ReadingSins 444 members · 398 stories

We here at ReadingSins dive into the waters of fanfiction, searching for obvious mistakes or plot-holes. We will delve a little deeper and find mistakes unnoticable by the untrained mind.

We are ReadingSins. Nit-picking at stories since 8/8/2014.

Banner and Icon by Kanzlerin Maud

Rules
1: Disrespecting other members will not be tolerated.
2: No NSFW material within the comment sections of threads and home page.
3: A thread about hating on a specific story will be locked.
Those are the rules!

Things you should/have to do when posting a sin thread.
1: Name of story, and link to said story.
2: Name the author.
3: Do a sin tally, it should be obvious for any fans of Cinema Sins.
4: State your sentence.
5: And/Or do a bonus round on author rage, miss-spellings, grammar, punctuation etc.

That's it! Do good out there marines!

Comments ( 69 )
  • Viewing 50 - 69 of 69

If this is anything like cinimasins, I'm all ears(or eyes in this case):trollestia:

So... Am I just allowed to put one of my stories in the request folder?

My sin for this group: Group uses the name Reading Sins instead of Literature Sins. Thus, making this group feel like just another parody.

"Guy Who Knows Absolutely Nothing About Reviewing Stories Joins Review Group" cliche.

TOTAL SINS COMMITTED BY ME: 1
SENTENCE: BECOME A REVIEWER.

I am so quitting reading the flood in my feed. Sorry. I'll come back to it.

I'm seeing a lot more stories in the request folder.... and I can't do them all. I have to get on my computer somehow.

387479 All of them aren't neccasarily bad.

397065 Just came across this. I'll watch.

I am now part of this group.

I've seen cinema sins ever since the beginning. Literally.

So.....I know everything about sins :P

388208 Allrighty then :twilightsmile:

387711 It has to be a story. We're called Readingsins for a reason, after all.

Can I do one of Rainbow Rocks or does it have to be an actual story?

Am I glad I found this group! It's just like the actual Cinmasins, but with bad fan fics and ponies!

Oh! My family has been here all allong!

385342 then there will be fire. Have a nice day.

383234 I talked with Gobsmacker about it. He said that reviewing Cupcakes is OK, if you want to do it. As long as it follows the rules, of course.

Can I do cupcakes, or does that equal a ban?

382925 If we had an "absurdly high" folder, than anything with 1000 sins or more would probably qualify as "absurdly high".

373248
Definitely. Somepony's gonna get the bright idea to go after the more infamous fanfics out there. Like Cupcakes. ...Or My Little Unicorn. Even individual chapters of the latter would go into the Absurdly High area.

The question is, what number of sins will count as "Absurdly High"?

  • Viewing 50 - 69 of 69