, so if you freed one wouldn't that also free the other?

Of course it would!

But Twilight and her dumb ass didn't think that would happen, even though it's such an obvious example of cause-and-effect that even a kindergartner would be able to understand it. So yeah, that's basically how the conflict gets kicked off.

This special is a step up from both season 5 and 6's finales. There is a lot to like here, even if the overall package felt a bit messy.

Login or register to comment