It's the night Cheese Sandwich finally admits his feeling for Pinkie Pie. The night starts off perfectly, but slowly Cheese begins to notice something isn't quite right with her. What could it be? Might it be Pinkie's nightmares taking over her?
Cheese Sandwich doesn't consider his own birthday to be more special than the happy faces he encounters. After getting a doozy pointing him to Ponyville, it might shock everyone with who he happens to share the same birthday with.
A few years after the show has ended, Pinkie Pie will receive a very important proposal from her very special friend Cheese Sandwich. But will his question bring the two party planner ponies together, or tear them apart?
While Luster Dawn is tasked to learn more about the magic of friendship, Princess Twilight Sparkle and her friends try their best to settle a friendship problem that points more likely to be a new threat to Equestria. (Takes place after S9E26)