Pinkie doesn't realize it yet. Like you could blame her, she doesn't have much experience in the subject. Shes never exactly had... a crush before. So really, you can't blame her.
When a mysterious pony extracts all laughter from a Cheese Party, including Cheese Sandwich himself, two ponies find themselves seeking help from the Element of Laughter to stop the Amulet of Sorrow.
After meeting Cheese Sandwich's brother and learning about their feud, Pinkie Pie takes it upon herself to help them mend their broken bond. Shenanigans ensue.
There is one birthday Cheese Sandwich never forgets: Pinkie Pie’s, and the three little ponies who share it with her. He never misses throwing their party—but they’re never there.
Cheesy Sense is hitting Cheese Sandwich hard, but Pinkie’s having a difficult pregnancy, and Cheese doesn’t want to leave her. And he also suspects there’s something Pinkie isn’t telling him.
Cheese Sandwich keeps a lot of his thoughts to himself when he's around Pinkie Pie. For a party pony, he’s still awfully shy. But today he slips up, thinks out loud when he’s barely awake, and says much more than he ever meant to.
Is there any reason why Cheese Sandwich isn’t afraid of meeting Pinkie Pie’s sisters? It’s only for a day he keeps telling himself. But then again, maybe it won’t go all bad for him.
Cheese Sandwich doesn't consider his own birthday to be more special than the happy faces he encounters. After getting a doozy pointing him to Ponyville, it might shock everyone with who he happens to share the same birthday with.
Working hard at Sugarcube Corner takes its toll on Pinkie Pie. Even she has to take lunch breaks. Today just so happens to call for a special meal, and she has a good reason why.