This story is a sequel to The Mane Six Regret Playing Truth or Dare

The first time the Mane Six played Truth or Dare, Rainbow Dash threw Fluttershy into the portal to the other world. She came out and said, "What happens at the Lit Club stays in the Lit Club." However, Rainbow wants answers. One day, Rainbow Dash and Twilight demand an answer from Fluttershy. She invites them over for tea and cookies, and explains what happened on the other side of the mirror portal. Fluttershy's story will leave Twilight and Rainbow speechless.

Reading the first story is not required, but recommended, especially if you would like to read about more shenanigans.

Since the Mane Six reformed Starlight Glimmer, they've decided to celebrate by having a slumber party every Saturday night. During one particular slumber party, Rainbow Dash suggests playing Truth or Dare. Of course, the rules are simple:

1. If choosing Truth, you must tell the truth when some pony asks you a question.
2. If choosing Dare, you must perform the dare some pony dares you to do.
3. The game ends after everypony has gone three times.

It's going to be a long night.

Takes place at the end of season 5.
Now edited!
Credit and a bunch of thanks to MissPolycysticOvary for permission to use the awesome artwork!
Check out the sequels!
What Happens at the Lit Club...
Celestia and Luna Regret Playing Truth or Dare
Link to the previous unedited version is available here!

On the way back from Fluttershy's house, Starlight takes notice of a young filly under a tree and soon discovers that she is without any known parents. Starlight wants to take care of the poor orphan, but is uncertain if she has the qualities that it takes to be a 'mother'.