Page generated in 0.019 seconds
Total duration
1,019 users online
1,353,179 hits today, 2,073,628 yesterday
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Fanfiction
Designed and coded by knighty & Xaquseg - © 2011-2024
Support us
SubStar
Chat!
Discord
Follow us
Twitter
MLP: Friendship is Magic® - © 2024 Hasbro Inc.®
Fimfiction is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Hasbro Inc.®
Yeah...
Anybody else wanna help me completely fucking murder Princess Dumbfuck? I'd love volunteers!
She's condemning a now-innocent pony to live with the memories of being a ruthless killer in a society of peace. That'll do wonders for Shendu's life.
6622518 Ooh! Ooh! Pick me, pick me!
6622569 What do you want to use? I've got dibs on the matches and gasoline.
6622567 Yeah... That's why I commented what I did.
Given that the soul and personality are defined by magic, shape and memory what will happen after the changes end and the monster's memories begin asserting themselves upon the pony's soul?
Wraith is already thinking she'll experience crushing guilt in a world where jealousy made the nightmare and shiny things made sombra.
6622588 I'll take the frying pan and the flying house.
6622567
It's totally not like Princess Celestia didn't surround Shendu with a bunch of good people to, ya know, help rehabilitate her and assimilate into society and help her psychologically.
6622604 Still.
Do they know what it's lie to have those memories floating around in their heads?
6622600 Anything else?
6622604
6622608
Right.
Because people that have no idea what you went through are so great they can just tell you why you're an awful person and how you can fix while making themselves sound perfect?
Uh huh. Gimme a call when that works.
Or when ya know.
It doesn't.
6622518 yes
6622624
While you're sitting there, please tell me what the better alternative would have been to this situation? Removing the memories? Congrats at that point you might as well have killed her because there was nothing left of the original person.
There are zero good options in this situation. This is the best option outside of killing Shendu or sealing her away forever.
6622621 Now that you mention it...
*Pulls out iPod and several pairs of earplugs*
Ten-hour-each obnoxious songs playlist! Including, but not limited to, 10-hour Nyan Cat, 275 Billion bottles of beer on the wall, and 'Happy Birthday' loop.
6622637 What weapons do you want? Indigo has the Frying Pan and the flying house.
6622645 Ooh, devilish. I like it.
6622641 ...Would you rather be killed, or have the guilt that you KILLED A HUNDRED FUCKING PEOPLE IN COLD BLOOD?
Let's be honest.
Most people can't point a gun at somebody that is trying to kill them and pull the trigger because 'he's a human too'.
I'd kill Shendu in a heartbeat.
It's the humane thing to do.
So, you sadistic bastard, which is it?
Kill her, and end her suffering, or let her live with a pain worse then death?
HUH?!
WHAT WOULD YOU DO?!
*takes a deep breath to calm himself*
*takes a few more*
Hot mother of fuck on a stick, I hate people like you.
'Yeah, let everybody live! It's the right thing!'
SOMETIMES IT ISN'T.
Fucking idiot...
God, now I have to go shoot Handsome Jack in the face to calm down, I'm so mad.
Thanks, asshole. Next time, think before you decide, 'Hey, let's type every word that comes outta my ass!'
6622670
Ok, seeing how you're turning into a raging immature child about this I'm not even going to bother.
Did you even see what you typed there? Hilarious.
6622674 Yeah, well. Have you ever killed somebody?
Because I have.
The guilt eats at me.
Every second of every day, I am plagued with guilt and sadness.
Every night, I don't dream.
I remember.
I have trouble sleeping.
It's been ten years.
He was going to kill me.
*grits teeth*
Now tell me again how you understand.
6622518 You are not alone.
6622690 Bro, calm down. I don't wanna see any flame man. Insult in PMs if you must but not here, please.
6622720 This isn't a flame war. Not even close.
6622518 BURN THE WITCH!
I wonder how long until they connect the dots and realize Luna was basically rebuilt into a new being with Luna's old memories as well. If that's how it went in this universe at least.
Like I said a few chapters ago, It's one thing if the victim agreed to the procedure to avoid the death penalty, but forcibly doing so is a far worse punishment than death and it takes a pretty twisted individual to be able to do so without guilt. It would be better to just kill a unrepentant killer(there's a difference between killing and murder) who eats ponies as prey and be done with it than do this.
6622648 mmm psychological torture prefer something like you see a marathon Barney followed by The Crazy Ones and to finish this ghhh DRAGON BALL EVOLUTION
Woah. What a shit storm this comments section visit turned out to be.......... Continue.
6622762 Ok.
First, "victim"? No. Half the people that would warrant this level of "punishment" would lose the title of victim long ago. This method is something that is clearly reserved for people who are incredibly fucked up and have zero redeeming qualities and/or is a danger to society at large. I.E. Serial Killers/Mass Murders. And when people get to that point they don't really deserve a choice in the matter.
Second, it was revealed by Luna that Shendu is basically a child and the only reason she ate an entire town was because the child mentality was "Hungry so I have to eat". If anything, after learning about that it would probably weighed even more on Celestia and Luna had they killed her because they would've effectively killed a kid who was doing nothing more than a child following natural instincts. to stave of hunger. Not for petty or horrible reasons like "because I could" or "because it was fun".
Lastly, when Shendu does grow enough of an identity for said memories to take an impact do you not realize that Celestia has surround Shendu with the Six Elements of Harmony. The Six who are supposed to be the greatest embodiment of friendship. Sure you can kill her and do nothing but add one more number to the death toll and produce no positive results or you can take a chance and surround her with people that can possibly help her through it as best than can and produce a functional member of society.
If Twilight doesn't know about soul composition then it's probably a pretty sure bet that Celestia doesn't either. I'd guess Princess Sunbutt took the action she did in reasonably good faith, not knowing the true consequences to Maiden-Shendu.
I like how the story progressing. Can't wait for the next chapter.
6622748 HEY! THE MATCHES AND GAS ARE MINE! GET YOUR OWN TORTURE METHODS, ASSHOLE!
I have one thing to say to several people in the comment section...Shut up with your hypocritical white knight templar preaching!
Seriously.
And Done.
6623376 or there is the possibility that Sunbutt covered it up.
I'm still surprised Twilight hasnt considered the implications that the elements of harmony are weapons that target the soul and considered that they were used against Luna. Then again, she's been distracted with the Shendu in front of her but it would be nice for the dawning horror to make an appearance. I can't remember but I don't think Wrath is aware that the elements were used on Luna. So only Twilight currently has enough information to put 2 and 2 together to get 4.
6623973 So, Perhaps she is in fact the villain....
When are you going to go back and address whatever has been done to SPIKE? That's not a Chekov's gun, it's a blippin' chekov's HOWITZER.
6623117 True. A predator that young wouldn't see what they did from the perspective she now possesses... She gave one of the harshest punishments she could have: forced upon her the perspective where she will feel regret to those she has slain. And on a child, less than a week old, no less. Not only that, she has this creature surrounded by those who could make her a good pony. This is a forced reformation, if ever I saw one.
6624320 Twilight informed him that the Elements were used on her on their way around town, before Shendu attempted to abduct Princess Luna.
6622588
Would that work on the sun goddess? Imma use the toothpicks.
6622518 I call the black hole cannon. Yes, we will all die, but we don't need to aim for it.
I'm beginning to think Celestia is a very twisted mother fucker... I like it.
Someone commited a gross mutilation of the soul of a creature and admitted to planning to do it again if pressed!!!!!
Oh it is Celestia it is okay.
Twilight thought
6868731
What's a Howitzer?