• Member Since 12th Feb, 2012
  • offline last seen Mar 12th, 2019

MyLittlePonyTales


Comments ( 29 )

AWWW YEA PERFECT SHIT JUST GOT REAL WOOT AMAZING I LOVED IT I CANT EXPRESS IT ANYMORE BECAUSE ITS JSUT OMFG

Must you copy Discordantly word for word?...

Really good! :rainbowkiss:

WOOOOOOOOOOOOT! NOW THE TRUTH IS KNOWN WE MUST BEGIN OUR REBELLION AGAINST CELESTIA! WE-
Oh, your highness! No, we weren't talking about you.... Rebellion? Don't be silly, I...
I'm going to the moon, aren't I? :fluttershysad:

:trollestia: Damn right biiiiitch.

I love it when someone is misunderstood for their looks and gets called a monster, but then because of that becomes a monster.

Stop calling this good... He didn't even write it...

???

220044 are you blind? sure he didn't make ALL of it but he made most of it

220119

Ripping off a video, using it's entire ideals to base your fic and copying it word for word in about half your story = NOT MAKING ANYTHING.

219980 Ah, the self fulfilling prophecy. There is no sweeter irony in the world

???

220128 you may think that...and i will not care

220148

I don't need to "think" anything. Solid proof: His fic.

219869 No he didn't just copy it from Discordantly, he took a concept and added more depth to it.There were a total of 7-10 sentences that were taken from Discordantly. In the comic I felt that Discord's emotions weren't shown as well as they could have been, and this provided that. I call this fic good because it is well written and displays emotion. There are a lot of fics that copy things from other places. You know, like all pony fan fics are based off of My Little Pony? Not all fics can be 100% thought up by the author, they have to get their idea from someplace most of the time. So maybe you should go have a lie down and think about what it means to be a brony. Because this, that you're doing? That isn't it.

220287

Stealing from someone else also isn't it. Maybe you should learn what it means, troll.

220520 He didn't steal. CrappyUbicorn never once said that he was going to make a fic of his comic. And let me tell you right now, putting people down about something that doesn't even matter, and then acting as if you're better than others ISN'T the brony way. Does love and tolerance mean nothing to you?

220618

How am I acting like I'm better?

220641Okay, maybe not that exactly, but the point is you're not perfect, so don't criticize others for their imperfections. Constructive criticism is fine, and generally sought after, but what you're doing is destructive criticism, completely denouncing the entire thing because of one tiny detail. If you want to rage at authors rage at people like me who put off writing for months, or gore-fic writers. Not people who don't deserve it.

220714

I'm not criticizing him for imperfections, any imperfections aren't his mistakes. They're the mistakes of the person who made Discordantly.

220739 But that guy didn't write this! The main story was from Discordantly, but the majority of it was made by this author. I suppose I would be stealing for putting one of Pinkie's songs into my fanfic, because I didn't write it, but the rest of the fic would be mine. This is the same. The premise of the story and some of the words in this are taken directly from Discordantly, yes, but that isn't stealing an idea, it is expanding on it.

219869 Well, it was inspired by/based on the picture linked in the discription. It's supposed to go along with it.

219980 Phantom of the Opera, anyone?

220128 Oh, could you point me to which video? Sorry if you actually meant picture.

220520
I wouldn't say that I stole anything. Heck, I even gave credit to the original.

221097

Now you're all nice and I feel bad because of it. Was all randomly pissed off for no reason and I read this, knew it was based of Discordantly, raged about it. I still think this is mostly a fic copied from that but I shouldn't of flamed over it.

Forgive me.

221194 I DID specifically copy words from the picture. But, I also gave credit to the original, and I hope I didn't come off as claiming the fanfic was completely and totally my original idea. I think what Soulsilver said sums it up: "The premise of the story and some of the words in this are taken directly from Discordantly, yes, but that isn't stealing an idea, it is expanding on it." I took a picture I saw, was inspired by it, and wrote a story from it. (Plus, if you compare the ratio of copied words to original words... well, let's say there isn't much of a comparison. :twilightsmile:)

Fear not Brony, all is forgiven.

This is a story about a comic. Why should that be stolen? And as far as i know it's even linked on CosmicUnicorn deviantart page. So, seriously, wtf?
My hoof of approval for this one. :eeyup:

755903 Thanks! I do not hide the fact that it was inspired, and in fact, I have shared this fic with the original artist.

Wow, my fic is also based on this comic. You should check it out

I think my heart just broke in two.. :fluttercry:

Login or register to comment