[Canterlot - Dungeons.]
All members of the Pie family are walking briskly through the dungeon. The guards were on either group, moving at the same pace. The jail itself had a slew of occupants. But, it was primarily vacant the closer they got to Pinkie's cell. There, the Pie family finds Pinkie. She is sitting with her back facing them. However, a white jacket covers her body. Pinkie's mane and tail were still flat and straight. She is rocking back and forth while Limestone looks at the scene with a scowl. She turns to one of their escorts and starts shouting.
"What the hay is this!? Why is she in one of those looney pony clothes?!"
"A precaution, ma'am. She would not stop struggling and bending the bars to escape," One guard said.
"Yeah, the only way to appease her was to give these rocks. Aside from the muttering and occasional twitch, she's been docile," The other guard said.
Limestone huffs and goes back to her sister. "Pinkie?"
"La-la la-Lala. Hmm-hmm hm hm hm-hm-hm," Pinkie mutters.
"Pinkie, it's us," Maud's tone was slightly higher due to her concern.
When Pinkie continued to hum that song, her mother spoke. "Pinkamena Diane Pie,"
Pinkie finally turns around as her family grimaces. Black tear stains left streaks on her cheeks. A manic smile unnerves her family. And her pupils darted in every direction. In front of her were miniature stone figurines of her and her friends with Jason. "Hey, Ma and Pa. Limey, Marbie, and Maudie. You're just in time for Jason's birthday bash,"
Seeing Pinkie throw her unrestrained hooves in the air made the guards move forward. "How did you get out of your restraints--"
Before the guards could finish, Maud was standing in their faces. "Leave!" There was no indication of two escorts save for an outline of pony-shaped smoke. "Pinkie? What's going on?"
"I'm making up for lost time with all my best friends. See, I did the math. Jason missed his welcome party. Then, three birthdays. And we can't forget the once-a-month get-togethers. So, that's like two thousand hours of partying. All my friends are having a blast. Come say hello, Marble,"
Marble Pie flinches back as Pinkie thrusts the figure of Jason to her face. "H-hello?"
"Hello, Marble. Your sister told me all about you. Let's have fun," Pinkie puppets.
"Pinkie," Limestone asks tentatively.
"You'll all love Jason. He has so many new and crazy stories from his world. Weirdly, no one else has come by yet. I could've sworn I sent invitations to everyone in town. Meeting an alien is something everyone should enjoy," Pinke said with a deranged chuckle.
"Maybe they don't want to come to see that thing! It's so uncouth!" Pinkie puppets the Rarity figure.
"It terrifies me more than any critter I've met," The Fluttershy figure said.
"Now, that's not very nice," Pinkie said.
"It's freaky and dishonest looking. I don't want it near my family!" The Applejack figure said.
"Pinkie!" Limestone calls her name.
"Come on, girls. If we like Spike, then Jason is no different. Did you hear all the funny jokes he told us?" Pinkie asks.
"What jokes? You don't know any because you never talked to him. You were fine spreading fake rumors. I bet you can't name any of his favorite foods," The Rainbow puppet said.
"Sure I can!"
"Pinkie Pie!" Maud said more forcefully than her sister.
"There's chocolate cake. Strawberry cinnamon rolls--"
"Those are all the things you like eating. You don't know anything about Jason, do you?" The Rarity puppet said.
"Well, that's what the party is for, silly. To get to know each other better,"
"Pinkie!!!" Marble mutters loudly.
"How can you do that if Jason ignores you? Face it. He wants nothing to do with you, and you have no one to blame but yourself!" The Twilight puppet stated.
"No, he's not ignoring. I, Pinkie, Promise everything is going to be better now! I Pinkie Promised! I Pinkie--"
*SMACK*
Pinkie's head jerks back from the sudden blow to her cheek. She looks at her father in shock as he hugs her. "No more, pumpkin. You hold no fault in this,"
Pinkie tears up again as she pulls away. "I can't, Pa. I Pinkie Promise. I have made things right!"
"Pinkie! Get this through your thick head! He wants nothing to do with you! It's time to stop all these silly promises. You can't fix things like that!" Limestone hollers.
Pinkie's lips tremble as she looks down. "It's the only way I know how to be serious--"
"No, it isn't! Do you know your problem? You never grew up! From the moment you first left the farm to now. You treat everything like it's sunshine and rainbows,"
"What was I going to do? Stay at the boring old rock farm and always be miserable?!"
"No. But farming those rocks build maturity. Something you never did! I always told you that the world isn't friendly. It can be mean and nasty!"
Maud places a hoof on Limestone's shoulder and moves past her. "I know you don't want to hear this, Pinkie. But she is right. Being a grown-up means accepting the mistakes we made. Only fillies and colts rush to fix things when they know it's bad,"
"B-But, adults do fix the problems. H-He won't let me do that. Even though I am guilty..." Pinkie said solemnly.
"And part of an adult is accepting things beyond our control. Pinkie. There is a strong chance that Jason will never forgive anypony for his suffering. You must understand that. Some scars never go away, and he wears them for the world to witness. What must happen now is you learn this. Give yourself room to grow, and never repeat your failings. Undersand?" Cloudy Quartz explains.
"So, he'll never forgive me?" Pinkie whines.
"That is his choice, Pinkie. You have to respect it," Marble said. Overcome with more emotion, Pinkie hugs her family and sobs intensely.
[Canterlot - Hall of Mural Windows.]
Big Mac trots up and down Canterlot to find his sister. It was amazing how much ground a distraught filly can cover. Eventually, with the aid of some guards, Big Mac finds his sister sitting in front of the stained glass window of the time their sister defeated Nightmare Moon. Big Mac sighs in relief before he gasps at what is in Applebloom's hoof—a big fat rock. Big Mac quickly gallops to his sister just as she goes to rear back a throw. Thankfully, Big Mac stops his litter sister before she can ruin it.
"What are you doing, Big Mac?" Applebloom said in a huff.
"Stopping you from defacing a royal mural and dropping a fine on us the size of the farm,"
Realizing her actions, Applebloom drops the rock before scowling at the window. "...She doesn't deserve ponies looking up to her! She isn't a hero! She belongs in Nightmare Moon's place! I hate her!"
Big Mac frowns as he tries to find the right words. "I suppose you're right. I can't rightly excuse what she did. It goes against our apple hospitality. I understand protecting your kin. But, the way she has gone about it wasn't right..." Big Mac looks down at his sister and sees her grumbling before looking out the window. "Do you think Princess Luna is evil?"
"What? Of course not. She's not Nightmare Moon,"
"So, you like her even though she did something bad, got banished, and returned to do it again?"
"Nightmare Moon took over Princess Luna. Nothing took over, Applejack!" Applebloom counters.
Big Mac nods at his sister. "But Luna is feeling responsible because she got all jealous. Since then, she's done an excellent job making up for it. You don't have to forgive Applejack right now. I know she's kicking herself down right now. But give her a chance to make up for this. Apples don't abandon their kin if they are sorry,"
"...I didn't hear her apologize to Jason..."
Another frown appears as Big Mac responds. "It will take time for Applejack's actions to hit her. You know how she is. And, I reckon that Jason fellow is not in the mood for any of her words. Things will get better with time. Granny asked me to take you home,"
"No, I want to see how this ends,"
"Eeyup," The two Apple siblings begin walking out of the castle and back to the courtroom.
[Canterlot Judicial hall.]
Jason groans in annoyance as, yet again; he stares up at the ceiling. He knew this was going to happen eventually with one of the crusaders. And it was the first one he thought would do something like this. However, the weight was off his chest almost as soon as he hit the ground. He sits up to see Scootaloo struggling in a green aura. The unamused face of Chrysalis came into view.
"Honestly, I am going to have to put foal locks around you. How many times today will I be scrapping you off the ground?' Chrysalis complains.
"Let her go!" Rainbow hollers as she gears up for a charge. However, Celestia's wing bars her path. "Princess, what gives?"
"If you move an inch into the air, I will pluck out each feather until you're as flightless as a chicken!" Celestia threatens. The look she was sending Rainbow made the prismatic mare shriek into her seat.
"Enough! It appears this court is far too lenient on all these outbursts. Guards! Take Scootaloo--"
"No, let her stay," Jason said, cutting Luna off. "Tempers are bound to flare up during this. And a filly like Scootaloo here lacks the self-control of any adult. Well, mature adults anyway," Rainbow scowls at the subtle jab at her and Pinkie Pie. Jason smiles at her before moving to Scootaloo. Chrysalis lets go of her hold while the filly glares up at Jason. Jason noticed she clutched her stomach in the same spot she hit him. "You should count yourself lucky that little tummy ache is all you are feeling right now,"
"Is that all you got?!" Scootaloo grunts out.
"Scootaloo, stop!" Sweetie Belle said.
"Well, that was all you had. Actually. Have you not been paying attention? Now, why did you feel the need to disrupt court proceedings?"
"I'm not going to let you bully my friends!"
Jason stares at the filly for a time before he bursts out laughing. "Bully, huh? That's a new one. Tell me do you know at all how courts work? Here's how adults do handles bullies. The defendants - your friends and sister - hurt me. They tease me. They pushed me. And many other things I haven't shown the court yet. Ponyville was the schoolyard, and I was the kid everyone pointed their hooves at and laughed. I mean, look at them and look at me. If I was the bully, where are their scars? You know exactly what's that like, don't you?"
Scootaloo was hesitant a moment before continuing. "W-Well. You didn't have to make Applebloom--"
"I didn't. She did," Jason points to Applejack. "Alright, let's get down to the real thing bothering you. You're an intelligent filly. You know right from wrong, which is more than I can say for Ponyville. But here's why you acted out. It's not because I am a bully. Or, I made your friend cry. It's because you are afraid. You're worried that your hero, Rainbow Dash, isn't who she said she was. You're so scared that I am right. Everything that you believe I am, Rainbow Dash is! You're afraid I'll ruin the image of your hero. And, you know what? You should be! The one thing the world loves more than a hero is to see a hero fail. Why do you think no one is defending her?"
"You're wrong!"
"Yeah, you don't know our daughter!" Windy said.
"We'll stand by her no matter what you try to say!" Bow said.
"By all means. Stand by the rotten mare you help create. I can see why she thinks she's god's greatest gift to the world. There's nothing I hate more than parents that excuse the fucked up behavior of their kids! But let's get started. We all know Rainbow Dash. Courageous. Heroic. Element of Loyalty. She's also reckless. Headstrong. Arrogant. Always the first pony to engage--"
"You forgot one hundred percent more awesome than you'll ever be!" Rainbow said proudly, but no one but her parents cheered for her
"--And make everything worse,"
"Indeed, this appears to be true. Your boastful pride will be the end of you!" Judge Zekia said.
"What? So, am I wrong for having confidence in myself? And tackling anything that would hurt my friends and Equestria?" Rainbow said.
"So, when you and your friends went to tackle Crimson, why did you think assaulting him and driving him into a rage was a good idea?"
"None of the other ideas was working. Get him out of the cave. Let Fluttershy work her magic,"
"Right, because Fluttershy only responded to the imminent threat to all your lives. We wouldn't have had this conversation if she had not stepped up. But that's what you believe is a job well done. Was this the same mindset you had at the Gala? Where you knocked a stallion in the air to impress the Wonderbolts. Not to mention the statue you so bravely stopped from breaking until it smashed into the pillar that destroyed the ballroom,"
"The thing was too heavy. Yeah, I was trying to impress the Wonderbolts. But, I wasn't out there looking to hurt anypony. I was good enough and fast enough to make sure things went smoothly. Princess Celestia even said it was the best triple G she's had. That's why we have invited us!"
More murmurs went off as Celestia hid her hoof with a groan. "Mother of me..." She said.
"So, all that damage was blown over because the Princess knew you and your friends' penchant for causing disaster was just the thing to liven the party up. It's incredible how many things involving you girls are overlooked. But, you contest that there is no fault on your part. Well, what about this?"
The Gjallarhorn glows from Jason's touch as the memory that Pinkie displayed shows again. "Why are we watching this again?" Rainbow asks.
"There's a segment I want to court to see. This entire conflict between the Appleloosians and Buffalo tribe did not escalate with Pinkie's Pie's silly dance. It happens much earlier with you and Applejack,"
"We promised to get the buffalo a chance to talk," Rainbow said while pushing Little Strongheart to Bareburn.
Applejack walks up with a frown on her face. "Yeah, about what?"
"We brought our pal Little Strong Heart here to explain to the Appleloosian why they should leave Buffalo lands,"
"Why, thank you. That sounds helpful--"
Braeburn tries to say, but Applejack pushes him. "That's funny because cousin was about the buffalo and why the apple trees need to stay,"
"That will be a useful thing to--"
This time, Rainbow Dash cuts Little Strong Heart off. "The land is theirs. You planted the trees without knowing. Honest mistake. Now, you just got to move them, that's all,"
"They busted their rumps here. And now they're supposed to bust their rumps again because some buffalo won't stampede somewhere else?"
"Plant the trees somewhere else!" Rainbow inisited.
"Where? It's the only flatlands around these parts!" Applejack refuted.
"The Buffalo had it first!"
"The settler ponies need it to live!!!"
The memory ends with Applejack and Rainbow arguing. "What does that prove? That Applejack and I can disagree on something?"
"No, it proves that you could not keep impartial on an important matter that honestly did not concern you. If you had let Braeburn and Little Strongheart talk things out instead of walking over them, the fight in Appleloosa never would've come about,"
"Or if the Appleloosians made sure there was nopony else on the land before planting trees, then none of that would've happened!"
"To settle on the land, the Appleloosian should've gone to the royal court for permission," Judge Luna said. Celestia nods in confirmation. "However, the responsibility over the land dispute lies with the settlers and buffalo tribe. What were the circumstances of the element's arrival?"
"We were delivering a tree from Applejack's to help out," Twilight informs. "We just stumble across this problem,"
"Then, I do not believe it is fair to place sole blame on this issue on any of the elements," Judge Luna said.
"If you merely stumble upon this incident, why did you not report to Celestia about the issue instead of injecting yourselves right in the middle? You had no diplomatic authority,"
"Well, if the elements attempted to use their status to promote themselves as diplomats, they would be guilty of any consequences for posing as them. They acted only as civilians helping their friends and relatives,"
"Hmm, I suppose I can concede this point to you," Rainbow smiles smugly at their first win. "However, I have to question why you switched loyalties and stood against your friends and the Appleloosians. This was not the first instance of this happening,"
"I've always been loyal to friends and Equestria. I never turned my back on them!!!"
"Well, I have two witnesses that say different,"
The door opens as several ponies and a griffin walk through them. Rainbow's eyes slam open at so many familiar faces. "Spitfire. Soarin. Fleetfoot? You're speaking against me?"
"We were invited here. I don't know what's going on, to be honest. We only just arrived from Cloudsdale," Spitfire explains.
"You should be worrying about us, Rainbow Crash!" A blond-maned and turquoise-furred pegasus said. She wore a black and green flight suit with a cocky grin.
"Huh? I used to call her Lame-bow Dash. Let's combine them. Lame-bow Crash. Ha, nice," The griffin laughed. She had white feathers with purple accents around her eyes with brown fur.
"Gilda? Lightning Dust?" Rainbow hollers.
"Hey, she remembers me," Lightning Dust snarks.
"How could you, Gilda? Lightning, I get it. But, you? I thought we made up!"
"We did until I got his story. And it fits so well with how you always treated me," Gilda said.
"Not to mention, you got me kicked out of the Wonderbolts!" Lightning added.
"You did that to yourself when you nearly got my friends killed. And you G were acting like a jerk at your welcome party!" Rainbow counters.
"Order! Order in the court! It seems you have a lot of disgruntled acquaintances, Miss Dash," Luna said.
"I can attest that Lightning Dust was kicked out of the Wonderbolts. Judge," Spitfire said.
"Then, I would say you tarnished the Wonderbolts' reputation," Jason calls out.
"Gah-- Oof!" Soarin nearly shouts out before Fleetfoot elbows him in the side.
"What makes you say that?" Spitfire asks.
"Before I answer that, could everyone here state their names and profession for the record?"
"Captain Spitfire of the Wonderbolts,"
"First Lieutenant Soarin of the Wonderbolts,"
"Second Lieutenant Fleetfoot of the Wonderbolts,"
"Lightning Dust. Ex Wonderbolt cadet,"
"Gilda Bronzetalons. Scones baker,"
"How would you describe Rainbow Dash and Lightning Dust during their time at the training academy?" Jason asks.
"Both mares are exceptional. However, Lightning pushed herself harder than Rainbow Dash. But, therein lies her flaws. She went too far, and her extreme stunts were a danger to herself, her teammates, and bystanders,"
"Tsk," Lightning sucks her teeth. Rainbow Dash shoots her a smug grin.
"But that isn't the full detail. As I understand, the training academy puts their cadets in pairs where one is the leader and the other is the second. You appointed Lightning Dust as the lead pony because she pushes herself harder than Rainbow Dash, correct?" Jason asks.
"Correct," Spitfire said. Lightning sends a grin right back at Rainbow.
"How would you describe Lightning and Rainbow as a duo team?"
"The two of them together were exemplary. They were breaking every academy record we had. Unfortunately, we had to scrub them when Lightning was expelled,"
"What?! You mean you didn't keep my records?" Lightning shrieks.
"Why should she? You didn't deserve recognition for ignoring safety rules and putting ponies in danger," Rainbow taunts.
"Just like she did not deserve getting kicked out in the first place," Jason said. "Lightning, can you show the court the events leading up to your expulsion?"
"Just touch this horn thing, right?" Lightning asks while Jason nods.
The memory plays out at the dizzy Tron. Rainbow had the fastest recovery time from a spin-out, while Lightning Dust requested to do her test with the maximum settings. While she did not recover the most immediately, Spitfire commended the mare for going the extra mile. Thus, Spitfire made her lead pony. The next scene shows the cadets running obstacle courses. Lightning tells Rainbow to follow her lead. While Lightning had no trouble moving at her pace, Rainbow was struggling. They broke the course record by the end, but Rainbow clips her wing. The final exercise was cloudbusting. Lightning suggests the two form a tornado to pass the course quickly. The tactic was working; however, no one accounted for the elements to arrive and get swept up in the tornado. After being saved, Lightning goes to hoof bump Rainbow Dash, but she refuses. Sometime later, Lightning Dust was flanking behind Spitfire and two stallions as the elements sat at the runway.
"Rainbow Dash. How dare you leave my office without me saying a word back! You were right. The Wonderbolts accept only the best. But being the best should never come at the expense of our fellow pony. We should strive to push ourselves in the right direction. You've shown that you can do that," Spitfire motions for Lightning to come forward before she rips the medal off her uniform and sends her away.
Lightning pulls her hoof away in a huff. "Ha. That's for the reminder. If you wanted to make me look bad, you're doing a sorry job," Rainbow taunts.
"Rainbow Dash, could you show the court when you told Spitfire you'd quit the Wonderbolts?" Jason asks, undeterred by the taunting.
"Pfft, fine, make me look better," Rainbow Dash said.
Touching the Gjallarhorn, Spitfire's office came into view. "This better be important. You're supposed to be out there busting clouds with your partner,"
"We're done with that, ma'am," Rainbow saluted.
"Already? That's an academy record. Explain your methods,"
"That's why I'm here, ma'am. Lightning Dust decided to use a tornado,"
"A bit excessive for cloudbusting. But, judging by your time, it was an effective tactic,"
"Yeah, well, that effective tactic nearly took out my friends! There's a big difference between pushing yourself as hard as possible and being reckless. And if being reckless is award around here, then I don't want any part of it!" The memory ends with Rainbow taking off her wing pony medal.
"Whoo, Way to go, Rainbow," Scootaloo cheers.
"That's my girl!" Bow said.
"You're an inspiration," Windy said.
Suddenly, the sound of uncontrollable laughter goes off. Gilda was on the ground, holding her belly as she wiped the tears from her eyes. "S-Seriously? Are you plucking kidding, Dashie? Are you trying to act like you are the humble, upstanding type? You're the most reckless pony I know. I got more than a few stories to prove it,"
"You don't know what you're talking about, Gilda!" Rainbow sneers.
"You will have your chance, Glida," Jason interrupts.
"So, what was the point of showing us this?" Cadance asks. "This only works in favor of Rainbow Dash,"
"The point is to highlight the rampant hypocrisy the elements bearer exude. Rainbow has the nerve to lecture Lightning Dust about recklessness when we have seen time and again her doing arguably worse with her recklessness. And, she, ironically, is rewarded for said behavior that she abolishes. Where was the integrity for all the other times? Now, I know what you're going to say. It was all in the past. Rainbow has changed. Yet, in this same court, in the present time, Rainbow Dash tried to attack me twice and received multiple warnings. Despite this fact, the Gjallarhorn would not allow such actions. Is that not reckless? In truth, I do not believe Lightning Dust should've been expelled from the Wonderbolts,"
"Are you saying that her behavior was acceptable?" Spitfire said, stunned.
"No, I am saying that Rainbow Dash and Lighting Dust should've been expelled!"
"What?!" Both Lightning and Rainbow exclaim.
"Both Rainbow and Lightning made that tornado together. Both Rainbow and Lightning made their classmates spin out on the course. A wing pony doesn't just follow their leader. They can tell their leader when they disagree with a course of action,"
"Are you kidding? Lightning wouldn't listen to anything I said. She's too full of herself!" Rainbow said.
"Hello, pot. Have you met my friend, kettle?" That simple phrase made Rainbow Dash lose steam. "Why else were you so quick to be her friend initially? Regardless, you could've informed Spitfire of Lightning Dust's actions earlier. But, you still aided her."
Spitfire signs as she speaks up. "Okay, I may have given the wrong impression of what the Wonderbolts wanted from our cadets. But I am a big enough mare to admit I am wrong. Rainbow showed me that. So, I let her stay,"
"But that is not the only reason. Let me ask you this; are civilians allowed on military grounds?"
"No, we have specially assigned dates where civilians come tour the grounds,"
"And why is that?"
"We run dangerous drills that can be detrimental to inexperience flyers and non-winged creatures," Fleetfoot said.
"Then, it is safe to assume that Rainbow's friends were punished accordingly for trespassing on military ground unannounced,"
Spitfire's eyes go wide at the question. "I am afraid I don't understand your meaning," She winces slightly and rubs her ear as the Gjallarhorn emits a low hum.
"It's a simple question. I am sure you have a procedure - Laws even - for illegally entering military buildings. What was the punishment for the elements interrupting a training drill?"
"W-Well, you see. It was an honest case of wrong place, wrong time. We can't punish everypony too harshly," The hum grew louder as Spitfire grunted in discomfort.
"Is it that everypony gets a pass for an honest mistake? Or is it to do with those ponies and their connections? I want to know why only Lightning Dust was punished when you praised her behavior multiple times. Why was she kicked out for nearly smashing Rainbow Dash's friends when none of them had the authority to be there? Lightning could not have known that would happen since cadets and experienced members were allowed there!"
The humming was loud enough for everyone to hear. Yet, strangely, only Spitfire was showing signs of visible discomfort. "Stop! Stop that humming!"
"You cannot lie in the presence of the Gjallarhorn. All you have to do is answer truthfully, and the humming stops,"
With sweat pouring down her brow, Spitfire screams out. "ALRIGHT! Alright. Here's the truth; I did not want to expel Rainbow because of her status as the Element of Loyalty..." Several gasps went out from this confession. "Neither did I want to punish her fellow elements. The news headlines would tear us apart if I punished Celestia's student and the mares that saved Equestria. The Wonderbolts would lose our credibility,"
"Ugh! I don't believe this!" Lightning screams as she gets in Spitfire's face. "Do you know what I faced getting kicked out of the bolts? I was a laughingstock in my hometown. A failure! Some losers could not bring their A-game to be a wonder bolt, but I am the one thrown away because I'm not buddy-buddy with the Princess. Well, forget that! I'm starting a group of my own. The Washouts! We'll be better than any show and member your cheap organization puts out!"
"For what it is worth, Lightning Dust, Rainbow Dash never wanted to play second to you," Jason touches the horn again to show Rainbow going into Spitfire's office again.
"Permission to enter, ma'am," Rainbow said.
"What is it, Rainbow Dash?" Spitfire asks.
"I had the best time on the Dizzy-Tron. Only six seconds!"
"And?"
"And you made me a wing pony!"
Spitfire slowly takes off her glasses. "Because I believe you and Lightning Dust will be an unstoppable time. Do you not think you will be an unstoppable team?"
"Yes, ma'am. I mean, no, ma'am. We'll be an unstoppable team, ma'am!"
"Then, what's the problem?"
Rainbow puffs out her chest as she speaks with conviction. "I think I should be lead pony, ma'am!"
"And I think Lightning Dust likes to push herself harder than you do. That's why I made her lead pony, got it?"
Rainbow's expression visibly deflates as she sulks out of Spitfire's office. "...Yes, Ma'am..."
As the memory ends, Lightning turns to Rainbow with a snarl. "Well, would you look at that? I always knew I was better than you. But, you could not stand it. How do we know you weren't trying to sabotage me?"
"Please! Even if I was a little bummed about being a wing pony, it doesn't change that you would've hurt somepony eventually," Rainbow said.
"But, I bet your ego could not stand that there was a pony better than, huh, Dashie?" Gilda taunts.
Rainbow grits her teeth in response. "Shut. Up!"
"You deserve everything this guy has in store for you. And can't wait for you to be the one that's rejected!" Lightning turns with a flock to her tail as she moves to the prosecution side.
"Miss Gilda. How long would you say you've to know Rainbow Dash?" Jason asks.
"We've known each other since we were fledglings. We both met at the Junior Speedster Flight Camp," Gilda explains.
"And how would you describe your friendship from then until now?"
"Looking back? We weren't friends,"
I knew it…i smelled it i sniffed the april fools joke SNIIIIIIF! amazing as always
Way to throw Celestia under the carriage Rainbow.
Oooh yes! The beginning of the end for Rainbow!
11546951
Actually since Celestia decided to praise their bad behavior what idea was she was supposed to get. That they messed up. Celestia may hate the boring parties but that doesn't change that letting someone get away with wrong behavior only tells them that its okay. She should have explained that although she enjoyed the change in pace that their behavior was wrong and she hopes they won't do again. And they have go back to clean up the mess they made.
Oh man this better then I could expect. Seeing spitfire openly confess was unexpected. But it's so satisfying when people confess to their own bias choices.
I love how the pie family doesn't fully excuse pinkie of her actions or lack there of against jason and give her some tough guidance on how she can move on not by fixing the problem but by telling her to grow up. Tough but fair.
Oh I can't wait to see how rainbow screwed up her "friendship" with Gilda its gonna be her true rude awakening before Jason's truth
I’m legitimately scared of the next chapter and not just cause I have a soft spot for Gilda… I have a feeling her “friendship” with Rainbow was a lot more toxic than we already thought (which is saying something!). I’m not even gonna try to make some guesses at what we will learn… but… I doubt Scootaloos adoration will leave this courtroom intact. I’m also curious to see how Rainbows parents react since they seem like enablers… or at least they are in denial of their daughters behavior.
From this chapter it sounds like the Wonderbolts will be under scrutiny when all is said and done. Hopefully Spitfire has to explain herself at a military tribunal/review board. She handed the situation badly because she cared more about the Wonderbolts “reputation” (or maybe her own), more than handling a major national security and civilian safety issue. Yes, civilians flying unopposed into a live fire range is both those things!
Celestia might also have to take a back seat for awhile considering that her actions to “liven up the Gala” put ponies at risk and eventually ruined the party for the attendees. A party being boring and droll isn’t an excuse to invite known dangerous ponies to spice things up! Imagine if the next party her invitation gets “lost”, meanwhile Luna gets hers mysteriously without fail?
*Rubs hands in excited anticipation for Gilda's testimony*
Scootaloo is in for reality check to the face once Jason reveal blow rainbow struck every hurtful word and the lightning incident
I can already guess how rainbow dashes parents are going to react either in denial but that can only go so far
You know those parents or specifically those moms that put their child in beauty pageants. Not because it's the child's passion but because the mother wants to live that fame through her daughter.
That's how think its gonna go down, her parents are going to be pissed and disappointed at her, but not because she's an abusive sociopath that got sick kicks out of tormenting an innocent creature. But because she failed, and made them look bad. Now their reputation and dream of being the famous parents of a legendary wonderbolt is ruined.
11547014
I like this… Rainbow being made into a monster because her parents tried to live through her…
Oooh, the next chapter will be a doozy in many ways...
Edit: also if I remember correctly; wasn't Spitfires 'paperwork' in her office seemingly just her signing her own pictures?
Raimi's spider man movies wefe unironically kino.
Looking forward to the God tier flank kicking Dash is going to get, that mare deserves everything that's coming to her.
I had a feeling Jason was going to make Scootaloo stay in the court so she can witness the deconstruction of Rainbow Dash. I didn't expect the Wonderbolts to be bashed so much in this chapter though, I thought they were going to be the ones on Jason's side along with Lighting and Gilda because I assumed Jason would have shown them evidence of Dash's actions. It was also good we got to see the fallout between Pinke's actions and Apple Bloom running off. Great job!
(Hmmm, good to see someone taking The Wonder Bolts to task, even if only a little bit. Their presentation in the show ALWAYS bugged me. The same mistakes over and over again. I had no idea why Dash wanted to be a part of them... I have no idea why ANYONE would want to be a part of them.
Heheheh, and that moment with Celestia and Rainbow mentioning her opinion of the Gala was gold.
Lightning Dust is a good show of nepotism and how it applied there. But what I'm really looking forward to... is Gilda. Ooooohhhhhh, she's got a strong start and I can only hope she keeps it up! I'm looking forward to it.)
11546951
I guess that's just another example of Rainbow Dash's thoughtlessness. She does things without thinking and ends up doing more harm. I can't even begin to imagine the fallout Celestia will have on her end from that one comment alone. A high profile party filled with some of the highest ranking ponies in Equestria being sabotaged by the mare who threw the party and endangering the guests with all the wonton destruction and wild animals that were running around
I am enjoying the small tidbits of how the horn works being given to us by showing us what it does to ponies instead of just being given an expositional info dump all at once.
11546987
Why would she do that, though? Judging by the fact that she invited Discord to a future Gala with the express purpose of ruining that one too, it's obvious that she either doesn't think it's wrong or just doesn't care. And from my perspective, the latter is more likely. After all, between her deliberately (as confirmed in the opening of Season 9) being as unhelpful as possible in times of crisis - thus imperiling countless innocent lives - in order to push her own agenda of dumping her crown onto her neurotic control freak of a student, and (when piecing together data from the beginning and end of Season 3 and the final three episodes of Season 9) her withholding the key to immortality from anyone that doesn't somehow become her personal student and then prove some arbitrary level of "worthiness", thus effectively condemning the vast majority of ponies -- including every single Earth Pony and Pegasus -- to death, she routinely shows far more disregard for the well-being of others than a couple of trashed parties.
Damn... if that truth bomb was added in the show, then any trouble that Twilight and her friends cause and create would be ignored and immediately forgiven because of their high connections.
11547070
Yes but she also knows that other ponies like the gala as is . If she doesn't like there are more responsible ways of changing the gala instead of causing a ruckus and possibly causing someone to get hurt.
11547084
Which again leads to my previous conclusion - she doesn't care about others, as long as she gets what she wants.
The part where Spitfire confesses that she didn't want to punish Twilight and her friends because she didn't want the Wonderbolts' reputation be put under fire of disappointment?
You know, that reminds me of an episode from an anime I watched, where the Fleet Admiral admonishes an Admiral for bowing down to a king and apologizing for the marine's ignorance of what was going on in the kingdom, that doing as such dirties the face of justice. There are various English translations of what the Admiral said in response to that, so I'll type out what one of the manga translations said:
"If it dirties that easily, why don't you just keep that face hidden in your damn nightie! If our credibility has been so compromised by the admission of a single mistake, it never existed in the first place!"
11547088
The was my point that as an adult who was trying to help twilight become a responsible leader she should have told her to clean up the mess she made and not to do it again. Applejack might the least worst of the bunch in that episode because her was dumb but didn't hurt anyone. Pinkie wanted her kind of party and never thought if they wanted a different kind they would have changed it. Rarity was too busy trying to live a fairytale in the real world to realize that he was trying to drive her off. Twilight could see Celestia was busy with the other nobles but still thought she would have time for a long talk with her.
11547104
I don't think you're getting what I'm saying here.
Yes, she should have told the others to not do that again. Just like she should have done everything in her power to help resolve the myriad crises that occurred in the show, and she should share ascension with all ponykind (and, if possible, try to find a way to get other species to an ascended state) rather than reserving it for the few she deems "worthy". But all the "should" in the world doesn't mean a thing if the one who should be doing it doesn't care. And as I've stated multiple times already, her actions clearly demonstrate that CELESTIA DOESN'T CARE.
11547112
She does care she doesn't think like twilight her empathy skills are lacking. It easy to play nice while not thinking about others you just have to be important that nobody would yell at you.
11547099
one piece?
I only ask cause of the fleet admiral and admiral
Damn.... this is getting spicey. RD is really bad and enabled by her parents and peers. It's going tp take a lot to break her down. But I really hope she gets put in her place.
Don’t forget rainbow destroying the weather factory just to stop winter so her pet tortoise wouldn’t go to sleep for the winter. Which would cost millions to fix
And here I thought Canterlot would only get a hall of memes with Discord in charge
I'm having a real hard time with this story.
While every revelation is accurate... None are "true"
The nickpicking of individual events and the whole scale creation of non canon out of character "got ya"s is just infuriating. (Like the whole Celestia's law and the bug queens non canon backstory)
The damage to Equestria is way out of scale to the "crimes" and it's clear that the changelings and I would expect a large number of Equestria's citizens to fight ,even to the death, against this trial. As the cost in real blood and power to the ponies would overshadow any trivia discomfort felt by a strange ape, who failed to effectively communicate with the ponies.
The maguffin of the horn, is too OP and national armies would line up against it as too great a threat to national independence.
Only way I can see this story being able to redeem itself is if in the end we discover all the "freed memories" are infact implantated fake ones, created by Jason's fevered nightmares and empowered by Chrysalis mind magic.
Alright what predictions do we have for gilda's testimony?
Maybe rainbow dash threw her under the bus so she can make herself look better
Maybe when gilda first joined camp she didnt have many friends, on account she was a griffon. So rainbow dash became her friend not out of pity but because it fueled her ego (Hero complex)
But maybe when Gilda started doing good at the camp, rainbow dash got jealous and sabotaged her. Or maybe as she got popular rainbow dash sabatoged her so she wouldn't be popular so she can keep being Gilda's "Hero"
11546994
Seems like its time for Princess Luna to finally take charge and bring a newer, more balanced no nonsense approach to rule.
11547119
You got it.
Oda used the Japanese marine ranks for his One Piece manga, and in that story there is one fleet admiral and there can be only three admirals at a time.
11547134
Whoops.
11547145
Have you ever read the Ending universe before this one?
I don't think Rainbow is going to be going down very easily (as the equivalent of the final boss), so I'd estimate this will probably be a multichapter arc like the one for Twilight.
11547147
Actually, in the treasure of Griffinstone episode. Gilda calls Rainbow Dash out on her idea to find the Idle of Boreas as a hero complex.
11547190
Ah sorry I get them mixed up all the time
Oh rainbow dash….trying your absolute hardest to make sure you leave the courtroom looking squeaky clean, but you can’t…cause everyone in the courtroom can see the stains!
11547129
On top of all the damage, repair costs, and Pegasi out of work for weeks/months…. Are we really sure no-pony was hurt because of her actions, if even indirectly?
I just hope u won't pull a fast on us like the last story that just made discord the villain in the end and elements were manipulated or some shit i still cant forget when i read the story and author was like yeah its discord fault.............
11547247
The Elements were barely manipulated, it was both their fault AND Discord. All Discord did was light a match, but they supplied the tinder.
*showing my empty plate*
More please
11547247
Like 11547279 said, Discord can't take the full blame. The Elements weren't under some mind control, if they had stopped and think, remembered everything they learned about friendship, all the lessons, the spell would have broken on its own, but instead they chose shoot first, don't ask questions later.
The greatest shock (pun intended) this court will ever see will be when the Gjallarhorn shows Rainbow Dash attacking Jason with lighting. A lot of bile is coming up, I presumed.
While Rainbow Dash might defend herself by saying that she protects Ponyville from the monster but that doesn't excuse the multiple strikes that Rainbow gives to Jason.
Even when Jason begs her to stop, Rainbow still gives him a lot more strikes followed by a kick to the stomach to the Everfree. The only one saving Jason is probably Zecora.
11547279
In all honesty I don't think discord had to do much
I mean, twilight admitted that she only rejected jason because she saw humans as monsters. A judgement discord probably didn't assist with she did that on her own
So discord didn't even need to give her a push. It is likely that twilight would have still rejected jason and the events still would have happened the same way since twilight's friends are to pig headed to question her
In all honesty I when I first read the big twist about it being discords doing in another ending fic... I hated it, because it kinda devalues everything that just happened.
But with how this story is going I can guess that twilight, rarity, rainbow, maybe even applejack are going to cling onto it for dear life. And them being shamed in court for throwing discord under the bus to save their own hide like mayor mare.
"The devil made me do it"
"I wouldn't have done B if A hadn't happen"
It still happened discord may have set up the kindling but they started the fire and now it's time for the burns
11547441
Maybe the Endingverse would have taken a different route had Celestia sent a letter to Twilight explaining that a new creature will be coming to Ponyville and expects her to be friends with him.
"You admit to playing favorites? Rainbow gets to live her dream not because of her talent or 'good qualities', but because she was an Element Bearer and in good with all members of royalty? You just implied that you wouldn't have taken any disciplinary action against Lightning had it been actual civilians instead of royalty and national heroes. Maybe if you actually did your job and corrected her the first several times, and if you were paying attention to who wanders up there like you were supposed to, that could've been avoided."
"You're supposed to be a branch of the military and you can't even spot a hot air balloon in broad daylight that's not even trying to be subtle? You encouraged that kind of behavior from Lightning, you allowed Twilight and her friends to create that situation, and you basically just admitted she was kicked out not because her recklessness that you encouraged, but because a few specific ponies were illegally in the worst possible location at the worst possible time? That's no different than wrongful termination."
"You were worried about your credibility then? How about now after you've been proven to lie about your records, proven of incompetence unfitting someone in your profession on top of criminal negligence and reckless endangerment? Like I'm fully expecting of Rainbow soon enough, you can say goodbye to your position and everything you tried to use Lightning as a scapegoat for. I hope it was worth it."
11547145
You are a lost cause my friend!
11547188
Probably not.
11547099
LOCK ON!!!
Sogeking sees the reference you made there.
Btw I was thinking the same thing.
How would Spitfire, the leader and defacto representative of THE elite flying force of Equestria, deminish their reputation and credibility by showing that there is no nepotisme in their group and non can curry any favors from them even if their conection is princess Celestia herself.
If anything it show that this is THE group that only accepts the 'best of the best' no matter what and only your skill, talent and Integrity will grant you entry to this group.
Now that Spitfire's nepotism is showing, the groups members only got in due to connections and not due to pure skil, talent and Integrity.
Right now the Wonderbolts is a sinking ship and only a miracle will save it's reputation.
Also with them scrubbing Lightning Dust's records and her potential wrongful termination from the academy, it puts the Wonderbolts other records into question.
What other records have been srubbed because of the "wrong" ponies not having the "right" connections.