• Member Since 20th Dec, 2012
  • offline last seen April 14th

Ephemeral Prose


T

Caelus and Aurora are the king and queen of Equestria; a land where magic flourishes and ponies live in prosperity. Truly, Equestria is a land of balance. Celestia and Luna are heirs to the throne, and stand to inherit the sun and the moon very soon. Gleeful at this prospect, Celestia eagerly prepares for the day when her time will come to control the sun

Discord has always had a thing for the sporadic. Imbued at a young age with the Spirit of Chaos, Discord finds immense pleasure in his namesake. Yet, this wasn't always the case. An eternity ago, when the Princesses were young, he had a different name. A real name.

Contains Discord and Celestia romance.

Image is not mine. It is the result of the brilliance resulting from a google search. If anyone wants to draw me some cover art, feel free

Chapters (1)
Comments ( 5 )

Two centuries before the return of Nightmare Moon, Discord, or Twilight Sparkle's ascension, a fair-coated teenage alicorn stood looking up at the waning night sky. Her sister would one day have dominion over this, just as she would eventually come to control the sun.

Two centuries is 200 years-did you mean 2,000 years?

2823961
You would be correct. 2000 years would be 2 millennia.

You know, I actually had it written originally as "Two millennia."

I suppose this is what I get for second-guessing myself.

a few spelling errors here and there, of course i didnt mind at all, thoroughly though i enjoyed this story alot, the names, the places the entire idea of what exactly happened when he was encased in the stone like that is ba-bam in the face. its been awhile since i said "oh shit" out loud from a story man, excellent job in my opinion. thumbs up and a favorite from me broski. :pinkiehappy:

This is one of those stories that I couldn't finish. It had so many technical errors and pacing missteps that I stopped around the 1,000 word mark.

It opens with tell-y exposition. The narration bluntly and explicitly tells the audience Celestia's feelings and concerns. She also expounds on her family's setup and characteristics for no reason other than to dump info on the reader.

It also describes (at length) things that the audience already knows. Things like the appearances of characters and their relationships are given a disproportionate amount of attention, even though it can be safely assumed the reader knows most of this. The story spends an entire 200 word paragraph on describing Discord's appearance, for instance.

Many of the sentences meander or include useless information. The narration often goes on tangents or repeats itself. There's lots of padding and qualifiers that don't add anything to the meaning of sentences. There's also a significant number of typos or misused words. All this adds up to a story that is very difficult to read. Some examples of what I mean:

but he would never be content to let his personal feelings jeopardize the well-being of his people.

Misuse of phrase: usually this phrase is only use when someone is reacting to a situation. Since the king is the one making the decision, this reads awkwardly.

Therefor, no matter what he felt for his daughters, The king would not simply pass on the monarchy to ones who would be ignorant of how to keep it from falling into disarray.

Meandering sentence, lots of clauses, tell-y

To make matters worse, whoever it was had to be cold. While it was certainly not freezing, it was quite chilly out on this particular night.

Tell-y/redundant information

but if she had to take a gander she'd guess that they slept in the walls.

Not what that word means.


The plot feels somewhat contrived (from the small part I read). While the idea that Discord and Celestia's relationship began as a sort of rescuer/rescued dynamic is nice, the details lack subtlety and believability. A bunch of teenage bullies beating up Discord for being different clashes so badly with the show, and the story doesn't explain itself well enough to turn this situation into a good hook.

Middle English is accurate, from what I can tell. I'm far from a capable judge, but I didn't notice any glaring inaccuracies in the way it was structured.

Overall, this story was a chore to read. I couldn't finish it enough to make any real comment on the plot or do a full review on it. You mentioned yourself that it had a lot of technical issues, and you were not exaggerating.

I think that if you want advice on how to improve your writing, then you need to ask yourself some questions about every sentence: could this sentence be divided into smaller sentences without losing anything? Does this clause need to be here? Does the audience know this information already? Is this information crucial to the story?

If you are having trouble asking these questions of your own writing, then I highly recommend getting an editor/prereader who will be able to help you pinpoint word cruft and wandering.

From what I read, this story really does not need to be 11,000 words long. Another thing you might consider is trying to write stories that do not go past X words. While setting arbitrary limits isn't a great way to write stories, it can reinforce an important principle about writing. Every word matters. Every word you put in the story should have a purpose. If there is no purpose or not enough purpose, it needs to be removed.

Of course there are exceptions to this and every principle of writing. One needs to be able to follow the rules, however, before they can effectively judge when to break them.

Some additional reading:
Show Don't Tell
The Law Of Conservation Of Detail

If you have any questions, of course feel free to ask :raritywink:

Login or register to comment