After everyone thinks they're a couple, Pipp and Hitch realize their feelings for each other and start dating. Meanwhile Zipp, Sunny and Izzy also search for love. Unknown to them, Opaline continues her attempts to take all magic for herself.
It is Hearth's Warming, and the snow is coming down. Ponies are gathering for the holiday, some friends, others more than. For Hitch and Pipp, it will be unforgettable.
It is Nightmare Night. The Mane 5 are all dressed up and are hitting the town of Maretime Bay, and were invited to a private party, included are free drinks. While everypony is having fun, Hitch doesn't take the drinking part all too well.
Shortly after the events of a big storm in Maretime Bay, and Hitch and Pipp finally letting their feelings about each other be known, they now have to tell the others. While everypony does approve, Zipp knows that she'll need to talk to Hitch soon.
Hitch recently just moved to the lighthouse and Pipp keeps connecting with him in more ways than imagined. Pipp is learning how to live in Maretime Bay and Hitch is just starting to take lessons of parenthood.
Hitch does a favor for Pipp to help her get famous recording the first ever sighting of a Manticore. Things do not go as planned, and Izzy is determined to figure out where it all went wrong.