• Member Since 22nd Oct, 2012
  • offline last seen 3 hours ago

MoonLily


Comments ( 58 )
Comment posted by Quiznak deleted Jun 8th, 2019

Sorry about the deleted comment.

I enjoyed this start of a new fic. Though it is hard to understand, it is quite confusing and long paragraphs don't help.:derpyderp2:
But overall it is a great start and I hope for more (as long as it is easier to read) :twilightsheepish:

9669027
Thanks, and it's alright. I was up working late last night. I was going to get up and rework this chapter

9669253
OK, as I said before, great start. But it is still hard to understand.

“Well I am happy” Twilight pulled herself from her arms before she bowed to Selene “Well get some sleep”

This line for example could be improved, if I understand it twilight invited Selene to stay. Twilight could say instead of "well I am happy", she could say great or something like that.

I'm sorry if I overstep in giving advice but I wanted to help.:twilightsheepish:

OK, it's good. I'll give you that. Nice introduction of the rest of the main six.

Ok, incorrect use of thy, it is only used when speaking; you, your, etc.

A lot of your sentences tend to be run-on for much of the story so far.

“I don’t know. I can”

"I don't know. I can..."

“Our magic is stored in our hearts. Unicorns do not exist as their horns are either damaged from outsides or broken from the caves and caverns most live in. Our bodies are used to the magic flow as we use it in our hooves except for guards and my family. we channel our magic through our tridents. Now that leads us to your question. That magic that flows around your body is constantly changing and adapting to the environment around you. it changes the way you breath depending on the water your in.” Selene was moving her hoof around Twilight’s body as she looked her in the eye.

Ooh, nice concept. Makes a lot of sense.

Hmm, the shipping is coming in fast...what are you using, a racer?

Anyways, great chapter, I do hope those few pointers help. I mean I'm not that much better at writing, but still I try my best.

Oh my, things are getting interesting.

As I said before, confusing. But, really great story!:pinkiehappy::pinkiecrazy:

Hrm...the plot thickens...erm...you know what I mean...

9748425
In this Equestira their are two rulers of the sea one rules over seaponies that live close to the shores and ruled my queen nova and then you have the merponies scared of the surface ponies and ruled by trion each owning a different power of the sea. Queen nova can change her forms at will yes Selene has that but her powers are still settling and will settle into the one where she can detect things and can read the currents

I hope you don't change your mind and abandon this story. Its very good and far too many good stories get abandoned.

9769258
No still working on the next chapter.

Nice chapter but I'm a bit confused did you remove and change this chapter because I thought she's was almost sold on the black markit

I did I wanted to bring that later when she was further from canterlot

Each chapter there is one thing that keeps irritating my brain. Most if not all "half"s should be replaced with "have"s.

9838930
I'm working g on that. I get confused on which one to use

So wait, if Selene is pregnant, and Selene also did Twilight (if I remember correctly), does that mean Twilight is also pregnant?

9877370
:pinkiehappy:

Twilight never taught her the spell. Everything she been using hasn't been real like

Blue blood is dead meat just miff off a entire Kingdom your princesses and discord as well as the most powerful unicorn in your Kingdom

No I need to see blueblood death please

Oh and great chapter thx for it

“Trust me” he smiled as he placed the different ingredients in front of him “What could go wrong”

Why did you ask that discord

HALT!

Ze Grammar Nazi Group has spotted a mistake!

=======•=======G=======•=======

Error Suggestion

The ocean was alive with creatures as the warm water was calmly flowing. A school of bright yellow tangs sawm[swam] around the coal following the current. As small Sea horses were going about their day. A few queen angelfish were present as another school of tuna sawm[swam] through.(1)

A pair of bright ice blue eyes were gazing down upon the shipwreck that lied on the bottom of the ocean. The ship was cracked in half most of it covered in the light tan sand as the other was sitting up tall covered in barnacles. White and blue fins beat slightly in the ocean current as it sent the merpony towards the shipwreck.

A long white and blue merpony with fins stretching out to her side as she came to the shipwreck.(2)

She lit up a small silver trident allowing her to see inside of the abounded ship. She moved her hooves along the waterlogged wood. Her dark blue mane was tied up in a bun as she stuck her head into a room looking for anything.

Outside of the ship, the fish had all swam away leaving the place calm and quiet. A predator laid in wait watching the merpony move through the empty ship.

The merpony let out a simple sigh as she found nothing of interest. She left the ship feeling down as she couldn’t bring anything new to her collection.

As soon as she exited the ship the predator from afar sawm[swam] as fast as they could towards her. The young merpony only had a second when she glanced up. She felt a pair of hooves pressing her up against the shipwreck. The merpony looked up and noticed she was being held to the ship by a large grey shark. She watched as the shark leaned it’s head down grinning towards the merpony.

(1)Paragraph bit too long, you should find a nice place and split it there. A wall of text is always hard to read.
(2)Perhaps you should revisit and overdo this part. Better describe the merpony.

“Daddy! Your[You are] home! How was the surface? Did you see anything?” she was swimming around him causing him to laugh patting her head.

“Yes, momma[.]” Selene sat up as she watched her mother tuck her in.

“Can I get a story?” she[She] glared up at her mother as she[who] nodded smiling towards her daughter.

I told my mother and she was not having any of it. My sister Solarium and Lararium[,]” Selene watched as she saw her mother giggle at the names[,] “they were not sure what to do. But my youngest told me to follow my heart. That night under her moon I jumped into the water and I never looked back[.]sheShe had a smile on her face as Selene let out a yawn.

=======•=======G=======•=======

10096919
Thanks for the recommendations ^_^

=======•=======G=======•=======

[ Twelve years later…

“No I am fine” she[fine." She] rolled the scroll on as she emptied her bags on the bed beside her. Her mother was used to this whenever she bought something new to join her collection.

Always capitalise after a quote and always end one with either dot or comma.

There are whole lot of errors like this. You can find them by using Control-Find and ' ” '

“Yep follow here and keep her safe” the shark nodded as the[they] raced to keep up with Selene. She was moving quietly as she noticed a large humming sound coming from above her. Glancing up she noticed a large ship slowly drifting over her causing her face to light up.

“A merpony? Thy hasn’t seen them since thou sister went away” The darker alicorn spoke up as she moved towards the bed.

I am not entirely sure what you wanted to say here but:

Thy = Your
Thou = You

“I was on my way to the surface. I only stopped on the ship because I never seen a[one] still floating. This ship is still floating and not sinking? ”she tilted her head causing Celestia to smile nodding at her.

“My aunts the Queens Solarium and Lararium are to rule the land. Mother always tells me stories about them. I just want to meet them. I also want to see what kind of life my mother use[used] to have” Selene looked up towards the unicorn as she reached her hoof out.

=======•=======G=======•=======

I hope she is okay

“You want to fight monster than fight me on my grounds” Star growled as her trident started to glow blinding everypony for a while. Once the light calmed down Selene was floating in the water her eyes closed. She had a golden scrolled words around her neck and her wrist. She was resting as her fins floated around her and the fish lazy saw around her mane while a few of them nestled into it.

Here we go

“Romance? What is that about?” Selene silently thought to herself as she picked up a book and started flipping through it.
“Her moans [...]

When you are reading something on the internet while only mildly listening to a mlp fanfic via text2speech that should have been about a merepony and was totally sfw for all it's 10 chapters so far and then wonder if you copied the wrong fic to the text2speech. I was just literally saying "Wait, whaaat?!" :rainbowlaugh:

“Yes, momma” Selene sat up as she watched her mother tuck her in.

One problem caught right off that bat, you can't have dialogue like this. You need a period, dash(in specific circumstances), or comma, or anything that ends the sentence. I do believe it was in the fimfiction writing guide.

Ah, yes here it is.

10096919
Phew, if small errors like that catches a grammar nazi, then I'm happy they haven't found my story:rainbowlaugh:

Edit:Just wanted to toss in a little bit but "You are," could also be said as "You're," it's just that I personally usually shorten it to "You're" whenever possible

How is the story going

11000792
good just finishing up the editing for the last half of the story

Your doing a great job

Is this story based off of the Disney movie?

Is there more to come, because the story is still marked incomplete?

11089983

11089497
No, this story is complete. I forgot to change the story. Been trying to catch things up. And no not really about the movie. I saw a lot of adaptations of sea ponies and if there are sea ponies then their half to be other types than the ones we saw in the movie.

You made a great story

11232642
Thanks, I am currently working on the other one. I had lost everything so I am starting with what I have now

I think the shipping is moving along a bit too fast, imho.
This is romance, not amazon same day delivery.

11385018
yeah looking back at it now I would change this up so much. Between this and my origin story I had ton of help with writing stories and where my characters needed to go. This was way before that when an Idea was an idea and was not executed correctly

11385018
However, I love the amazon comment,

Really nice story and I get the Amazon shipping comment, but think it is also a little down to the writing, while I really like the story, the amount of spelling/ grammatical errors, makes it a Little confusing at times, so have to read some of the sentence multiple times 😅

For have read story's where the shipping and delivery happened so fast that you didn't even know you had ordered it 😅

Since I have finished the other story and been thinking about it....this might just get a rewrite.

Login or register to comment