Nightmare Rarity
Founded by Ianpiersonjdavis · Report

Shipping

Any shipping involving Nightmare Rarity.

Order: Date Added

TNightmaribat: Origins
MLP: FiM
MLP: Comic
Romance
Dark
Rarity has fused with the Nightmare force, and their bond cannot be broken. But to what lengths would Fluttershy go to reach the pony she loves? Sometimes it takes a monster to tame a monster...
Sex
Alt. Universe
Fluttershy
Rarity
Nightmare Moon
Nightmare Rarity
Bat Pony
Ponyo · 1.6k words · 16 2 · 1.2k views
EA Second Attempt at Love
MLP: FiM
Gravity Falls
Romance
Adventure
Nightmare Moon and Nightmare Rarity return to Earth. Nightmare Moon aims to cause eternal night and Nightmare Rarity as well, but she also intends to try again to conquer Nightmare Moon. Will she succeed in winning Nightmare Moon's heart this time?
Crossover
Alt. Universe
Rarity
Nightmare Moon
Main 6
Nightmare Rarity
Twilight Star · 14k words · 20 10 · 998 views
ETogether on the moon
MLP: FiM
Romance
Tragedy
When Nightmare Moon was trapped on the moon, she found a companion.
Alt. Universe
Nightmare Moon
Nightmare Rarity
Twilight Star · 3.2k words · 31 6 · 1.4k views
TMy Celestial Villainess
MLP: FiM
Romance
As Rarity recovers from her time under the Nightmare Forces' control, a stranger from their ranks appears and offers her the most unexpected of deals--to be by her side.
Alt. Universe
Rarity
Coco Pommel
Nightmare Rarity
Bat Pony
Quillamore · 3.9k words · 35 2 · 1.4k views
TMy Nightmarish Heroine
MLP: FiM
Romance
In a world where the nightmare forces have their own country, Coco Pommel joins their ranks in hope of a better life.
Alt. Universe
Rarity
Coco Pommel
Nightmare Rarity
Bat Pony
Quillamore · 3.1k words · 75 4 · 2.4k views
TGoodnight, Spike
MLP: FiM
Romance
Sad
Tragedy
An alternate story about Nightmare Rarity, the battle on the moon and in Ponyville, and its aftermath.
Spike
Celestia
Luna
Main 6
Zandar13 · 4.1k words · 44 6 · 3.4k views
TThere's Something About Nightmarity
MLP: FiM
Romance
Dark
Comedy
Slice of Life
An aging Rarity makes a deal with Nightmare Moon to once again let her transform her into Nightmarity. Menawhile, Spike has to contend with a mare with two brains.
Sex
Gore
Rarity
Spike
Nightmare Moon
thewaffler · 29k words · 223 16 · 3.9k views
TDiamond's Dusk
MLP: FiM
Romance
Adventure
Sad
Rarity is “freed” from Nightmare Moon’s grasp, but must come to terms with what the spirit’s final strike has done to her.
Sex
Gore
Alt. Universe
Rarity
Spike
Other
Main 6
The Dragon Warlock · 112k words · 212 17 · 5.4k views
TChaotic Nightmare
MLP: FiM
Romance
Dark
Adventure
Comedy
Random
Rarity been turned into the dreaded Nightmare, and in her efforts to free her friend, Twilight is lost to the evil as well. Ponyville is... in no real danger? What? What do you mean they're in love?! Damn it! Somepony tell em to get a r
Alt. Universe
Twilight
Rarity
Sam Cole · 20k words · 290 21 · 6.8k views
EThe Nightmares That Form Bonds
MLP: FiM
Romance
Sad
Slice of Life
Rarity discovers she can change into her Nightmare form at will, but she needs help to control her new power. Lucky for her, a certain dragon is there to help.
Twilight
Rarity
Sweetie Belle
Spike
Ty The Draco · 5.9k words · 170 5 · 4.1k views
TA Nightmare Rarity Story: A Knight in Shining
MLP: FiM
Romance
Dark
Sad
A one-shot featuring NightMare Rarities Redemption at the hands of Spike
Rarity
Spike
Main 6
Commando-Scarecrow · 2.2k words · 168 12 · 5.2k views

Shipping

Stats

FIMFiction

Follow & Support Us