• Member Since 3rd Nov, 2011
  • offline last seen Aug 25th, 2012

Cookies Need Love


E

Instead of being turned to stone by the Mane 6, Discord is banished. As he trudges away from the place he was simply trying to make livelier, he is joined by a peculiar pink pony with a simple request. As the two walk and talk, will Discord regain his joy in creating chaos? And will Pinkie Pie ever get her chocolate rain?




Currently getting the horse apples edited out of it. Edited version will be added as a new chapter when I finish!
The cover art is not my own. I got it from this link: http://fc02.deviantart.net/fs70/i/2012/052/4/2/pinkie_pie_crawled_up____by_njung-d4q53nc.png

Chapters (1)
Comments ( 85 )

Great story.
This is the best pairing.
All others will bow before it.
Good day.:moustache:

331267
Before I officially reply, I have to admit that when I saw the notification saying someone had commented the first thoughts that went through my head were Oh, someone hated it! They just commented to tell me how awful it was and how my writing sucks and I'm so scared to look. No, I must be brave! I will face all critiques with the expression of a stone soldier! :pinkiecrazy:
So, when in saw your comment I laughed aloud (partly relief, partly Spike with a mustache) and I'm super happy you enjoyed it! :raritystarry:

Yes. DiscoPie is best pie. :pinkiehappy:
THERE NEEDS TO BE A DISCORD EMOTICON!

I'll write you a critique. This sort of thing has potential. Give me a moment while I prepare, please.

331302
:pinkiegasp: A-a critique? I'm truly worth it?? :raritystarry:
Thank you! I was seriously cringing as I looked back on this, but I honestly do that with all my writing so a critique would seriously be epic. Thank you again!! :pinkiehappy:

331312
Thank you for the brony hug there. Although technically not a brony myself (Pegasister ^-^) the hug is and will always be...
Epicness :pinkiesad2:

So.... much..... DiscoPie...... :pinkiegasp:
My mind, I cannot handle it all :pinkiecrazy:

I was initially interested in the prospect of a non-shipping Discord and Pinkie Pie story. I think there's a lot of potential for some hilarious situations between the two, yet typically most writers fall flat in this department. Unfortunately, this is one of those stories.

The premise is cute for a one-shot, and I quite like the idea. This is definitely the sort of scenario that could lead to a lot of laughs. The problem with this particular story is that it doesn't really seem to do anything with its premise, other than devolve quite quickly into meme territory. You write Pinkie Pie decently well - quite a rarity in this fandom. She retains her "random," slightly annoying nature, while still being ultimately charming.

I can specifically point to the scene where she "becomes Pinkamena," the idea of which is already very tired and has been done to death in multiple forms of media. While it's good that you didn't dwell on it, the only reason that's a plus is because it's annoying in the first place. There's no reason for her to become a "different" character here; it adds nothing to the story, and isn't really funny enough to be worth using in the first place.

It also seems like it suffers from being a little too short. Nothing is really developed, so all you have is a random, unmemorable collection of paragraphs in which Pinkie Pie asks Discord for a chocolate rain cloud. There's some interesting ideas in here, like Pinkie Pie and Discord teaming up - that's something you should explore! - but they are only really given a cursory look in the story, which is rather disappointing.

All in all, it was a decent story at best, and it's clear that you did pour your heart into it, but it needs work to be something great. What you have here shows potential, but it is nothing special in its current form.

I suppose I should also point out more thoroughly what I did like about it. As I stated previously, I liked the premise very much. Your writing is, for the most part, technically sound, though you could perhaps do with an editor, as I noticed a few typos. Your characterizations are sound, and they are enjoyable to read. You managed to keep my interest for the most part, which lends some credence to the assertion that your writing is technically sound. And, again, you have some very nice ideas, but you need to expand upon them more.

I hope my initial offering was not too harsh. I did not intend it to come off as such.

331330
Since it vanished here is the commet agian.
arch.413chan.net/I_know_that_feel_brony-(n1301655838986).png
And.
twilight.ponychan.net/chan/art/src/132901507262.png
I repost the Discopie later.
Good day.:moustache:

331351
Oh, don't worry about hurting my feelings. This is gonna sound kinda weird, but I actually enjoy reading flames. :twilightblush: Not that yours was a flame, but I'm trying to show that harsh critiquing is a go with me! :raritywink:
For the most I agree with what you're saying. Wait, scratch, that, everything you said, really. Especially the Pinkamena thing since I do see that fairly often. But how to show Discord her random side? ..... OMG.
Pinkie Sense. Discord is going to witness her Pinkie Sense and be bonked on the head by something. It will happen!!! Dear lord, I need to find time to edit this thing to bits...... But when? :raritycry:
Although, it'll probably just turn into something completely different :trollestia:
Ah well. I will do my best to make this as awesome as it has the potential to be, seeing as it includes both Discord AND Pinkie Pie!

331372
I removed it because there were far too many pictures that were completely breaking the tables. Please do not post so many in one comment.

this is a good story, not OMG LIKE SIX STARS ON EQD good, but pretty good. the only complaint i have is the glaring spelling errors, eg "ponkie pie", and the editor note you forgot to take out about adverbs. it's a shame, the lack of editing really
holds back what would have been a solid piece of writing.

tell you what, i'm going to give you a like, but if you fix the errors mentioned above, i'll come right back up and pin one of my elusive "favorite" stars on this story.

331467
Ah yes, the elusive art of editing... I seriously have yet to master it :twilightblush:
I'm planning on going back and editing all the technical stuff right after I post this, actually. Which would be now-ish.... Anyways, I'm glad you liked it anyway :rainbowkiss:

Discord.. only has one hoof. And it isn't exactly in the proper position for one to place said hoof on their face.

331578
Really? Huh....I haven't exactly memorized what he looks like, although I probably should've kept a picture of him on-hand for this since I do refer to his anatomy a lot..... :twilightblush:
Would it be face clawed then? I mean, that sounds kinda violent.... :twilightoops:

Finally a good DiscoPie story. :pinkiehappy: :DiscordSmileEmoticonThatShouldBeHere:

331769
Thanks!!!!! :pinkiesad2: :DiscordSmileEmoticonThatShouldBeHere:

Actually, what I posted about not adding anything on your profile before was a dirty lie :twilightblush: I'm probably gonna be adding a couple edited versions and maybe even a chapter or two.... Although that might take a while :fluttershysad:

hmmm, i like it, and i usually only like HiE fics, (or gorefics) but this was well-written, not the most origional, but still an interesting view on an old topic, and it was spot-
on with personalities. so i like it, you deserve a yay for this work :yay:
ALLof my OC's clap for you
assets0.ordienetworks.com/images/GifGuide/clapping/audience.gif

I'd like MOAR. :flutterrage: Um.. That is.. If you don't mind. :yay:

331420
Alright, I didn't know thier was a picture limit.
And I was just supporting this guys ship.
Good day.:moustache:

332866
Well, I'm glad you liked it even if it's outside your usual scope! :pinkiehappy: It makes me feel all warm and fuzzy :pinkiesad2:

332902
There actually might be more, if I get around to editing the horse apples outta this :applejackunsure:
Anyways, I'm glad you liked it! :coolphoto:

I love Discord and Pinkie Pie together! They're like my one true pairing! Thank you for an awesome read!
:pinkiehappy:

333266
No problem! DiscoPie is best, indeed. :moustache:
I'm really glad you liked it!! :raritystarry:

The picture...It is so fitting...yet weird.

I do not know.

-The Doctor

333122 you have no idea. even DJ and flutterblood clapped, (DJ's an OC i made, the incarnation of cruelty and insanity, and Flutter i the dauhter of DJ and the devil's wife) it taks a LOT to please them. there is only 1 other non HiE story that they clapped for. (http://www.fimfiction.net/story/6109/Three-of-Me%3A-School-Society-)

333530
Yup, that basically describes DiscoPie :trollestia:
I found it on Deviantart and knew it was perfect!!!

333744
Wow, really? :twilightblush: I-I don't even know what to say to such an honor!! I'll have to check out that other stor. It must've been impressive, way more impressive then mine :yay:

334686 :applejackconfused: Why are we doing this?

Login or register to comment